Imperfect Markets and Welfare ECO /8/13 Dr. Watson AUN
People are Rational Making “right” choices: Maximize utility People think at the margin – marginal cost Preference Have GOALS. Make choices in order to fulfill those goals Preferences complete Preferences transitive Bananas>apples>papaya>banana
What are your goals? Graduate Get a job Work for customs Governor of CBN Graduate school – higher degrees N N N N N N N 4.0 this semester Go out there somewhere. Do research Write a fantasy book; religion book See my children married and happy Stay awake during this class
Self-Interested Trying to please yourself Trying to make yourself better off Doing this to make you happy Needs come before everyone else NOT SELF-CENTERED I am happy when my kids are happy In ECO 301, we ignore other people Others can be in my utility function
Why do markets work? If I make my customers happy, I become rich Social awareness provides intrinsic value As customer, I trade money for something I need more. Producer does not value the stuff as much as the consumer. Producer wants to buy something else and needs money to do it. Coffee bean video:
What are the conditions? Craftsmanship and quality Demand – need People who CAN and WILL spend money Market PLACE Sufficient supply Inputs, factors of production Trust Why thieves hate free markets Transparency Thick markets – lots ofbuyers/sellers Princess Academy by Shannon Hale
The market works. Hunh? Everybody is “happy” Goods have to move freely A: Efficient allocation of resources 1. Resources used to their full productive capacity Prices tell us 2. Resources used to make people as happy as possible PARETO EFFICIENCY
Pareto Improvements
Pareto Pareto improvement: I can make at least one person better off without making anyone else worse off. DOES NOT NOT NOT mean: If you cannot make anyone better off without making someone else worse off, DON’T do it In that case, Pareto says: “????”
First Welfare Theorem Given some assumptions ANY competitive equilibrium is Pareto efficient Perfect Information Complete markets Price-taking behavior Marginal social benefits/costs = private
Second Welfare Theorem Given some more assumptions You can reach ANY Pareto outcome using a competitive equilibrium through lump sum transfers PLUS No increasing returns to scale What the government needs Perfect knowledge of tastes and production Perfect benevolence All power of enforcement
Homework Watch the following video on why markets do not work in Africa MJi9tRok MJi9tRok For each case study in the video, identify which of the assumptions of the 1 st and 2 nd Welfare Theorems are failing and why.