Health ( R )evolution: (Quality = Learning) + (Ethics = Justice) Peter J. Hammer Damon J. Keith Center for Civil Rights Wayne State University Law School.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Guadalupe Pacheco, MSW Project Officer, Think Cultural Health
Advertisements

Disaster Risk Reduction and Governance. Ron Cadribo.
Creating a Window of Opportunity for Policy Change By Nancy Yinger, The Population Reference Bureau AMDD Conference Kuala Lumpur, 2003.
Universal and Equal: Ensuring Equity in State Health Care Reform Brian D. Smedley, Ph.D. The Opportunity Agenda
Primary Care in Minnesota Innovations in Primary Care Jeff Schiff, MD MBA Medical Director Minnesota Department of Human Services 13 December 2010.
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act: The Patient Perspective Stephen Finan American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network.
A Socio Cultural Framework for Mental Health and Substance Abuse Service Disparities Research with Multicultural Populations Margarita Alegria, Ph.D. Glorisa.
PUBLIC INTEREST AND COMMON GOOD BY BRUCE JENNINGS, DANIEL CALLAHAN, AND SUSAN M. WOLF.
Organización Panamericana de la Salud.... Information Knowledge Management Evolution of Bioethics Dr. Richard Van West-Charles.
Sakthivel Selvaraj, Habib Hasan, Preeti Kumar, Maulik Chokshi Public Health Foundation of India, India 1.
Session Creating Health Equity: Going Beyond the Health Gap, the Mental Health Gap, and the Climate Gap Advancing equity through health in all policies:
Entrepreneurial Mind-Set
Session Creating Health Equity: Going Beyond the Health Gap, the Mental Health Gap, and the Climate Gap Advancing equity through health in all policies:
Local Government & Community Participation
DECENTRALIZATION AND RURAL SERVICES : MESSAGES FROM RECENT RESEARCH AND PRACTICE Graham B. Kerr Community Based Rural Development Advisor The World Bank.
Intelligence Unit 6 - Mandates for Action Policy exerts a powerful influence on public health nutrition (PHN) practice because it affects:  service delivery.
CHS 382 Fundamentals of Health Education
E-HIM ™ : It Will Transform Your Job! By Beth Hjort, RHIA, CHP National Health Information and Technology Week November 7–13, 2004.
Strategies for Improving Global Environmental Governance: Challenging the Status Quo Strategies for Improving Global Environmental Governance: Challenging.
Code of Practice: Toward Implementation Eric B. Williams Health Workforce Advocacy Initiative Physicians for Human Rights.
What is “Biomedical Informatics”?. Biomedical Informatics Biomedical informatics (BMI) is the interdisciplinary field that studies and pursues.
Outcome Accountable Care Outcome Accountable Care Coordinated Seamless Healthcare System 2.0 Patient/Person Centered Transparent Cost and Quality Performance.
Chapter 2 The Managerial Role. Copyright © 2006 by Thomson Delmar Learning. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 2 Purpose and Overview Purpose –To understand roles of.
Leadership in Nursing. Stogdill (1982) defined leadership as “the process of influencing the activities of an organized group in its efforts toward goal.
Providing Access to Healthy Solutions (PATHS): Reforming Law & Policy to Foster Equitable Responses to Diabetes Maggie Morgan Center for Health Law and.
Chapter 4 Social Responsibility and Justice. Objectives Describe the role of the dental hygienist in meeting the oral health care needs of the public.
Sustaining Change in Higher Education J. Douglas Toma Associate Professor Institute of Higher Education University of Georgia May 28, 2004.
Cost-Containment, Medical Technology and Access to Care: A Comparative Analysis of Health Policy in the United States, the United Kingdom And Canada Emily.
Performance Measurement Orientation To schedule a presentation of “Performance Measurement Orientation” for your organization staff and/or collaborators,
Kenneth Ojo & Paul Angbazo Partnership for Transforming Health Systems 2 (PATHS2) Abuja, Nigeria.
September 10, Introductions Steering Committee Members Action Teams Action Plans by teams Group discussion - Comments Networking AGENDA.
Fostering a ‘Whole Community’ Approach to Emergency Management David J. Kaufman Director, Office of Policy and Program Analysis 8 June 2011.
Public Policy. Authoritative decisions – government What is the relationship between the policy and the desired goal or “outcome”? Connection between.
Health Care Reform and Implications for Filipino American Health Increased Access to Care, Improved Preventive Care and Measures to Improve Quality and.
Summary of ICIUM Chronic Care Track Prepared by: Ricardo Perez-Cuevas Veronika Wirtz David Beran.
What is participation? How would you describe what it is to participate? How does it make you feel when you get to participate?
Vision and Vital Uncertainties for Nursing Futures Jonathan C. Peck President & Senior Futurist June 13, 1014.
SPALW Membership Call Agenda Call to Order Roll Call Overlapping Vulnerabilities ASSE in Action OSHA Latino Workforce Initiatives SPALW in Action Contact.
1 S trengthening accountability for gender equality To learn more visit
Comparative Health Systems Why compare? We have problems and others have different and perhaps better solutions What kind of comparison? Scientific enterprise.
1 Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Communities: Risks and Opportunities NIFL/LINCS Regional Health Literacy Summit, Center for Literacy Studies Atlanta,
The shift to programs in the LAC region. What is a program? A program is a coherent set of initiatives by CARE and our allies that involves a long-term.
FAMILY HEALTH PROMOTION
T he Istanbul Principles and the International Framework Geneva, Switzerland June 2013.
BLENDING CCIs, PROJECTS, COLLECTIVE IMPACT, AND EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICES TO ACHIEVE SYSTEM AND PROGRAM OUTCOMES Hiram E. Fitzgerald, PhD. Robert Brown,
Educational Pathways and Expanded Roles. Educational preparation Diploma in Nursing Associate’s Degree in Nursing Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing Master’s.
Environment: PHN Education and Health Policy Armenia Williams, DPA, RNC, FNP Associate Professor Byrdine F. Lewis School of Nursing Georgia State University.
Draft Framework on Health and Wellness. Emerging Issues from Sessions Lack of collaboration amongst govt depts and other stakeholders: What drives collaboration?
Older Person’s Bill Presentation to Select Committee – Social Service National Treasury 25 October 2004.
Ethics, values and Legal Aspects of Nursing
Health insurance and micro health insurance Denis Garand
Definition of Public Health Public health is the science and art of organized societal efforts to ensure [and create] the conditions for the highest possible.
Peter J. Hammer Professor of Law and Director Damon J. Keith Center for Civil Rights Wayne State University Law School October 16, 2014.
Course Goals HSM 775 Bioethics for Public Health Professionals.
 Explain how asymmetrical information creates economic problems  Understand how the subprime mortgage crisis was a moral hazard issue  Explain how.
D. HEALTH POLICY AND MANAGEMENT Health policy and management is a multidisciplinary field of inquiry and practice concerned with the delivery, quality.
Chapter 10 Physical and Mental Health. Health Health – a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being. –Well-being of any population reflects.
Perspectives on health and social policy M6920 December 4, 2001.
Sustainable Energy for All Draft framework for action The Secretary-General's High-Level Group on Sustainable Energy for All Discussion document, Abu Dhabi.
Community Benefits Ordinance: Putting People not Property at the Center of Development Peter J. Hammer, Professor of Law and Director Damon J. Keith Center.
Overview of health promotion. Over the past two decade the explosion of interest and participation in health promotion and wellness activities has resulted.
1 Copyright © 2012 by Mosby, an imprint of Elsevier Inc. Copyright © 2008 by Mosby, Inc., an affiliate of Elsevier Inc. Chapter 40 The Nurse Leader in.
Prof Rakhshanda Rehman, Prof Emeritus,Dean Medical Education,CPSP Prof Emeritus,Dean Medical Education,CPSP. 17 th Health Science Research Symposium 27.
Introduction to Health Policy and Law Jody Blanke Distinguished Professor of Computer Information Systems and Law Mercer University.
Chapter 9 Case Management Copyright © 2015, 2011, 2007, 2001, 1997, 1993 by Saunders, an imprint of Elsevier Inc.
Understanding Health Care Policy
Ethical Issues in Health
Reform Trends in OECD Member countries
Writing Ethics/ Writing Rights
Economic Foundations of Political Legitimacy
Presentation transcript:

Health ( R )evolution: (Quality = Learning) + (Ethics = Justice) Peter J. Hammer Damon J. Keith Center for Civil Rights Wayne State University Law School Detroit, Michigan

Health (Non) System is Broken General Indictment  Cost: Costs too much  Quality: Get too little  Access: Exclude too many Symbolic Indictment  Medical Errors  Racial Disparities

 Medical errors & patient safety  1 million+ injuries, 100,000 deaths (IOM)  Frame as an issue of quality  Illustration of intra-system irrationality  Lack of capacity of learning and adaptation Medical Errors as Symbol

 Racial Disparities & Health Inequalities  “Detroit area residents age are dying at a rate 48% higher than their peers in the rest of the state” (Dying Before their Time)  Frame as an issue of ethics  Illustration of inter-system irrationality  Narrow biomedical understanding of health  Lack of capacity to incorporate notions of justice in advocating for health Racial Disparities as Symbol

 Forecasting the future: Must understand dynamics of existing processes  Factors in modeling system dysfunctionality  Balkanization of American health care  Fractured nature of Coasian firm  Insurance as finance mechanism not risk allocation mechanism (Nyman)  Dynamic moral hazard (Glied)  Absence of mechanisms for rational adaptation What Drives the Biomedical-Industrial Complex?

PoliticalMarket Health Care System Professional (Civil Society? ) Biomedical-Industrial Complex...

 Power Analysis: Architecture of Health System  Actors rationally manipulate parallel 1) political, 2) market and 3) professional processes  Development theory: limit capacity of state to expropriate private resources (how public is public?)  ERISA preemption trumped political/state power (unintended consequences)  Power of professionalism waning (doctors as distributors) Biomedical-Industrial Complex...

 The conundrum of asymmetric information  Asymmetry of information (uncertainty) is real (as are asymmetries in understanding changes in information)  Asymmetries tend to disempower market processes  Asymmetries tend to disempower political processes (Pauly’s non-transformation principle)  Asymmetries empower parties who can claim legitimacies in interpretation and understanding (or who benefit from confusion and uncertainty) Biomedical-Industrial Complex...

 “Law” can do very little  Law is constrained by Balkans of American health care  Health law tends to lag, not lead (two decades out-of- date)  Question: Does law ensure quality?  Question: Does the malpractice regime help or hinder efforts to improve patient safety?  Question: Do medical ethics lead to better social decision making? What Can Health Law do?

 Health law lags and does not lead  Law tracks the superstructure of the biomedical- industrial complex  Much of law reflects the shadow of a dysfunctional system (fraud and abuse, self-referral)  Change will come first in evolving organizational structures What Changes Health Law?

 Health Care Quality = Learning  Visualization: What would patient safety look like in a system designed to foster intra-system rationality?  Insight: Importance of organizational learning and adaptation as ingredients to quality  What are the implications for health law?  What pictures would your draw?  What enabling environment is necessary? Re-Imagining Health Quality

 Health Care Ethics = Justice  Visualization Exercise: What would racial inequalities look like in a system designed to foster inter-system rationality?  Insight: Importance of new ethics focusing on justice  What are implications for health law?  What pictures would you draw?  What enabling environment is necessary? Re-Imagining Health Ethics

 Claim: Need greater sensitivity to developing structures the facilitate learning, adaptation and evolution  “Complex Adaptive Systems” as a framework  Health Systems Development  A LLIANCE FOR H EALTH P OL ’ Y & S YSTEMS R ESEARCH, S YSTEMS T HINKING FOR H EALTH S YSTEMS S TRENGTHENING (Don de Savigny & Taghreed Adam eds., 2009)  Structural Racism: Kirwan Institute  S TEPHEN M ENENDIAN & C AITLIN W ATT, K IRWAN I NST., S YSTEMS P RIMER (2008) The Path to the Future

 Claim: Need greater intra-system rationality  Focus on quality as a learning problem  Positive signs: Quality components of ACA  Comparative effectiveness research  Center for Quality Improvement & Patient Safety  Sensitivity to cultural/organizational factors  Office of Communication and Knowledge Transfer  Blending outcomes and payment  Information systems in Stimulus Package  Caveat: Building effective organizational structures is easier in theory than in practice The Path for Quality

 Claim: Need greater inter-system rationality  Focus on ethics as a problem of social justice (inclusion)  Incorporate social & economics determinants  Greater role for public health programming  Addressing chronic illnesses from a community perspective (real medical homes)  Expand “scope of practice” laws  International “Community System Strengthening” initiatives as a model  Must solve these problems for global cost control The Path for Ethics

 General Equilibrium Framework  All prices in all markets in equilibrium  Ultimate agenda  Merge agendas of facilitating intra-system and inter- system rationality  Health ( L )evolution: (Quality = Learning) + (Ethics = Justice) Ultimate Imaginative Undertaking