Israel Interdependent Networks From Single Networks to Network of Networks Bar-Ilan University Electric grid, Communication Transportation Services …..

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Dynamics of Social Interactions at Short Timescales G. Bianconi Department of Physics, Northeastern University SAMSI Workshop: Dynamics of networks SAMSI,
Advertisements

Topology and Dynamics of Complex Networks FRES1010 Complex Adaptive Systems Eileen Kraemer Fall 2005.
Transport and Percolation in Complex Networks Guanliang Li Advisor: H. Eugene Stanley Collaborators: Shlomo Havlin, Lidia A. Braunstein, Sergey V. Buldyrev.
Complex Networks: Complex Networks: Structures and Dynamics Changsong Zhou AGNLD, Institute für Physik Universität Potsdam.
Complex Networks Advanced Computer Networks: Part1.
ETC Trento Workshop Spectral properties of complex networks
Mobile Communication Networks Vahid Mirjalili Department of Mechanical Engineering Department of Biochemistry & Molecular Biology.
Scale Free Networks.
Marzieh Parandehgheibi
School of Information University of Michigan Network resilience Lecture 20.
Information Networks Failures and Epidemics in Networks Lecture 12.
VL Netzwerke, WS 2007/08 Edda Klipp 1 Max Planck Institute Molecular Genetics Humboldt University Berlin Theoretical Biophysics Networks in Metabolism.
Daniel ben -AvrahamClarkson University Boston Universtiy Reuven Cohen Tomer Kalisky Alex Rozenfeld Bar-Ilan University Eugene Stanley Lidia Braunstein.
Cascading failures in interdependent networks and financial systems -- Departmental Seminar Xuqing Huang Advisor: Prof. H. Eugene Stanley Collaborators:
Sergey Buldyrev Department of Physics Yeshiva University
Network theory and its applications in economic systems -- Final Oral Exam Xuqing Huang Advisor: Prof. H. Eugene Stanley Collaborators: Prof. Shlomo Havlin.
Weighted networks: analysis, modeling A. Barrat, LPT, Université Paris-Sud, France M. Barthélemy (CEA, France) R. Pastor-Satorras (Barcelona, Spain) A.
University of Buffalo The State University of New York Spatiotemporal Data Mining on Networks Taehyong Kim Computer Science and Engineering State University.
The Barabási-Albert [BA] model (1999) ER Model Look at the distribution of degrees ER ModelWS Model actorspower grid www The probability of finding a highly.
The structure of the Internet. How are routers connected? Why should we care? –While communication protocols will work correctly on ANY topology –….they.
Scale Free Networks Robin Coope April Abert-László Barabási, Linked (Perseus, Cambridge, 2002). Réka Albert and AL Barabási,Statistical Mechanics.
Networks FIAS Summer School 6th August 2008 Complex Networks 1.
1 Epidemic Spreading in Real Networks: an Eigenvalue Viewpoint Yang Wang Deepayan Chakrabarti Chenxi Wang Christos Faloutsos.
From Complex Networks to Human Travel Patterns Albert-László Barabási Center for Complex Networks Research Northeastern University Department of Medicine.
Zhenhua Wu Advisor: H. E. StanleyBoston University Co-advisor: Lidia A. BraunsteinUniversidad Nacional de Mar del Plata Collaborators: Shlomo HavlinBar-Ilan.
Physical Mechanism Underlying Opinion Spreading Jia Shao Advisor: H. Eugene Stanley J. Shao, S. Havlin, and H. E. Stanley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103,
Finding the best immunization strategy Yiping Chen Collaborators: Shlomo Havlin Gerald Paul Advisor: H.Eugene Stanley.
Physical Mechanism Underlying Opinion Spreading
The structure of the Internet. How are routers connected? Why should we care? –While communication protocols will work correctly on ANY topology –….they.
Transport Properties of Fractal and Non-Fractal Scale-Free Networks
Large-scale organization of metabolic networks Jeong et al. CS 466 Saurabh Sinha.
Optimization Based Modeling of Social Network Yong-Yeol Ahn, Hawoong Jeong.
Epidemic spreading in complex networks: from populations to the Internet Maziar Nekovee, BT Research Y. Moreno, A. Paceco (U. Zaragoza) A. Vespignani (LPT-
(Social) Networks Analysis III Prof. Dr. Daning Hu Department of Informatics University of Zurich Oct 16th, 2012.
Complex networks A. Barrat, LPT, Université Paris-Sud, France I. Alvarez-Hamelin (LPT, Orsay, France) M. Barthélemy (CEA, France) L. Dall’Asta (LPT, Orsay,
Niloy Ganguly Department of Computer Science & Engineering Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur Kharagpur Stability analysis of peer to peer.
Claudio Castellano CNR-INFM Statistical Mechanics and Complexity and
MEDUSA – New Model of Internet Topology Using k-shell Decomposition Shai Carmi Shlomo Havlin Bloomington 05/24/2005.
Weighted networks: analysis, modeling A. Barrat, LPT, Université Paris-Sud, France M. Barthélemy (CEA, France) R. Pastor-Satorras (Barcelona, Spain) A.
Self-Similarity of Complex Networks Maksim Kitsak Advisor: H. Eugene Stanley Collaborators: Shlomo Havlin Gerald Paul Zhenhua Wu Yiping Chen Guanliang.
Analysis of biological networks Part III Shalev Itzkovitz Shalev Itzkovitz Uri Alon’s group Uri Alon’s group July 2005 July 2005.
Robustness of complex networks with the local protection strategy against cascading failures Jianwei Wang Adviser: Frank,Yeong-Sung Lin Present by Wayne.
Complex network of the brain II Hubs and Rich clubs in the brain
Networks Igor Segota Statistical physics presentation.
Physics of Flow in Random Media Publications/Collaborators: 1) “Postbreakthrough behavior in flow through porous media” E. López, S. V. Buldyrev, N. V.
Percolation Processes Rajmohan Rajaraman Northeastern University, Boston May 2012 Chennai Network Optimization WorkshopPercolation Processes1.
Robustness and Structure of Complex Networks Shuai Shao Boston University, Physics Department A dvisor: Prof. Gene Stanley Co-advisor: Prof. Shlomo Havlin.
Lecture 10: Network models CS 765: Complex Networks Slides are modified from Networks: Theory and Application by Lada Adamic.
Application of statistical physics to random graph models of networks Sameet Sreenivasan Advisor: H. Eugene Stanley.
Percolation and diffusion in network models Shai Carmi, Department of Physics, Bar-Ilan University Networks Percolation Diffusion Background picture: The.
Recent developments in the study of transport in random networks Shai Carmi Bar-Ilan University Havlin group Minerva meeting Eilat, March 2009.
Network resilience.
Class 10: Robustness Cascades
Transport in weighted networks: optimal path and superhighways Collaborators: Z. Wu, Y. Chen, E. Lopez, S. Carmi, L.A. Braunstein, S. Buldyrev, H. E. Stanley.
Community structure in graphs Santo Fortunato. More links “inside” than “outside” Graphs are “sparse” “Communities”
Class 21: Robustness Cascades PartII
Network Dynamics and Simulation Science Laboratory Structural Analysis of Electrical Networks Jiangzhuo Chen Joint work with Karla Atkins, V. S. Anil Kumar,
Netlogo demo. Complexity and Networks Melanie Mitchell Portland State University and Santa Fe Institute.
Fractal Networks: Structures, Modeling, and Dynamics 章 忠 志 复旦大学计算机科学技术学院 Homepage:
Response network emerging from simple perturbation Seung-Woo Son Complex System and Statistical Physics Lab., Dept. Physics, KAIST, Daejeon , Korea.
Cascading failures of loads in interconnected networks under intentional attack Yongxiang Xia Department of Information Science and Electronic Engineering.
Complex network of the brain II Attack tolerance vs. Lethality Jaeseung Jeong, Ph.D. Department of Bio and Brain Engineering, KAIST.
Lecture II Introduction to complex networks Santo Fortunato.
Scale-free and Hierarchical Structures in Complex Networks L. Barabasi, Z. Dezso, E. Ravasz, S.H. Yook and Z. Oltvai Presented by Arzucan Özgür.
Complex network of the brain II Hubs and Rich clubs in the brain Jaeseung Jeong, Ph.D. Department of Bio and Brain Engineering, KAIST.
Daniel ben - Avraham Clarkson University Boston Universtiy Reuven Cohen Tomer Kalisky Alex Rozenfeld Bar-Ilan University Eugene Stanley Lidia Braunstein.
The intimate relationship between networks' structure and dynamics
Structures of Networks
Topology and Dynamics of Complex Networks
复杂网络可控性 研究进展 汪秉宏 2014 北京 网络科学论坛.
Presentation transcript:

Israel Interdependent Networks From Single Networks to Network of Networks Bar-Ilan University Electric grid, Communication Transportation Services ….. Two types of links: 1. Connectivity 2.Dependency Cascading disaster-abrupt transition

Extensive Studies Since Single Networks A Network is a structure of N nodes and M edges (or 2M links ) Called usually graph – in Mathematics Complex systems can be described and understood using networks Internet: nodes represent computers links the connecting cables Biological systems: nodes represent proteins links their relations Climate system: nodes represent locations links similar climate Successful research: Efficient immunization strategies, identifying key players, robustness, climate (KURTHS), physiology, protein networks- function ….. Wang et al (Science 2009) Brown-same operating system-now Percolation-Immunization

Complex Single Networks- Since 2000 Poisson distribution (ER ) Erdős-Rényi Network Scale-free Network -λ-λ m K Scale-free distribution (Barabasi -1999)

Internet Network Faloutsos et. al., SIGCOMM ’99

WWW-Network Barabasi et al (1999)

Jeong, Tombor, Albert, Barabasi, Nature (2000)

Classical Erdos-Renyi (1960)Barabasi-Albert (1999) Homogeneous, similar to lattices Heterogeneous-translational symmetry breaks! New universality class-many anomalous laws -- Small world Ultra Small worlds ( Cohen and SH, PRL (2003)) Breakthrough in understanding many problems! SF more robust!!

Classical Erdos-Renyi (1960)Barabasi-Albert (1999) Homogeneous, similar to lattices Heterogeneous-translational symmetry breaks! New universality class-many anomalous laws -- Small world Ultra Small worlds ( Cohen and SH, PRL (2003)) Breakthrough in understanding many problems! SF more robust!!

Classical Erdos-Renyi (1960)Barabasi-Albert (1999) Homogeneous, similar to lattices Heterogeneous-translational symmetry breaks! New universality class-many anomalous laws -- Small world Ultra Small worlds ( Cohen and SH, PRL (2003)) Breakthrough in understanding many problems! SFER SF more robust!! 1

Infectious disease Critical Threshold Malaria 99% Measles 90-95% Whooping cough 90-95% Fifths disease 90-95% Chicken pox 85-90% Internet more than 99% Known values of immunization thresholds: This puzzle is solved due to the broad degree distribution (HUBS) of social networks which does not occur in random graphs! Such immunization thresholds were not understood since they were well above the expected value of percolation in classical random networks: WHAT IS DIFFERENT?

Scale Free networks --immunization strategies targeted Random Acquaintance order 1 robust vulnerable order 2 Efficient immunization Poor immunization Efficient Immunization Strategy: Acquaintance Immunization Cohen et al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, (2003)

A. Vespignani and V. Collizza, PNAS (2009)

Global spreading of epidemics, rumors, opinions, and innovations Brockmann and Helbing Nature 342, 1337 (2013) Transportation Network (GAN) Simulated Epidemics (HK)

Network Motifs-System Biology Uri Alon,, Science (2002)

Detecting overlapping communities A Lancichinetti, S Fortunato, J Kertész New Journal of Physics 11 (3), (2009) Structure and Function: Useful for unveiling protein function: Irene Sendin˜a–Nadal et al, PlosOne (2011) Michele Tumminello, Roasario Mantegna, Janos Kertesz Networks in economy and finance

Bashan et al, Nature Communication [2012] Structure and Function

Climate networks are very sensitive to El Nino Sea surface temperature network 5km height temperature network Yamasaki, Gozolchiani, SH (PRL 2008, 2011) Challenge: Predicting El-Nino and other extreme events

EL-NINO BECOMES AUTONOMOUS: ONLY INFUENCE-NOT INFLUENCED Gozolchiani et al PRL (2011) VERY EARLY PREDICTION!!! Ludescher et al, PNAS (2014)

Mitigation of malicious attacks on networks Power Grid Internet Schneider, Moreira, Andrade, SH and Herrmann PNAS (2011)

Collaboration: Amir Bashan, BIU Sergey Buldyrev, NY Dong Zhou, BIU Yang Wang, BIU J. Gao: Northeastern Yehiel Berezin, BIU Michael Danziger, BIU Roni Parshani: BIU Christian Schneider, MIT H. E. Stanley, Boston PARTIAL LIST Buldyrev et al, Nature, 464, 1025 (2010 ) Parshani et al, PRL,105, 0484 (2010) Parshani et al, PNAS, 108, 1007 (2011) Gao et al, PRL, 107, (2011) Gao et al, Nature Phys.,8, 40 (2012) Bashan et al, Nature Com., 3, 702, (2012) Wei Li et al, PRL, 108, (2012 ) Bashan et al, Nature Phys. 9, 667 (2013) From Single Network to Network of Networks

Blackout in Italy (28 September 2003) CASCADE OF FAILURES Railway network, health care systems, financial services, communication systems Power grid Communication SCADA Cyber Attacks- CNN Simulation (2010) Rosato et al Int. J. of Crit. Infrastruct. 4, 63 (2008)

Rinaldi S, et al IEEE (2001)

BRAIN HUMAN BODY: NETWORK OF NETWORKS

Until 2010 studies focused on a single network which is isolated AND does not interact or influenced by other systems. Isolated systems rarely occur in nature or in technology -- analogous to non-interacting particles (molecules, spins). Results for interacting networks are strikingly different from those of single networks. Interdependent Networks

Comparing single and coupled networks: Robustness Continuous abrupt Remove randomly (or targeted) a fraction nodes Size of the largest connected component (cluster) Single networks: Continuous transition ( ER ) ( SF ) Coupled networks: New paradigm-Abrupt transition Cascading Failures Single ER Coupled Cascades, Sudden breakdown Message: our world is extremely unsafe!

RANDOM REMOVAL – PERCOLATION FRAMEWORK

after τ-cascades of failures Catastrophic cascades just below ER network Single realizations RESULTS: THEORY and SIMULATIONS: ER Networks Removing 1-p nodes in A ABRUPT TRANSITION (1 st order) τ Dong Zhou et al (2013)

Simultaneous first and second order percolation transitions Dong et al, arXiv: (2013)

Partial Interdependent Networks Determining in simulations: Theory and simulations

GENERALIZATION: PARTIAL DEPENDENCE: Theory and Simulations Parshani, Buldyrev, S.H. PRL, 105, (2010) Strong q=0.8: 1 st Order Weak q=0.1: 2 nd Order q-fraction of dependency nodes Schneider et al arXiv: arXiv: Scientific Reports (2013)

Designing Robust Coupled Networks: Italy 2003 blackout Random interdependenciesNearly optimal interdependencies Schneider, Araujo, Havlin, Herrmann, Designing Robust Coupled Networks, Scientific Reports (2013)

IN CONTRAST TO SINGLE NETWORKS, COUPLED NETWORKS ARE MORE VULNERABLE WHEN DEGREE DIST. IS BROADER Buldyrev, Parshani, Paul, Stanley, S.H. Nature (2010)

Network of Networks (tree) Gao et al PRL (2011) n=5 For ER,, full coupling, ALL loopless topologies (chain, star, tree): Vulnerability increases significantly with n n=1 known ER- 2 nd order n=1 n=2 n=5 m

Random Regular Network of ER networks RR, m=3 ER = 2.2 Surprisingly Independent on n!

Interdependent Spatially Embedded Networks Theory (based on critical exponent): NO continuous transition for any q>0-extreme vulnerability!! Bashan et al, Nature Physics ( 2013) Many networks are spatially embedded: Internet, Power grid, Transportation etc r=2

Spatial embedded compared to random coupled networks when q changes: q=0.2 q=0 Bashan et al Nature Physics, (2013) EXTREMELY VULNERABLE!! Message: our world is extremely unsafe!-no safe zone!

Interdependent European Communication Network and Power Grid Experimental test on real spatial embedded coupled networks Results for European and US Interdependent Communication Networks and Power Grids Bashan et al, Nature Physics (2013)

Interdependent Spatially Embedded Networks Many networks are spatially embedded: Internet, Power grid, Transportation etc Wei et al, PRL, 108, (2012) Bashan et al, Nature Physics (2013) When connectivity links are limited in their length---same universality class as lattices! THREE DIFFERENT BEHAVIORS DEPENDING ON

Interdependent Spatially Embedded Networks Many networks are spatially embedded: Internet, Power grid, Transportation etc Wei et al, PRL, 108, (2012) Bashan et al, 1 st order 2 nd order

New percolation-localized attacks Y. Berezin et al,. arXiv: Localized attacks on spatially embedded systems with dependencies: critical size attack Theory Gradient percolation, Sapoval et al (1985)

Simulation ResultsAnalytical Results New percolation-localized attacks

Summary and Conclusions First statistical physics approach for robustness of Networks of Interdependent Networks—cascading failures New paradigm: abrupt collapse compared to continuous in single network Generalization to “Network of Networks”: n interdependent networks- 50y of graph theory and percolation is only a limited case! Larger n is more vulnerable–spatial embedding-extremely unsafe: New percolation: Localized Attacks-more vulnerable compared to random Rich problem: different types of networks and interconnections. Buldyrev et al., NATURE (2010) Parshani et al., PRL (2010) Gao et al, PRL (2011) Parshani et al, PNAS (2011) Wei et al, PRL (2012) Gao et al., Nature Phys. (2012) Bashan et al, Nature Phys. (2013)

PARTIAL DEPENDENCE: critical point Analogous to critical point in liquid-gas transition: Parshani et al PRL, 105, (2010)

Unveiling Protein Functions by Synchronization in the Interaction Network Irene Sendin˜a–Nadal, Yanay Ofran, Juan A. Almendral1, Javier M. Buldu, Inmaculada Leyva, Daqing Li, Shlomo Havlin, Stefano Boccaletti, Plos One (2011)

Unveiling Protein Functions by Synchronization in the Interaction Network Irene Sendin˜a–Nadal, Yanay Ofran, Juan A. Almendral, Javier M. Buldu, Inmaculada Leyva, Daqing Li, Shlomo Havlin, Stefano Boccaletti, Plos One (2011)

Interdependent Spatially Embedded Networks Many networks are spatially embedded: Internet, Power grid, Transportation etc Wei et al, PRL, 108, (2012) Bashan et al,

The extreme vulnerability of spatial embedded coupled networks q=0.2 q=0 Bashan et al EXTREMELY VULNERABLE!!

Summary and Conclusions First statistical physics approach for robustness of interdependent networks Broader degree distribution is more vulnerable in interacting networks Generalization to “Network of Networks”: n interdependent networks-50y of graph theory and percolation is only a limited case! Larger n is more vulnerable Network A Network B Rich problem: different types of networks and interconnections. Buldyrev et al., NATURE (2010) Parshani et al., PRL (2010) Gao et al., (preprint)

CITATIONS PER YEAR –DIFFERENT FIELDS

SCADA Power grid Blackout in Italy (28 September 2003) SCADA=Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition

Blackout in Italy (28 September 2003) Power grid SCADA

Blackout in Italy (28 September 2003) Power grid SCADA

Summary and Conclusions First statistical physics approach --mutual percolation-- for a Network of Interdependent Networks—cascading failures Generalization to Network of Networks: 50ys of classical percolation is a limiting case. E.g., only n=1 is 2 nd order; n>1 are 1 st order Partial Dependence: Strong coupling: first order phase transition; Weak: second order Extremely vulnerable: broader degree distribution in single networks more robust ---- in interacting networks -less robust Network A Network B Rich problem: different types of networks and interconnections. Real data. Buldyrev et al, NATURE (2010) Parshani et al, PRL (2010); Gao et al, PRL (2011) Parshani et al, EPL (2010) Parshani et al, PNAS (2011) Bashan et al, PRE (2011)