1 Fábio Gomes May 1, 2009 This work was adapted from my social policy master dissertation entitled: “Threats to equity in organ allocation for transplantation:

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Data 14/10/08 Research Department National Accounts Coordination Health and education volume output in Brazil.

Advertisements

GOOD GOVERNANCE AND REGULATORY REFORM Dr. Panagiotis Karkatsoulis Policy Advisor, Ministry of Interior, Public Administration and Decentralisation.

Second Regional Conference on Prospects and Challenges facing the Modernization of the Legal Environment to enable Business and Investment in the MENA.

Cohesion Policy focus on performance experiences of the Hungarian Presidency Dr. Györgyi Nyikos Deputy State Secretary for Development Affairs Ministry.

Ecological Economics Lecture 11 Tiago Domingos Assistant Professor Environment and Energy Section Department of Mechanical Engineering Doctoral Program.

213 INADEC - C2013 INADEC INADEC – Consumer Protection and Competition Highlights By : Paulina Semedo – Director General of INADEC Livingstone,

1 HEALTH LITIGATION AND NEW CHALLENGES IN THE MANAGEMENT OF PHARMACEUTICAL SERVICES Vera Lucia Edais Pepe Tatiana Aragão Figueiredo Luciana Simas Claudia.

O.C. Ferrell, UNM Linda Ferrell, UNM. What are principles? Laws of the universe that pertain to human relationships & human organizations Fairness, equity,

Ministério da Saúde Secretaria de Vigilância em Saúde - SVS Coordenação Geral de Vigilância em Saúde Ambiental - CGVAM Bangkok - July 6 th, 2008 CONSULTATIVE.

SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT AND THE INFORMAL SECTOR: AN UNEASY RELATIONSHIP Written by Helen Briassoulis Presented by Marit Lothe - Norway Leanna Robertson.

C h a p t e r o n e Economics: Foundations and Models.

Expanded Version of COSO a presentation by Steve Wadleigh Expanded Version of COSO a presentation by Steve Wadleigh Standards for Internal Control in the.

© 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education. This is proprietary material solely for authorized instructor use. Not authorized for sale or distribution in any manner.

Master course Compound System of Governance Thomas Fleiner Guestprofessor Constitutional models and problems of distribution of powers in compound systems.

The State Aid Action Plan Thibaut KLEINER DG COMP Global Competition Law Centre 19 September 2005 – Brussels.

Opportunities for RAC Participation. Three Part discussion General presentation; Example of oil and gas decision making; and Panel Discussion of RAC involvement.

Tasks and responsibilities of the German organ procurement organization DSO Technical Assistance for Alignment in Organ Donation 1st International Symposium.

Class 11 Slides Shifting From Efficient Allocation to Fair Distribution of Resources If Suppliers Are More Than Passive Actors in the Markets for Health.

European values and media pluralism Petra Lea Láncos.

ATHIAS,L MDG data disaggregation by ethnic group Brazil Session 3: Localizing MDG monitoring Panel 3.1 Localizing the MDGs October 20, 2011 Leonardo.

Meeting I Development Plan Health Stakeholder Group.

Defining Responsible Forest Management FSC Forest Certification Standards Defining Responsible Forest Management Version:

Implementing the Second Pillar of the Aarhus Convention: Problems Identified in the National Implementation Reports Magda Tóth Nagy, Senior Expert Geneva,

States and Government Companies Murilo Barella Brasília – 12 Março 2013.

Food an Nutrition Security Policy in Brazil. Luciene Burlandy.

AU- MAEL Dr. Dan Bertrand

ALL-UKRAINIAN PUBLIC ORGANIZATION “PUBLIC TRANSPORT SAFETY COMMITTEE”

Indicators for Criminal Cases Management in Bulgaria Public Hearing: Improving Criminal Justice Systems in Europe: The Role of E-Tools and Performance.

CRITICAL QUESTION How should the bounty of a society be distributed?

Strategic Planning Process in the Labor Administration _________________________________________ Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare (MTPS) El Salvador.

Locating Authority in Urban Climate Adaptation: Processes and Consequences Sara Hughes National Center for Atmospheric Research Governing Adaptation Amsterdam.

A.ABDULLAEV, Director of the Public Fund for Support and Development of Print Media and Information Agencies of Uzbekistan.

Zimbabwe CSOs TRIPS and Access to medicines Aulline Mabika-Chapisa.

First Class: Main Institutional Concepts of Federal Systems of Governance Thomas Fleiner Prof. Thomas Fleiner*/ Prof. Dr. Lidija R. Basta Fleiner Theories.

Environmental Management System Definitions

MOT Dr. Dinh Thi My Loan Director General, Competition Administration Department MINISTRY OF TRADE STRENGTHENING THE TASK OF CONSUMER PROTECTION IN VIETNAM.

Trends in use of coercion in Norway Trond Hatling Head.

Dimension 5. Social dialogue and workplace relationships Prepared by Judit Lakatos and Elizabeth Lindner Hungarian Central Statistical Office.

Basic Nursing: Foundations of Skills & Concepts Chapter 7 ETHICAL RESPONSIBILITIES.

Strengths and weaknesses of the implementation of the Bologna Process: Spain Round Table Bratislava,10-12 October Guillermo Bernabeu, University of Alicante.

1 UNECE REAL ESTATE MARKET ADVISORY GROUP (REM) UN ECONOMIC COMMISSION FOR EUROPE REAL ESTATE MARKET ADVISORY GROUP (REM) FIABCI WORK DAYS - BRUSSELS 3.

T he EU Budget and Cohesion Policy: Looking to the future Carlos Mendez EPRC EU Cohesion Policy workshop, 5 December 2008, Glasgow.

Class 12 slides: Equity and Redistribution following Rawls Other conceptions of Welfare (151) Alternative Concepts of Utility (154) Cash versus In-kind.

Guide to Options Comparison Revision of the SAFEGROUNDS Guidance James Penfold, Quintessa SAFESPUR, 4 October 2007.

Health Services Organization and Management HSA 500 Ethical Issues in Public Health and Health Services Williams, S. J., & Torrens, P. R. (2008). Introduction.

Judicial Review The Judicial Branch Article III. Jurisdiction Original jurisdiction: where the case is heard first, usually in a trial. Appellate jurisdiction:

Equity: Ethical Approaches to Social Justice “Excuse me, but its important to get those drinks to those who need them the most.”

Peter Reading Equality and Human Rights Commission United Kingdom 1.

Kuliah 4 Etika Profesi dan Bisnis Oleh Coky Fauzi Alfi cokyfauzialfi.wordpress.com Ethical Decision-Making Process.

Strategic Objective 4 To promote the exchange of experiences and regulatory knowledge between NRAs inside and outside PANDRH“ Lessons learned from international.

National Consultation. Custome Slide Outline Regional Strategy – Introduction – Background – Current situation: challenges in moving toward Universal.

Bulgarian National Hepatitis Plan and Compassionate Use Regulations Dr. Stanimir Hasardzhiev Executive Director, ELPA Chairperson, Hepasist REPUBLIC OF.

Universal Health Coverage:

American Government and Politics Today Chapter 15 The Courts.

Georgia Council on Economic Education w w w. g c e e. o r g Focus: Understanding Economics in Civics and Government LESSON 4 What Are The Economic Functions.

Key Challenges in extending social security. Social Security: key Challenges   Social Security as a human right? Or is it individual responsibility?

Overview of Environmental Management Systems Using ISO John Rupe Forest Service Rocky Mountain Region.

Building an Effective Paperless Records Management Governance Structure BADM 559 Enterprise IT Governance Professor Michael Shaw By Moh’d A. Obeidat 12/15/2008.

BLM Decision Making Process

Chapter 13 Managing compensation

Internal Control.

Agency Performance: A New Agenda

Project Human Resource Management

WHO Meeting of Interested Parties

Seminar on Evaluation of Internal Control Systems

Health in the Americas: Regional Challenges and Strategic Directions

DIRECTORATE GENERAL FOR INTERNAL POLICIES

Outline What is governance and what does it comprise?

OECD good practices for setting up an RIA system Regional Capacity-Building Seminar on Regulatory Impact Assessment Istanbul, Turkey 20 November 2007.

Bulgaria – Capital Budgeting And Fiscal Institutions

Presentation transcript:

1 Fábio Gomes May 1, 2009 This work was adapted from my social policy master dissertation entitled: “Threats to equity in organ allocation for transplantation: an analysis of Brazilian legal criteria” (2007), advised by Dr. Debora Diniz, (University of Brasilia, Brazil).

2 The Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) has a broad, complex and productive public transplantation program, which can benefit from informations that sponsor its improvement. Examples of extensive media coverage on the issue of organ transplantation during 2009.

 Topics for evaluation of legal documents: - principles of social justice; - principles of access to health actions and services (including specific criteria for organs); - transplantation program structuring; - mechanisms that have influence on organs availability; - sanctions related to breaches of the Transplantation Law; - jurisdictions for transplantation policy regulation; - transplant information transparency.  Equity debate: - John Rawls´ principles of justice and - Amartya Sen´s multidimensional health equity approach. 3

Basic access criteria to organs  Federal Constitution, Health Organic Law (nº of 1990) and Transplantation Law (nº of 1997): - solidarity principle - solidarity principle - equality principle  Executive regulations (federal decree and ordinances from the Ministry of Health): - compassion principle - compassion principle - efficient distribution principle - efficient distribution principle 4

Brazilian regulations on transplantation seek equity, but two significant threats were found:  Omission to regulate weights used to apply allocation criteria for most types of organs (available on computer programs but not in regulations);  Breakage of hierarchy between regulations in the establishment of a new allocation criterion based on clinical severity of disease (by means of an ordinance, not considering a principle established by a decree). 5

 Context of scarcity and regional inequalities;  Stagnation in productivity observed after 2004 is being reverted! 6

7 Chart 1. Selected organs transplantation absolute frequency recorded by the Brazilian Transplantation Program from 2001 to 2008

8 Chart 2. Selected organs transplantation absolute frequency recorded by the Brazilian Transplantation Program from 2001 to 2008

9 Table. Performance indicators of the Brazilian Transplantation Program – 2006 and 2008 Source: (*) Ministry of Health – Brazil (2009); (**) Council of Europe (for 2006) and Brazilian Registry of Transplantations – ABTO (for 2008). Legend: p.m.p= per million persons. Performance indicators Situation in 2006 Situation in 2008 Number of transplants (*) 15,132 (50% - cornea) 19,125 Cornea transplantation rate (p.m.p) (*) North Region Southeast Region S olid organs transplantation rate (p.m.p) (*) North Region Southeast Region Persons in waiting list (*) 69,053 (49% - kidney) 68,906 (50% - kidney) Donation rate (p.m.p.) (**) 5.5 (was 7.3 in 2004) 7.2

 Greater attention must be taken to the relationship between the transplantation program, the National Unified Health System (SUS) and the Brazilian Welfare State.  More equitable results depend on: improved program management, strategic planning, greater transparency of information, revisions and eventual corrections of normative omissions.  The program cannot act isolated from SUS. 10

Files available (both in English and Portuguese) through the following sources: