A study about the effects of affective valence on a source-monitoring error: cryptomnesia Beaufort, A. (1), Brédart, S. (1), Perfect, T. J. (2), & Dehon,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Remembering Can Cause Forgetting – but Not in Negative Moods Psychological Science – 2007 Karl-Heinz Bauml and Christof Kuhbandner Presented by Tachelle.
Advertisements

METHOD PARTICIPANTS 393 undergraduates completed the study, (M age = 20; 75% female; 50% Asian, 21% Caucasian). MATERIALS AND PROCEDURE All subjects completed.
Background The Self: Strongly influences cognition and behaviour [1,2,3] Directs our attention [1] Triggers elaboration of information [2,3] Is this elaboration.
Method Participants 36 healthy participants (19 females) aged from 17 to 24 years (mean = 20; SD = 1,67) Material Participants were randomly allocated.
K. PHILIP CHOONG and ZHAOHONG HAN Teachers College, Columbia University Task Complexity and Output Complexity:
Statistics for the Social Sciences
DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY U N I V E R S I T Y O F C O P E N H A G E N Suppression of neutral but not emotional words Background Anderson & Green (2001)
Schemas & Research. What is a schema?  Framework of knowledge  Affects our perception and understanding.  Organise information to help recall what.
References 1 Brown, A. S., & Murphy, D. R. (1989). Cryptomnesia: delineating inadvertent plagiarism. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory,
Comprehension and Memory for Sexist Jokes Doug Eamon, Dawn Dent, & Kim Pleva University of Wisconsin - Whitewater Memory and Text Comprehension Montpellier,
BHS Memory and Amnesia Memory and Reality.
Statistics for the Social Sciences Psychology 340 Fall 2006 Repeated Measures & Mixed Factorial ANOVA.
Neag School of Education Using Social Cognitive Theory to Predict Students’ Use of Self-Regulated Learning Strategies in Online Courses Anthony R. Artino,
Individual Differences in Dissociative Experiences and Recovered Memory Accuracy Introduction  Some researchers claim that memory blocking can be explained.
Self-Protective Memory of Interpersonal Events Margaret Wile, Angela Neal, Christine Coyne, and Edward Lemay Department of Psychology, University of New.
Wrap-up and Review Wrap-up and Review PSY440 July 8, 2008.
 The misinformation effect refers to incorrect recall or source attribution of an item presented after a to-be-remembered event as having been presented.
The Scientific Method Try This: Eye Color Quest.
Type your project title here Your name Your teacher’s name Your school
TEMPLATE DESIGN © Recollection of Negative & Positive Images Jackie Davis (Dr. Hildy Schilling, sponsor) Behavioral Sciences.
Research Methods in Psychology. There are a number of methods used in Psychology to study people Laboratory Experiments Field Experiments Natural Experiments.
BRS 214 Introduction to Psychology Methodology used in psychology field Dawn Stewart BSC, MPA, PHD.
Environmentalism and Personality Simon Cohen Jeff Edgar Chris Latham-Warde Sanni Kujala.
Ratings of and Memory for Gender Jokes Doug Eamon, Dawn Dent, Kim Pleva, Jesse Nelson-Rowe University of Wisconsin - Whitewater Midwestern Psychological.
Frequency Judgments in an Auditing-Related Task By: Jane Butt Presenter: Sara Aliabadi November 20,
How Does Television Affect the Perception of Affluence? A Work in Progress Ava Mauriello – RTVF Department Susan Brown Eve Ph.D. College of Arts and Sciences.
Adaptive memory: Survival processing enhances retention Nairne, J., Thompson, S., & Pandeirada, J. (2007). Adaptive memory: Survival processing enhances.
Similar Stimuli and Misattribution McNeese, T. Fort Lewis College In this study I investigated the memory error known as misattribution. I examined how.
Individual Preferences for Uncertainty: An Ironically Pleasurable Stimulus Bankert, M., VanNess, K., Hord, E., Pena, S., Keith, V., Urecki, C., & Buchholz,
Statistics for the Social Sciences Psychology 340 Spring 2006 Factorial ANOVA.
Designs. Single-factor designs: Between-subjects.
Music & Studying.
A Scientific Method How Science is Done. Science is a method for answering theoretical questions.
Reading Comprehension Exercises Online: The Effects of Feedback, Proficiency and Interaction N97C0025 Judith.
The Effects of Ink Color on the Accuracy of Recall Erika Douglas & James Giacomantonio.
What's yours is mine, what's mine is yours: unconscious plagiarism and its opposite. Tim Perfect, Nicholas Lange & Ian Dennis Plymouth University.
1 of 29 Department of Cognitive Science Adv. Experimental Methods & Statistics PSYC 4310 / COGS 6310 Mixed Model ANOVA Michael J. Kalsher PSYC 4310/6310.
From Bad to Worse: Variations in Judgments of Associative Memory Erin Buchanan, Ph.D., Missouri State University Abstract Four groups were tested in variations.
The role of retrieval cues in producing same-sex bias in unconscious plagiarism Nicholas Lange & Timothy J. Perfect, Plymouth University Falsely recalling.
The Influence of Emotion on Memory for Temporal Information Arnaud D’Argembeau, Martial Van der Linden University of Geneva Emotion December 2005, Vol.
JAM-boree: A Meta-Analysis of Judgments of Associative Memory Kathrene D. Valentine, Erin M. Buchanan, Missouri State University Abstract Judgments of.
Reliability of one cognitive process
Unit 1c: Scientific Method & Inquiry. The Methods Biologists Use The common steps that biologists and other scientists use to gather information and answer.
Trait transference and the logic of conversation Ben Van Calster and Vera Hoorens Abstract Trait transference or the phenomenon that people ascribe traits.
What is Science? - Ideas developed by scientists and the methods used to gain information about the idea. – A process of making observations and asking.
Scientific Method.
Some of your best ideas are mine: unconscious antiplagiarism Nicholas Lange, Timothy J. Perfect and Ian Dennis.
Scientific Method 1.Observe 2.Ask a question 3.Form a hypothesis 4.Test hypothesis (experiment) 5.Record and analyze data 6.Form a conclusion 7.Repeat.
Physical Science and You Chapter One: Studying Physics and Chemistry Chapter Two: Experiments and Variables Chapter Three: Key Concepts in Physical Science.
A Comparison of Methods for Estimating the Capacity of Visual Working Memory: Examination of Encoding Limitations Domagoj Švegar & Dražen Domijan
Experiment 2: N = Factor Repeated Measures ANCOVA  Span Factor Score Covariate: Shortened Complex Span Tasks. 8  Conditions: Negative-Arousing.
Processing Faces with Emotional Expressions: Negative Faces Cause Greater Stroop Interference for Young and Older Adults Gabrielle Osborne 1, Deborah Burke.
Ease of Retrieval Effects on Estimates of Predicted Alcohol Use Joshua A. Hicks University of Missouri-Columbia and the Midwest Alcoholism Research Center.
Conducting Research Psychology, like chemistry and biology, is an experimental science, assumptions must be supported by scientific evidence. It is not.
Poster presented at APS 2014 Abstract This study was conducted to determine if explaining criminal behavior influences later identification. Schooler and.
High school still haunts us: Effects of past and current peer victimization on memory Aaliyah Gibbons, Alanna Wormwood, and Jennifer M. Knack Clarkson.
Psychology research methods– Analysis Portfolio Taylor Rodgers B
Chapter 2 Section 1 Conducting Research Obj: List and explain the steps scientists follow in conducting scientific research.
Emilie Zamarripa & Joseph Latimer| Faculty Mentor: Jarrod Hines
Sarah Carroll Faculty Advisor: Chad Dodson
The involvement of visual and verbal representations in a quantitative and a qualitative visual change detection task. Laura Jenkins, and Dr Colin Hamilton.
Dissociated developmental trajectories for conceptual and perceptual sensibility in eyewitness testimony? Valentine Vanootighem*, Hedwige Dehon*, Laurence.
Memory for Actions: A two-way mirror?
Catherine Barsics & Serge Brédart
Two randomised controlled crossover studies to evaluate the effect of colouring on both self-report and performance measures of well-being Holt, N. J.,
New Face-Name Paradigm for Patients with Mild Alzheimer’s Disease
Type your project title here Your name Your teacher’s name Your school
The effect of aging on associative memory for
What is Science?.
Similarity Breeds Proximity: Pattern Similarity within and across Contexts Is Related to Later Mnemonic Judgments of Temporal Proximity  Youssef Ezzyat,
Presentation transcript:

A study about the effects of affective valence on a source-monitoring error: cryptomnesia Beaufort, A. (1), Brédart, S. (1), Perfect, T. J. (2), & Dehon, H. (1) (1) University of Liège – (2) University of Plymouth AB is supported by a grant from the Belgian FNRS. TJP is supported by the ESRC. Contact information: Procedure 1,2 ParticipantsDesign N = 96 (48 males) Mean age : 19 years Same-sex dyads within-subject design  Repeated measures ANOVA’s A one-week delay “Generate alternately original/non-conventional uses to the presented objects” (1 Positive, 1 Neutral & 1 Negative object) For each orally generated idea, both participants made 3 judgments: Valence (-3 “highly negative“  +3 “highly positive”), Arousal (1 “unexciting”  6 ”very exciting”) & Feasibility (1 “unrealizable”  6 “feasible”) (2 participants together) “Recall as many ideas as you can that YOU personally produced last week.” Confidence rating and Remember-Know-Guess judgments (1 = “Not sure” to 5 = “Sure I said that idea last week”) (2 participants separately) “Generate four new ideas for each object.” Confidence rating (1 = “Not sure” to 5 = “I'm sure no one has produced that word last week”) Initial Generation Recall-Own taskGenerate-New task Recall-Own Results Mean plagiarism rate : 7.71% Confidence ratings Remember-Know-Guess judgments Generate-New Results Mean plagiarism rate : 15.21% Confidence ratings Self-plagiarism < Other-Plagiarism (F (1,94) =34.262, p = 0.000, η 2 p = < < Interaction : Valence*Gender (F (2,188) = 5.314, p = 0.006, η 2 p = 0.054) Valence Effect : Women only Negative vs Positive (F (1,94) =10.1, p=0.002) Negative vs Neutral (F (1,94) =3.985, p=0.049) > (F (1,94) =10.827, p=0.001) > (F (1.94) = , p = 0.001) p < 0.01 Remember responses : Correct R. > Plagiarism and Intrusions Know responses : Correct R. // Plagiarism // Intrusions Guess responses : Correct R. < Plagiarism and Intrusions Conclusion The emotional content of the to-be-remembered material was found to affect the rates of plagiarism in the RO task for women only and for both gender in the GN task. That is, in the RO task, women plagiarized negative words less frequently than both positive and neutral words. The same pattern of results was observed in the GN task. These results do not support the Paradoxical Negative Emotion hypothesis 2 which predict higher rates of correct responses and plagiarism for negative materials. References 1 Brown, A. S., & Murphy, D. R. (1989). Cryptomnesia: delineating inadvertent plagiarism. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 15, 432– Porter, S., Bellhouse, S., McDougall, A., ten Bricke, L. & Wilson, K. (2010). A prospective investigation of the vulnerability of memory for positive and negative emotional scenes to the misinformation effect. Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science, 42(1), doi: /a Stark, L.-J., & Perfect, T. J. (2006). Elaboration inflation: How your ideas become mine. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 20(5), doi: /acp Background The emotional content of the to-be-remembered material could affect source monitoring accuracy as suggested by numerous studies 2,3. Although inadvertent plagiarism is considered as a source monitoring error and is often linked to creative-emotional environments such as arts, the effect of emotional content on inadvertent plagiarism has never been investigated. Therefore, the objective of our experiment was to examine the possible impact of emotion on inadvertent plagiarism. Inadvertent plagiarism either when a person remembers an item and erroneously thinks that he/she was the generator of that item (RO task) or when the person erroneously thinks that he/she produces the item at the moment although, in fact, this item is a memory not recognized as such (GN task). In order to make our experiment as close as possible of the creative processes implicated in real-life, we used the Alternative Uses Task 3 in a slightly modified version of the Brown and Murphy classical paradigm 1.