Research Assessment Exercise 2006 University Grants Committee.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
QAA Research Teaching Linkages: Enhancing Graduate Attributes Theme Linda Juleff, QAA Steering Group Representative.
Advertisements

Promotions and Tenure UAB School of Medicine Administrators and Department APT Committee Members 2010 Cycle Boni E. Elewski, M.D. Chair, UAB School of.
The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching Scholarship Reconsidered: Priorities of the Professoriate The scholarship of discovery The scholarship.
Introduction to Service-Learning for Students
Scholarship of Teaching & SCL/LCE
PEER REVIEW OF TEACHING WORKSHOP SUSAN S. WILLIAMS VICE DEAN ALAN KALISH DIRECTOR, UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR ADVANCEMENT OF TEACHING ASC CHAIRS — JAN. 30,
Eighth Grade MYP Service Project
Teaching and Learning Center What Do We Offer?? 9/27/2012.
The Priority of Research and Doctoral School Nino Zhvania Head of the Quality Assurance Office.
Quality Enhancement and Communications The development and delivery of a research active curriculum will be promoted as a core and high quality activity.
An Excellent Proposal is a Good Idea, Well Expressed, With A Clear Indication of Methods for Pursuing the Idea, Evaluating the Findings, and Making Them.
1 General Education Senate discussion scheduled for April 11 and 25 1.Proposal to base General Education on outcomes that can be assessed 2.Proposal for.
Educational Scholarship and Academies of Teaching Scholars William A. Anderson, PhD Professor, Medical Education College of Human Medicine Michigan State.
SCHOLARSHIP OF TEACHING AND LEARNING IN THE COMPOSITION CLASSROOM Or Faculty Journeys Down the Rabbit Hole of SoTL Janice Kelly Instructor, ASU Department.
National Science Foundation: Transforming Undergraduate Education in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (TUES)
ACCREDITATION SITE VISITS.  DIVISION 010 – SITE VISIT PROCESS  DIVISION 017 – UNIT STANDARDS  DIVISION 065 – CONTENT STANDARDS.
Weber State University’s Teacher Preparation Program Conceptual Framework.
The Toolkit for Community-Engaged Scholarship: Successfully Navigating the Faculty Promotion and Tenure Process Sarena D. Seifer, Jen Kauper-Brown, Diane.
Nancy Brattain Rogers Linda Maule Greg Bierly.  The development of collaborative partnerships between education, business, social services, and government.
Documenting Scholarship in Clinical Teaching Eileen Herteis Programme Director Gwenna Moss Teaching & Learning Centre.
Community Engagement: A Continuum from Outreach to Engagement
Matt Moxham EDUC 290. The Idaho Core Teacher Standards are ten standards set by the State of Idaho that teachers are expected to uphold. This is because.
Pathways to Success in Academic Clinical Medicine Anil K. Agarwal MD FACP, FASN, FNKF Associate Director for Clinical Scholarship, Center for FAME Professor.
Queensland University of Technology CRICOS No J Scholarship of teaching and learning Dr Margaret Lloyd Faculty of Education
Catherine Wehlburg, Ph.D. Assistant Provost for Institutional Effectiveness Texas Christian University TAMU Assessment Conference 2011.
Spring 2012 Pilot Project Module Nine A New Texas Core Curriculum 1.
Framework for K-12 Science Education
Meeting SB 290 District Evaluation Requirements
Introduction to the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning Biology Scholars Institute July 16-19, 2008 Tony Ciccone Senior Scholar and Director Carnegie.
SCHOLARSHIP IN HEALTH PROFESSIONS EDUCATION Jim Lau and Sarah Williams Surgery and Emergency Medicine Medical Education Scholars Program August
Education Portfolio Sean Elliott Chairman, AMES.  The 3- (or 4-) legged stool RESEARCH RESEARCH Clinical care Clinical care Service Service Teaching.
Promotion Expectations and Preparation Dianne Delva.
Where Innovation Is Tradition Students as Scholars : QEP Update Fall 2010 Kimberly K. Eby Bethany M. Usher QEP Planning Committee.
Designing and implementing of the NQF Tempus Project N° TEMPUS-2008-SE-SMHES ( )
The Scholarship of Civic Engagement Adapted from a presentation by Robert G. Bringle Director, Center for Service and Learning Indiana University-Purdue.
Illinois State University General Education Program.
National Science Foundation 1 Evaluating the EHR Portfolio Judith A. Ramaley Assistant Director Education and Human Resources.
Jan Shorey Associate Dean for CME & Faculty Affairs.
Graduate studies - Master of Pharmacy (MPharm) 1 st and 2 nd cycle integrated, 5 yrs, 10 semesters, 300 ECTS-credits 1 Integrated master's degrees qualifications.
Preparing and Evaluating 21 st Century Faculty Aligning Expectations, Competencies and Rewards The NACU Teagle Grant Nancy Hensel, NACU Rick Gillman, Valporaiso.
Documenting Your Teaching for Promotion and Tenure Karl A. Smith Civil Engineering - University of Minnesota
Office of Academic Affairs January 12, 2007 Confirming Portland State’s Leadership Position and Defining Academic Priorities Campus Symposium 2007.
1. Administrators will gain a deeper understanding of the connection between arts, engagement, student success, and college and career readiness. 2. Administrators.
The Conceptual Framework: What It Is and How It Works Linda Bradley, James Madison University Monica Minor, NCATE April 2008.
Summer Workshop for Tenure Track Faculty University of Maryland Extension August 5 and 10, 2009.
STANDARD 4 & DIVERSITY in the NCATE Standards Boyce C. Williams, NCATE John M. Johnston, University of Memphis Institutional Orientation, Spring 2008.
How to pursue scholarship through your Daily Academic Work?
Assessment Presentation Day For Faculty Cindy J. Speaker, Ph.D. Wells College August 21, 2006.
1Mobile Computing Systems © 2001 Carnegie Mellon University Writing a Successful NSF Proposal November 4, 2003 Website: nsf.gov.
Knowledge building in the 21 st century at The Geelong College: Information-to-Knowledge Continuum “As we increasingly move toward an environment of instant.
Course, Curriculum, and Laboratory Improvement (CCLI) Transforming Undergraduate Education in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics PROGRAM.
The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) Karl A. Smith Engineering Education – Purdue University Civil Engineering - University of Minnesota
ATMCH meeting February 28, Outline Accountability Content Evaluation Communication and Outreach.
Welcome 2nd annual intercollegiate community engagement institute.
Carpe Diem Phase II Making the Case. Jot down 3 questions that you have related to Phase II (the one’s that you carried into the room today)
Relationships in the 21 st Century Parent Teachers Students Association (PTSA) Goals, Membership, Participation.
Criterion 1 Mission A. The institution's mission is broadly understood within the institution and guides its operations. B. The mission is articulated.
What is and what should be considered a SoTL Output? 23 February 2015 Professor Patrick Crookes WATTLE THINK TANK.
CSWE Overview This resource highlights key aspects of the mission of the Commission on Research and its goals for the next 5 years. It will then.
Reflecting upon and using a taxonomy of teaching and learning practices PROFESSOR PATRICK CROOKES National Head of School School of Nursing, Midwifery.
The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning: an intro Jane MacKenzie
The Teaching-Research Nexus
Chartered College of Teaching
UGC RAE /9/20.
NJCU College of Education
Research Assessment Exercise
The Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
Education Portfolio Sean Elliott, MD.
Accreditation Leadership Committee Opening Meeting
PRINCIPLES OF GOOD PRACTICE IN SoTL
Presentation transcript:

Research Assessment Exercise 2006 University Grants Committee

Opening Remarks by Prof Roland Chin Convenor, Research Ad Hoc Group (RAG) University Grants Committee

Opportunities for Scholarship University Grants Committee Research Assessment Exercise January 23 rd & 24 th 2006

The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching Lee Shulman, President Richard Gale, Senior Scholar & CASTL Director Stephanie Waldmann, Foundation Secretary Chun-Mei Zhao, Research Scholar Dan Bernstein, University of Kansas

The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching “To do and perform all things necessary to encourage, uphold, and dignify the profession of the teacher and the cause of higher education” - from The Carnegie Foundation Mission Statement

The Work of the Scholar The work of the scholar remains incomplete until it is understood and used by others.

Scholarship Reconsidered (1990) “Is it possible to define the work of faculty in ways that reflect more realistically the full range of academic and civic mandates?” “… the work of the professoriate might be thought of as having four separate, yet overlapping, functions” Discovery Integration Application Teaching

The Four Scholarships: Discovery Scholarship that makes a commitment to knowledge for its own sake, to freedom of inquiry and to following in a disciplined fashion an investigation wherever it may lead … Comes closest to what is usually meant when we speak of “research”

The Four Scholarships: Discovery Science Mathematics

The Four Scholarships: Integration Scholarship that makes connections across the disciplines, in a larger context, at the boundaries where fields converge … that seeks to interpret, draw together, and bring new insight to bear on original research … Interdisciplinary, interpretive, integrative

The Four Scholarships: Integration Humanities Professional

The Four Scholarships: Application Scholarship that serves the interest of the larger community by addressing consequential problems … bringing knowledge to bear on the issues faced by members of the society The community’s issues themselves define the agenda for scholarly investigation

The Four Scholarships: Application Education Science

The Four Scholarships: Teaching Scholarship using disciplinary methods and practice to study and improve student learning … building on, peer reviewing, and sharing knowledge gained through investigation to improve teaching and learning Not only transmitting knowledge, but transforming and extending it as well

The Four Scholarships: Teaching Science Humanities Professional

The Advancement of Learning The University Teaching Application IntegrationDiscovery

Scholarship Assessed (1997) All forms of scholarship include: Clear goals Adequate preparation Appropriate methods Significant results Reflective critique Effective presentation Glassick, Huber, & Maeroff

Framework for Scholarly Accomplishment Levels of Scholarly Performance Components of Scholarly Work

Threshold Goals of the projectWell-articulated and intentional Preparation for scholar’s work Based upon prior scholarship in its area Methods used to conduct work Follows conventions of scholarly efforts within its domain Evidence gathered to demonstrate impact of work Evidence appropriate to the scholar’s field to evaluate proposed practices or ideas Reflection on workScholar has articulated lessons learned Communication of results to others Work is publicly accessible for others to use, build upon, and review critically

ThresholdAdvancedExemplary Goals of the project Well-articulated and intentional Move well beyond existing work in the field and represent innovations Articulates new goals that will advance the work of other scholars Preparation for scholar’s work Based upon prior scholarship in its area Includes broad synthesis of prior work Scholar acquires new knowledge and skills that enhance quality of the work Methods used to conduct work Follows conventions of scholarly efforts within its domain Takes full advantage of methods available to make its impact Generates new methods that enable others to enhance their scholarship Evidence gathered to demonstrate impact of work Evidence appropriate to the scholar’s field to evaluate proposed practices or ideas Evidence suggests that the scholar’s ideas or practices are worth implementing Evidence suggests practices or ideas have had great impact on other scholars Reflection on work Scholar has articulated lessons learned Scholar has made adjustments in practice based on reflection Scholar can report enhanced achievement of goals resulting from lessons learned Communication of results to others Work is publicly accessible for others to use, build upon, and review critically Scholar’s reflective work has been cited by others Work has had broad impact on practices and inquiry of many others interested in the same questions

Establishing Excellence Qualities of Surprise and Delight Transparency of Argument and Evidence Commitment to Rigor and Peer Review Communication and Dissemination of Standards and Examples

Acknowledgements Prof. Roland Chin, Mr. Michael Stone, and The University Grants Committee Hong Kong Institutions of Higher Education Research Assessment Exercise Participants

Opportunities for Questions