Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction in Women with non Hereditary BC Risk Fabienne Liebens MD Breast Unit Isala Breast Cancer Prevention Center CHU Saint.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Breast cancer chemoprevention in the high-risk patient
Advertisements

Which of the following increases a women’s risk for Breast Cancer? A.Starting her menses at age 14 or older B.Breastfeeding C.Extremely dense breast tissue.
Breast Cancer. Dr. Swapna Chaudhary M.S. (MUM) M.S. (MUM) Consultant Obstetrician & Gynaecologist Infertility Specialist.
†Source: U.S. Cancer Statistics Working Group. United States Cancer Statistics: 1999–2011 Incidence and Mortality Web-based Report. Atlanta (GA): Department.
Breast MR Imaging Workshop th September 2014 High-Risk Screening Evidence-based Clinical Indications for Breast MRI Dr. Muhamad Zabidi Ahmad, AMDI.
Benign Breast Disease – Focus on Atypia Lynn C. Hartmann, MD Women’s Cancer Program Mayo Clinic Cancer Center.
Strategies for Breast Cancer Prevention John Park Hannah Connolly Jeff Tice Mary S. Beattie.
Sponsored by Division of Cancer Control and Population Sciences Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics Office of Women’s Health National Cancer Institute,
Hereditary Factors in Breast Cancer
Breast Cancer Risk and Risk Assessment Models
Genetic Susceptibility Risk Models in Clinical Decision Making Susan M. Domchek, MD Abramson Cancer Center University of Pennsylvania.
Journal Club Alcohol, Other Drugs, and Health: Current Evidence January–February 2010.
Breast Cancer 101 Barbara Lee Bass, MD, FACS Professor of Surgery
Every Woman, Every Time: Disparities in Breast Cancer Tony L. Weaver, D.O. ALOMA 2015.
Breast cancer screening Recommendations for breast cancer screening چه شواهدی برای خطر وجود دارد؟ برای غربالگری چه باید کرد؟
Breast Cancer screening in the NHS Dr D J Rohan Subasinghe.
Screening Tests for Brest & Cervical Cancer
ASSESSMENT OF BREAST SYMPTOMS/LUMPS Professor P Grantley Gill Specialists Without Borders Seminar in Surgery Rwanda, September 2010.
Elshami M.Elamin, MD Medical Oncologist Central Care Cancer Center Wichita, KS, USA
Christina Laukaitis, MD, PhD, FACP 22 June * To continue to increase the competitive stance of cancer research and training at Northern Arizona.
Epidemiology of Breast Cancer Selected Highlights Jack Cuzick, Ph.D Cancer Research UK London.
Breast cancer: why do people get it and can we prevent it? T. Kuan Yu, M.D., Ph.D. Houston Precision Cancer Center.
These slides were released by the speaker for internal use by Novartis.
Extending the Gail model for Breast Cancer Risk Prediction to Account for Modifiable Factors in the Italian Population. Calza S, Ferraroni M, Decarli A.
Menopause: The Journal of The North American Menopause Society
Ductal Carcinoma In Situ (DCIS)
Criteria for Assessment of Performance of Cancer Risk Prediction Models: Overview Ruth Pfeiffer Cancer Risk Prediction Workshop, May 21, 2004 Division.
Risk Prediction in Clinical Practice Joann G. Elmore MD, MPH SCCA June 11, 2014.
ACRIN Protocol 6666 ACRIN Protocol 6666 Screening Breast Ultrasound in High-Risk Women Made possible by grants from the Avon Foundation and National Cancer.
Jump to first page First pregnancy after age 30 (RR 1.48). BMI >29 (RR 1.48). Being a college graduate, independent of OB-GYN history (RR 1.36). (Collaborative.
1 Study of Tamoxifen and Raloxifene STAR Larry Wickerham, MD NSABP STAR Project Officer.
EPIB-591 Screening Jean-François Boivin 29 September
Prevention and Early Detection of Breast Cancer: Weighing the Risks and Benefits Kathy J. Helzlsouer, M.D., M.H.S. Prevention and Research Center, Women’s.
Clinical Utility of BRCA Testing Mark Robson, MD September 7,
Oral Bisphosphonate and Breast Cancer: Prospective Results from the Women’s Health Initiative (WHI) Chlebowski RT et al. SABCS 2009; Abstract 21.
Clinical Applications of Risk Prediction Models Laura Esserman, M.D., M.B.A. Professor of Surgery and Radiology Director, UCSF Carol Franc Buck Breast.
Session Fertility and Pregnancy FL-BBM Specific questions Risk of premature ovarian failure Ability to become pregnant Safety of pregnancy.
These slides were released by the speaker for internal use by Novartis
Best first ? The ATAC completed treatment analysis Professor Jack Cuzick Wolfson Institute of Preventive Medicine, London, UK.
Shiva Sharma SHO to Professor Redmond.  Introduction  Increased risk groups  Consideration of genetic testing  Management of patients with mutation.
Prevention with Finasteride Ian M. Thompson, MD October, 2009.
How will you approach the 35-year old, with a 2x2x2cm, firm, mobile, well-circumscribed non-tender mass on her R breast?
Personal Risk Factors Gender being a woman is the main risk factor for developing breast cancer (100 times more common in women) Age occurrence increase.
DL Wickerham MD Deputy Chairman NRG Oncology Oct 5, 2015
During this presentation the learner will be able to: 1. Understand current breast cancer screening guidelines for mammography. 2. Compare and contrast.
Breast Cancer Prevention Art or Science? Kristi McIntyre M.D. Texas Oncology 2005.
BREAST CANCER: Half a million women later… Amy Miglani M.D September 3, 2004.
Breast Cancer. Breast cancer is a disease in which malignant cells form in the tissues of the breast – “National Breast Cancer Foundation” The American.
Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium (BCSC): A Research Infrastructure sponsored by the National Cancer Institute Breast Cancer Risk Models William Barlow,
Kevin S.Hughes, MD, FACS Co-Director, Avon Comprehensive Breast Evaluation Center Massachusetts General Hospital Surgeon The Newton-Wellesley Hospital.
S1207: Phase III Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Clinical Trial Evaluating the Use of Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy +/- One Year of Everolimus in Patients.
1 Risk Benefit and Conclusions George Sledge, MD Indiana University School of Medicine.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 28 – Consumer and Health Protection.
Chemoprevention of cancer Dr Manal Kahwaji Cancer fighting day Feb 2, 2016.
SCREENING IN GYNECOLOGICAL CANCER Taravat Fakheri OB/GYN KUMS.
Treatment Options for Postmenopausal Women With Early-Stage Hormone Receptor–Positive Breast Cancer Recent Trials and Future Directions Harold Burstein,
© 2010 Jones and Bartlett Publishers, LLC. Chapter 12 Clinical Epidemiology.
© Copyright Annals of Internal Medicine, 2016 Ann Int Med. 164 (6): ITC6-1. In the Clinic Breast Cancer Screening and Prevention.
Cancer prevention and early detection
Pathways involved in hereditary breast cancer
Cancer prevention and early detection
Breast Cancer Updates Risks, Genetics, DCIS
Clinical Pearls and Tools for Optimizing Breast Cancer Risk Assessment
Definition of Cancer Screening
Breast Screening and Risk Assessment
Breast Health Katherine B. Lee, MD, FACP April 26, 2018.
Breast Cancer Review 2/3/2018
ABSTRACT ABCSG 6a MA17-1 MA.17R NSABP B-33. Extended Adjuvant Therapy With Aromatase Inhibitor Among Postmenopausal Breast Cancer.
Stamatia Destounis, MD, FACR, FSBI, FAIUM
Breast Cancer Guideline Update – Sharp Focus on Who is at Risk
Presentation transcript:

Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction in Women with non Hereditary BC Risk Fabienne Liebens MD Breast Unit Isala Breast Cancer Prevention Center CHU Saint Pierre – ULB-VUB Brussels

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Prevention WHO definitions Primary prevention: covers all activities designed  to reduce the incidence of an illness in a population risk  to reduce the risk of new cases appearing Secondary prevention: (early screening/diagnosis)  to reduce the prevalence of an illness in a population  to reduce its duration Tertiary prevention:  to reduce the incidence of chronic incapacity or recurrences in a population,  to reduce the functional consequences of an illness  knowledge of independent risk factors of the disease  efficient risk reduction options

FL - BBM Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Why do we need to address these issues? – Are there effective preventive strategies? How do we assess BC risk? How could we refine risk and predict benefit of interventions? Challenges/Conclusion?

FL - BBM Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Why do we need to address these issues? – Are there effective preventive strategies? How do we assess BC risk? How could we refine risk and predict benefit of interventions? Challenges/Conclusion?

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Why ? Burden of BC European BC  2006  cases  deaths  Life time risk approaching 1 in 9 women  Demographic increase  Ageing population  Rise in young women  Wide differences in survival (16%) Eurocare 3 Adapted from Dr Nick Perry, Europa Donna Pan-European Conference- Amsterdam 2007

FL - BBM Belgian Cancer Patients’ Needs Study Frequency of difficulties encountered % More than 26 difficulties6,3% From 21 to 25 difficulties 14,0% From 16 to 20 difficulties28,7% From 11 to 15 difficulties23,7% From 6 to 10 difficulties17,9% No difficulty0 % From 1 to 5 difficulties9,4% Courtesy of Darius Razavi and Isabelle Merckaert Assessment of 38 types of difficulties (psychosocial, physical, marital, sexual…)

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Why ? Risk Factors Tamoxifen Genetic Factors Life Style EnvironmentHormonalhistory Breast Biopsy BRCA1 BRCA2  Obesity  Lack of physical activity  Alcohol  Irradiations  Diet  Tobacco Early menarcheEarly menarche Late menopauseLate menopause NulliparousNulliparous Age of first pregnancyAge of first pregnancy HRTHRT -ADH -ALH -DCIS -LCIS 5-10% >25% Breast Density

FL - BBM Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Why do we need to address these issues? – Are there effective prevention strategies? How do we assess BC risk? How could we refine risk and predict benefit of interventions? Conclusion?

FL - BBM Prevention strategies Risk FactorPrevention OptionsRisk reduction Gail risk ≥1.67Tamoxifen/Raloxifen49% BRCA1/2Mastectomy90–95% BSOophorectomyAge <35 ans 61% Age 35–50 ans 51% Age >50 yans 49% Tamoxifen50% AtypiaTamoxifen86% All womenLife style modifications30%–45% Adapted from Ozane EM. The Breast Journal 2006; 12:

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Why ? Preventive strategies  Tamoxifen/raloxifen  Prophylactic surgery  Life style modifications to quantify accurately the net risk/benefit ratio depends on the ability to quantify accurately a woman’s baseline likelihood of developing breast cancer June 2008 Bishop J et al. The Health Economic of chemoprevention for Breast Cancer in Australia. Cancer Institute NSW, June 2008

FL - BBM Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Why do we need to address these issues? – Are there effective prevention strategies? How do we assess BC risk? How could we refine risk and predict benefit of interventions? Conclusion?

FL - BBM How do we assess BC risk? Models Gail, Claus, Tyrer Cuzick  The most common models used to predict a woman’s risk of breast cancer BRCAPRO, Frank, Cough  Used in a subset of the high-risk population to predict a woman’s probability of having a genetic mutation

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment How ? Models  The Gail risk assessment model  estimates the risk of developing breast cancer in women undergoing annual screening.  Gail et al used data from 284,780 predominately white women in 28 participating centers of the Breast Cancer Detection Demonstration Project (BCDDP) to develop the model.  An unconditional logistic regression model  based on the ratio of risk in a woman with specified risk factors compared with the risk in a woman with no risk factors.

FL - BBM YES NO 0 0 1

Breast Cancer Risk Assessment How ? Models: Gail Advantages  Use is widespread, with many forms of access (National Cancer Institute [NCI] Web site, handheld and computer applications).  Applicable to the largest number of women  Has been validated  Has been shown to be well calibrated.Limitations  Does not show great discriminatory power (predicts population risk well, but not individual risk).  58%-65%-73% discriminatory  Not sufficient family history Rockhill et al. J Natl Cancer Inst 93:358, Tice. Breast Ca Res Treat 88(suppl 1):2004; abstract 13 Cuzick. ASCO Educational Session 2005 Cuzick. ASCO Educational Session 2005.

FL - BBM

Breast Cancer Risk Assessment How ? Models It is not sufficient Conclusion: It is not sufficient to use only these mathematical models for the purpose of individual decision making regarding prevention interventions.

FL - BBM Risk Assessment and Risk Reduction Why do we need to address these issues? – Are there effective prevention strategies? How do we assess BC risk? How could we refine risk and predict benefit of interventions?How could we refine risk and predict benefit of interventions? Conclusion?

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Options to Refine Risk and Predict Benefit of InterventionBiomarkers Breast Density Histologic or Cytologic evidence of atypia - To improve individualized risk assessments - To tailor prevention care

FL - BBM Mammographic Density Mammographic Density Options to Refine Risk and Predict Benefit of Intervention Reflective of amount of epithelium, stroma, and fluid relative to fat. Stroma and collagen make up the bulk of density. Strong hereditary component Boyd et al. Lancet Oncol (10): McCormack VA et al. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev (6): Chen J. et al. J Natl Cancer Inst 2006; 98: Risk biomarker for both ER + and ER - cancers in pre- and postmenopausal women.

FL - BBM Risk of Breast Cancer According to Breast Density in Premenopausal and Postmenopausal Women RR=3.4 RR=5.3 Santen et al. N Engl J Med 2005;353:275

FL - BBM Agreement between computer-assisted quantitative measurement of mammographic breast density (MBD) and clinicians' assessment. F. Liebens et al. Proceedings of EBCC-6; European Journal of Cancer 2008; 6 (7):63. (abstract 45).

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Options to Refine Risk and Predict Benefit of InterventionBiomarkers Breast Density Histologic or Cytologic evidence of atypia - To improve individualized risk assessments - To tailor prevention care

FL - BBM Proliferative benign breast disease with atypia 19/100 15y Degnim AC et al. JCO : Elmore, J. G. et al. N Engl J Med 2005;353:

FL - BBM Multifocal occult hyperplasia (+/- Atypia) is prevalent in young and middle aged high risk women high risk womenBut 80% of women have never had a diagnostic biopsy Hoogerbrugge et al. JCO :41 Schnitt. Amer J Surg Pathology :836

FL - BBM New methods Nipple aspiration fluidNAF cytology Risk Prediction Ductal LavageDL RPFNA Random peri areolar fine-needle aspiration RPFNA RPFNA  Efficient way to obtain tissue for a prevention trial (Fabian et al Frontiers Prev Res 2005)  Cost effective to determine who gets chemoprevention (Ozanne et al Cancer Epidemiol Bio Prev 2004)  Women with AH more likely to enroll on NSABP Prevention Trial (Vogel et al JNCI 2002) and to take tamoxifen (Goldenberg VK Cancer Epidemiol Bio Prev 2007)

FL - BBM Adapted from Arun, B. et al. Clin Cancer Res 2007;13: Cytologic findings RPFNA Ductal lavage Non proliferative epithelium Atypical hyperplasia

FL - BBM Models for Phase II Chemoprevention Trials for Women at High Risk of BC Study Agent Tissue Based Biomarkers Morphology Proliferation NAF Nipple aspiration fluid DL Ductal lavage RPFNA Random periareolar fine needle aspiration RANDOMIZATIONRANDOMIZATION Placebo Repeat Biomarkers 6-12 months Adapted from Fabian C. Endocrine related Cancer 2005 Imaging-Based Biomarkers Mammographic Breast density

FL - BBM  AIM of a consultation about breast cancer risk assessment determine  to determine if risk level is high enough to warrant special surveillance measures or prevention interventions, motivate  if so, motivate those at high risk to partake in surveillance/prevention options eassure  reassure those at low/moderate risk Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Why and How ? Clinical Practice NCNN Breast Cancer risk reduction V Kushi LH. CA Cancer J Clinic 2006 Sivell S. Cochrane databases of systematic reviews 2007 Kiluk J. Cancer Control 2007

FL - BBM European Journal of Cancer Prevention 2008 in press

FL - BBM Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Challenges  Improve woman’s awareness/Knowledge?  Best practice in risk communication ?  Cost effectiveness ?  Best biomarker that predicts both risks and benefits from intervention ?  Improve the skills of primary care providers ?

FL - BBM “…Cancer is a multistage disease, not a single event, and doctors should emphasize cancer prevention in addition to cancer treatment and cure …” Peter Greenwald, Division of Cancer Prevention, National Cancer Institute.

Life is a sexually transmitted disease and there is a 100% mortality rate “… Life is a sexually transmitted disease and there is a 100% mortality rate. …” Woody Allen