Measuring Author Contributions to the Wikipedia B. Thomas Adler, Luca de Alfaro, Ian Pye and Vishwanath Raman Computer Science Dept. UC Santa Cruz, CA,

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Introduction to open access – Creative Commons licensing Where can I find free educational materials – Shared content sites – Creative Commons searches.

Advertisements

Measuring Reliability in Wikipedia Wen-Yuan Zhu

CPIT 102 CPIT 102 CHAPTER 1 COLLABORATING on DOCUMENTS.

1 Lesson 14 Sharing Documents Computer Literacy BASICS: A Comprehensive Guide to IC 3, 3 rd Edition Morrison / Wells.

Exploring the Filter Bubble: The Effect of Using Recommender Systems on Content Diversity Date: 2014/8/25 Author: Tien T.Nguyen, Pik-Mai Hui, F. Maxwell.

Explorations in Tag Suggestion and Query Expansion Jian Wang and Brian D. Davison Lehigh University, USA SSM 2008 (Workshop on Search in Social Media)

The user entered the query “What is the historical relation between Greek and Roma”. Here are the query’s results. The user clicked the topic “Roman copies.

To trust or not, is hardly the question! Sai Moturu.

Wikis This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial- Share Alike 3.0 License. Skills (application development): wiki editing.

Using Wikispaces This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial- Share Alike 3.0 License. Skills: Wikispaces: editing and management.

McGraw-Hill/Irwin The Interactive Computing Series © 2002 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Microsoft PowerPoint 2002 Working with External.

Writing A Research Paper Usha Arya Martin Luther King, Jr. Middle School 1290 Ivey Ranch Road Oceanside, CA

| 1 | 2014 NFHS Boys Lacrosse Major Rules Revisions Rule 1-5 Note – NOCSAE Ball  Beginning in 2014, all game balls must include labeling which states.

Thesis and Publication Style Statistical Editor, Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Statistical Editor, Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial.

Teaching with Wikis Ken Baclawski College of Computer and Information Science.

Zhichen Xu, Yun Fu, Jianchang Mao, and Difu Su Yahoo! Inc 2821 Mission College Blvd., Santa Clara, CA {zhichen, yfu, jmao, Towards.

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No , and Any opinions, findings, and.

About WIKIS What is a WIKI ? A WIKI is a website that invites anybody to create pages. Or, add content. Or, edit content.

Brett Favre was born on October 10, 1969.

EXtreme Programming: Test-First Copyright Rick Mugridge UoA Rick Mugridge Department of Computer Science University of Auckland

Wikis McCook Inservice October 9, 2009 ESA2. What is a wiki?

Intro to Google Docs Table of Contents Video What is Google Docs? What can you do with it? Creating a new document Uploading an existing document.

1 ADVANCED MICROSOFT WORD Lesson 14 – Editing in Workgroups Microsoft Office 2003: Advanced.

Let’s All Wiki Wiki! Creative Uses for Wikis in Any Library Debbie Ginsberg July 9, 2006 C-2.

May 7, We manage documents and their changes with versioning and check out/check in procedures.

An Introduction to Wikis Bushra Faisal February 17, 2009.

LABORATORY OF APPLIED THERMODYNAMICS ARISTOTLE UNIVERSITY THESSALONIKI SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING DEPT. OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING Proposal for the authorship.

Tajik Wikipedia Free Encyclopedia Ibrahim Rustamov Note: To view pages on the Internet properly with all Tajik letters, please.

WikiTrust: Turning Wikipedia Quantity into Quality B. Thomas Adler, Luca de Alfaro, and Ian Pye.

Evgeniy Gabrilovich and Shaul Markovitch

Organizing Web Content V. Wiki Content Wiki Writing: Chapter 10 Letting Go of the Words: Chapter 9.

REPUTATION SYSTEMS FOR OPEN COLLABORATION CACM 2010 Bo Adler, Luca de Alfaro, Ashutosh Kulshreshtha, Ian Pye Reviewed by : Minghao Yan.

Ian F. C. Smith Writing a Conference Paper. 2 Disclaimer This is mostly opinion. Suggestions are incomplete. There are other strategies.

Computer Programming Application Friday 10/29/2010.

Title:___________________________________________________ Author:_________________________________________________ Place photo here.

FIRST COURSE PowerPoint Tutorial 4 Integrating PowerPoint with Other Programs and Collaborating with Workgroups.

Title Authors Introduction Text, text, text, text, text, text Background Information Text, text, text, text, text, text Observations Text, text, text,

Using a wiki This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial- Share Alike 3.0 License. Skills (application development): wiki.

1 Introduction to Software Engineering Wen-Yang Lin Dept. of Computer Science and Information Engineering National University of Kaohsiung February, 2007.

The Essay App: Justin Martin My Essay App Username: Password: User must login for each use or they can have the device remember their information for the.

Web Science 4/4/08 Information Reputation, Ratings, and Quality on the Web Nick Diakopoulos | School of Interactive Computing.

Open Wikipedia at any page in the language you want to contribute (English or Swedish). Press Create account (Skapa konto). Enter username and password.

INTRODUCTION TO MAPNET WIKI Anar Khan on behalf of AgResearch IS Bioinformatics, Mathematics and Statistics 10/10/2006.

Using Custom Submission Questions and Questionnaires in Editorial Manager™ Created by J. Strusz (9/21/2010)

 In wikipedia, a peer-reviewed periodical in which academic works relating to a particular academic discipline are published. Academic journals serve.

Reputation Systems For Open Collaboration, CACM 2010 Bo Adler, Luca de Alfaro et al. Nishith Agarwal

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Insert Authors’ Headshots or Group Photo Here

<Article Title> <Name of the authors>

Argumentative essay- You have been asked to write an argumentative essay about the necessity of a College Education. Use information from the sources listed.

Lesson 9 Sharing Documents

The Writing Process Steps to Follow.

Motivation and Background

Motivation and Background

The Writing Process Steps to Follow.

Put the names of the people in the group here

History Honors Research Paper.

How to write a History report

12/8 Entry Task: Find one example of each type of language in the text: figurative, connotative and technical. Objective: SWBAT cite evidence, summarize,

Put the names of the people in the group here

<Article Title> <Name of the authors>

Presenter’s Name (if case)

Research Article Title

GEN ad hoc Summary - Sep 14 ‘07

Title Cover Page You can add slides to print your title in larger text if needed but remove after. This page is for teacher and should not be on the board!

Title Introduction: Discussion & Conclusion: Methods & Results:

Title Goes Here Title Goes Here Title Goes Here Title Goes Here

Wikis Skills (application development): wiki editing and management

TECHNICAL REPORTS WRITING

Author’s Name(s) and Affiliation(s)

Presentation transcript:

Measuring Author Contributions to the Wikipedia B. Thomas Adler, Luca de Alfaro, Ian Pye and Vishwanath Raman Computer Science Dept. UC Santa Cruz, CA, USA Computer Engineering Dept. UC Santa Cruz, CA, USA Technical Report, May 2008 Presented by Wen-Yuan Zhu

Outline Introduction Contribution Measures Analysis Conclusion

Introduction to choose the order of authors when citing the content how much work various users have performed? incentive

Introduction(2) previous works – the total text created – total number of edits performed but they are vulnerable to manipulation – doing a small modification – adding insignificance content

Introduction(3) not only quantity, but also quality – how many edits, how much text -> quantity – how long the change lasts -> quality it cannot be easily gamed

Introduction(4) for each page p in Wikipedia

Contribution Measures if your edit is longevity, then you have the higher contribution – Edit Longevity if text that you introduced is longevity, then you have the higher contribution – Text Longevity

Contribution Measures(2) Text longevity – only to consider adding text so that – unfair – it fails to penalize spammers and vandals Text longevity with penalty

Edit Longevity Contribution Measures

average edit quality Contribution Measures::Edit Longevity

edit quality Contribution Measures:: Edit Longevity:: average edit quality

edit distance every word that is inserted or removed contributes 1 to the distance every word that is replaced contribute 1/2 Contribution Measures:: Edit Longevity

Text longevity Contribution Measures

text quality measure Contribution Measures:: Text longevity

Text longevity with penalty anti-vandal vandals will be reverted immediately Contribution Measures

Edit Only and Text Only only quantity in Edit Longevity only quantity in Text longevity Contribution Measures

Analysis main namespace article revisions from the Wikipedia dump of February 6, 2007 we consider only versions before October 1, 2006 keeping only the last of consecutive versions by the same author Analysis

compare

Conclusion to present and compare several possible ways to measure author contribution to make sure that authors who make bad contributions get a low score the Edit Longevity measure is a very interesting measure in our opinion