RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 High Density Limit in RFP’s M Valisa and the RFX-mod team.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Dynamo Effects in Laboratory Plasmas S.C. Prager University of Wisconsin October, 2003.
Advertisements

Control of Magnetic Chaos & Self-Organization John Sarff for MST Group CMSO General Meeting Madison, WI August 4-6, 2004.
Ideas for overseas contributions to CMSO Piero Martin Consorzio RFX Associazione Euratom-ENEA sulla fusione And Physics Dept., Univ. of Padova, Italy CMSO.
Introduction to Plasma-Surface Interactions Lecture 6 Divertors.
9th TTF Spain September 11, 2002 B. J. Peterson, NIFS, Japan page 1 Radiative Collapse and Density Limit in the Large Helical Device.
First Wall Heat Loads Mike Ulrickson November 15, 2014.
M. Zuin RFX ws 2011 Padova, 7-9/2/2011 Innovative contributions to confinement understanding M. Zuin.
Momentum Transport During Reconnection Events in the MST Reversed Field Pinch Alexey Kuritsyn In collaboration with A.F. Almagri, D.L. Brower, W.X. Ding,
Two-dimensional Structure and Particle Pinch in a Tokamak H-mode
SUGGESTED DIII-D RESEARCH FOCUS ON PEDESTAL/BOUNDARY PHYSICS Bill Stacey Georgia Tech Presented at DIII-D Planning Meeting
Introduction to the disruption JET/MST program E. Joffrin & P. Martin Presented by P. Martin.
RFP Workshop, Stockholm 9-11 /10/ 2008 Numerical studies of particle transport mechanisms in RFX-mod low chaos regimes M.Gobbin, L.Marrelli, L.Carraro,
Reduced transport regions in rotating tokamak plasmas Michael Barnes University of Oxford Culham Centre for Fusion Energy Michael Barnes University of.
Paper O4.007, R. A. Pitts et al., 34th EPS Conference: 5 July 2007 Neoclassical and transport driven parallel SOL flows on TCV R. A. Pitts, J. Horacek.
8.30 – 9.10 Coffee and Registration (fee 400 Swedish crowns) Welcome Plasma wall interactions and edge physics – chairman: Brunsell P. - Hirano.
13th IEA/RFP Workshop – Stockholm October 9-11, D characterization of thermal core topology changes in controlled RFX-mod QSH states A. Alfier on.
HEAT TRANSPORT andCONFINEMENTin EXTRAP T2R L. Frassinetti, P.R. Brunsell, M. Cecconello, S. Menmuir and J.R. Drake.
M. Zuin 13th IEA/RFP WorkshopStockholm, October 9-11, 2008 Self-organized helical equilibria emerging at high current in RFX-mod Matteo Zuin on behalf.
Non-collisional ion heating and Magnetic Turbulence in MST Abdulgader Almagri On behalf of MST Team RFP Workshop Padova, Italy April 2010.
D. Borba 1 21 st IAEA Fusion Energy Conference, Chengdu China 21 st October 2006 Excitation of Alfvén eigenmodes with sub-Alfvénic neutral beam ions in.
RFX-mod Workshop – Padova, January Experimental QSH confinement and transport Fulvio Auriemma on behalf of RFX-mod team Consorzio RFX, Euratom-ENEA.
Plasma particle fuelling a general view of methods and issues David Terranova.
Valisa et al C-mod Ideas Forum, 8 April Electron heating and Ni / Mo Pump Out L Carraro, I Predebon, ME Puiatti, M Valisa ( Consorzio RFX Padova)
RFX-mod 2009 programme Workshop, January 20-22, 2009 Report on experimental proposals submitted to TF1 ‘RFP performance: high current operation and advanced.
6 th Japan-Korea Workshop on Theory and Simulation of Magnetic Fusion Plasmas Hyunsun Han, G. Park, Sumin Yi, and J.Y. Kim 3D MHD SIMULATIONS.
TOTAL Simulation of ITER Plasmas Kozo YAMAZAKI Nagoya Univ., Chikusa-ku, Nagoya , Japan 1.
RFX Programme Meeting Feb-2010 Influences of main gas choice on RFP plasmas RFX-mod Programme Planning Workshop, 9 Feb 2011 M Valisa with contributions.
Excitation of ion temperature gradient and trapped electron modes in HL-2A tokamak The 3 th Annual Workshop on Fusion Simulation and Theory, Hefei, March.
The efficient sustainment of a stable, high-β spheromak: modeling By Tom Jarboe, To PSI-Center July 29, 2015.
NSTX-U NSTX-U PAC-31 Response to Questions – Day 1 Summary of Answers Q: Maximum pulse length at 1MA, 0.75T, 1 st year parameters? –A1: Full 5 seconds.
14 Oct. 2009, S. Masuzaki 1/18 Edge Heat Transport in the Helical Divertor Configuration in LHD S. Masuzaki, M. Kobayashi, T. Murase, T. Morisaki, N. Ohyabu,
Comparison of Ion Thermal Transport From GLF23 and Weiland Models Under ITER Conditions A. H. Kritz 1 Christopher M. Wolfe 1 F. Halpern 1, G. Bateman 1,
QSH/SHAx states: towards the determination of an helical equilibrium L. Marrelli acknowledging fruitful discussions with S.Cappello, T.Bolzonella, D.Bonfiglio,
Plasma-wall interactions during high density operation in LHD
(National Institute for Fusion Science, Japan)
M. Onofri, F. Malara, P. Veltri Compressible magnetohydrodynamics simulations of the RFP with anisotropic thermal conductivity Dipartimento di Fisica,
Contribution of KIT to LHD Topics from collaboration research on MHD phenomena in LHD S. Masamune, K.Y. Watanabe 1), S. Sakakibara 1), Y. Takemura, KIT.
Transport in three-dimensional magnetic field: examples from JT-60U and LHD Katsumi Ida and LHD experiment group and JT-60 group 14th IEA-RFP Workshop.
U NIVERSITY OF S CIENCE AND T ECHNOLOGY OF C HINA CAS K EY L ABORATORY OF B ASIC P LASMA P HYSICS Recent experimental results of zonal flows in edge tokamak.
Physics of fusion power Lecture 12: Diagnostics / heating.
STUDIES OF NONLINEAR RESISTIVE AND EXTENDED MHD IN ADVANCED TOKAMAKS USING THE NIMROD CODE D. D. Schnack*, T. A. Gianakon**, S. E. Kruger*, and A. Tarditi*
ITER STEADY-STATE OPERATIONAL SCENARIOS A.R. Polevoi for ITER IT and HT contributors ITER-SS 1.
RFX-mod Program Workshop, Padova, January Current filaments in turbulent magnetized plasmas E. Martines.
RFX workshop / /Valentin Igochine Page 1 Control of MHD instabilities. Similarities and differences between tokamak and RFP V. Igochine, T. Bolzonella,
EXTENSIONS OF NEOCLASSICAL ROTATION THEORY & COMPARISON WITH EXPERIMENT W.M. Stacey 1 & C. Bae, Georgia Tech Wayne Solomon, Princeton TTF2013, Santa Rosa,
HL-2A Heating & Current Driving by LHW and ECW study on HL-2A Bai Xingyu, HL-2A heating team.
RFX-mod Programme Workshop, 20-22/01/09, Padova - T. Bolzonella1 Tommaso Bolzonella on behalf of RFX-mod team Consorzio RFX- Associazione Euratom-ENEA.
1 Stability Studies Plans (FY11) E. Fredrickson, For the NCSX Team NCSX Research Forum Dec. 7, 2006 NCSX.
MCZ Active MHD Control Needs in Helical Configurations M.C. Zarnstorff 1 Presented by E. Fredrickson 1 With thanks to A. Weller 2, J. Geiger 2,
T. Bolzonella – 9 February 2011 – RFX-mod programme workshop TF1: Physics integration for high performance RFP Proposals and discussion T. Bolzonella,
ContributorsEuratom Associations L. Carraro, M. Mattioli, M.E. Puiatti, P. Scarin, B. Zaniol Consorzio RFX, Padova, Italy P.DuMortier, A. Messiaen, J OngenaEcole.
Role of thermal instabilities and anomalous transport in the density limit M.Z.Tokar, F.A.Kelly, Y.Liang, X.Loozen Institut für Plasmaphysik, Forschungszentrum.
IEA RFP Workshop, April Padova Internal electron transport barriers in RFX-mod helical equilibria R. Lorenzini on behalf of the RFX-mod team.
1 Peter de Vries – ITPA T meeting Culham – March 2010 P.C. de Vries 1,2, T.W. Versloot 1, A. Salmi 3, M-D. Hua 4, D.H. Howell 2, C. Giroud 2, V. Parail.
Simulation of Turbulence in FTU M. Romanelli, M De Benedetti, A Thyagaraja* *UKAEA, Culham Sciance Centre, UK Associazione.
Plan V. Rozhansky, E. Kaveeva St.Petersburg State Polytechnical University, , Polytechnicheskaya 29, St.Petersburg, Russia Poloidal and Toroidal.
Energetic ion excited long-lasting “sword” modes in tokamak plasmas with low magnetic shear Speaker:RuiBin Zhang Advisor:Xiaogang Wang School of Physics,
U NIVERSITY OF S CIENCE AND T ECHNOLOGY OF C HINA Influence of ion orbit width on threshold of neoclassical tearing modes Huishan Cai 1, Ding Li 2, Jintao.
Reconnection Process in Sawtooth Crash in the Core of Tokamak Plasmas Hyeon K. Park Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology, Ulsan, Korea National.
25 th IAEA Fusion Energy Conference, St. Petersburg 2014 M. E. Puiatti 25 th IAEA Fusion Energy Conference, St. Petersburg 2014 Overview of the RFX-mod.
Features of Divertor Plasmas in W7-AS
Similarities and differences in SOL physics
Huishan Cai, Jintao Cao, Ding Li
T. Markovič1,2, P. Cahyna1, R. Panek1, M. Peterka1,2, P. C
L-H power threshold and ELM control techniques: experiments on MAST and JET Carlos Hidalgo EURATOM-CIEMAT Acknowledgments to: A. Kirk (MAST) European.
Studies of Bias Induced Plasma Flows in HSX
Influence of energetic ions on neoclassical tearing modes
KTM & CWGM 2006 Kyoto University, Kyoto ( Sep., 2006)
Stabilization of m/n=1/1 fishbone by ECRH
Presentation transcript:

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 High Density Limit in RFP’s M Valisa and the RFX-mod team

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 OUTLINE Background on density limit in RFP’s New RFX-mod experimental results Discussion

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Why are we interested in High Density plasmas? In a reactor P_fusion ~ n e 2 (provided T is around 10 keV) In RFX  E ~ n e The density limit is a commonality of all of the magnetic configurations.

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Upper Density Limit in RFP’s known since many years Costa,De Angelis, Ortolani Puiatti, Nuc. Fusion 22, 1301 (1982). Radiation limit Ortolani & Rostagni 1983 Nucl. Instrum. Meth Radiation limit around n/nG= 0.5 (I/N=2) Perkins & Hulse 1985 Phys. Fluids Bartiromo et al th EPS Conf. Budapest Published in M. Greenwald’s review PPCF 2002 MST density limited regimes ( Wyman’s Thesis 2007) Rencent work : Puiatti et al Submitted to PoP Puiatti et al IAEA Conf 2008 Geneve Valisa et al IAEA Conf 2004 Villamoura Valisa et al IAEA Conf 2006 Chengdu

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 * RFX-Mod RFP and Tokamak share the same limit The Greenwald limit is an empirical law The Greenwald threshold is not an absolute limit but provides values in the right range In Tokamaks nG can be exceeded by a factor 2 by peaking the density profile. Some ITER scenarios assume n/nG ~ 1.2

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 JET Predicted pedestal DL (detachment) and Experimental In JET a pedestal DL is found overlap Borrass NF and is worse than the Greenwald limit

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Stellarator : Sudo limit, much higher than nG RFX

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 In LHD the critical edge density that leads to complete detachment is well reproduced by the Sudo scaling with a factor 0.8. Pellet-fuelled plasmas with large density peaking factor  Ne(0)/ne Sudo up to 7 ! Core density can be increased until the core plasma locally collapses, as long as the edge density is kept below the Sudo scaling. Stellarators: Sudo Scaling The Sudo scaling is an edge density limit scaling. The operational limit is ne_ edge < ne Sudo J. Miyazawa. Nucl Fus 2008 and EPS 2008

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 New RFX-mod data New current regime Old RFX space Greenwald limit Runaway region

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 New on RFX-mod Confirmed the difficulty to keep the current derivative = 0 at high density Normalized Current derivativevs n/nG

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Radiation pattern: a MARFE-like structure Toroidally localized, poloidally symmetric belt

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 New experiments with induced rotation of a strong artificial m=0 n=1 mode for a “3D” diagnostic of the relevant structures RFX-mod: DL experiments with induced m=o modes rotation

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 At the same relative position with respect to the Locked Mode (90 ° apart where the plasma shrinks): the radiating belt develops edge density accumulates due to the flow stagnation point ( and low diffusivity. Instead at the LM (m=1 modes) : Strong H  signal= main particle source, edge flow displacement due to m=0 radiation electron density HH m=1 toroidal angle plasma shrinking induced m=o modes rotation (Normalized to the Locked mode position) Locked mode position

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 New. Reconstruction of local flux structure Poincaré plot. Region where large radiation belts develop. The relationship between specific m=0 islands and radiaon belts still unclear. Measurements of Flow and radial electric field reversal are consistent. Possible explanation: the pattern of m=0 islands conveys the electron parallel flow to the wall in certain regions only. ( Carraro et al JNM 2003) (Bartiromo, Phys. Plasmas 5, 3342 (1998) Magenta line: toroidal flux function. m=0 islands develop around the reversal surface ( green line).

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Edge Diffusivity is low with increasing n/nG Diffusion coefficient estimated from turbulence plotted as a function of normalized density This confirms old RFX measurements (Gregoratto et al NF 96)..

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 (open dots) Prad=Pohm as a function of n=nG ; m = 1 mode normalized amplitude vs n=nG : Squares : low- n modes n = 7 ¡ 9), Dots: high- n modes ( n = 10 ¡ 18). Prad/P_input ratio LOCALLY very high (full dots) Prad=Pohm taking into account the fraction of input power impinging on the toroidal portion of the radiating layer Radiating layers tend to manifest and grow beyond the dashed line

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 In the ULq case, appraoching and slightly exceeding the Greenwald limit is quite simple with flat current waveforms. The ULq case Well sustained current.

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Summary of the RFX-mod experimental evidence With induced rotation of artificially produced modes At high density in the vicinity of m=0 modes ( not of the m=1 locked mode ) the composition of the radial Er procures a stagnation point for the toroidal flow Diffusion is sufficiently low to allow local density increase favoured by the RFP topology ( around the reversal parallel flow has no or little toroidal component) Density ( not necessarily impurity ) accumulation causes radiation to locally build up At high density localized radiation dissipation is experimenatlly comparable to the power flow to that region  possibility of a thermal instability.

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Question What in absence of artificially induced m=0 modes (i.e. pure Clean Mode Control) ? 1) Fast TV images (1 kHz) show PWI patterns rapidly changing in space 2) 1D Simulation can be made to check the RFP response to an increase density in an axi-symmetric topology MST is more m=0 stable. Experiments could clarify the role of m=0 modes In RFX shallow F experiments at high desnity will be performed

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / D Simulation of high density discharge ( Riport code) “Riport” code: - 1D ( cilindrical symmetry – does not include 3D effects of plasma deformations - Heat and particle equations ( including impurities solved self-consistently with Spitzer resistivity and  -dynamo term See Predebon et al submitted to PoP

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Simulated RFP discharge with a linearly increasing influx 1D Simulation od high density discharge ( Report code) Increased resistivity causes the current to decrease unless the dynamo term is proportionally augmented

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Conclusions 1 New experimental evidence in RFX—mod confirms that localized radiation belts develop in the region where m=0 islands are formed. The evolution is favoured by converging toroidal flow of particles and low edge diffusivity. ULq reaches quite easily the Greenwald DL with well sustained current ( despite general transport is worse). NB: In ULq’s the m=0 resonance is no longer in the plasma In RFX-mod best performance is with QSH which is instead prefers regimes at high Lundquist ~ Te3/2/ ne1/2 We must learn how to to make QSH and high ne compatible..

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Conclusions 2 In Tokamak, Stellarators and RFP’s exceeding a density threshold triggers some kind of instability processes at the egde: typically involving radiation cooling.at the edge (except TEXT : DL due to transport change.D. Brower et al PRL 67, 200 (1991) ) In Tokamaks MARFE structures can lead to a disruption. In the Stellarator and in the RFP (including ULq) the consequences are not disruptive In the RFP current sustainement becomes critical even before nG is reached unlike the ULq  The density limit is originated by similar physics, but modulated by the topological and stability properties of each configuration.

RFP Workshop Stockholm 9-11 / 10 / 2008 Conclusions 3 Questions: Would an m=0 controlled RFP plasma avoid the Greenwald density limit? Is the RFP intrinsically limited in density due to its topology and the need of an internal dynamo? In Tokamaks and Stellarators average densities well above the “DL” have been achieved. Can we conceive a high density RFP with peaked profiles and sufficiently low edge density to overcome the Greenwald limit? Try with internal fuelling (pellet/ power beams )& edge recycling control