Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe A Life-time Analysis SHARELIFE Meeting – Svendborg, (DK) July 20 th, 2010 Nicolas Sirven *, Zeynep.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Health Care Sector Efficiency: Measuring and improving it

Advertisements

LABOUR FORCE SURVEY The aim is to show that only an integrated approach to these data makes the contribution of Italian women to the economy more visible.

ESA/STAT/AC.219/15 Survey Analysis for Gender Indicators Sulekha Patel Development Data Group World Bank Manila October 11, 2010 ESA/STAT/AC.219/15.

Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys Data Interpretation, Further Analysis and Dissemination Workshop Basic Concepts of Further Analysis.

Donald Bruce, Xiaowen Liu, and Matthew Murray Center for Business and Economic Research and Department of Economics The University of Tennessee, Knoxville.

The Link Between Childhood Adversity and Adult Health Risk Trajectories Andrea Willson Kim Shuey The University of Western Ontario.

Analysis of farm household incomes in OECD countries Master in Agricultural, Food and Environmental Policy Analysis Université catholique de Louvain University.

1 SUMMARY OF SOCIAL INDICATORS USED BY THE OECD Denis Ward Statistics Directorate OECD.

Sex Differences in the Prevalence and Correlates of Colorectal Cancer Testing: Health Information National Trends Survey Sally W. Vernon 1, Amy.

Trend in use of health care services and long term care Results of AGIR - WP 2 and WP4A Dr. Erika Schulz.

Poverty entry and exit during old age: comparative evidence from the ECHP Mattia Makovec Università Bocconi (Milan) and European Centre for Social Welfare.

Health care systems: efficiency and policies

1 James P. Smith Childhood Health and the Effects on Adult SES Outcomes.

OECD, Directorate for Employment, Labour and Social Affairs Social Policy in the OECD: what lessons for Chile? National Social Security Meeting, Santiago.

Demographic change, pension reform, and household saving in urban China.

EUROPEAN DATA CENTER FOR WORK and WELFARE your direct access to EUROPEAN COMPARATIVE DATA - opinions - - indicators and statistics - - policies and institutions.

I. I.Population Dynamics - Trends F. F.Population Projections – UN All scenarios include shifts in geographic distribution of population Medium variant.

FENICs Female Employment and Family Formation in National Institutional Contexts Women’s Entry into Motherhood in France, Sweden, East and West Germany,

Employment Decisions of European Women After Childbirth Chiara Pronzato (ISER) EPUNet Conference, May 9th 2006.

Presented By: Dr. Ehsan Latif School of Business and Economics Thompson Rivers University, BC, Canada.

Social Welfare Policymaking Chapter 18

Do Friends and Relatives Really Help in Getting a Good Job? Michele Pellizzari London School of Economics.

1 Canadian Institute for Health Information. Physician Cost Drivers 2.

Knowledge, Cancer Fatalism and Spirituality as Predictors of Breast Cancer Screening Practices for African American and Caucasian Women Staci T. Anderson,

Chapter Three Health, Education, Poverty, and the Economy.

28 November rd Annual Canadian Employee Benefits Conference Ambrose M. Hearn, CHE CEO, VON Canada 1 NATIONAL VIEW OF AN AGING POPULATION BRIDGE.

Haripriya Gundimeda Associate Professor Department of Humanities and Social Sciences Indian Institute of Technology Bombay Human capital estimates for.

HOW DATA CAN DRIVE IMPROVEMENTS IN HEALTH SYSTEMS Mark Pearson Head, OECD Health Division Japanese Health Economics Association 21 July, 2012.

School Dropout in Rural Vietnam: Does Gender Matter?

Europe Institutional reforms that really matter: OECD institutional indicators vs. Dutch reform history. Ruud Gerards, Manuel Müllers and Joan Muysken.

Dean R. Lillard 1,3, Richard V. Burkhauser 2,3,4, Markus H. Hahn 4 and Roger Wilkins 4 1 Ohio State University, 2 Cornell University, 3 DIW-Berlin, 4 Melbourne.

Why are White Nursing Home Residents Twice as Likely as African Americans to Have an Advance Directive? Understanding Ethnic Differences in Advance Care.

Information on public family supports in the OECD Family database ECEC Network meeting Paris, 21-22, 2010 Willem Adema Senior Economist, OECD Social Policy.

Working Conditions, Health and Reward at Work of European Older Workers Thierry Debrand (*), Pascale Lengagne (**) (*) (**)

1 Institute for Population and Social Research (IPSR) FACTORS AFFECTING HEALTHCARE EXPENDITURE OF THE THAI ELDERLY Danusorn Potharin 1 and Wathinee Boonchalaksi.

Spatial and non spatial approaches to agricultural convergence in Europe Luciano Gutierrez*, Maria Sassi** *University of Sassari **University of Pavia.

Elizabeth Docteur European Health Forum Gastein 7 October 2004 Towards High-Performing Health Systems: Challenges and Opportunities for Reform.

Social Protection and Social Insurance Age Transfers in Poland Social Protection and Social Insurance Age Transfers in Poland Institute of Statistics and.

Employment Trendswww.ilo.org/trends Millennium Development Goals Employment Indicators Theo Sparreboom Employment Trends International Labour Organization.

Labour mobility and retirement Agar Brugiavini, Mario Padula, Giacomo Pasini, Franco Peracchi Svendborg, July 2010.

1 The Labour Market Integration of Immigrants in OECD Countries on-going work for OECD's Working Party 1, EPC presented by Sébastien Jean (OECD) Workshop.

HAOMING LIU JINLI ZENG KENAN ERTUNC GENETIC ABILITY AND INTERGENERATIONAL EARNINGS MOBILITY 1.

Massimiliano Riva Istanbul, 19 November 2008 Trade and Human Development How to conduct trade needs assessments in transition economies.

Health Expenditures, Longevity and Growth by B. Dormont, J. Oliveira Martins, F. Pelgrin and M. Suhrcke Discussant: V. Galasso.

Use of Summary Measures in the US Healthy People and Healthiest Nation Initiatives Richard J. Klein US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National.

Felicia Yang DeLeone, Institute for Children, Poverty and Homelessness Dona Anderson, Homes for the Homeless November 7, 2011 Child Care Use in Homeless.

Human costs of tobacco-related diseases * Marco Vannotti, France Priez, Claude Jeanrenaud, Jean-Pierre Zellweger Institut de recherches économiques et.

1 Joaquim Oliveira Martins Economics Department, OECD From Ageing to Longevity Facts and policy challenges European Health Forum Gastein Workshop 3 – Health.

The Effect of Consumer Driven Health Plans on Pharmaceutical Cost & Use: Do 3-Tier Plans Have a Competitor? Stephen T Parente Jon B Christianson Roger.

A Webinar for Girls Not Brides members and partners

Determinants of Corruption in Local Health Care Provision: Evidence from 105 Municipalities in Bolivia Roberta Gatti, George Gray-Molina and Jeni Klugman.

Differentials in desires and realisation: 1st, 2nd and 3rd child Marion Burkimsher.

A County Level Analysis of Educational Attainment in the United States by Social, Economic and Geographic Variables BY Brandon Hallstrand (University of.

1 Political Economics Riccardo Puglisi Lecture 8 Content: The Future of Pension Systems: Demographic Dynamics A Complex Simulation Model Evaluating the.

Statistical data on women entrepreneurs in Europe Jacqueline Snijders 11 October 2014.

Modernizing Health Care Inez Bartels.  Strong focus on the provision of health care  Institutions governing health care consumption control patients.

Son preference, maternal health care utilization and infant death in rural China Jiajian Chen 1, Zhenming Xie 2, Hongyan Liu 2 1 East-West Center, USA,

Francia L., Gitto L., Mennini F.S., Polistena B (*). HEALTH EXPENDITURE IN OECD COUNTRIES: AN ECONOMETRIC ANALYSIS Francia L., Gitto L., Mennini F.S.,

Arnold School of Public Health Health Services Policy and Management 1 Women’s Cancer Screening Services Utilization Versus Their Insurance Source Presenter:

Hearing impairment among 50+ year old Europeans Results from the SHARE survey Karen Andersen-Ranberg, MD, PhD Associate Professor, Andreas Kryger Jensen,

Wine Consumption Across Generations – A Life Cycle Approach Work in Progress Geir W. Gustavsen 1 and Kyrre Rickertsen 1,2 1 Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy.

Hipólito Simón Universidad de Alicante

ZHANG Juwei Institute of Population and Labor Economics

Retirement Prospects for Millennials: What Is the Early Prognosis

Eliminating Reproductive Risk Factors and Reaping Female Education and Work Benefits: A Constructed Cohort Analysis of 50 Developing Countries Qingfeng.

Robots and jobs: Empirical evidence and the citizen's perspective

Measuring Progress in Health and health care: how does estonia compare with other EU and OECD countries? Gaetan Lafortune, OECD Health Division Conference.

12th Annual Conference June, 2018 Ithaca (NY), USA.

Timon Forster Alexander Kentikelenis Clare Bambra

Presentation transcript:

Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe A Life-time Analysis SHARELIFE Meeting – Svendborg, (DK) July 20 th, 2010 Nicolas Sirven *, Zeynep Or Institute for Research and Information on Health Economics Paris, France (*)

1.What do we know? Regular Health Care utilisation is a public policy matter (prevention, early detection, care) contribute to improved health status Despite common social security systems in Europe, disparities in care utilisation across countries are significant 2.What is less well known? What are dynamics of these disparities? - How the utilisation of the health care system evolved across generations? - What contributes more to changing habits? Econ. developt. or health system? What are the determinants of cross-country differences? - Few cross-country analysis - No analysis of individuals’ long term care habits 3. Our contribution Life-time analysis of individual + system characteristics on people’s behaviour Comparison of 3 cohorts and 13 European countries over the last 35 years Introduction Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

1.SHARE data Individuals 50+ in 15 European countries (on health, social, economic) Panel = 2 repeated cross-sections (2004, 2006) + retrospective (2008) Sharelife 2.Selected sample w3 + w1|w2 = 13 countries Born between ] ]  3 cohorts: ; ; “Good understanding of Sharelife questions” = drop 0.6% of the sample Full rank = 22,814 obs. (12,440 for women only) 3.Dependant variables “Did you ever had regular checks…”  Blood tests, blood pressure, gynaecological, mammogram, vision Binary: 1 Yes (has started regular checks), 0 No (didn’t star so far) Data Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Regular Health Care at a Glance Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Age Start Regular Health Care Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Cohort 1 Born ] ] Cohort 2 Born ] ] Cohort 3 Born ] ] Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) Period 1Period 2Period 3 Analysing Cohort Effects in a Given Country Age Age Age 20-39

Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) Period 1Period 2Period 3 Analysing Cohort Effects in a Given Country Age Cohort 1 Born ] ] Cohort 2 Born ] ] Cohort 3 Born ] ]

Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) Period 1Period 2Period 3 Context Variables in a Given Country Age OECD Series statisticsGDP per capita Total health expenditure per capita Public expend. on health (as % of total exp. on health) Practising physicians (Density /1000 pop.) Cohort 1 Born ] ] Cohort 2 Born ] ] Cohort 3 Born ] ] What context variables explain differences in individual behaviour across cohorts?

Context Variables in a Given Country Age Cohort 1 Born ] ] Cohort 2 Born ] ] Cohort 3 Born ] ] Period 1Period 2Period 3 OECD Series statisticsGDP per capita Total health expenditure per capita Public expend. on health (as % of total exp. on health) Practising physicians (Density /1000 pop.) Total growth rate over period p average volume/level over period p Mean average annual growth rate over period p Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) Context Variables in a Given Country Age Cohort 1 Born ] ] Cohort 2 Born ] ] Cohort 3 Born ] ] Period 1Period 2Period 3 OECD Series statisticsGDP per capita Total health expenditure per capita Public expend. on health (as % of total exp. on health) Practising physicians (Density /1000 pop.) Total growth rate over period p 1 variable taking 3 different values (cohort) for each country average volume/level over period p Mean average annual growth rate over period p CONTEXT VARIABLES = The influence of public policy at different times for individuals having the same age

Econometric Methodology Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) 1.Country × Cohort effects Retrospective data allow disentangling age/cohort effects Idea: cluster (C=39) = country (J=13) × cohorts (T=3)

Y* ic =  0c + X ic  + e ic with Hyp. 1:  0c =  0 +  0c Hyp. 2:  0c =  0 +  01 Z c +  0c Econometric Methodology Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) 1.Country × Cohort effects Retrospective data allow disentangling age/cohort effects Idea: cluster (C=39) = country (J=13) × cohorts (T=3) 2.Multilevel Model (parsimonious) 3. Two-Step Multilevel - Gives same results (Coeffs. & S.E.) when comparing with HLM - Allows more interesting Level 2 specification 4. Variables Set - Age, gender, education, income, Employment status, ADL, Chronic illnesses (Cancer) - Initial conditions (Index of comfort, SRH child, Relative School Performance) + Context variables (Z c )

Step 1: Individual level regressions 1/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

2/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) Step 1: Individual level regressions

Step 2: Country × Cohorts level regressions 1/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Step 2: Country × Cohorts level regressions 1/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Step 2: Country × Cohorts level regressions 1/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Step 2: Country × Cohorts level regressions 1/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)

Step 2: Country × Cohorts level regressions 2/2 Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010) Purge the effect of health policies from economic conditions Volume effect (no price effects)

1. Summary At the individual Level: Health! & Healthy Worker Effect Education & economic conditions … but still significant differences between countries & cohorts Cohort effect: General shift towards more preventive care across generati Cross-country: Investment in health care matters - (Time invariant unobserved heterogeneity) - People in times & places with higher spending in health have more chances to have regular care (Economic growth per se matters less) 2. Further Work… Duration analysis of “Age start regular health care”... Any suggestions? Thank you! Discussion Disparities in Regular Health Care Utilisation in Europe: A Life-time Analysis – Nicolas Sirven & Zeynep Or (2010)