Pakistan Punjab Female Stipend Program Evaluating the Impact.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Poverty and the Environment Understanding Linkages at the Household Level Kirk Hamilton The World Bank.

Advertisements

MICS4 Survey Design Workshop Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys Survey Design Workshop Household Questionnaire: Education.

Global Child Poverty Study Sierra Leone Report to the Regional Workshop in Abidjan 12 th -14 th February 2008.

Baela Raza Jamil Zara Khan Zaheer Abbas PRESENTED AT: Comparative and International Education Society (CIES) – 10 th to 16 th March 2014 Effects of Parental.

According to the Statistical Yearbook for 2010, in 2008/09 year, only 41% of the total number of children in Serbia, aged between 0 and 7 years, were enrolled.

AME Education Sector Profile

The World Bank Human Development Network Spanish Impact Evaluation Fund.

Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys Data dissemination and further analysis workshop Literacy Education MICS4 Data Dissemination and Further Analysis Workshop.

Public Expenditure in Latin America: Trends and Key Policy Issues Benedict Clements Western Hemisphere Department International Monetary Fund* ECLAC Fiscal.

School meals and child outcomes in India Farzana Afridi, Delhi School of Economics IGC-ISI Conference, 20 th – 21 st December, 2010.

AME Education Sector Profile

The Impact of Electricity Tariff Reforms and Alternative Mitigating Measures David Coady PSIA Group Fiscal Affairs Department International Monetary Fund.

Evaluating the Impact of Food Stamps and Microfinance Evidence from Sri Lanka Dr. Iffath A. Sharif.

Annotated Bibliography Presentation April 17, 2013 Carol Redmond ED 521: Educational Research and Analysis Flipping Literacy and Improved Reading Levels.

Targeting the Hardcore Poor An Impact Assessment March, 2011 Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo, Raghabendra Chattopadhyay and Jeremy Shapiro.

Non Experimental Design in Education Ummul Ruthbah.

Impact Evaluation for Evaluating Social Safety Nets at the World Bank Javier E. Baez Economist IEG World Bank AEA Conference San Antonio, TX November 12,

Name: Course: Cert II in General education for Adults Kangan Institute V2013.

Pathway to progress: Girls making the grade in rural Sindh Theresa Castillo, MA CHES * Teachers College, Columbia University.

Gender and Impact Evaluation

MEXICO ’ S PROGRESA PROGRAM: WHO BENEFITS? A Presentation by Deon Filmer Of Material by David Coady.

Using willingness to pay data to inform the design of health insurance for the poor: evidence from micro-lending clients in Lagos, Nigeria November 1,

Recent Trends in Worker Quality: A Midwest Perspective Daniel Aaronson and Daniel Sullivan Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago November 2002.

Comments on “Testing alternative approaches to CCT programs in education: evidence from Colombia” IEN, LACEA, October 2007.

1 Discrepancies between National and International Data WORKSHOP ON MDG MONITORING BANGKOK, THAILAND 14 th – 16 th January 2009 By W.J.Nigamuni Deputy.

Effect of a values-based prevention curriculum on HIV- positive couples from four regions in Ethiopia Presented at XIX IAC 2012 By Misgina Suba, MPH 25.

Evaluating a test-based subsidy program for low-cost private schools: Regression-discontinuity evidence from Pakistan Felipe Barrera-Osorio Dhushyanth.

T Balochistan Launch – 29 March ASER PAKISTAN ASER - The Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) is a citizen led large scale national.

The World Bank Human Development Network Spanish Impact Evaluation Fund.

November 6, 2003Social Policy Monitoring Network1 Evaluation of the pilot phase of the Social Safety Net (RPS) * in Nicaragua: Health and Nutrition Impacts.

Public Social Expenditures Education (2.3 percent of GDP) Health (1 percent of GDP) Social protection (1 percent of GDP) -- equal to $12 per capita and.

Assessing progress towards universal primary education in the Kassena-Nankana District Cornelius Debpuur George Wak Paul Welaga Navrongo Health Research.

The World Bank Human Development Network Spanish Impact Evaluation Fund.

Kazakhstan AME EDUCATION SECTOR PROFILE. Education Structure Source: World Development Indicators, UNESCO Institute for Statistics. Kazakhstan Education.

AFRICA IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE, AFTRL Africa Program for Education Impact Evaluation David Evans Impact Evaluation Cluster, AFTRL Slides by Paul J.

Pilot Program: Conditional Cash Transfers (CCT) to Increase Girls’ Participation in Education Kano & Bauchi States, Nigeria Presented by Sadi Yahaya SESP.

1 Key Uses of Household Survey Data Kathleen Beegle Workshop 17, Session 1b Designing and Implementing Household Surveys March 31, 2009.

1 John Page, Chief Economist Africa Region, World Bank October 31, 2006 EIGHT THINGS YOU (MAY NOT) KNOW ABOUT AFRICA.

Applying impact evaluation tools A hypothetical fertilizer project.

Non-experimental methods Markus Goldstein The World Bank DECRG & AFTPM.

Gender and CCTs in South Asia Education Nazmul Chaudhury Washington DC, October

Dist Chiniot Launch – 11 Feb ASER PAKISTAN 2011  ASER- Annual Status of Education report is a survey of the quality of education.  ASER seeks.

Targeting of Public Spending Menno Pradhan Senior Poverty Economist The World Bank office, Jakarta.

Implementing an impact evaluation under constraints Emanuela Galasso (DECRG) Prem Learning Week May 2 nd, 2006.

Economic Analysis of Education: Public-Private Roles E. Jimenez March 2008.

5 Education for All Development Issues in Africa Spring 2007.

Bosna i Hercegovina Agencija za statistiku Bosne i Hercegovine Bosnia and Herzegovina Agency for Statistics of Bosnia and Herzegovina Tirana, November.

Randomized Assignment Difference-in-Differences

Caner ESENYEL Senior Expert on Family and Social Policy “Workshop on Social Assistance Systems” October 2015 ANKARA, Turkey CENTRAL REGULAR CASH.

A Webinar for Girls Not Brides members and partners

Bilal Siddiqi Istanbul, May 12, 2015 Measuring Impact: Non-Experimental Methods.

PUNJAB EDUCATION SECTOR REFOME POGRAM (PESRP)

Remittances and Human Capital Investment: Evidence from Albania Ermira Hoxha Kalaj December 2010.

The Social Protection Challenge in Middle income Countries

Helping reduce poverty in the short- and long-term: The experience of Conditional Cash Transfers Ariel Fiszbein The World Bank Delhi, October 24-26, 2007.

BISP - Pakistan’s Unique Social Safety Net Model Integrated Package of Services and Support for the Family (Nouman Ghani) May 30, 2013.

Revamping the Teaching Profession by Attracting Non-Teachers to It: Evidence from Enseña Chile Mariana Alfonso Education Division, Inter-American Development.

TRANSLATING RESEARCH INTO ACTION Randomized Evaluation Start-to-finish Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab povertyactionlab.org.

Kehinde Oluseyi Olagunju Szent Istvan University, Godollo, Hungary. “African Globalities – Global Africans” 4 th Pecs African Studies Conference, University.

Introduction, Conceptual Framework and Initial Findings

Empowering Women - Pakistan’s Experiences

Assessment on Literacy/ Life Skills

Promoting Gender Equality and Empowerment of Women

Propensity Score Matching Makes Program Evaluation Easy

Part 2: Country studies Monitoring the MDGs

Presentation to Parliamentary Portfolio Committee 31 May 2011

1 Causal Inference Counterfactuals False Counterfactuals

North Carolina Positive Behavior Support Initiative

Impact Evaluation Methods: Difference in difference & Matching

Felipe Barrera-Osorio (HDNED World Bank)

Presentation transcript:

Pakistan Punjab Female Stipend Program Evaluating the Impact

Outline  CCT Program  Evaluation question  Data and methodology  Impact estimates

Female Secondary School Stipends  Part of Punjab Education Sector Reform Program (PESRP), World Bank financed education program  PERSP – quality, access and governance  Female Stipends – CCT for middle school started in 2004

Stipends Program  Eligibility: girls enrolled in 6-8 grades in government schools in target districts  Target districts: 15 of the 34 districts were chosen based on the district’s female literacy rate  Conditionality: 80% average attendance  Amount: Rs 200 ($3) transferred directly to student via postal money order from EDO

Evaluation Question  Impact on enrolments  School switching  Impact across welfare quintiles  School Quality  Externality: male enrolments  Externality: health, marriage, malnutrition

Data  Government School Censuses 2003, 2005  LSMS-type national household surveys (PIHS , LSMS )  Growth in enrolments (absolute and relative)  Changes in school participation rates

Methodology  Estimating impact requires choosing a suitable comparison group  Simple before and after or between program and non-program groups are misleading  Combination of techniques  Difference-in-Difference (DD)  DD-in-Difference (DDD)  Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD)

School Level Census Data BasicRDD parametric RDD non- parametric DD absolute DDD absolute DD percent DDD percent Impact Estimates (net growth of girl enrolments per school )

National household data (PIHS , PSLM ) BasicRDD parametric DD percent DDD percent Impact Estimates II (net change in school participation rate)

Findings and next steps  Modest but statistically significant impact on enrolments  Evidence from national household survey data indicates stipends helping poor children attend schools  Preliminary evidence from primary survey data points to similar findings on enrolments  In the process of analyzing the linkage between stipends and quality (test scores)