5 Point Rubric 5 = A Comprehensive / analytical Essay (uses all documents, strong thesis, extensive outside information) 4 = B well written / includes some analysis (uses 6-8 docs, good thesis, strong outside information) 3 = C Well written but lacks balance / lacks analysis (uses 5 to 6 docs, acceptable thesis, limited outside info.) 2 = D Weak Essay / lacks organization / no analysis (uses at least 5 docs, simple thesis, little outside information) 1 = F Poorly written / barely addresses question (less than 5 docs, no thesis, no outside info, factual errors

5+ = 50/50 points 100% 5 = 47/50 points 94% 5- = 45/50 points90% 4+ = 44/50 points88% 4 = 42/50 points84% 4- = 40/50 points80% 3+ = 39/50 points78% 3 = 37/50 points74% 3- = 35/50 points70% 2+ = 34/50 points68% 2 = 32/50 points64% 2- = 30 points60% 1 = 28 points58%

Question Question: To what extent is it justified to characterize the industrial leaders of the era as either “robber barons” or “industrial statesmen”? An argumentative paper makes a claim about a topic and justifies this claim with specific evidence. The claim could be an opinion, a policy proposal, an evaluation, a cause- and-effect statement, or an interpretation. The goal of the argumentative paper is to convince the audience that the claim is true based on the evidence provided.

Outline Introduction Paragraph * background information about the industrial revolution & rise of the industrial statesman Age of new industry: later 1800’s, new technology, methods of manufacturing, establishment of corporations (Trusts), Industrialist: Vanderbilt, Morgan, Rockefeller, Carnegie, Edison

Thesis Your thesis statement should be specific—it should cover only what you will discuss in your paper and should be supported with specific evidence. A thesis is a statement that reflects what you have concluded about the topic of your paper, based on a critical analysis and interpretation of the source materials you have examined.

sample Identify issues raised by the growth of Manchester in the 19 th century. Thesis: “ Over the course of the 19 th century the growth of Manchester raised provocative issues of public health, political unrest, and concerns over the beauty of the city.

Body Introductory sentence: identify the topic of the paragraph (address thesis) Paragraph should provide a comprehensive analysis of the topic with outside information (information not included in the documents) and the documents. Focus on addressing your thesis by providing supporting evidence! When a document is used by referring to the content of the document, paraphrasing, and or quoting – end the sentence. (Doc A)

sample John D. Rockefeller was depicted as a “robber baron” in political cartoons which illustrated the greedy, cut throat tactics he used to build Standard Oil into a monopoly. (Doc. F)

Conclusion Summary of your essay Focus on restating your thesis statement DO NOT introduce new information in the conclusion!

Outline Intro Paragraph * Background / Thesis Body Paragraph: Robber Baron * Outside info / documents Body Paragraph: Industrial Statesmen * Outside info / documents Conclusion * summary / restate thesis

5 Point Rubric 5 = A Comprehensive / analytical Essay (uses all documents, strong thesis, extensive outside information) 4 = B well written / includes some analysis (uses 6-8 docs, good thesis, strong outside information) 3 = C Well written but lacks balance / lacks analysis (uses 5 to 6 docs, acceptable thesis, limited outside info.) 2 = D Weak Essay / lacks organization / no analysis (uses at least 5 docs, simple thesis, little outside information) 1 = F Poorly written / barely addresses question (less than 5 docs, no thesis, no outside info, factual errors )