The Local Problem Natalie Colabianchi, Ph.D. Chris Kippes, M.S. Mireya Diaz-Insua, Ph.D. Alfred Rimm, Ph.D. Jessica Diggs In cooperation with: Cuyahoga.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
NFPA Urban Fire Safety Project Urban Fire Forum October 21, 2011 Sharon Gamache Program Director High-Risk Outreach Programs.
Advertisements

Toledo Collaboration for Lead Safe Housing 2014 Ohio Healthy Homes Summit Matthew Currie, Esq. Advocates for Basic Legal Equality.
A Look at the Future of Children’s Health Insurance Coverage Joan Alker, Executive Director Georgetown University Center for Children and Families January.
1 City of New Orleans Health Department Lead Poisoning in New Orleans Safe & Healthy Homes Initiative Presented by: Kevin U. Stephens, Sr., MD, JD Director.
© 2013 Empire Justice Center How Detailed Data Analysis Reveals the True Face of Suburban Poverty PART 2 September 26, 2013 Presented by: Michael L. Hanley.
Looking at Stroke Mortality, Hospitalization and Service Delivery through Maps Presenters from the Iowa Department of Public Health Terry Meek, GIS Training.
Foreclosure Trends Frank Ford Senior Vice President for Research and Development Neighborhood Progress, Inc. June 15, 2012.
Cuyahoga County Partnership for Tobacco Reduction: Results from the Adult Tobacco Surveillance Survey E. Borawski 1, S. Zelenskiy 1, E. Trapl.
The Sunbelt = High Growth!. World (Now) 6,571,046,993 US (Now) 301,005,394 Georgia Estimate Census projections for July 20069,028,029 Georgia (July 2006)
Henry Clay’s plan to make economy self- sufficientHenry Clay’s plan to make economy self- sufficient Protective tariffProtective tariff –Protect American.
Segregation and Concentration of Poverty: The Role of Suburban Sprawl Paul A. Jargowsky University of Texas at Dallas and Centre de Sciences Humaines.
Which factors make a difference when identifying pockets of under-immunization? Gayle Moxness Hennepin County Community Health Department Minneapolis,
Stunning Progress, Hidden Problems: The Dramatic Decline of Concentrated Poverty in the 1990s Paul A. Jargowsky University of Texas at Dallas May 19, 2003.
Homicide Predictions : Saint Louis City IS6833 February 28, 2010 Group B: Chris Gaynor Robert Jones Kevin Prinke Poernomo Wikandjojo.
The Global Report Card Jay P. Greene, University of Arkansas Josh B. McGee, The Laura and John Arnold Foundation.
Promoting the Economic and Social Vitality of Rural America: The Demographic Context Rural Education Conference New Orleans, LA April 14, 2003 by Dr. Daryl.
Asthma Prevalence in the United States National Center for Environmental Health Division of Environmental Hazards and Health Effects June 2014.
Who is ProvPlan? Mission to promote the economic and social well-being of the city, its people, and its neighborhoods. 501(c)3 non-profit created in 1992.
Racial Segregation in urban-rural continuum: do patterns by geographical region? Racial Segregation in urban-rural continuum: do patterns vary by geographical.
Childhood Lead Poisoning in New York State Symposium To Examine Lead Poisoning in NYS March 13, 2006 Rachel de Long, M.D., M.P.H. Director, Bureau of Child.
REFERENCES ABSTRACT BACKGROUND METHODS RESULTS DISCUSSION CONCLUSION ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Assessing the Risks and Knowledge of Econominically-Disadvantaged,
The Burden Of Obesity Alison Patrick, MPH, RD, LD Cuyahoga County Board of Health.
Meagan Hatton Department of Geography POVERTY AND HIV/AIDS IN EAST TEXAS.
Literacy and Poverty in Greater Cleveland
Jack Buckley Commissioner National Center for Education Statistics December 7, 2011.
Environmental Risks in the Southern Central Valley, California A presentation for: Californians for Environmental Justice By: Dan Williams.
Coastal Bend and State Population % Distribution by Age Groups % Fewer in Working Age Source: US Census.
Community Needs Assessment Project Highlights and Key Findings of Data Analysis.
IDENTIFICATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SOURCES OF LEAD EXPOSURE IN NUNAVUT (CANADA) USING STABLE ISOTOPE ANALYSES Myriam Fillion 1,2, Jules Blais 2, Emmanuel.
DEVELOPMENT AND USAGE OF METROPOLITAN STATISTICAL DATA IN SELECTED U.S. CITIES Anna Marie Schuh Associate Professor Roosevelt University Metropolitan International.
Poverty and HIV Infection: NHBS National* and San Diego Findings Vanessa Miguelino-Keasling, MPH National HIV Behavioral Surveillance System.
Addressing Community Pb Concerns: A Health Screening and Education Approach Across Three States Mary O. Dereski, Ph.D. Associate Professor Institute of.
Analyzing the Teen Wellness Program using the YRBS Prevention Research Center for Healthy Neighborhoods, Case Western Reserve University Gloria Agosto.
Analysis of Salmonella Data for Health Disparities by Socioeconomic Status, King County, WA, 2000 and 2010 Atar Baer 1,2, Jenny Lloyd 1, Jeffrey S. Duchin.
Old Louisville by the Numbers A Statistical Profile by Michael Price Urban Studies Institute University of Louisville Spring 2006.
Texas Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program Diana L. Salzman, MPH Adult Lead Surveillance Coordinator.
Improving Lead Screening Rates Through The Use of Statewide Immunization Registry Data Jacob L. Bidwell, MD Medical Director, Aurora Clarke Square Family.
Jack Buckley Commissioner National Center for Education Statistics February 24, 2011.
Housing Trends In Cuyahoga County __________ Is The Foreclosure Crisis Over? It Depends On Where You’re Standing. Frank Ford Senior Policy Advisor, Thriving.
Utah Department of Health 1 1 Identifying Peer Areas for Community Health Collaboration and Data Smoothing Brian Paoli Utah Department of Health 6/6/2007.
Stuart Kerachsky Deputy Commissioner National Center for Education Statistics December 8, 2009.
CityMatCH: Equity-Science-Leadership to Reduce Gaps in Infant Mortality Chad Abresch, MEd Executive Director, CityMatCH
Additional analysis of poverty in Scotland 2013/14 Communities Analytical Services July 2015.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Millions of uninsured Source: Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: United States Census Bureau,
Institute for Urban Policy and Research Analysis, Professor Tang November 19, 2013 Ryan Robinson City Demographer Planning & Development Review Department.
Health and Welfare Building Harrisburg, PA (717)
Lead Exposure Among Females of Childbearing Age — United States, 2004 What Does ABLES Tell Us? Sara Luckhaupt, MD, MPH Surveillance Branch CDC, NIOSH,
Client-level Analysis of Emergency Shelters: Columbus and Franklin County, Ohio RLUS Steering Committee Presentation December 5, 2006.
Modeling and Forecasting Household and Person Level Control Input Data for Advance Travel Demand Modeling Presentation at 14 th TRB Planning Applications.
Finding a Predictive Model for Post-Hospitalization Adverse Events Henry Carretta 1, PhD, MPH; Katrina McAfee 1,2, MS; Dennis Tsilimingras 1,3, MD, MPH.
Housing Trends In Cuyahoga County __________ Is The Foreclosure Crisis Over? It Depends On Where You’re Standing. Analysis by Frank Ford Senior Policy.
Stuart Kerachsky Deputy Commissioner National Center for Education Statistics May 20, 2010.
2015 English Indices of Deprivation – Torbay Contact: Torbay Public Health.
Sample Brand Q2 Facebook Report April - June 2015.
HEALTH DISPARITIES IN OHIO Lashale D. Pugh Ph.D. October 29, 2015.
Community Foundation of Collier County Our Mission: To improve the quality of life in Collier County by connecting donors to community needs and providing.
Spatial Changes in Public School Enrollments in Wisconsin Mitch Collins.
. Associations between natural amenities, physical activity, and body mass index in rural and urban North Carolina counties Stephanie B. Jilcott 1, PhD,
HEALTHY HOMES DATA USING PUBLICLY AVAILABLE DATA TO STRENGTHEN YOUR HEALTHY HOMES PROGRAM Amanda Reddy, MS National Center for Healthy Housing.
BREAST CANCER BY STAGE OF DISEASE AT DIAGNOSIS, CENTRAL OKLAHOMA Arthur Owora, MPH; Aaron Wendelboe, PhD; David Thompson, PhD; Janis Campbell, PhD The.
Diabetes Disparities in Washington State: Exploring Changes Over Time Presentation to the Washington State Diabetes Leadership Team Marilyn Sitaker July,
Blacks account for 13% of the population in the United States.
Status of Lead in Detroit
Medicaid Funded Lead Abatement and Statewide Lead-Safe Rental Registry
Using Longitudinal Data on Readmission Rates to Guide and Evaluate Interventions to Control Pediatric Asthma Henry J. Carretta, MPH, Virginia Commonwealth.
Health and Health Care for Blacks in the United States
Kewl Stuff from Ch. 2.
Cathy Schoen Senior Vice President The Commonwealth Fund
2017 HIV/AIDS Epidemiology profile Cleveland/cuyahoga county
Immunization Disparities in U. S
Presentation transcript:

The Local Problem Natalie Colabianchi, Ph.D. Chris Kippes, M.S. Mireya Diaz-Insua, Ph.D. Alfred Rimm, Ph.D. Jessica Diggs In cooperation with: Cuyahoga County Board of Health Cleveland Department of Public Health

Background Lead poisoning may be the most significant environmental problem facing our children Lead poisoning may be the most significant environmental problem facing our children Nationally and locally, lead levels in children have been decreasing dramatically over the past 20 years Nationally and locally, lead levels in children have been decreasing dramatically over the past 20 years –Much of the decline is due to the removal of lead from gasoline Rates remain high in urban areas and in poor communities Rates remain high in urban areas and in poor communities Steep rates of decline not likely to continue Steep rates of decline not likely to continue

Ohio compared to 18 other states

Cuyahoga County relative to other counties in Ohio EBLL (10  g/dL +) Cuyahoga17% Cuyahoga17% Hamilton 7% Hamilton 7% Franklin 2% Franklin 2% Lucas11% Lucas11% Mahoning 14% Mahoning 14% Summit 1% Summit 1%

Estimated Number of Children with Elevated Blood Lead Levels (EBLL) CityEst. Children w/EBLL (10  g/dL +) 1. New York, NY41, Chicago, IL20, Los Angeles, CA15, Detroit, MI12, Philadelphia, PA11, Baltimore, MD 6, Houston, TX 6, Cleveland, OH 5, New Orleans, LA 4, Milwaukee, WI 4, Milwaukee, WI 4,600

Cleveland relative to other cities in Ohio EBLL (10  g/dL +) Cleveland20% Cleveland20% Cincinnati 7% Cincinnati 7% Columbus 2% Columbus 2% Toledo12% Toledo12% Youngstown16% Youngstown16% Akron 2% Akron 2%

Local Data Years Years ,190 tests representing 82,396 children 130,190 tests representing 82,396 children 33% of children had more than one test 33% of children had more than one test Included only children less than 6 years of age Included only children less than 6 years of age Children across the years: Children across the years: –28404 children tested in 1997 –27603 children tested in 1998 –24371 children tested in 1999 –23441 children tested in 2000

Sampling Data come from mandatory reporting; Not a random sample Data come from mandatory reporting; Not a random sample Proportions are influenced by rates of testing, who is tested and requirements for testing Proportions are influenced by rates of testing, who is tested and requirements for testing Cleveland is considered a universal screening area Cleveland is considered a universal screening area Medicaid population also mandated to be tested Medicaid population also mandated to be tested Other high risk zip codes in Cuyahoga County with universal designation Other high risk zip codes in Cuyahoga County with universal designation

High risk zip codes with universal designation

Defining a confirmed test Venous tests are confirmed tests Venous tests are confirmed tests Capillary tests under 10  g/dL are confirmed tests Capillary tests under 10  g/dL are confirmed tests Capillary tests with results of 10  g/dL or higher need a second test within the CDC guidelines to be confirmed Capillary tests with results of 10  g/dL or higher need a second test within the CDC guidelines to be confirmed Other tests were deemed unconfirmed and child was consider not elevated Other tests were deemed unconfirmed and child was consider not elevated

Analyses 1. Proportion of children with EBLL  In year 2000  Across census tracts  Trends from 1997 to 2000  Demographic correlates  Neighborhoods and municipalities with high proportions of elevated children 2. Average levels over time 3. Multiple children in a household 4. Numbers of children tested

Proportion of children with EBLL in year 2000 In Cleveland, 20.3% of children, one out of five, have blood lead levels that are elevated (e.g., 10  g/dL or higher) In Cleveland, 20.3% of children, one out of five, have blood lead levels that are elevated (e.g., 10  g/dL or higher) In Cuyahoga County, 8.5% of children have blood lead levels that are elevated (e.g., 10  g/dL or higher) In Cuyahoga County, 8.5% of children have blood lead levels that are elevated (e.g., 10  g/dL or higher)

Cuyahoga County

 g/dL Proportion of children with EBLL >10  g/dL in Year 2000

 g/dL Proportion of children with EBLL > 10  g/dL in Year 2000 Cleveland Only

 g/dL Proportion of children with EBLL > 10  g/dL in Year 2000 Cuyahoga County Only

 g/dL Proportion of children with EBLL > 10  g/dL in Year 2000 East Cleveland Only

4 Sub-areas

Proportion of children with EBLL ( 10  g/dL) Proportion of children with EBLL (> 10  g/dL) Geographic AreaYear 2000 Cleveland20.3 Cleveland20.3 East Cleveland27.7 East Cleveland27.7 Inner Ring Suburbs4.9 Inner Ring Suburbs4.9 Outer Ring Suburbs1.8 Outer Ring Suburbs1.8

Trends over Time: Proportion of children with EBLL ( 10  g/dL ) Trends over Time: Proportion of children with EBLL ( > 10  g/dL ) mg/dL % of children with > 10 mg/dL

Proportion of children with EBLL ( 25  g/dL) Proportion of children with EBLL (> 25  g/dL) Geographic AreaYear 2000 Cleveland1.9% Cleveland1.9% East Cleveland3.2% East Cleveland3.2% Inner Ring Suburbs0.5% Inner Ring Suburbs0.5% Outer Ring Suburbs0.2% Outer Ring Suburbs0.2%

Trends over Time: Proportion of children with EBLL ( 25  g/dL ) Trends over Time: Proportion of children with EBLL ( > 25  g/dL ) mg/dL % of children with > 25 mg/dL

Proportion of children with EBLL ( 45  g/dL) Proportion of children with EBLL (> 45  g/dL) Geographic AreaYear 2000 Cleveland0.2 Cleveland0.2 East Cleveland0.3 East Cleveland0.3 Inner Ring Suburbs0.1 Inner Ring Suburbs0.1 Outer Ring Suburbs0.0 Outer Ring Suburbs0.0

Trends over Time – Proportion of children with EBLL ( 45  g/dL ) Trends over Time – Proportion of children with EBLL ( > 45  g/dL ) mg/dL % of children with > 45 mg/dL

Tracts with EBLL of 45  g/dL and 70  g/dL Tracts with EBLL of > 45  g/dL and > 70  g/dL

Areas with children that have BLL 45  g/dL Areas with children that have BLL > 45  g/dL Neighborhoods with children 45  g/dL Neighborhoods with children > 45  g/dL  Clark-Fulton  Corlett  Cudell  Detroit-Shoreway  Fairfax  Forest Hills  Glenville  Hough  Mt. Pleasant  North Collinwood  South Broadway  South Collinwood  St. Clair-Superior  Union-Miles  Woodland Hills  Cleveland Heights  East Cleveland  Garfield Heights

Areas with children that have BLL 70  g/dL Areas with children that have BLL > 70  g/dL Neighborhoods with children 70  g/dL Neighborhoods with children > 70  g/dL  Cudell  Fairfax  Glenville  North Collinwood  Union-Miles

Demographic correlates

 g/dL Proportion of children with EBLL >10  g/dL in Year 2000

Percent of Housing Built before 1950

Median Levels of Income

Cleveland

Statistical Planning Areas with over 12% of children having BLL of 10  g/dL Statistical Planning Areas with over 12% of children having BLL of > 10  g/dL Cleveland Only

Cleveland Neighborhoods

Highest and Lowest Neighborhoods in Cleveland over Time

6 Highest and 6 Lowest Neighborhoods in Cleveland Year 2000

3 Highest Neighborhoods by Tract

St. Clair-Superior Tract% with EBLL of 10  g/dL + (N) (36) (26) (103) (116) (194) (94) (80) Overall SPA37.7 (671) Note: Tract had insufficient sample and is therefore not reported

3 Highest Neighborhoods by Tract - Glenville Tract %BL 10+ (N) (97) (70) (62) (71) (219) Tract %BL 10+ (N) (185) (115) (164) (143) (96) Overall SPA = 32.0 (1222)

3 Highest Neighborhoods by Tract – Fairfax Tract % with EBLL of 10+ (N) (43) (53) (97) (69) (45) Overall SPA 31.3 (320) Note: Tracts 1131, 1132 and 1139 have insufficient sample and are therefore not reported

Municipalities

Municipalities with EBLL of >10  g/dL

Census Tracts in East Cleveland

Census Tracts in Cleveland Heights

Census Tracts in Shaker Heights

East Cleveland, Cleveland Heights and Shaker Heights

Census Tracts in Garfield Heights

Average levels of those with elevated blood levels over time

Lead Levels of those 10  g/dL over time Lead Levels of those > 10  g/dL over time

Average levels of those 10  g/dL over time Average levels of those > 10  g/dL over time mg/dL Average levels of those > 10 mg/dL

Individuals over time

Multiple Children in a Household

Households with >1 Child Tested and Measured BLL  25  g/dL HH + East Cleveland Cleveland Heights Shaker Heights Glenville All high 107 (0.8%) Mixed 803 (6.3%) All low11864 (92.9%)

Households with >1 Child Tested Households with >1 Child Tested BLL  25  g/dL CUYAHOGA All high 107 (0.8%) Mixed 803 (6.3%) All low11864 (92.9%) CLEVELAND All high 97 (1.0%) Mixed 697 (7.2%) All low 8885 (91.8%) CLEV HTS, EAST CLEV, SHAKER HTS All high 10 (1.0%) Mixed 81 (7.6%) All low 971 (91.4%) OTHERS All high 0 (0.0%) Mixed 25 (1.2%) All low 2030 (98.8%)

Households with >1 Child Tested Households with >1 Child Tested BLL  10  g/dL CUYAHOGA All high 1715 (13.5%) Mixed 3581 (28.0%) All low 7478 (58.5%) CLEVELAND All high 1511 (15.6%) Mixed 3058 (31.6%) All low 5113 (52.8%) CLEV HTS, EAST CLEV, SHAKER HTS All high 160 (15.0%) Mixed 312 (29.4%) All low 590 (55.6%) OTHERS All high 44 (2.2%) Mixed 211 (10.4%) All low 1175 (87.4%)

Numbers of Children Tested

Conclusions

Summary Point 1 Cuyahoga County and Cleveland have high proportions of children with elevated blood lead levels relative to other counties and cities in the U.S. Cuyahoga County and Cleveland have high proportions of children with elevated blood lead levels relative to other counties and cities in the U.S.

Summary Point 2 Lead levels continue to decrease although at a slower rate than previously seen Lead levels continue to decrease although at a slower rate than previously seen

Summary Point 3 Age of housing and income levels are associated with lead levels in Cleveland and in Cuyahoga County as has been seen nationally Age of housing and income levels are associated with lead levels in Cleveland and in Cuyahoga County as has been seen nationally

Summary Point 4 Many neighborhoods in Cleveland and East Cleveland show consistently high percentages of children with elevated blood lead levels across census tracts Many neighborhoods in Cleveland and East Cleveland show consistently high percentages of children with elevated blood lead levels across census tracts

Summary Point 5 Over time, the percent of children with elevated lead levels has decreased Over time, the percent of children with elevated lead levels has decreased However the average level of those that test over 10 has remained fairly constant However the average level of those that test over 10  g/dL has remained fairly constant

Summary Point 6 There are some households with multiple children under six in Cleveland and some municipalities where all the tested children have elevated blood lead levels There are some households with multiple children under six in Cleveland and some municipalities where all the tested children have elevated blood lead levels

Summary Point 7 Children that are required to be lead tested are not being tested Children that are required to be lead tested are not being tested

Conclusion We have made important progress in the past couple years but need to continue our efforts to provide our children a healthy environment in which they can thrive We have made important progress in the past couple years but need to continue our efforts to provide our children a healthy environment in which they can thrive

Acknowledgements Cuyahoga County Board of Health Cuyahoga County Board of Health –Terry Allan, M.P.H., R.S. –Chris Kippes, M.S. –John Sobolewski, R.S. –John McLeod, R.S. Cleveland Department of Public Health Cleveland Department of Public Health –Wayne Slota –Jonathan Brandt –Wendy Johnson, M.D. –Matt Carroll, J.D.

The Local Problem For further information contact: Natalie Colabianchi: Case Western Reserve University