Learning Forum: Regulatory Issues Affecting Contracts and Operations in the Near Term Presented to the SEE Joint Use Committee by Charles A. Zdebski Troutman.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Business and Legal Issues in Developing Vacant Land and Underutilized Existing Buildings Jeffrey G. Wright Nixon Peabody LLP June 28, 2007.
Advertisements

Regulatory-Utility Dispute Settlement Process Dennis J. Buckley Office of Administrative Law Judge Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission.
Straight Talk on Tough Infrastructure Access Issues Charles A. ZdebskiEric B. Langley Troutman Sanders LLPBalch & Bingham LLP Washington, DCBirmingham,
1 Licensing in the Energy Sector Georgian National Energy And Water Supply Regulation Commission Nugzar Beridze June 27 – July 3, 2008.
Federal Communications Commission Intergovernmental Advisory Committee
October 30, 2014 Terry Wolf, Manager of Transmission Services.
Net Metering and Interconnection Stakeholder Discussion Net Metering and Interconnection Stakeholder Meeting September 21, 2012 Discussion of.
Economic Criteria for Transmission Planning in the ERCOT Region Public Utility Law Seminar DeAnn Walker August 3, 2012.
Upcoming FCC Spectrum Auctions Bryan N. Tramont Wilkinson Barker Knauer, LLP
1 March 1, 2007 Report An Overview October 30, 2006 – Staff Workshop.
©Troutman Sanders LLP Joint Use and Pole Attachment Issues Troutman Sanders LLP November 7-8, 2007 Columbus, Ohio.
Oregon Public Utility Commission Safety and Reliability Section Jerry Murray, Manager Bob Sipler, Utility Analyst What is an “Attachment”? … that’s easy!
B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N 1 Network Operating Committee (NOC) June 12 th, 2014.
WEI 2009 Joint Use Conference Boise, Idaho September 28, 2009 Richard J. Busch Busch Law Firm PLLC Kirkland, WA
CHIPPEWA FALLS AREA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT PROPOSED BUDGET.
Experience you can trust. Hurricane Hardening Commission Staff Workshop on Electric Utility Infrastructure Richard E. Brown, PhD, PE Tallahassee,
The role of ERE in Costumer Protection Eduard Elezi Albanian Regulatory Authority ERE Conference “Albanian Energy Sector, Challenges and Regulation” Tirana,
Customer Service Enforcement After AB 2987 John Risk Communications Support Group, Inc. (c) 2006 John Risk Communications Support Group, Inc. (c) 2006.
Electric Infrastructure Workshop Gulf Power Company January 23, 2006.
SDG&E Electric Reliability Reporting CPUC Workshops May 26-27, 2015.
Legislative Update: What’s Happening on the Hill? Presented to the SEE Joint Use Committee by Charles A. Zdebski Troutman Sanders LLP Washington, DC
IRSDA Conference What Do the Amendments to Indiana Code Section Mean to You? Kristina Kern Wheeler, General Counsel Ja-Deen L. Johnson, Consumer.
Utility Service Quality Regulation in Pennsylvania A Presentation For The NARUC Consumer Affairs Subcommittee September 27, 2005 By Wayne L. Williams,
1 of 19 Development of Industry Standards Energy Regulatory Partnership Program Abuja, Nigeria July 14-18, 2008 Ikechukwu N. Nwabueze, Ph.D. Director,
Small Renewable Generators Tony Marciano Public Utility Commission of Texas May 2, 2007 (512)
Washington, D.C. ● Brussels ● San Francisco ● Shanghai FCC Pole Attachment Order - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly REMDC 2011 Annual Meeting.
FERC’s Role in Demand Response David Kathan ABA Teleconference December 14, 2005.
Storm Hardening Workshop Docket No Verizon Florida, Inc. July 13, 2006.
Discussion of Market Participant Choice for Transmission Connections Stakeholder Session October 14, 2011.
1 Overview of Reliability Requirements XYZ Cooperative Date: abc.
BROADBAND ACCELERATION INITIATIVE: POLES, ROW State and Local Government Webinar (FCC) Oct. 5, 2011.
The Energy Policy Act of 2005 and Its Revisions to PURPA November 11, 2005 Grace D. Soderberg Assistant General Counsel National Association of Regulatory.
MPSC Licensing Issues Energy Regulatory Partnership Program Abuja, Nigeria July 14-18, 2008 Presented by Robert W. Kehres.
It is a definite goal, course or method of action, set of rules designed to manage and control a system. It dictates our present and future decisions.
Demand Response in Energy and Capacity Markets David Kathan FERC IRPS Conference May 12, 2006.
SCAN NATOA 16 th Annual Spring Conference and Star Awards June 21, 2012 Legislative/Regulatory Update.
©2003 By THELEN REID & PRIEST LLP 1 NRECA/NRTC Joint Conference July James A. Stenger Regulatory Impacts on BPL What ’s Happening at the FCC.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
INC Report to the NANC - September 25, INC Report to the NANC September 25, 2003 Dana Smith - INC Moderator Ken Havens - INC Assistant Moderator.
The Utility Consumer Bill of Rights Information About the Rights and Responsibilities of Utility Consumers in the District of Columbia DC Office of the.
Utah Geothermal Power Generation Workshop Regulatory Issues August 17, 2005 Presented by Becky Wilson Utility Economist Utah Public Service Commission.
Order 1000 Implementation in PJM – Challenges and Opportunities Jodi L. Moskowitz Senior Director – Transmission Development & Strategy October 13, 2015.
ANNEXATION. WHY ANNEXATION CITIES PAY FOR A WIDE ARRAY OF SERVICES AND FACILITIES THAT BENEFIT ENTIRE REGIONS AND THE ENTIRE STATE. MOST STATES RECOGNIZE.
2009 Hurricane Season Preparations Florida Public Utilities Company May 6, 2009.
Level 3 Petition for Forbearance from Interstate and Intrastate Switched Access Charges Victoria R. Mandell Regulatory Counsel Level 3 Communications,
2015 HURRICANE SEASON PREPARATIONS March 18, 2015.
2009 Hurricane Season Preparedness Briefing Gulf Power Company Presented by Andy McQuagge Power Delivery Services Manager May 6, 2009.
2008 Hurricane Season Preparedness Briefing Gulf Power Company Presented by Andy McQuagge Power Delivery Services Manager May 1, 2008.
Network Reliability and Interoperability Council Focus Group 3 April 14, 1999 Ray Albers- Bell Atlantic Focus Group III Chair.
© 2010 AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved. AT&T and the AT&T logo are trademarks of AT&T Intellectual Property. Intercarrier Compensation.
New CPUC Order on Pole Attachments Wireless West Conference Anaheim, California April 21, 2016 Charlotte F. TerKeurst Program Manager Electric Safety and.
San Antonio: Striking the Balance FCC DAS/Small Cell Workshop May 3, 2016 Ron Nirenberg San Antonio City Councilmember Member, FCC-IAC.
Briefing on New Franchise Ordinances for Telecommunications & Video Services Applicant: Verizon.
Florida Keys Electric Cooperative Association, Inc. Storm Hardening Florida Public Service Commission May 1, 2008 Scott Newberry, CEO John Stuart, COO.
SPECTRUM WARS 2002 The FCC’s RF Lighting Proceeding (ET Docket 98-42) Robert D. Primosch, Esq. Wilkinson Barker Knauer, LLP Washington, D.C.
AEMCPresentation to GWCFPAGE 1 AEMC and Rule changes Presentation to AEMO Gas Wholesale Consultative Forum Kamlesh Khelawan Director This presentation.
UTC STUDY OF DISTRIBUTED GENERATION AND RECOMMENDATIONS Presentation for the Washington Future Energy Conference October 19, 2011.
Interim Fuel Factor Adjustment and Surcharge for Under-Recoveries
Application of Northern Virginia Electric Cooperative PUE
High School Capacity Committee
2008 Hurricane Season Preparations
Marsha Spellman, JD Regulatory Director, WST October 17, 2016
JOINT USE 101: Past, Present & Future Southwest Electric Distribution Exchange Horseshoe Bay, Texas May 4, 2017 Eric Langley.
2007 Hurricane Season Preparations
Florida PSC 2014 Hurricane Season Preparation
NPA 450/579 (Area Code) Relief in Quebec
NPA 403/587/780/825 (Area Code) Relief in Alberta
Neopay Practical Guides #2 PSD2 (Should I be worried?)
Presentation transcript:

Learning Forum: Regulatory Issues Affecting Contracts and Operations in the Near Term Presented to the SEE Joint Use Committee by Charles A. Zdebski Troutman Sanders LLP Washington, DC

WIRELESS ACCESS ISSUES Negotiations with wireless carriers for access to poles are now more common than with cable companies. Some frequently arising issues: –Annual rental rate (no FCC formula) –Location of antenna on the pole (top of pole) –Change-out to taller pole / pole-top extenders –Transmission structures (definition of transmission vs distribution pole) –Ingress and egress to pole site –Prior review/approval by utility of antenna(s)

WIRELESS ACCESS ISSUES (Continued) –Location of power supplies on or near pole (additional rent; pad site) –Reclamation of pole space by utility –Rf exposure from radiating antenna –Rf cut-off (switch on pole or call to NOC?) –Provisions to limit competing sources of rf interference –Considerations relating to state utility commissions’ concerns for infrastructure reliability and continuation of service during and after storms or other events (e.g., Florida pole hardening proceedings)

TREND: STILL MORE WIRELESS! Licenses awarded by FCC in Auction 66, “Advanced Wireless Services,” concluded September 18, 2006 Negotiations to relocate incumbent microwave operators (probably your utility) are now underway; pole access negotiations will follow FCC opened WT Docket on September 7, 2007, to consider service rules for yet another Advanced Wireless Services band ( MHz) Auction 73, (700 MHz band, a/k/a the “beachfront property” for wireless service) begins January 24, 2008

ARE YOU PREPARED FOR RULE CHANGES? Strong rumor that FCC may initiate rule making in response to Fibertech (codify pole access practices) and USTA (regulated access by ILECs) petitions and seek to unify the cable rate formula and telecom rate formula Are you prepared to file comments? Will your contract with cable providers allow you to implement a higher rate?

Other Important Current Issues Rate for VoIP Attachments Counting Telecom Attachments Collecting Past Due Amounts

Rate for VoIP Attachments FCC’s IP-Enabled Proceeding Several cases

Counting Telecom Attachments Often raised by cable companies Several pending cases

Collecting Past Due Amounts A longstanding problem The only solution is good contracts and strong state law cases

CURRENT CASES TO WATCH Charter v. Ameren (collecting telecom rate for telephone service by cable company) Georgia Power v. Comcast (counting average number of attaching entities for purposes of the telecom rate) TECO v. Brighthouse (telecom transport by affiliate not a party to the access agreement) ACTA v. Entergy (permissible utility practices)

Charter v. Ameren VoIP Counting Telecom Attachments Trial in December

Georgia Power v. Comcast Two cases pending Average number of attachments Counting telecom attachments Typical dance moves

TECO v. Brighthouse Similar to Ameren v. Charter Transport State case stayed

ACTA v. Entergy -- Arkansas Major Proceeding at FCC, Arkansas Cable Television Association v. Entergy Arkansas, Inc., EB Docket No Arkansas Act 740, March 30, 2007, “To vest the Arkansas Public Service Commission with Jurisdiction over Pole Attachment Agreements and Disputes…” –Requires PSC to adopt rules within 1 year

Arkansas (continued) –Parties Entitled to Nondiscriminatory Access Include Electric Utilities (compare, US Telecom petition at FCC) and Internet Access Service Providers –Does not Cover Rights-of-way –PSC Required to Consider Reliability of Public Utility Services –PSC Authority to Resolve Complaints

Florida In response to two straight devastating hurricane seasons and a long-range forecast for a prolonged period of worse than average hurricanes, the Florida PSC adopted rules to require utilities to “Storm Harden” their system (Docket No EU). Rule Electric Infrastructure Storm Hardening: Each utility must file a comprehensive storm hardening plan for review and approval by the FPSC. The initial plans are due within three months of the effective date of the rule (May 7, 2007), then every three years thereafter. –Each storm hardening plan must identify the extent to which collocation facilities are affected. –Attachment Standards and Procedures governing the safety, reliability, pole loading capacity, and engineering standards and procedures for third-party attachments must be included. –Each plan must contain an estimate of the costs and benefits to the utility such as reductions in storm restoration costs and outages. –Each plan must provide an estimate of the costs and benefits to third- party attachers, with such information to be provided to the utility by the affected third-party attachers.

Florida (cont’d) Audits of Joint-Use Facilities (Docket No EI) –In April 2006, the Florida PSC found that Florida’s utilities had not provided adequate assurance that their practices and procedures governing joint-use facilities serve to mitigate storm damages and customer outages. –Florida PSC required each utility to establish a plan, an implementation timeline, and a calculation of rate impacts to audit joint-use agreements that include pole strength assessments. –Each utility’s plan includes the stress impacts of all pole attachments as an integral part of its eight-year pole inspection program. –The Commission required that each utility reevaluate its plan annually to assess the need for any adjustment. –Hearings held October 3 rd