Piecing Together the Governing Puzzle: An Exploration of Florida's Special Districts Robert J. Eger III and Joseph Vonasek September 12, 2012 LeRoy Collins.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Bureau of Accounts Gerard D. Perry Director of Accounts Anthony Rassias Deputy Director of Accounts (BOA)
Advertisements

Chapter 11 Issues of Reporting, Disclosure, & Analysis.
GASB 34 And the Public Schools of Petoskey GASB 34: Basic Financial Statements – and Management’s Discussion and Analysis – for State and Local Governments.
Nonprofit Finance and Reporting: What every board member should know Molly Lovelock
Florida CDDs: A Preliminary Look at Financial and Accountability Characteristics Sarah Ayers Florida State University MBA Student and Collins Institute.
Parkview School District Budget Hearing and Annual Meeting Monday, August 18, :30 p.m. Parkview Jr./Sr. High School LMC Monday, August.
Budget Hearing and Annual Meeting Monday, August 20,
1 Family Care (report 11-5) Legislative Audit Bureau January 2012.
Florida Redevelopment Association
Deficit District Roles & Responsibilities. MCL A district or intermediate district receiving money under this act shall not adopt or operate.
Northern Michigan SBO March 16, 2011 Jeff Kolb Michigan Department of Education Jeff Kolb Michigan Department of Education.
1 Finance Basics Rania A. Azmi University of Alexandria, Department of Business Administration.
Faculty Council Student Enrollment Dr. Bernadette Gray-Little, Executive Vice Chancellor and Provost September 15, 2006 The University of North Carolina.
Receivables Chapter 9.
The Fed and Monetary Policy
Assessing the Impact of Revenue Limits on Florida Local Governments Robert J. Eger III Florida State University August 19, 2010 LeRoy Collins Institute.
Bank Performance Banking & Finance. Bellringer Chapter 13 Online Pretest.
Accounting: What the Numbers Mean Study Outlines and Overhead Masters Chapter 3.
Overview Finance 101. Topics Financial Statement Overview Report Examples Key Performance Indicators Responsibilities of a Finance Department.
GASB Statement No. 34 Cliff Notes Laurie L. Piccirillo, Business Manager Brockway Area School District Dr. David M. Piper, Assistant to Superintendent.
Presented by: Professor N Amy Santos, State College of Florida GOVERNMENTAL ACCOUNTING.
Chapter Thirteen Financial Statement Analysis Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Chapter 3 Budget Structures and Institutions
Community Redevelopment Agency Reporting From a Dependent Special District Perspective Jack Gaskins Jr. Department of Community Affairs Special District.
Introduction to Public Hospital Districts April 25, 2002 Association of Washington Public Hospital Districts.
Joint Task Force on Local Effort Assistance September 25, 2002 Bill Freund, Consultant To The Task Force.
Controlling Preview Steps in the Control Process Three types of Control Characteristics of Effective Control Systems Financial Controls a. Financial Ratios.
1 North Orange County Community College District North Orange County Community College District Proposed Budget.
Govt. Reporting - 1 GOVERNMENTAL REPORTING City Council Budgetary Hearing.
The Role of Fiscal Institutions in Managing the Oil Revenue Boom CEPAL XIX Regional Seminar on Fiscal Policy January 2007 Rolando Ossowski Fiscal Affairs.
CHAPTER Financial Reporting Issues Fundamentals of Advanced Accounting 1 st Edition Fischer, Taylor, and Cheng 11.
Budget Committee Workshop February16, Oregon’s local budget law is a group of statutes that require local governments to prepare and adopt annual.
From the Shredded Files of Big Business Assuring safeguards with effective Financial Policies Pam Baker and Ernest Werstler.
The What and Why of Fund Accounting May 15, 2014 GFOAz 1.
1 Riverwood Community Governance Forum March 7, 2011 Cal Teague Riverwood C.D.D. District Manager.
Accounts and Bills Receivable Chapter 8 HORNGREN ♦ HARRISON ♦ BAMBER ♦ BEST ♦ FRASER ♦ WILLETT.
Financial Analysis Ag Management Chapter 3. Objectives Know the three kinds of financial analysis Be able to calculate liquidity, solvency, and equity.
Introduction Chapter 1: Getting to know you…. Comparison of GNPs with Business Different mission - no profit motive Budget - legal document –most significant.
5.01 Budget Planning & Control. Budget Planning Financial planning is one tool managers use to improve profitability. Planning the financial operations.
Highlights of the 2011 Audit Report Highlights of the 2011 Audit Report.
Raising Money Types of Taxes Managing the Country’s Money.
County Financial Statements – The County Official’s Role
Chapter 15 – The Federal Reserve System Section 1.
1 Chapter 5 The Federal Reserve. 2 The Federal Reserve (the Fed) The U.S. Central Bank I.The Role of the Federal Reserve System A.The purpose is to control.
8 - 1 ©2002 Prentice Hall, Inc. Business Publishing Accounting, 5/E Horngren/Harrison/Bamber Accounts and Notes Receivable Chapter 8.
Overview Goal Setting. Budget The Importance of Budgeting Preparation of an annual budget and continuous budget monitoring allows management to anticipate.
12-1 Chapter Twelve Financial Considerations Chapter learning objectives 12.1 Appreciate the potential benefits of accounting and financial analysis.
FACSA Performance Management for Florida Authorizers St. Petersburg, Florida June 16, 17 and 18, 2009.
© 2014, Florida Department of Education. All Rights Reserved. Charter Schools in Florida Friday, February 13, 2015 Mid-Year Transportation.
Financial Management Returning To The Farm University of Nebraska- Lincoln.
Section 3The Balance Sheet What You’ll Learn  The purpose of a balance sheet.  How to prepare a balance sheet.  How to analyze information on financial.
Local Government Retirement Benefits David S.T. Matkin Askew School of Public Administration & Policy November 9, 2010 LeRoy Collins Institute ~ Carol.
K-State Research and Extension Community Board Leadership Series You are serving on a board-now what? K-State Research and Extension Community Development.
Hands on Budgeting Wendy Watson April 18, Agenda Why and when to budget? Types of budgets Revenues Expenses Cost allocation Types of budget Reports.
Trends Across and Within Florida on County Spending and Revenues Robert J. Eger III, PhD ~ Bruce D. McDonald III University Center Club ~ May 6, 2009 LeRoy.
Trends Across and Within Florida County Seats Spending and Revenues Robert J. Eger III, PhD ~ Bruce D. McDonald III University Center Club ~ October 13,
FIRST NATIONS FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT BOARD “SUPPORTING FIRST NATIONS THROUGH CERTIFICATION” Presentation to CESO – North Shore Chapter July 21, 2015.
UNC General Administration Debt Capacity Study Michael Juby, Director First Tryon Advisors 1355 Greenwood Cliff, Suite 400 Charlotte, NC Phone: (704)
Chapter 36 Financing the Business Section 36.1 Preparing Financial Documents Section 36.2 Financial Aspect of a Business Plan Section 36.1 Preparing Financial.
Copyright © 2012 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall 15-1 # Copyright © 2015 Pearson Education, Inc. The Role of Accountants and Accounting.
Ken Strobeck, Executive Director
Budgets and Financial Cost Analysis chapter 13
Basics of financial management
SOUTHGATE COMMUNITY SCHOOLS AUDIT REPORT
Managing Chapter Funds
Centralia School District Unaudited Actuals
Legislative-Citizen Commission on Minnesota Resources July 18, 2018
Report to Board of Education – September 6, 2016
Structures of Central Banks and the Federal Reserve System
Presentation transcript:

Piecing Together the Governing Puzzle: An Exploration of Florida's Special Districts Robert J. Eger III and Joseph Vonasek September 12, 2012 LeRoy Collins Institute ~ Carol Weissert, Ph. D., Director FSU Campus ~ 506 W Pensacola Street Tallahassee FL ~ fax

Governance in Florida is granted by the state to local and special district governments. Although imparted with governance authority, special districts remain largely invisible to citizens who use and pay for their services ▫Contemporary evidence in Florida is observed in newspapers and surveys This provides an opportunity to analyze the role and fiscal behavior special districts Focus of Today’s Presentation

Transmission of governance powers to special districts governments ▫Usually for a single function Powers include ▫Revenue authority ▫Expenditure authority ▫Debt authority Overview of Governance Powers

1.How are special districts in Florida conveyed?  Focus is on the legislative (legal) definition of special districts and the process of creation, operation, and dissolution  Analysis creates a document for citizens and legislators who would like specifics associated with the creation of special districts Research Question #1

Operate under a confusing and often contradictory set of laws with different levels of government approving the creation of the district ▫State executive branch and the local government executive branch can create  Given the different levels of government for creating, a question is raised as to how districts avoid fragmentation in the provision of services The use of the term “creation” and “establishment” are unclear in statute ▫Are powers associated with both terms equal for local governments? Findings – Conveyance of Special Districts

Lack of consistent uniformity in the composition of governing boards ▫Methods of appointment ▫Number of seats Dissolution guidelines are divergent Recent efforts to reassess continued existence, accountability, and effectiveness failed in the House In 2012 special district convertibility into municipal governments was signed into law ▫We estimate that 53 CDDs may be eligible for conversion Findings – Conveyance of Special Districts (cont.)

What does Analysis Suggest Under law, task is to serve “a public purpose with accountability to the public and general- purpose local governments” ▫This directly conflicts with the often confusing set of laws ▫The number of creating documents available ▫The ability to reassess the accountability, effectiveness, and existence 7

2.What has been the fiscal performance of special districts in Florida?  Focus is on exploring the financial aspects of Florida’s special districts including revenues, expenditures, debt, assets, and liabilities  Analysis provides citizens and legislators the opportunity to directly examine the recent fiscal behavior of special districts Research Question #2

Fiscal Performance- Methodology We stratify the special districts based on statutory creation ▫F.S. 189 (Independent districts) ▫F.S. 190 (Community Development Districts) ▫F.S. 191 (Fire Districts) Within each stratum ▫Simple random sample based on our desired error rate of ± 4% Sample only the 992 districts that are active as of June 12, 2012 Of our 96 sampled districts, 74 have complete information We further subdivide our districts based on board structure ▫Dominated by an elected board structure (Chapters 190 and 191)  Community development districts (CDD)  Fire control and rescue districts ▫Not dominated by elected board structure (Chapter 189)  Elected board  Gubernatorial appointed  Mixed board (boards that have both elected and appointed members)  Appointed board structures. 9

Findings- Fiscal Performance CDDs ▫End-of-year cash on hand has been declining  Indicating that cash to pay for annual financial liabilities are eroding ▫25% of CDDs had less than 35 days of cash on hand in 2010 ▫At least 50% of CDDs are in balance sheet insolvency ▫CDDs have high liabilities compared to unrestricted net assets and high debt to asset ratios over the entire time period  Indicates that debt has the potential to place the average CDD into a financially distressed position which may require an inflow of outside revenues to reduce the default risk of these districts

Findings- Fiscal Performance (cont.) Non-CDDs ▫Elected board districts have seen a decline in their average liquidity position over time ▫Fire districts, mix board districts, and appointed board districts  May have a difficult time responding to temporary cash shortages, emergencies or deficits do to low unrestricted net assets ▫Elected board and governor appointed board districts have about 2 times their annual expenses available in spendable unrestricted net assets in 2010

Findings- Fiscal Performance (cont.) Non-CDDs ▫For each year analyzed  Average fire district had actual revenues below budgeted revenues  Average elected and governor appointed board districts had actual revenues that exceeded budgeted revenues  Both of these outcomes indicate consistent inaccuracy in projecting revenues ▫For all years (exception is average fire district in 2009)  Actual average expenditures are lower than budgeted expenditures for all the special district types ▫Consistent across the time period for every year evaluated  Independent special districts with gubernatorial appoint boards or elected boards always understate their actual revenues and overstate their actual expenses

What does Fiscal Analysis Suggest Fiscal performance for all districts ▫Generally appear to have writhed during this economic slump ▫Fiscal health appears to be marginal to poor ▫Districts have seen a decline in liquidity, but appear to be slowly improving over the time period ▫Find a limited ability to respond to temporary cash shortages, emergencies or deficits ▫The trend was for districts to overstate expenditures on average ▫Consistently inaccurate in projecting both revenues and expenditures 13