Sociology 114 Joshua Wakeham March 27 th, 2013. The Rise of Enron In 1985, in the midst of the deregulation of the gas market, Ken Lay founds Enron. 1990s:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
AC 4304 Financial Reporting Theory Week 2 Presentation Dennis Ivan Rita.
Advertisements

European Graduate Opportunities. Agenda Who are JPMorgan?
The Financial Environment
1 Using and Misusing Investment Incentives James Alm and David L. Sjoquist March 2008.
Executive Summary Nokia's net sales in 2003 decreased by 2% compared with 2002 and totaled EUR million (EUR million in 2002). Operating.
Enron Bankruptcy Philip B. Livingston, President and CEO Financial Executives International.
FRAUD EXAMINATION ALBRECHT, ALBRECHT, & ALBRECHT Financial Statement Fraud CHAPTER 11.
By Aleksandra Whistle, Rachel Davis and Jie li
 FINANCIAL INTEGRATION Paula Garrido Mirat. Background  High levels of financial integration a hundred years ago.  British investment in Argentina,
SPEs as Off-Balance Sheet Vehicles. Paul Zarowin2 Key Issues Special purpose entities (SPE) Synthetic leases Enron case.
Ethics Dr. Jeanette Kersten, EdD. Ethics Doing what is right in every circumstance Business ethics – Standard that guide acceptable behavior Common unethical.
Chapter 1 Accounting: The Key to Success. What’s so important about Accounting? Accounting is at the heart of every business It is the means through which.
Elite Offenders offenders in the highest socio- economic status group, such as owners of large firms, senior executives, high status civil servants or.
Chapter 2 Business Ethics. 2 o Ethics is the study of right and wrong behavior; whether an action is fair, right or just. o In business, ethical decisions.
The Financial Statements
Earnings and Financial Reporting Quality MIM 517 Fall 2010 Class 6.
Chapter 6 Earnings Management.
Earnings Management What is earnings management? Creative accounting Cook the books – falsify their financial statements. Earnings? - profit of company.
Welcome to Accounting 211! Chapter 1: An Introduction Your Instructor: Larry Stout Hours: See syllabus.
Introduction – MBA5041 Stock Market Trading and insider trading Daily trading volatility Mutual fund scandals late trading and market timing fees IPO allocations.
Financial Accounting, Sixth Edition
New York Stock Exchange Enron was a publicly traded company whose shares were listed on the New York Stock Exchange and were bought, held and sold by individuals.
1 Walt is Finance? Finance is both an academic and a professional discipline devoted to the study and practice of making “investments.” Investment - anything.
Group 5 Andrew Beamon Brandon Hall Joseph Gasparini Matthew Pugh
Lecture 1: An Overview of Financial Management FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT.
FINANCE IN A CANADIAN SETTING Sixth Canadian Edition Lusztig, Cleary, Schwab.
By: 1. Kenneth A. Kim John R. Nofsinger And 2. A. C. Fernando
CORPORATE ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL GOVERNANCE ISSUES.
Accounting as a Form of Communication
Financial Management and Corporate Governance. WHAT FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT IS REALLY ABOUT you must then develop a plan. The plan requires answers to some.
ENRON SCANDAL.
Internship Announcement. Group Project sure ways to lose points Missed due date on a deliverable Inappropriateness during the presentation (goes for when.
Introduction to the Financial System. In this section, you will learn:  about securities, such as stocks and bonds  the economic functions of financial.
By: 1. Kenneth A. Kim John R. Nofsinger And 2. A. C. Fernando.
The World of Business and Accounting Making Accounting Relevant Owning and operating a business takes special skills and traits. Making Accounting Relevant.
Chapter 1 Accounting and the Business Environment
Chapter Nineteen Accounting in the International Business.
1 Today’s Presentation Sarbanes Oxley and Financial Reporting An NSTAR Perspective.
Mark Carey, CPA, CISA President x8431 Management-ese: An Introductory Course.
Chapter 14 Using Financial Information and Accounting n.
© 2014 Cengage Learning. All rights reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
Financial Accounting and Its Environment Chapter 1.
By: 1. Kenneth A. Kim John R. Nofsinger And 2. A. C. Fernando.
ACCOUNTING AND FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY IN STRATEGIC PLANNING By Charles D. Little, Ph.D.
  An ex-employee at Enron, he was been hired by Enron 9 months before it was collapsed.  Author of the book “Anatomy Of Greed : Unshredded Truth from.
What Is Business? Activities to provide members of an economic system with goods and services LO1.
00 CHAPTER 1 Governance, Ethics, and Managerial Decision Making © 2009 Cengage Learning.
14-1 Copyright © 2012 Pearson Prentice Hall. All rights reserved. C H A P T E R 14 The Federal Reserve and Monetary Policy Copyright © 2012 Pearson Prentice.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2007 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 9 GROUP PROCESS Behavioral Corporate Finance by Hersh.
ENRON Enron … took great pains to project an image of being a stalwart and responsible corporate citizen…(it) appeared to have superior internal controls,
Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. George Santayana.
Chapter 1 Accounting in Action ACT 201 By: Ms. Adina Malik (ALK)
Accounting Process of measuring, interpreting, and communicating financial information to support internal and external business decision making. USERS.
Chapter 1 – Accounting The Link Between Business and Accounting.
ENRON Thomas Clarke. “The company that once held the admiration of the business world, promised the future and envisioned itself to be the world’s leading.
Accounting Scandals: What we have learned from Enron and World Com Debacle? Pertemuan 04 Matakuliah: F0122 – Seminar Akuntansi Tahun: 2009.
+ Enron the Unsinkable Ship Nancy Vazquez. + Overview Describe the concept of ‘Creative Accounting’. How the unsinkable ship was sunk to the bottom of.
A brief introduction to ENRON SCANDAL Student name: Olga Balzhinimaeva Student ID: Ma3n0231.
Fiasco Report. WorldCom  Founded in 1983 in Mississippi  Bernard Ebbers appointed CEO in 1985  Company went public through merger with Advantage Companies.
1-1 ©2006 Prentice Hall, Inc ©2006 Prentice Hall, Inc. LINK BETWEEN BUSINESS & ACCOUNTING (1 of 2)  Learning objectives Learning objectives  Definition.
PRE-PARED BY: AZHAR AHMED 1-1 CHAPTER 4 The Financial Statements.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Chapter 1 The Nature and Purpose of Accounting Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies. All Rights Reserved.
Presented By: W. Andrew Powell, CPA Principal Halt, Buzas & Powell, Ltd.
Enron: 21,000 Arthur Anderson: 29,000 Retirement: $1.2 Billion Pensions: $2 Billion
上海金融学院 1-1 Lecture 3 Investment Banking Basics: The Financial Statements.
1 Chapter 1 The Link Between Business and Accounting.
Should Every Board have a Financial Expert? Wayne H. Shaw, Ph.D.
Treasury Market Risk Management. Treasury Management Treasury management is a broader concept than liquidity management Management of cash flows in terms.
The Fall of Enron A Stakeholder Failure by Merve Yalaman Ayşegül Güner
Financial Accounting, Sixth Edition
Presentation transcript:

Sociology 114 Joshua Wakeham March 27 th, 2013

The Rise of Enron In 1985, in the midst of the deregulation of the gas market, Ken Lay founds Enron. 1990s: Financialization of gas markets Expanded into other utilities, other countries Shift to “Asset Light” strategy (Skilling)

The Peak From 1996 to 2000, Enron reported net income rising from $580 million to $970 million. While revenues from traditional physical assets slowed during this time, revenue from trading grew enormously: $40 billion, $100 billion.

Why? Why did Enron’s executives (Skilling, Lay, others) think that they could get away with this? Why did the accounting firm allow Enron to get away with such questionable accounting practices? Why did investment banks and other partners (Merrill Lynch, Citibank, Deutsche Bank, and so on) let Enron get away with this financial shell game? Why did the SEC—and the government in general—fail to detect Enron’s fraudulent practices? Why did the media and the business world get sucked into this image of Enron as a brilliant, unstoppable success story? Why didn’t any of Enron’s employees speak up?

What went wrong? There are several things we need to account for in order to understand what went wrong at Enron: Business practices: Mark-to-Market Accounting Special Purpose Entities (SPEs) The complicity of external auditors Enron’s culture KEY: As we examine the case, we should be asking is this simply a case of people acting unethically—that is, knowingly violating a shared standard for moral behavior—or is it a case in which the circumstances themselves shaped (and distorted?) people’s moral evaluations of their own behavior?

Understanding Enron’s Financial Shell Game Understanding why Enron did so well in the market for so long requires understanding the role of appearances in the market. Investors, business partners look for particular pieces of information in order to determine the financial health or worthiness of a company. Accounting  Assurance about the Information? Enron’s accounts of key financial measures signaled to investors and the broader business community that the organization was doing quite well. However, in actuality, Enron’s “creative accounting” disguised losses, expenses, and risks and inflated earnings, assets, and value.

Mark-to-Market Accounting When trading commodities that have prices that fluctuate, it is often difficult to determine the real value of a transaction. Enron lobbied to use present value accounting on its long-term contracts.

Special Purpose Entities SPEs are supposed to be third-party, independent legal entities created to serve a specific purpose for a company (such as securitization of debt, risk sharing, tax avoidance). Enron developed hundreds of SPEs under CFO Andrew Fastow. SPEs would primarily buy or take on debts and expenses from Enron, essentially changing their status in Enron’s books from costs to revenues.

Enron’s Shell Game Enron’s increased reliance on increasingly complex financial tools arguably led it to a place where questionable, if not outright fraudulent and corrupt practices, were acceptable. By its peak, Enron had constructed a completely false account of its financial standing. Debt and costs were hidden in SPEs. Mark-to-market accounting allowed the company to basically make-up its earnings. With things going so well, no one questioned why or how. Not even the people who were supposed to.

Complicity from the Outside An important part of the Enron story is the role of outsiders in propping up Enron’s falsely constructed version of its success. The list of complicit players includes: Arthur Anderson, Merrill Lynch Various investment banks and financial firms The government

Why did Outsiders Approve? Easy answer: Most had a financial (or political) interest in doing so. Another problem: Skilling and others were really smart and what they were doing was really complicated. How Enron made its money was intentionally kept opaque to outsiders. Skilling et al. played up an intimidating image of “we know better.” The cost of complicity: Approval by these high status outsiders fueled the confidence of people outside of Enron (including workers with 401k’s) and the confidence of people within Enron. If the SEC, investment banks, and the accountants approved what we were doing, how could it be considered wrong?

Looking Inside Enron Another key part of this story is Enron’s unique business culture. Enron cultivated an image of a company that rewarded talent in a highly competitive environment. KEY: The Performance Review Committee Grading employees on a curve: “Rank and yank” Along with critical system was the potential for huge financial rewards in the form of bonuses. Lessons from Moral Mazes? The business community ate this up (e.g. HBS).

Enron’s Leadership At the top of this competitive organizational culture were a group of executives who cultivated an image of being macho, smarter-than-you risk takers. Under such conditions and under such leadership, who would dare dissent?

Eventually… Was it too little, too late?

Questions How would Jackall, using Moral Mazes as a framework, want us to think about the Enron case? How is this different than someone who might teach a “business ethics” course? Do you think that the various people at Enron knowingly violated ethical principles that they held, or did circumstances change what it meant to do good business? How is Enron a harbinger of things to come?