Queue Reform at the Midwest ISO NARUC February, 2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Midwest ISO from a Transmission Owner Perspective.
Advertisements

Order 2000 and PJM: A Natural Match Craig Glazer Manager of Regulatory Affairs PJM Interconnection, LLC.
SWE IG Meeting Paris, CRE XBID Overview Supported by.
AN INTRODUCTION TO THE MIDWEST ISO By Bill Malcolm Manager-State Regulatory Affairs Pierre, South Dakota June 9, 2006.
Rate Plan. Value Story When asked, our customers identify the following topics as ways MidAmerican Energy provides value – Emergency Response.
Transmission Transporting Electricity by Wire Darcy Neigum Montana-Dakota Utilities Co.
Kansas Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Conference Wind 2007 RFP Update John Grimwade - Sr. Director Strategic Planning and Development September.
1 The Midwest ISO At the Crossroads of America International Meeting of Very Large Power Grid Operators October 24 & 25, 2005 Beijing, China.
Buffalo Ridge Incremental Generation Outlet (BRIGO) Transmission Study Presentation to National Wind Coordinating Committee June 22, 2005 W Grivna, PE.
1 Dale Osborn Midwest ISO February 27, Wisconsin Renewable Energy Summit Transmission Expansion Opportunities with Wind Energy.
BOSTON CHICAGO DALLAS DENVER LOS ANGELES MENLO PARK MONTREAL NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO WASHINGTON Governors’ Wind Energy Coalition November, 2011 Competitive.
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Large Generator Interconnection Final Rule RM July 23, 2003.
RenewElec October 21, 2010 Robert Nordhaus, David Yaffe Van Ness Feldman 1050 Thomas Jefferson Street, NW Washington, DC (202) FERC’s.
The Transmission Imperative November 3, 2011 Jay Caspary.
EnergyForward Fleet Transition 2014 AAPT Summer Meeting July 28, 2014 Minnesota Power David J. McMillan, Executive Vice President.
E.ON on the Romanian Energy Market ZF Power Summit Bucharest, February 27, 2013 Frank Hajdinjak CEO E.ON România.
Electric Generation Reliability Remarks Before the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission 2011 Summer Reliability Assessment Meeting June.
PacifiCorp Participation in the California ISO. 2 Full participation provides significant benefits beyond those of the Energy Imbalance Market EIM BenefitsFull.
U.S. Energy Information Administration Independent Statistics & Analysis EIA Reporting Proposal: Balancing Authority Hourly Operating Information.
PJM© PJM Confidential PJM Generation Interconnection Overview Virginia Offshore Wind Conference Virginia Beach June 22, 2011 Paul McGlynn General.
Wyoming Infrastructure Authority Developing Electric Infrastructure for the Future of the West Energy Gateway Update Presented by Darrell T. Gerrard Vice.
Is NEPA Preventing Energy Development? Bryan Hannegan, Ph.D. Associate Director – Energy and Transportation White House Council on Environmental Quality.
Reliable Power Reliable Markets Reliable People Performance Targets for the Customer Interconnection Process January, 2008.
Network Customer Meeting Access Metric Update November 16, 2006.
Eastern Interconnection States’ Planning Council – Current Issues Brian Rybarik Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (Executive Assistant to Commissioner.
Large Generator Interconnection Procedures Reform Stakeholder Meeting February 19, 2009.
Kansas Renewable Energy Conference September 26th, 2007.
Joint Outreach Team Implementation Plan July 12, :30-11:30 a.m.
OSC Meeting April 27, Transmission Cost Allocation Overview.
Transmission for a 33% RPS Keith E. Casey Vice President Market and Infrastructure Development California ISO The Independent Energy Producers Association.
Supporting Industry Change Planning: Risk & Milestone Assessment Process & Tools 07/07/2014.
Page 1© 2009 Quanta Technology LLCPage 1 November 2007 BGE January 4, 2008 Strategic Midwest Area Renewable Transmission (SMART) Study October 06, 2009.
PJM©2010 PJM Regional Transmission Planning Experience Andrew Ott Senior Vice President, Markets 2010 NASUCA Mid-Year Meeting June 15, 2010.
Iowa State University Ames, IA July 5, 2011 Wind on the Wires – Wind and Transmission Issues Beth Soholt Wind on the Wires
Integrating More Renewable Energy in the Grid Bert Garvin Vice President, Regulatory Affairs July 21, 2008 NARUC Summer Meeting July 22, 2008.
California Independent System Operator Joint Agency Energy Action Plan Meeting Generation Interconnection Queuing & Streamlining Dennis Peters, Lead Interconnection.
1 Clean Line Energy National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates Charleston SC Annual Meeting June 2012.
Icfi.com © 2006 ICF International. All rights reserved. Wyoming Collector and Transmission System Project – Status Report Presented to: Wyoming Infrastructure.
MISO Northwest Exploratory Study Presented to National Wind Coordinating Committee Participants in study – MISO, Various utilities in Minnesota, North.
Large Generator Interconnection Procedures Reform 2 nd Stakeholder Meeting May 5, 2009.
Cost Allocation Proposals associated with MISO Transmission Expansion WIEG Board Meeting May 6, 2010 WIEG Board Meeting May 6, 2010 Presented by: Kavita.
R E T I Coordinating Committee California’s Renewable Energy Transmission Initiative: Status Update California Public Utilities Commission California Energy.
Transmission Issues & Renewables Perspectives of a Wind Developer.
Dale Osborn Midwest ISO October 13, 2008 EE 590 Transmission Planning with Significant Energy Resources.
Reliability Planning Priorities for 2015 Byron Woertz, Senior Project Manager W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
IWWG Annual Conference Wind Management at MISO July 22, 2011.
Midwest ISO Discussion February 5, 2009 Greg Levesque Manager – Regional Relations & Policy.
Proposed Analytical Approach - Modeling Phase 3 - Formation of new team December 9, 2003 Steering Committee Presentation.
Designing Energy Solutions without Borders National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners.
The Central Role of the Network Operators 28 March 2007 ERGEG-GTE Meeting.
1 NAUSCA Summer Meeting Boston June 30, 3009 David W. Hadley Vice President State Regulatory Relations Midwest ISO.
1 May 2012CACM Network Code Capacity Allocation and Congestion Management for Electricity Network Code ROME, 15 th May 2012.
Eastern Wind Integration and Transmission Study David Corbus - Project Manager Matt Schuerger (Consultant) National Wind Technology Center NREL Golden,
Bob Cupit Manager, Energy Facility Permitting Minnesota Public Utilities Commission.
1.
PacifiCorp & CAISO Regional Transmission Organization Presented by Scott Gutting President, Energy Strategies, LLC Independent Energy Producers Annual.
An Overview of: Generation Connections: Transmission Connection Cost Responsibility Review July
Coordinated Planning Concept (For Discussion Only) revised 11/30/04 07/01/04.
Long Term Transmission Integration Planning at the California ISO Intermittency Analysis Project (IAP) Energy Commission Staff Workshop February 13, 2007.
2006 Reliability Study James Manning Bryan Guy May 12, 2006.
SPP.org 1. Regional and Inter-Regional Planning Update Entergy Transmission Summit July 29, 2008 Astor Crown Plaza New Orleans, Louisiana.
Kansas City Power & Light and KCP&L Greater Missouri Operations – Suggestions for Chapter 22 Revisions Missouri Public Service Commission Meeting Aug 31,
4/16/2010 Regional Planning Group Meeting Long-Term Planning Study of the ERCOT Interconnection Warren Lasher Manager, System Assessment.
Michigan Public Power Agency Wind Energy Supply Agreement
TEPPC Review Task Force Ian McKay, Chair, TEPPC W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING C OUNCIL.
EE590 Transmission Planning Projects and Cost Allocation Ming NI Economic Studies, Midwest ISO.
The Midwest ISO – Platform to Meet Tomorrow’s Challenges Wisconsin Industrial Energy Group August 7, 2008.
Connecting the Dots in New England: NEPOOL’s IMAPP Initiative
Transmission As Enabler
Clair Moeller Mid-Continent ISO
Presentation transcript:

Queue Reform at the Midwest ISO NARUC February, 2008

Current Tariff Requirements First in-first out (FIFO) approach as mandated by FERC Results of first queued study must be known before second queued study can start Dependencies on early queued projects hard-wired as contingencies in Interconnection Agreements of subsequent projects—uncertainty range too wide for commercial decision making Literal interpretation of the Tariff rules would allow us to complete processing of all requests currently in the queue on August 26, 2362 Steps MISO has taken so far only reduce that date to 2050

Currently Active: 306 Requests (243 wind) Currently Active: 306 Requests (243 wind) Queue Evolution * *All requests received as of December 31, 2007 Wind Natural Gas Coal Nuclear Other Currently Active: 72.8 GW (57.6 wind) Currently Active: 72.8 GW (57.6 wind) Number of Requests GW of Requests

Steps Taken to Improve Queue Processing Parallel processing –Realized immediately that projects in Michigan have no discernable impact on projects in North Dakota –Start processing next request once conflicting requests are into the system impact study phase –Delay definitive completion until prior study complete –This moves the expected finish date for the current queue to about 2150 Group Studies –Group together requests in close geographic and time proximity to expedite study times –Moved expected finish date of queue processing, not including time to make upgrades, to the 2050 timeframe

Project Completion Rates Project Resolution Status (Inactive and Complete) 100% = 377 interconnection Requests since Dec Steps taken to date only allow for so much progress in eliminating queue backlogs because of low project completion rates –Low project completion rates lead to restudy, which results in additional time and uncertainty for later queued generators

3 P’s of Queue Reform Success in queue reform rests on addressing each of the 3 P’s Midwest ISO is currently working with stakeholders on solutions targeted at interconnecting generation more efficiently through improvements to Physics and Process –Focus study efforts on those generation projects most ready to achieve interconnection (Process) –Use alternative network upgrade identification methods to support interconnection of large quantities of generation in remote areas (Physics) Opening dialogue with regulators on items such as cost sharing and recovery Physics ProcessPolitics

Proposed Queue Reform – First In-First Out Process Alternative Working with Midwest ISO Stakeholders since September 2007 (Interconnection Process Task Force) on an alternative study prioritization scheme –Create new or increase current milestones (e.g. level of deposit, data completion requirements, site control, suspension costs, etc.) to reflect increased project readiness –Allow projects in relatively unconstrained areas, that meet the milestones, to proceed when ready Key consideration is ensuring milestone selection and alternative prioritization scheme is not unduly discriminatory (such as to small generators) Targeting a Q2 tariff filing on this concept

Current Queue Example: Buffalo Ridge Area A snapshot of the Buffalo Ridge area indicates that generator requests significantly exceed current transfer capability. Add BRIGO, 1200 Add CapX, 1900 Next upgrade, 825 Today’s level, 425

Current Queue Example: Group Study Process Under the current group study process, all generation requests meeting the location and time-based criteria are considered, independent of demand for power in the region, resulting in restudy

What is the Midwest ISO doing from a Transmission Planning perspective to integrate wind? Designing Transmission to connect Wind to high demand areas –Development of a high-voltage overlay to deliver wind; coordinating with PJM, SPP and TVA through Joint Coordinated System Plan (JCSP) –Beginning targeted planning study around Regional Generation Outlet transmission projects Working with local regulators in support of policy initiatives (e.g. Minnesota Renewable Energy Study) Developing a more efficient Interconnection process to allow wind resources to interconnect more quickly –Interconnection Process Task Force

Proposed Queue Reform - Regionally Planned Generator Interconnection Projects Overview –Goal is to increase integration with long-term planning process to allow more efficient generator interconnection Instead of restudying until supply / demand balance is achieved, use demand assessment up front to size the analysis and identify total supply need; define transmission upgrades accordingly –Began developing ideas to integrate projects of this type into current queue and cost sharing protocols through whitepapers and stakeholder discussion in June 2007 Path Forward –Regional Wind Outlet Targeted Study started in February 2008 to identify projects –Interconnection Process Task Force to continue evaluation of integration with current queue (e.g. subscription methodology) –Outreach to states on cost sharing and allocation issues

Conditions Precedent A robust business case for the plan –Need to demonstrate that the hypothesized benefits exist, including evaluation of alternatives –Regulators are the judge of the business case Increased consensus around regional energy policy –Does not exist today around wind, for example, across the Midwest ISO footprint A regional tariff that matches who benefits with who pays over time –For example, beneficiaries of wind may be due to public policy, rather than load flow or economic benefit analyses which are the current basis for cost allocation Cost recovery mechanisms that reduce financial risk –Investors in these projects need to be assured of cost recovery