Stigma and disabling images. For Goffman, we never meet others with our hands open and with an attentive gaze. Rather, we meet the other with a multitude.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Legal Capacity, Personhood and Supported Decision Making
Advertisements

Educational Psychology and Inclusion in Education
1 1.
The Narrator Pegasus Press. Necessity? Is The Narrator Necessary? – In all narratives?
Introduction to Moral Issues
The Man He Killed Thomas Hardy. Hardy reduces a killing on the battlefield simply to two innocent young men who have arrived at their present circumstances.
Cultural Diversity Lesson Three: Attitudes & Consequences and Sport In & Through Sport.
PDP 8 – Reflective writing
Introduction to Literary Terms and Short Stories
Social deprivation “Prisoners are people who have failed. Many will have had a long history of failure at home, at school, at work and at establishing.
Deviance? Deviance Deviance - behaviour that differs from the social norms of the group and is judged wrong by other members of that.
PSYCHOLOGY – RESEARCH METHODS Ethical Guidelines Human Participants The British Psychological Society – Human Participants.
T HINKING ABOUT RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN MEN AND WOMEN Partners, parents and people Prof Brid Featherstone Open University.
Introduction - disability1 Introduction to Disability.
Disabling imagery Images as ‘disciplinary power’.
Violence Prevention. Preventing school violence is a top priority for school and public safety officials today. Efforts include creating more positive.
Linking the Fairs to the 2013 Ontario Curriculum Social Studies 1 to 6 and History and Geography 7 and 8.
Income Programs and Social Rights and Wrongs Michael J. Prince Remarks for the Human Rights and Persons with Intellectual Disabilities Conference Niagara.
1 Labelling and rights Bailey (1998: 173):  ‘students with ADHD must be identified in order to receive the support they need to participate fully in the.
Chapter 6 Consumer Attitudes Consumer Attitudes.
Divine Truth Building Faith In God’s Love. Summary of Cornelius’ Life In 1st Century  Suffered a life of violent sexual and physical abuse as a child.
The Marxist perspective ‘Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please; they do not make it under circumstances chosen by themselves.
Understanding and Working with Students & Adults from Poverty
Seeman’s Theory/Durkheim & Suicide/ “The Bully” Debrief
Habitus and Cognitive Praxis among Environmentalists  Randolph Haluza-DeLay  Paper Two of dissertation: Developing a Compassionate Sense of Place  July,
Chapter 9, Race and Ethnicity Key Terms. chance Those things not subject to human will, choice or effort. context The larger social setting in which racial.
Sondra E. Solomon, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Psychological Science, College of Arts and Sciences Clinical Associate Professor of Psychiatry, College.
Intercultural learning
My Pedagogic Creed by John Dewey.
The role of self-handicapping in social networks Bridgett J. Milner Edward R. Hirt Thanks to: Kristin Hendrix & Erin Steury.
Groups and Intergroup Relations: Canadian Perceptions.
 Young children view the world very differently from adults.  E.g. no unusual for a child to think the sun follows them.  Field of cognitive psychology.
Writing Analytically.
Important Literary Elements Irony Point of View Symbolism.
United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
Social Justice Why are issues of diversity, oppression and social justice important to everyone? Do individuals have a responsibility to support social.
Key Concepts: Representation
Law & Promise Mary Nugent Programme Developers Summit 5 – 9 th May 2010, Jambville, France.
Media representations of disability
ETHICS ON BROADCASTING. BROADCASTING A medium that disseminates via telecommunications. It is the act of transmitting speech, music, visual images, etc.,
From the toolbox of theory:Which theoretical tools are uesful for understanding inclusive practices in Icelandic schools? The 8th International Conference.
How can we challenge stereotypes?
EDC1200 – Self, Education & Society Teaching Episodes Donna Huntress Student Number:
Education for Moral Development: Kohlberg’s Stages of Moral Development and Integrative Education CS480 Computer Science Seminar Fall, 2002.
Chapter 1: The Nature of Theatre Origins in ritual practices Theatre as a form is at least 2500 years old It has been as varied as the cultures in which.
Understanding Oppression Civil War Unit- Day 1. Dominant vs. Subordinate Dominant, Oppressor:  Access to power  Economic control  Provide standards,
Please check, just in case…. APA Tip of the Day: Quotations of 40 or more words Include direct quotations from your primary text only as absolutely needed.
1 Social Structure and Anomie Merton, R.K. (1938).
The state of play of inclusive education EASPD Salzburg conference 22-23th of October 2015 Peder Haug Volda University College, Norway 1.
Representation Who has voice (and who does not). Images, Images Everywhere! over abundance of images surround us we cant immediately decode all of the.
Race and Ethnicity as Lived Experience
A medium that disseminates via telecommunications. It is the act of transmitting speech, music, visual images, etc., as by radio or television. Broadcasting.
Looking Glass Theory. Meet John  John is a 20 year old college student  He attends a 4 year university  John is the only child of his overprotective.
Questions of representation However realistic media images seem, they never simply present the world direct. They are always a construction, a re-presentation,
Motif.
Language and Social Relations RACE. Language and Social Relations Black English, or African-American Vernacular English (AAVE) is one of the more debated.
Disability and Identity
Intro. To Psychology Intro. Unit Mr. Stalnaker. Psychology What is Psychology? Psychology is old as a study but young, vigorous, and growing as an organized.
Understanding Literary Theory and Critical Lenses
Dis/Ability in Pop Culture Jitka Sinecká, Ph.D. Class 1.
Ethics on Broadcasting
Tips: On Promoting the Positive Portrayal of People with Disabilities
Ethics on Broadcasting
CHAPTER 4 Designing Studies
Ethics on Broadcasting
Power as collective action
Psychoanalytic Critical Lens
PERSON CENTERED APPROACH
BASIC DATA ABOUT PWD IN SERBIA
Lesson 4: Perspective taking and the beauty, body, and perception
Presentation transcript:

Stigma and disabling images

For Goffman, we never meet others with our hands open and with an attentive gaze. Rather, we meet the other with a multitude of pre-existing categories and stereotypes into with the stranger may immediately be fitted. As a consequence, we are able, ‘without special attention or thought’, to meet a stranger and “anticipate his category and attributes, his ‘social identity’ …” (Goffman, 1990: 12). In other words, we all carry with us, ‘normative expectations’ (Goffman, 1990: 12).

However, we are often unaware of our ‘normative expectations’. We are not, that is, actively conscious of our projecting of a character type onto the other at the point at which we meet them. Thus, ‘the character we impute to the individual might better be seen as an imputation made in potential retrospect - a characterization ‘in effect’, a virtual social identity’ (original emphasis, Goffman, 1990: 12). It is a ‘socially anticipated category’ (Goffman, 1990: 13).

It is not until a stranger enters into our midst and disrupts the stereotype or identity we had projected onto them that a distance opens between this ‘virtual social identity’ and ‘his actual social identity’ (original emphasis, Goffman, 1990: 12). Goffman characterises a stigma as ‘a special discrepancy between virtual and actual social identity’ (Goffman, 1990: 12-3). It is ‘an undesired differentness from what we had anticipated’ (Goffman, 1990: 15). Hence, before we can begin to examine stigmas, ‘a language of relationships, not attributes, is really needed’ (Goffman, 1990: 13).

The discredited and the discreditable Goffman points us to stigma’s ‘double perspective’: there is ‘the plight of the discredited,’ for whom ‘differentness is known about already or is evident on the spot’, and ‘the discreditable,’ for whom ‘it is neither known about by those present nor immediately perceivable’ (original emphasis, Goffman, 1990: 14). Goffman (1990: 14) observes: ‘This is an important difference, even though a particular stigmatized individual is likely to have experience with both situations’.

The distinction points to two ways in which images might come to disable persons. First, it might strengthen the exclusionary force which acts ‘discredit’ the stigmatised by magnifying ‘differentness’, and thereby reinforcing the belief that ‘the person with a stigma is not quite human’ (Goffman, 1990: 15). Second, it might act to shift the plight of the ‘discreditable’ to that of those who are ‘discredited’ by making a hidden ‘differentness’ visible.

The stigmatised and the ‘normals’ ‘We and those who do not depart negatively from the particular expectations at issue I shall call the normals’ (Goffman, 1990: 15). (Note: irony.) “The notion of ‘normal human being’ may have its source in the medical approach to humanity or in the tendency of large- scale bureaucratic organizations, such as the nation state, to treat all members in some respects as equal” (Goffman, 1990, f/n: 17). (Consider connection with Arendt’s views about ‘society’.) A view of the ‘normal’ human being is itself a stereotype. To delimit the other is to have already done the same to one’s self. We are a subject of the tyranny of normality all the more we stigmatise the other as being something different to or less than ‘normal’.

Stigmas and disabling images Prejudice is not just interpersonal – between the abled and the dis-abled – but is also implicit in cultural representations of persons with impairments (Shakespeare, 1994).

From Barnes (1992): Categories of disability The disabled person as an object of ridicule The tragic conception of disability The disabled person as sinister and evil The disabled person with super human abilities The disabled person as incapable of participating fully in community life

The disabled person as an object of ridicule A stigma, Goffman observes, acts upon an individual to exclude and disable, it ‘spoils his social identity; it has the effect of cutting him off from society and from himself so that he stands a discredited person facing an unaccepting world’ (Goffman, 1990: 31). Perhaps, no images do more to amplify the exclusionary force of the sigma than those that present persons with impairments as objects of amusement.

The Trentonian (New Jersey), July 10th, 2002:

The tragic conception of disability The consequence of a pitying gaze is, Goffman suggests, ‘that the stigmatized individual is a person who can be approached by strangers at will, providing only that they are sympathetic to the plight of persons of his kind’ (Goffman, 1990: 28). There is a loss of privacy and human dignity. ‘The pitiful disabled characters initially evoke hostile feelings because they have come to represent experiences – such as vulnerability and dependency – which have been repressed in the spectator. These hostile feelings are then quickly transformed … into guilt and attempts to secure forgiveness’. (Marks, 1999: )

Posters for a drugs company

The disabled person as sinister and evil  ‘Newspaper articles sensationalising the connection between intellectual impairments and criminality are common in both the tabloids and the ‘quality’ papers. The overall message coming out of these stories is that such people cannot be trusted, are a danger to children and should be locked up’. (Barnes, 1992)

Schizoid (1972) The Warning: ‘Not Recommended Viewing for Persons with Schizophrenic Tendencies!’

The disabled person as a person with super human abilities Of the sigmatised individual, Goffman observes: ‘[H]e is likely to feel that the usual scheme of interpretation for everyday events has been undermined. His minor accomplishments, he feels, may be assessed as signs of remarkable and noteworthy capacities in the circumstances’ (Goffman, 1990: 26). ‘... by flaunting normal accomplishments as extraordinary, by hailing people with disabilities as human wonders, aggrandized presentations probably taught the lesson that achievement for people with differences was unusual rather than common’. (Bogdan, 1988: 279).

The disabled person as incapable of inclusion in community life The disabled amount to just 1.5% of all characters portrayed in TV films and dramas (Cumberbatch & Negrine,1992) In contrast, Government evidence reveals that at least 12% of the British population are disabled people (Barnes, 1992).

Goffman speaks of ‘moral careers’, that is the learning of what and who we are and how we are perceived by others (Goffman, 1990: 45). Goffman points, in particular, to the significance of formal school in the ‘moral career’ of those who come to be stigmatised. He writes:  Interestingly, the more the child is ‘handicapped’ the more likely he is to be sent to a special school for persons of his kind, and the more abruptly he will have to face the view which the public at large takes of him. He will be told that he will have an easier time of it among ‘his own’, and thus learn that the own he thought he possessed was the wrong one, and that this lesser own is really his. (Goffman, 1990: 47) What then of those images which point to the ‘natural’ segregation of persons with impairments? What is their educative force in the ‘moral careers’ of disabled persons?

Warned New Yorkers to beware of a terrifying new crime wave: "In our newfound complacency, we have forgotten a particular kind of violence to which we are still prey. The violence of the mentally-ill."

Poster for a drug company

Wiseness: Beyond disabling images ‘Wise persons are the marginal men before whom the individual with a fault need feel no shame nor exert self- control, knowing that in spite of his failing he will be seen as an ordinary other’ (Goffman, 1990: 41).

References Bogdan, R. (1988) Freak show: presenting human oddities for amusement and profit (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press) Barnes, C. (1992) Disabling Imagery and the Media: An Exploration of the Principles for Media Representations of Disabled People, [Online] studies/archiveuk/Barnes/disabling%20imagery.pdfhttp:// studies/archiveuk/Barnes/disabling%20imagery.pdf Cumberbatch, G. & Negrine, R. (1992) Images of Disability on Television, London, Routledge). Goffman, E. (1990) Stigma: Notes on the management of spoiled identity (Penguin, London) Oliver, M. and Barnes, C. (1998) Disabled People and Social Policy: From Exclusion to Inclusion, Harlow, Addison Wesley Longman. Marks, D. (1999) Disability: Controversial debates and psychological perspectives (London: Rutledge) Shakespeare. T. (1994) Cultural Representation of Disabled People: Dustbins for Disavowal? Disability and Society, 9(3) Shakespeare, T. (1999) Art and lies? Representations of disability on film, In M. Corker & S. French (Eds) Disability Discourse (Philadelphia: Open University Press)