Purpose of Testing Census Questions on Disability Regional Meeting of UN Washington City Group on Disability Statistics Rio de Janeiro September 19,20.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
United NationsUnited Nations Economic Commission for Europe Statistical Division Population Unit International initiatives on health and disability statistics.
Advertisements

Innovation data collection: Advice from the Oslo Manual South East Asian Regional Workshop on Science, Technology and Innovation Statistics.
Designing Accessible Reading Assessments National Accessible Reading Assessment Projects General Advisory Committee December 7, 2007 Overview of DARA Project.
Analysis Plan Regional Meeting of UN Washington City Group on Disability Statistics Rio de Janeiro, Brazil September
1 ESCAP/WHO Field Results on Communication Wei Liu Session 3, Sixth Meeting of the Washington Group on Disability Statistics, Kampala, Oct.
1 ESCAP/WHO Pilot Study Overview Wei Liu Statistics Division, ESCAP Sixth Meeting of the Washington Group on Disability Statistics, Kampala,
Barbara M. Altman Emmanuelle Cambois Jean-Marie Robine Extended Questions Sets: Purpose, Characteristics and Topic Areas Fifth Washington group meeting.
10 th Meeting of the Washington Group Results from the UNESCAP and the Granada Group testing Luxembourg November 3 – 5, 2010.
Disability Statistics at NCHS: An Update
Research Methods for Counselors COUN 597 University of Saint Joseph Class # 8 Copyright © 2015 by R. Halstead. All rights reserved.
SPECA Regional Workshop on Disability Statistics, Dec 13-15, 2006 Issues Related to Disability Measurement: Special considerations Daniel Mont Disability.
The Definition and Measurement of Disability
Using the ICF as a Framework for Washington Group Measures Barbara M. Altman Jennifer Madans Elizabeth Rasch National Center for Health Statistics.
Measuring Disability in a Survey or Census Context: Parallel Work Advancing the Field Barbara M. Altman, Ph.D. Disability Statistics Consultant.
Jennifer Madans Associate Director for Science
Core Competencies for Travel Instruction. Evolution of the Competencies How Why When Who was it intended for?
Disability Statistics:India 5th Annual Meeting of Washington Group September,2005 Rio de Janeiro.
General Disability Measures Used in Developed Countries: Question Characteristics Beth Rasch representing the collaborative work of the UN, ISTAT, and.
SPECA Regional Workshop on Disability Statistics: Dec 13-15, 2006 Purposes of Disability Statistics Jennifer Madans and Barbara Altman National Center.
Issues in Questionnaire Translation Mitchell Loeb National Center for Health Statistics/ Washington Group on Disability Statistics With special thanks.
Daniel Mont Disability and Development Team The World Bank
Aims of the study Title Eligibility criteria and access procedures to disability benefits (indemnities and support services), therefore to public resources,
The harmonized Joint Pilot Tests for 2010 Census Round in Latin American Countries: an integration experience Alicia Bercovich Population Census Committee.
Ensuring Inclusion Defining concepts and Identifying Indicators.
NCPEDP Study on Disability Question in Population Census of India 2011 Prepared by DEOC.
Cognitive Interviewing for Question Evaluation Kristen Miller, Ph.D. National Center for Health Statistics
September 19-20, 2005 Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Internationally Comparable General Disability Measures Barbara M. Altman National Center for Health Statistics.
SPECA Workshop on Disability Statistics, Dec 13-15, 2006 The Definition and Measurement of Disability: The Work of the Washington Group Jennifer Madans.
Comparable Health Data Between Canada and the U.S. n Many organizations such as the United Nations, World Health Organization and the Organization of Economic.
Fifth Annual Meeting of the WG: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A.
September 151 Screening for Disability Washington Group on Disability Statistics.
1 United Nations collection of national disability statistics from population and housing censuses and related national surveys and administrative registers.
The WG Workgroup on Child Functioning and Disability Elena De Palma *, Roberta Crialesi *, Mitchell Loeb** Washington Group on Disability Statistics *Italian.
Jane Scobie Cross-national research on well-being of older people: Insights from Global AgeWatch Index Setting the scene: Population.
National Institute for Public Health and the Environment WG 5 Rio September 2005 Marijke de Kleijn1 Washington Group on Disability Statistics: extended.
10/13/2015 Monitoring the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities… … and the work of the Washington Group on Disability Statistics Mitchell.
UNICEF’s work and planned activities for the production of data on children with disabilities Claudia Cappa, Data and Analytics Section, UNICEF, NY.
13 th Annual Meeting of the Washington Group on Disability Statistics: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer Madans (U.S.A.) National Center for Health Statistics/
Measuring Disability Prevalence Daniel Mont, HDNSP Disability and Development Team June 6, 2007.
The Definition and Measurement of Disability: The Work of the Washington Group (continued) Daniel Mont Disability and Development Group The World Bank.
Eighth Annual Meeting of the WG: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A.
Proposed Purpose of an Internationally Comparable General Disability Measure Jennifer H. Madans, Barbara M. Altman, Elizabeth K. Rasch – NCHS Malin Synneborn,
Comments on the ‘Proposed content of census questions for international use’ Xingyan Wen Ros Madden Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.
FATIGUE Results of ESCAP Testing Barbara M. Altman Disability Statistics Consultant Washington Group, November 3-5, 2010, Luxembourg.
Tenth Annual Meeting of the WG: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A. 10/29/20151.
Ninth Annual Meeting of the WG: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A.
SPECA Meeting, Paris, June 16, 2006 Activities Related to Health and Disability Statistics in the UNECE Region and Globally Jennifer H. Madans for the.
Reading and Evaluating Research Method. Essential question to ask about the Method: “Is the operationalization of the hypothesis valid? Sections: Section.
The WG Workgroup on Child Functioning and Disability Elena De Palma *, Roberta Crialesi *, Mitchell Loeb** Washington Group on Disability Statistics *Italian.
12/3/ th Annual Meeting of the Washington Group on Disability Statistics: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans (U.S.A.) National Center for.
The Research Process.  There are 8 stages to the research process.  Each stage is important, but some hold more significance than others.
Theme 2: Data & Models One of the central processes of science is the interplay between models and data Data informs model generation and selection Models.
Washington D.C. February Washington City Group on Disability Statistics 1 The ICF model and survey- instruments Niels Kr. Rasmussen National Institute.
Comments on the Washington Group Position Paper Proposed Purpose of an Internationally Comparable General Disability Measure Alicia Bercovich IBGE Brazil.
Proceedings and outcomes of WG workshops Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A.
SOCIOLOGICAL RESEARCH Importance of social research Help solve social problems by understanding how they come about, and why they persist. Makes clear.
… the work of the Washington Group on Disability Statistics Jennifer H. Madans National Center for Health Statistics, USA for the Washington Group on Disability.
Seventh Annual Meeting of the WG: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A.
1 Governance strategy for the Washington City Group Comments on draft proposal by Howard Meltzer (UK) February Brussels.
Sixth Annual Meeting of the WG: Objectives and Agenda Jennifer H. Madans U.S.A.
WG/UNICEF Child functioning module: Preliminary results from Samoa & Supporting documentation Mitchell Loeb National Center for Health Statistics/ Washington.
1 A Comparison of Motor Delays in Young Children: Autism Spectrum Disorder, Developmental Delay, and Developmental Concerns Beth Provost, Brian R. Lopez,
UN Washington Group Report and Next Steps
Human Functioning Participation; activity; body function and structure Mary Chamie United Nations Statistics Division.
Towards improved measures of disability for development indicators
Internationally Comparable General Disability Measures
Xingyan Wen Ros Madden Australian Institute of Health and Welfare
Ensuring Inclusion Defining concepts and Identifying Indicators.
Wrong Questions, Wrong Answers The Statistical Barrier to Accessibility Ann Frye Ann Frye Ltd.
Comments on Measuring Disability in an International Context
Presentation transcript:

Purpose of Testing Census Questions on Disability Regional Meeting of UN Washington City Group on Disability Statistics Rio de Janeiro September 19,20

Goal of Questions Internationally comparable data Suitable for censuses Captures most disabled people in a consistent fashion

Challenges Cultures and circumstances widely different across countries Functional limitations are very varied Type – mental, physical, sensory Degree – mild, moderate, significant Disability is a complex concept that is measured across different domains Body functions and structure Activities and participation Not really a single measure of disability, yet political reality demands reported prevalence rate

Purpose of Test Determine if questions are being interpreted as intended. That is, are they capturing important aspects of selected functional domains Determine if questions are interpreted consistently across countries Gain further insight into alternative prevalence measures

Types of Testing Cognitive – A direct look at how people are interpreting the questions – richer testing but less standardized Field – How do the questions work operationally? What is the relationship between the answers to different questions?

Procedure Normally, cognitive testing done first to refine questions, then field test done to operationalize In this case, different countries will do things differently Some countries may only test WG questions Some are including test within their testing of another instrument – this may restrict how the questions can be tested

Objectives Determination of whether a single question per domain is representative of that domain Determination of whether the questions produce comparable data across countries Determination of how the WG questions work as a set in comparison with other questions used by the country