Blood Management in the Cath Lab Sunil V. Rao MD Associate Professor of Medicine Duke University Medical Center Durham VA Medical Center Duke Clinical Research Institute
Disclosures n Consultant l Sanofi-Aventis, Bristol Myers Squibb l The Medicines Company l Astra Zeneca l Terumo Corporation n Research funding l Cordis Corporation l Ikaria n Off-label uses of drugs/devices may be discussed
Improving PCI outcomes n Why talk about blood transfusion in the cath lab? l Drivers of transfusion in cath patients n Data on transfusion and outcomes in patients with CAD n Reducing bleeding risk – risk assessment, drug therapy, vascular access
Thrombus formation Thrombin plays a central role among tissue injury, coagulation, and platelet response. Collagen Tissue Factor Thrombin Platelet activation Prothrombin ADP TXA 2 Plasma Clotting cascade THROMBUS FibrinogenFibrin Platelet aggregation
Twenty-five year trends in PCI outcomes N=24,410 procedures at the Mayo Clinic Singh M., et. al. Circulation 2007
In Hospital PCI Mortality & Bleeding Peterson ED ACC 2007 Mehta SR ACC 2007
log rank p-value for all four categories < log-rank p-value for no bleeding vs. mild bleeding = 0.02 log-rank p-value for mild vs. moderate bleeding < log-rank p-value for moderate vs. severe <0.001 Bleeding & Outcomes N=26,452 pts from PURSUIT, GUSTO IIb, PARAGON A & B Rao SV, et al. Am J Cardiol Kaplan Meier Curves for 30-Day Death, Stratified by Bleed Severity
Bleeding and Outcomes 26,452 patients from PURSUIT, PARAGON A, PARAGON B, GUSTO IIb NST Bleeding severity and adjusted hazard of death Bleeding severity 30d Death 30d Death/MI 6 mo Death Mild* Moderate* Severe* *p< Rao SV, et. al. AJC 2005
Bleeding and Outcomes 26,452 patients from PURSUIT, PARAGON A, PARAGON B, GUSTO IIb NST Adjusted hazard ratios for 30d Death Stratified by Procedure and Non-procedure related bleeds Bleeding severity Procedure Related Non-procedure Related Mild * Moderate 3.7* 2.5* Severe 16.5* 10.9* *p< Rao SV, et. al. AJC 2005
Bleeding and resource use Predictors of total costs N=1235 pts from GUSTO IIb Mod/sev bleed Per patient cost - $530 Transfusion - $2080, P < 0.01 Per patient cost - $287 Mod/sev bleed Per patient cost - $530 Transfusion - $2080, P < 0.01 Per patient cost - $287 Model C-index=0.87 Adjusted for patient characteristics Model C-index=0.87 Adjusted for patient characteristics Rao SV, et. al. AHJ 2008
Risk versus benefit Thrombosis Bleeding Transfusion
Bleeding – Mechanisms of harm n Severe bleeding l Hypotension l Reversal of antithrombotic therapy n Mild or Moderate bleeding l Cessation of antithrombotic therapy l Blood transfusion
Bleeding and Evidence-based Therapies N=2498 ACS patients from the PREMIER Registry Discharge ASA and thienopyridine Pts. with bleeding vs. pts. without bleeding Wang TY, et. al. Circulation 2008 Discharge 1 Month 6 Months 1 Year Aspirin OR (95% CI) Thienopyridine (0.31, 0.64) 0.68 (0.50, 0.92) 0.63 (0.46, 0.87) 0.62 (0.42, 0.91) 0.94 (0.66, 1.34) 0.83 (0.59, 1.17) 1.06 (0.78, 1.45) 1.12 (0.81, 1.55)
C.O mortality Hgb < ischemia HCT < – mortality HCT < C.O mortality Hgb < ischemia HCT < – mortality HCT < No ischemia Hgb < No mortality until Hgb < No ischemia Hgb < No ∆ Hgb 9 vs mortality for Tx at HCT >25% 2009 – No MACE for Sx-driven Tx No ischemia Hgb < No mortality until Hgb < No ischemia Hgb < No ∆ Hgb 9 vs mortality for Tx at HCT >25% 2009 – No MACE for Sx-driven Tx 12 million units of blood transfused annually Evidence for and against the “10/30” Rule
1.0 Less than USMore than US Unadjusted Adjusted for baseline characteristics Adjusted for baseline characteristics and procedures Adjusted for baseline characteristics, procedures, and bleeding 0.24 (0.19 – 0.30) 0.19 (0.15 – 0.25) 0.69 (0.54 – 0.88) 0.76 (0.59 – 1.00) Geographic variation in transfusion relative to U.S. N=24,112 Rao SV, et. al. AJC 2008
Variations in Transfusion Rates for NSTE ACS Across Hospitals Yang X, et. al. JACC 2005 Percentage of Patients Receiving Blood Transfusions (%) Percentage of Hospitals (%) Non-CABG Overall
Cooperative Cardiovascular Project 30 day death by transfusion and Hct n 78,974 pts > 65 years with confirmed MI n Grouped into categories of admission hematocrit n Excluded pts with bleeding and those with CABG n Primary endpoint: 30-day mortality Wu W, NEJM 2001 Odds ratio for 30 day mortality Odds ratio for 30 day mortality HigherHigher LowerLower HCT< 33 %
Transfusion in ACS N=24,111 pts from PURSUIT, PARAGON B, GUSTO IIb Rao SV, et. al., JAMA 2004
PRBC Transfusion Among NSTE ACS Patients: Cox model for 30-day Death (N=24,111) *Transfusion as a time-dependent covariate Adjusted for transfusion propensity Adjusted for baseline characteristics Characteristics, bleeding propensity, transfusion Propensity, & nadir HCT 3.77 (3.14, 4.52) 3.54 (2.96, 4.23) 3.94 (3.26, 4.75) Rao SV, et. al., JAMA 2004
Cochrane Collaboration Systematic Review 30-day mortality by strategy Carless P, et. al. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2010
FOCUS Trial Post-op Hip Fx CV disease Hgb < 10 g/dl Post-op Hip Fx CV disease Hgb < 10 g/dl Transfusion for Hgb < 10 g/dl Transfusion for Hgb < 10 g/dl Transfusion for Sx or Hgb < 8 g/dl Transfusion for Sx or Hgb < 8 g/dl FunctionalRecovery At 60 days FunctionalRecovery N=2600 Secondary endpoints: Transfusion errors, cardiac ischemia N=2600
FOCUS Trial N=2013 Carson JL, AHA 2009 Reported MI rate: Liberal 2.3% vs. Restrictive 3.8%, P=NS
CRIT Pilot Trial NSTEMI Hct ≤ 0.30 within 72 hrs of admission NSTEMI N=45 Maintain Hct Transfuse if Hct < 0.24 Maintain Hct Transfuse if Hct < 0.24 Maintain Hct Transfuse if Hct < 0.30 Maintain Hct Transfuse if Hct < 0.30 In-hospital Death, MI, or CHF Cooper HA, et. al. AJC %38% P=0.046
Properties of PRBCs n Low 2,3 DPG* n High O 2 affinity* n Depleted of Nitric Oxide l NO plays a fundamental role in O 2 exchange † n Low 2,3 DPG* n High O 2 affinity* n Depleted of Nitric Oxide l NO plays a fundamental role in O 2 exchange † *Welch HG, et. al. Ann Int Med 1992 †Stamler JS, et. al. Science 1997
Nitric Oxide NO/SNO TFeNOSHVein Stamler JS, et. al. Science 1997 O2O2O2O2Lungs Artery R FeO 2 SNO O2O2O2O2 SNOCapillary T FeNOSH Vein
Effects of Transfusion n Packed red cells l Depleted of NO Function as NO “sinks” Lead to vasoconstriction Platelet aggregation Ineffective O 2 delivery l Associated with increases in CRP and IL6* n Packed red cells l Depleted of NO Function as NO “sinks” Lead to vasoconstriction Platelet aggregation Ineffective O 2 delivery l Associated with increases in CRP and IL6* *Fransen E, et. al. Chest 1999
MINT Trial Planned N=200 patients with ACS or CAD + Hgb < 10 g/dl STEMI, NSTEMI, or Sig. CAD/PCI Hgb < 10 g/dl Tx for symptoms Or Hgb < 8 g/dl Tx to keep Hgb ≥ 10 g/dl Restrictive Liberal 30-day Death, MI, Urgent Revasc 6-month Mortality
Strategies to deal with bleeding and transfusion risks n Prevention is KEY n Pharmacological strategies n Dosing n Newer agents n Vascular access
Excessive Dosing of Anticoagulants by Age Alexander KP, et. al. JAMA 2005
Excess dosing of Gp IIb/IIIa and bleeding in women N=32,601 patients from CRUSADE OverallOverall WomenWomen MenMen 1.46 (1.22, 1.73) 1.72 (1.30, 2.28) 1.27 (0.97, 1.66) Excess Dosing More Likely to Bleed Alexander KP, et. al. Circulation 2006
STEEPLE IV enoxaparin STEEPLE OASIS 5 Fondaparinux Fondaparinux REPLACE-2ACUITYHORIZONSBivalirudinREPLACE-2ACUITYHORIZONSBivalirudin STEEPLE Investigators. NEJM 2006 OASIS Investigators. NEJM 2006 Lincoff AM, et. al. JAMA 2003 Stone GW. ACC 2006 STEEPLE Investigators. NEJM 2006 OASIS Investigators. NEJM 2006 Lincoff AM, et. al. JAMA 2003 Stone GW. ACC 2006 PLATOticagrelor
Bleeding in PCI Trials: Frequency and site* *All transfemoral access Among bleeders Rao SV, et. al., JACC 2010 (in press)
Unadjusted Relative RiskP-Value Access site2.33 (1.53 – 3.53)< Non-access site5.40 (4.32 – 6.74)< Adjusted Hazard ratio Access site1.82 (1.17–2.83)0.008 Non-access site3.94 (3.07–5.15)< Risk for 1 year mortality No Bleed TIMI Major + Minor Bleed ●Combined REPLACE-2, ACUITY, HORIZONS-AMI (n=17,393) ●1-year mortality risk of non-access site bleeding vs access site = HR 2.27 (95%CI ), p= Verheugt JACC Cardio Interv 2011;4:191-7:
PCI-related complications and costs N=335,477 Medicare pts undergoing PCI in 2002 Kugelmass A, et. al. AJC 2006
Updated meta-analysis including RIVAL Jolly SS, et. al. Lancet 2011
Radial access and 1-year mortality N=38,872 procedures Chase AJ, et. al. BMJ 2008
Prevalence of radial approach in the US Rao SV, et. al. JACC: CI 2008 N = 593,094 PCI procedures sites 606 sites 1.3% of all PCI procedures N = 593,094 PCI procedures sites 606 sites 1.3% of all PCI procedures 8.5% of diagnostics, 7.8% of PCIs at end of 2010 (118% growth ) Google stock 106% growth
Blood management in the cath lab Summary (1) n Patients with acute ischemic heart disease and those undergoing cath/intervention are at high risk for bleeding/transfusion n Antithrombotic therapy to reduce complications n Arteriotomy n Bleeding and transfusions have emerged as an important events that are associated with increased morbidity, mortality, and costs
Blood management in the cath lab Summary (2) n Reducing ischemic events while minimizing bleeding and transfusion risk is a clinical priority n Strategies that achieve this balance are associated with improved survival n The optimal transfusion strategy is not known…but prevention is the best approach n Appropriate choice/dosing of antithrombotics n Radial approach
Duke Univ. Medical Center Duke Clinical Research Institute