Goal 7: The NCPN will develop a plan to evaluate the performance of programs 7.1The Board of Governors, with input from the stakeholder advisory committees,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
. . . a step-by-step guide to world-class internal auditing
Advertisements

Welcome, Panel of Examiner and Process Development Members! Washington State Quality Award PEPD #1 Training 2008.
The HR Paradigm Shift Discover Stakeholder Value for the Human Resources Function.
Chapter 12 Health Care Information Systems: A Practical Approach for Health Care Management 2nd Edition Wager ~ Lee ~ Glaser.
Transition from Q1- 8th to Q1- 9th edition
Reorganization of APHIS Veterinary Services U.S. Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service Veterinary Services November 2013.
Continuous Value Enhancement Process
Goal 2: Rapid and Safe Introductions Facilitator: Eva Ring Participants:Kerry Britton Mark Chien Brian Correiar Wayne Dixon Ken Eastwell Joseph Foster.
South Carolina Finance Workshop for Small Water Systems June 4, 2013 Water Partnerships: Financial Advantages and Challenges SC Case Study: Lowcountry.
Peer Assessment of 5-year Performance ARS National Program 301: Plant, Microbial and Insect Genetic Resources, Genomics and Genetic Improvement Summary.
Program Management Overview (An Introduction)
Centralized vs. Decentralized: Pros, Cons & Best Practices
Shared Learning Services : Key Learnings Session 102 November 9, 2009.
Presentation By: Chris Wade, P Eng. Finally … a best practice for selecting an engineering firm.
IS Audit Function Knowledge
Project Management Process Project Description Team Mission/ Assignment Major Milestones Boundaries Team Identification Measures of Success Roles & Responsibilities.
Human Resource Management and Strategic Human Resource Management
Toolkit Series from the Office of Migrant Education Webinar: CNA Toolkit August 21, 2012.
© 2008 Prentice Hall11-1 Introduction to Project Management Chapter 11 Managing Project Execution Information Systems Project Management: A Process and.
Project Execution.
2011 SIGnetwork Regional Meetings Guidance in Structuring a Communities of Practice.
National Clean Plant Network Goal #3 Workshop Break-Out Group May 8, 2007.
Strategic Information Systems Planning
Strategic Planning. Definitions & Concepts Planning: is a scientific approach for decision making. Planning: is a scientific approach for decision making.
Organization Mission Organizations That Use Evaluative Thinking Will Develop mission statements specific enough to provide a basis for goals and.
Continual Service Improvement Process
HIDALGO COUNTY ASSET MAPPING AND STRATEGIC PLANNING PROJECT Kickoff Meeting
Iowa’s Teacher Quality Program. Intent of the General Assembly To create a student achievement and teacher quality program that acknowledges that outstanding.
Internet 2 Corporate Value Proposition Stuart Kippelman (J&J) Jeff Lemmer (Ford) December 12, 2005.
Lecture #9 Project Quality Management Quality Processes- Quality Assurance and Quality Control Ghazala Amin.
Information Assurance The Coordinated Approach To Improving Enterprise Data Quality.
GBA IT Project Management Final Project - Establishment of a Project Management Management Office 10 July, 2003.
Creating a Shared Vision Model. What is a Shared Vision Model? A “Shared Vision” model is a collective view of a water resources system developed by managers.
Alaska Staff Development Network – Follow-Up Webinar Emerging Trends and issues in Teacher Evaluation: Implications for Alaska April 17, :45 – 5:15.
Lecture 11 Managing Project Execution. Project Execution The phase of a project in which work towards direct achievement of the project’s objectives and.
Management & Development of Complex Projects Course Code MS Project Management Perform Qualitative Risk Analysis Lecture # 25.
Important informations
Introduction to Management
UNCLASSIFIED 1 1 United States Joint Forces Command United States Joint Forces Command “Growing a Political, military, Economic, Social, Information, and.
Take Charge of Change MASBO Strategic Roadmap Update November 15th, 2013.
Diagnostics and Treatments John Bowers Christopher Clark Marc Fucs John Halbrendt Markus Keller Margarita Licha Clarissa Maroon-Largo Naidu Rayapati Adib.
1 Ch. 4 Outline Introduction to Planning 1.Planning Fundamentals 2.Levels of Planning 3.Strategic Planning.
Example Incident Mgmt Initiation No recording of Incidents Users can approach different departments Solutions of previous incidents are not available.
International Marketing Final Term Presentation: Presented to: Presented to: Mr. Ali Saeed Mr. Ali Saeed Presented by: Presented by: Ibrar Ahmed Hunzai.
CSI—The Lifecycle Stage
Proventures reconnect session on Project Portfolio Management (PPM)
Technology Commercialization Technology Commercialization, 2011 Sanjay Dhole, Technology Programs Coordinator Maricopa SBDC.
IAB Involvement in ERCs: Assessing and Strengthening the Role.
State of Georgia Release Management Training
PHDSC Privacy, Security, and Data Sharing Committee Letter to Governors.
AITA Conference AFP Institute Board Development Joey Wallace RESNA/NATTAP January 24, 2007.
Organizational Learning and Influence of emerging business realities
Introduction to SPA Trade Services PDA Work Flow Management Systems The Era of Change.
Beyond the BACoE: Developing Business Analysis Maturity.
#327 – Legal and Regulatory Risk: Silent and Possibly Deadly Deborah Frazer, CPA CISA CISSP Senior Director, Internal Audit PalmSource, Inc.
Integrated Regional Water Management Grant Program Implemented Jointly by Department of Water Resources and State Water Resources Control Board.
1 Institutional Quality and Accreditation: A Workshop on the Basics.
OrbEEt Project Introduction <Location>, <Date> Presenter
A Productive Partnership
Jim Bland Executive Director, CRIX International
Service Management World Class Operations - Impact Workshop.
THE ADVANCED LEADERSHIP INITIATIVE
TSMO Program Plan Development
The Open Group Architecture Framework (TOGAF)
Critical Factors in Managing Technology
Implementing on a Limited Budget: Leveraging Existing Tools within Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Customer Support Centers Successful Collaboration and Knowledge.
Role of Industry Self-regulation in Phytosanitary Compliance
Module 5 Liaison and Managing Relationships with Stakeholders
National Clean Plant Network
Presentation transcript:

Goal 7: The NCPN will develop a plan to evaluate the performance of programs 7.1The Board of Governors, with input from the stakeholder advisory committees, will establish the process and timetable for program evaluation.

1. What was the first thing that struck you about the goal and/or the proposed strategies when you reviewed the plan? Vague Has implications on all goals There must be a plan to establish baselines, such as the current… –Number of germplasm releases/year –Time required to ‘clean’ and release –Cost per release (in time and resources) –Not all areas must be assessed, but a planned assessment from the start is optimum –Reassess periodically Development of a Qualitative Management System (QMS) development

2. What questions do you have about the content of the plan? What/who is NCPN referred to in the Mission/Vission statements? –Such as, Who is the NCPN that “creates” the Board of Governors and Advisory committees What authority does NCPN have? –Such as, What determines the location of a regional center and how does a “regional” center fit in a “national” program What’s in it for participants? –Will this program bring stability to current programs? –Will this program facilitate expanded/improved services?

3. What do you like about the goal and proposed strategies? There is no specifically defined strategy for Goal 7. However, this goal is directly related to all other goals.

4. What concerns or issues do you have about the goal or any of the objectives? Is the organizational structure appropriate for the suggested mission & vision? Consider clarification and alignment to the final mission/vision before finalizing strategic goals (reconfirmation of goals and objectives with accepted mission & vision).

5. What changes or modifications would you make to any of the objectives in the plan? Add assessments

6. What issues or objective seem to be missing and should be added? Defined authority of NCPN (mentioned before)? Absence of an Export goal? – a strong domestic program has implications on export (positively) Requirement for inclusion as an NCPN entity? –Disciplinary (science) integration –Infrastructure assessment What capabilities is available? What personnel and facilities are available? What are the condition of available services and facilities? Are there quarantine needs at sites? Economic assessment of value to the industry Needs assessment of the system. –What we have versus what we might prefer (optimally).

7. What strategies would you like to see included in the plan? Assessment plans in each goal area

Suggested Overall Program Assessment Plans Baseline data on crops and common pathogens Gap analysis by crop identify pests of concern, knowledge, facilities, maintenance of clean material Regular assessment of concentration of support on ‘new’ crops (new = not currently in program or emerging crop) Standard Operating Protocols/Procedures (SOPs) are critical to develop new programs (useful for assessments) Consider leveraged “buying power” of the NCPN project ($ match) Structure –Frequent assessment of needs (as defined by needs assessment). Should the NCPN avoid redundancies in regional structure (subcenters to address locally specific needs)? –Locally supported vs distributed/virtual expertise (not distributed locations) – either could work within the SOP

Goal 1. Management Structure - Suggested Assessment Plans Management provides a support function – regularly assess management’s role. –Are the boards/committees established in a timely manner –Are the boards/committees facilitating function in the system –Conflict resolution –Who holds trump (authority issue) –What structural model will be followed (NPDN, Seed Cert Program) Should the Board of Governors establish a substructure based on region or crop? Program Reviews. –Frequent (annual?) self assessment/internal audits. –Less frequent major review – entire process administered by Board of Governors. Regularly evaluate deliverables – ability to meet deadlines.

Goal 2. Rapid and Safe Introduction - Suggested Assessment Plans Baseline establishment. –Is the industry currently satisfied? –How many releases, time in process, etc? Assess issues identified through analysis of SOP implementation/functionality – follow QMS standards. Pick important systems as indicators. –Impractical to assess all commodities. –Rank importance by value ($) and acreage. –Biological importance may also work (bridging to economic hosts). Start simple. Develop a pilot assessment system such as grapes (LHF).

Goal 3. Provide Foundation Stock - Suggested Assessment Plans See Goal 2 and… Assess where collections are held – provide redundancy (repository). Reassess later. Quantify releases (service). Ascertain the role of ARS in germplasm maintenance (long-term repository). Develop process for determining… –Quality and viability of germplasm, –Trueness to type, and –Pathogen profile in long-term storage – addresses the expressed warranty issue

Goal 4. New Techniques and Technologies - Suggested Assessment Plans Evolution of available number of tests and tools (T 0 to T 1 to T 2, etc.) Consider improvements in sensitivity and specificity of techniques QA system for diagnosticians –Ring tests – results of ring tests provide a regular metric of lab quality –Lab certification Develop process for validation and adoption of new tests Consider how rapidly new technologies can be implemented Develop an agreed upon set of tests for important pathogens/varietal purity Consider acceptability/relevance of an ET/EIL concept with some pathogens Collaborate with NPDN labs for facilities and services Develop a National Data Repository to allow quantitative/qualitative –Report negative results as well as positive results –Assess prevalence of significant pathogens X genotype X location –Reporting also helps identify a successes and problems (eradications)

Goal 5. New Techniques for Pathogen Eradication - Suggested Assessment Plans Thermotherapy and chemotherapy at this point are researchable topics, but not assessable (other than baseline characteristics). As validated SOPs are developed, assess success rate by species/protocol. Evaluate successes of affiliated research.

Goal 6. Best Management Practice Development - Suggested Assessment Plans Develop metrics for what are perceived to be BMPs by crop. –What are the comparisons? –Expect record keeping (consider barcoding as a possibility through foundation programs).

8. What benefits will the proposed strategies have on the way you do business? It could save the service component. Crown gall-free stocks to sell in the eastern US would be a huge advantage – currently a limit to development of the industry in the Eastern US (stress related trigger to disease expression). Eastern production areas would have the most to gain from indexed stocks. Public involvement may sacrifice proprietary advantages that are unclear/undefined, but an offset in the partnership with the NCPN.