“Is development best facilitated nationally or through regional cooperation and harmonization: The Case of Biotechnology” Carlos Alberto Primo Braga John.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Relative Importance of North-South and South-South Trade Bipul Chatterjee Deputy Executive Director, CUTS International (
Advertisements

UN-OHRLLS International support measures and financial resources for LLDCs Gladys Mutangadura UN-OHRLLS.
Final Report Presentation By Mohammad Saber Sakhizada March,26 – 2009.
Entrepreneurship youth
Marshall McLuhan: The medium is the message. Introduction  ICTs – Information and Communication Technologies  ICTs can be an important tool in the fight.
1 Managing IP in Knowledge-based Development International cooperation to improve framework conditions in catching-up economies Ralph Heinrich UNECE Team.
1 Foreign Direct Investment and IP in Knowledge-based Development Ralph Heinrich UNECE Team of Specialists on Intellectual Property Minsk, 9-10 June 2010.
Advancing Knowledge in the Public Sector: A World Bank Perspective ©Knowledge for Development, WBI Carl Dahlman World Bank Advancing Knowledge and the.
EGM on Free/ Open Source Software in the Arab Region The UNDP Perspective: F/OSS as a Tool for Development and The F/OSS Initiative in the Arab Region.
Instrumental Philanthropy: Trade and the Geographical Distribution of Foreign Aid Erik Lundsgaarde, Christian Breunig, and Aseem Prakash Department of.
Describe the key policy measures that make globalization sustainable.
Cooperatives and Youth in the Context of Rural Development Presented at the Seminar Organized by Agri-Seta Prof. Muxe Nkondo National Small Business Advisory.
AGRICULTURE- TRADE- CHILDHOOD OBESITY PREVENTION Vincent J. Atkins Office of Trade Negotiations CARICOM Secretariat.
National Innovation Systems Presented by Team 4: Xindi Li Herlinna Chung Lina Liu Alix Linaker Katrina Cheney.
Introduction to Sociology
South-South Cooperation for Democratic Development: CSO Key Messages and Policy Recommendations.
1 Making choices for the 21 st century. A new strategy: What is needed? 2 Any new strategy should be based on: an understanding of key strategic challenges;
The WIPO Development Agenda: An Overview Geneva May, 2009 Esteban Burrone World Intellectual Property Organization.
GEO Work Plan Symposium 2012 ID-05 Resource Mobilization for Capacity Building (individual, institutional & infrastructure)
Switzerland’s Intellectual Property cooperation with Vietnam and Lao PDR Funded by: Federal Department of Economic Affairs FDEA State Secretariat.
Business in a Global Economy
Globalization Pg Globalization Globalization – the process by which national economies, politics, cultures, and societies become integrated with.
Part E – IMPACT OF MULTINATIONAL BUSINESSES ON HOST COUNTRIES AS (3.2): Demonstrate understanding of strategic response to external factors by a.
Mainstream Market for Products produced by Micro Entrepreneurs and means to sell in Larger Market Place.
The African Development Bank’s Contribution to Aid for Trade (AfT) Henri A. MINNAAR NEPAD, Regional Integration and Trade Department WIPO Conference on.
1 National innovation systems Sub-regional seminar on the commercialization and enforcement of intellectual property rights Skopje, Macedonia April.
How Can Countries Benefit from the Presence of Multinational Firms ? Evidence from EU Member Countries and Some Thoughts on South East Europe Bernhard.
Role of international networks in informing TVET policy and practice Rod Camm Managing Director UNESCO-UNEVOC Regional Forum 31 August 2014 #
1 ISSUES RELATED TO TECHNOLOGY AND INVESTMENT POLICIES AND THE TRIPS AGREEMENT UNCTAD Commercial Diplomacy Programme Assad Omer, DITE UNCTAD.
Armenia and Diaspora Armenia’s investment climate and Diaspora’s participation in development policies. Hayk Sargsyan, Johns Hopkins University.
Entrepreneurship As a Community Development Strategy John Gruidl and Deborah M. Markley.
A new start for the Lisbon Strategy Knowledge and innovation for growth.
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE sustainable solutions for ending hunger and poverty Ghana Strategy Support Program Concluding Remarks and.
WINGS Report International Meeting of Associations serving Grantmakers (IMAG) in Oaxaca, Mexico Recognized importance of creating.
1 1 The Global Project on Measuring the Progress of Societies OECD World Forum on Statistics, Knowledge and Policy Jon Hall, World Forum Project Leader,
What is HMN? Global partnership founded on the premise that better health information means better decisions and better health Partners reflect wide.
Globalization, Trade, Investment, and Environment Session Objectives: l Debate risks and opportunities of economic globalization l Identify SD requirements.
Overview of Issues and Interests in Standards and Interoperability Mary Saunders Chief, Standards Services Division NIST.
Trade, Environment and Sustainable Development Elements of A Southern Agenda.
1 Structural Reform: An Important Aspect of Regional Economic Integration Kyung-Tae Lee.
Globalization of Ethical Decision Making C H A P T E R 10.
Business Education in “Dynamic Societies”: identification of management models and cooperation opportunities Antonio Freitas, PhD Provost, FGV Brazilian.
UK INNOVATION SURVEY 2005 CIS4 – Introduction and Guide A brief introduction to the survey Some description of the data and analytical results, special.
Financing for Development: A Progress Report on the Implementation of the Monterrey Consensus Meeting of the Committee of Experts of the 3rd Joint Annual.
Developments in International Trade Stephen Karingi 2 nd June, 2011.
Global public policy network on water management Water and Climate Change Adaptation – Key Messages for COP-15 gppn.
Second International Seville Seminar on Future-Oriented Technology Analysis (FTA): Impacts on policy and decision making 28th- 29th September 2006 The.
South and East Africa Regional Working Group. Charge to Regional Working Groups Each Regional Group identifies: Strengths – Gaps –Opportunities, towards.
Regional Cooperation: NAFTA
Open-ended Forum on Proposed Development Agenda Projects October 13-14, 2009 Intellectual Property and Technology Transfer : “Common Challenges – Building.
Trade and Technology Transfer Working Group Session.
1 Commercialization Segment Introduction Ralph Heinrich UNECE Team of Specialists on Intellectual Property Skopje, 1 April 2009.
Unit 5, Lesson 14 Trade Barriers and Trade Agreements AOF Business Economics Copyright © 2008–2011 National Academy Foundation. All rights reserved.
© 2017 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
Unit 1 Globalization CGW 4U0. Globalization ✤ the trend toward greater interconnectedness of the world’s financial, economic, technological, political,
Global Cocoa Agenda Roadmap Mind-mapping for Change By Alex Bruijnis Chairman of ICCO Council for a Sustainable World Cocoa Economy.
Over the past few decades, there has been a growing trend toward families of interrelated and cooperating companies operating throughout the world. As.
Globalization. What is Globalization? Globalization: The increased movement of people, knowledge and ideas, and goods and money across national borders.
UN-OHRLLS Improving transit cooperation, trade and trade facilitation for the benefit of the LLDCs: Current Status and Policy implications - Global Report.
Globalisation, outsourcing and productivity Rachel Griffith UCL, Institute for Fiscal Studies.
Global Trade. Absolute Advantage given the same amount of resources, one country can produce more of a product than another country can. A country has.
Globalization.
Growth in East Asia: Innovative Firms in Dynamic Cities Shahid Yusuf World Bank DECRG February 18, 2004.
Australia’s aid for trade approaches Presentation by Henni Arup Multilateral Aid for Trade Section Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade.
International Economics Analyze costs and benefits of global trade
Chapter 8 Learning Objectives
The Role of Bilateral Donors in supporting capacity-building in the area of ICT Open Consultations on Financing Mechanisms for Meeting the Challenges.
African Energy Sector: Status Analysis and Main Challenges
How did this happen so fast?
Presentation transcript:

“Is development best facilitated nationally or through regional cooperation and harmonization: The Case of Biotechnology” Carlos Alberto Primo Braga John Anthony Daly Nancy Adele Johnson

The global biotechnology innovation system currently does not fully apply the technology to the most pressing global needs, especially as they pertain to the needs of development.

Society could do better by: improving the institutions that transfer biotech innovations from the strong R&D systems of the North to the South where they are needed; and building biotechnology capacity in developing nations.

Some Observations of the Impact of Harmonization on Development A network of international treaties has encouraged harmonization; A system of multinational organizations provides services which also encourage harmonization; A number of regional organizations further harmonize IPRs among the countries which they serve; and While there has been considerable harmonization of IPR systems among countries, there remains wide variation among nations.

In the case of biotechnology, the current status of the various debates around TRIPS make it unlikely that the maximalist agenda of harmonization can be further advanced at the WTO level.

We conclude that the jury is still out on the importance of harmonization of IPRs as a tool for development.

Disadvantages of Harmonization There are those who feel poor countries should create IPR systems to maximize the application of existing technology rather than to stimulate innovation. Innovating countries seek harmonization for commercial reasons rather than the public good The AIDS controversy has shown that in some cases there is a strong moral argument against a harmonized IPR system, and exceptions should be made.

Disadvantages of Harmonization Strengthening IPR systems has improved biotechnology application to the problems of poverty only where other factors are in place, and those factors may well be more important than the IPR. In biotechnology, there are culturally-based, deeply held values that may militate against harmonization of biotechnology IPRs across cultures.

Advantages of Harmonization As the European Union-Japan-United States enthusiasm for their trilateral harmonization shows, harmonization pays off for the big three. Harmonization probably raises the quality of IPR systems towards a high international standard. OECD countries have expended significant efforts toward improving their systems, while the least developed countries have few IPR experts and little IPR experience; the LDCs may therefore benefit from the knowledge and experience of the OECD countries. Harmonized IPRs help attract biotechnology investment into developing countries, which is a critical factor in the transfer of the technology.

Advantages of Harmonization The TRIPS agreement and related harmonization approaches are helping to open the world to trade involving biotechnology, which has significant benefits. Efforts such as the creation of regional IPR organizations (which provide efficiencies of scale among other benefits), the creation of an international knowledge base and dialog on IPRs, and of international technical assistance agencies serving the South's IPR community all tend to produce harmonization as a side product.

Advantages of Harmonization Harmonization helps provide incentives for innovators in the North to seek wider applications of their innovations and to innovate for a wider regional or global market. Harmonization may provide some incentives to innovators in the South to commercialize the biotechnology, and to seek wider markets for their innovations.

We leave unanswered whether the advantages outweigh the disadvantages.

Even if the advantages outweigh the disadvantage, we warn that harmonization of IPRs is only a small part of the job of institution building that needs to be done!