Thorvaldur Gylfason.  Comparison of Europe’s economic performance with that of the United States  Three suggestions o Output per hour worked – that.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
KEY SLIDES
Advertisements

Global Entrepreneurship. Questions Why Are Some: People More Entrepreneurial than Others? Organizations More Entrepreneurial than Others? Regions More.
11-12 June 2009 Survey of the data sources and compilation practices of EU Member States Item 4.1 International Technical Meeting on Measuring Remittances.
Pension Reform and Labor Market Policies In Central Europe Elaine Fultz Senior Specialist in Social Security International Labor Organization Budapest.
The Danish Labour Market Social security Active labour market policies Life long learning Dynamic labour market Social partners Public authorities The.
Long-run Pension System Reforms in Europe and Central Asia Anita M. Schwarz Lead Economist Human Development Department Europe and Central Asia Region.
GIS Project The European Union Maxime Muylle Laurent Houben December 18th, 2006.
 TAXES AND SPENDING  ECONOMIC INTERVENTION /GOVERNMENT OWNERSHIP  SOCIAL WELFARE PROGRAMS  CIVIL RIGHTS / CIVIL LIBERTIES  EDUCATION  POVERTY.
Pension systems during the financial and economic crisis Edward Whitehouse Social Policy division, OECD.
Economic Overview June Production Productivity Employment, working hours Inflation, output prices Wages, unit labour cost Trade balance Outline.
L.O TO KNOW WHAT THE EUROPEAN UNION IS AND WHAT COUNTRIES BELONG TO IT. The European Union.
Read to Learn Describe free trade. Indicate who benefits and who does not benefit from free trade.
The “internationalization” or “globalization” of the U. S
The Global Economic Environment
BellRinger 3/23/ What do you think is the richest country in the world today? 2.How do you think economists should measure a country’s wealth? We.
1 ECONOMICS 3150M Winter 2014 Professor Lazar Office: N205J, Schulich
Luxembourg 275.5% Ireland Czech Republic Hungary 134.5
Sustainable Management Metropolia, Business Ethics IP week. 4 Ecological Footprint; measuring human impact.
From health to wealth Thorvaldur Gylfason. What is at issue? Good health is crucial to individual and social welfare around the world  Health expenditure.
New Skills for New Jobs: Action Now Professor Mike Campbell OBE Director of Research and Policy ETUC Conference International Trade Union House, Brussels.
1 Pension Challenges and Pension Reforms in OECD Countries Peter Whiteford Social Policy Division OECD
European Union.
Environmental issues and local development Partnerships and the Green Economy Styria, 11 th October 2010 Gabriela Miranda
By: Victoria Macedo and Cody Carvahlo. To provide governments with a setting to discuss effective approaches to economic and social issues. Allows similar.
1 ECONOMICS 3150B Fall 2015 Professor Lazar Office: N205J, Schulich
Standard SS6G5b: Describe the purpose of the European Union and the relationship between member nations.
Media Freedom The Catch Up Index Findings. What is the Catch Up Index? Are the ten “new”, post-communist member states of the EU – the EU10 – catching.
Equity and Economic Growth University of Warsaw, School of Economic science Zoljargal Munkhsaikhan.
Capitalist. Main Points In a capitalist or free-market country, people can own their own businesses and property. People can also buy services for private.
The Global Economic Environment The Coming Boom Wealthy Industrial Countries Developing Countries East Asia South Asia Latin America
GDP. 1.What do you think is the richest country in the world today? 2.How do you think economists should measure a country’s wealth? We will take some.
Retirement in Europe Annika Sundén Presentation at 16th Annual Meeting of the Retirement Research Consortium “Social Security and the Retirement Income.
International Comparison of Health Care Gene Chang.
Standard SS6G5b: Describe the purpose of the European Union and the relationship between member nations.
Economic Overview October Production Productivity Employment, working hours Inflation, output prices Wages, unit labour cost Trade balance Outline.
Impact of the Crisis on Children in Europe Yekaterina Chzhen ChildONEurope Seminar Paris - November 26, 2015.
The Euro Area Crisis: Origins, Prospects and Implications for the World Economy and Global Governance Domenico Lombardi UNLV, April 3, 2013.
Economic Overview December 2015.
Purpose of the European Union For its members to work together for advantages that would be out of their reach if each were working alone Believe that.
THE EUROPEAN UNION Background 11 June Image by Rock Cohen. Used with permission europa.eu – official website of the EU.
Economic Overview April Production Productivity Employment, working hours Inflation, output prices Wages, unit labour cost Trade balance Outline.
INCOME DISTRIBUTION & POVERTY Elif Yeğenoğlu B. Onurcan Güner.
Economic Growth Chapter 25 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
European Innovation Scoreboard European Commission Enterprise and Industry DG EPG DGs meeting, May 2008.
Table 1. Number and rate of Legionnaires’ disease cases per population by country and year, EU/EEA, 2010–2014 ASR: age-standardised rate, C: case-based.
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Unit 2 Business Development GCSE Business Studies.
Best Sustainable Development Practices for Food Security UV-B radiation: A Specific Regulator of Plant Growth and Food Quality in a Changing Climate The.
6. Ráðstefnan um rannsóknir á íslensku þjóðfélagi Háskólanum á Akureyri, 20. – 21. apríl 2012 The Nordic Countries in an International Comparison Helga.
Incomes, Hours of Work, and Equality in Europe and the United States Thorvaldur Gylfason Presentation at 28 th Villa Mondragone International Economic.
Tax Policy Challenges in a Changing World. Unintended Consequences of Tax Rob Marston, “Window Tax”, 1 September 2010 uploaded via Flickr, creative commons.
NSO data collections of subjective well-being

Retirement Age Reform: Issues to Consider in Russian Federation
Sustainable use of Natural Resources
How Canada Compares Internationally
DISTRIBUTION AUTOMATIC - GENERATION
The European Union.
European Union.
The European Union.
The European Union © 2014 Brain Wrinkles.
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
The EUROPEAN UNION EUROPEAN UNION.
Read to Learn Describe free trade. Indicate who benefits and who does not benefit from free trade.
Gonorrhoea cases of gonorrhoea were reported by 27 EU/EEA Member States for The overall notification rate was 18.8 cases per 100 000 population.
EU: First- & Second-Generation Immigrants
The EUROPEAN UNION © Brain Wrinkles.
European Union Membership
REGIONAL COMPETITIVENESS: COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGES AND UNUSED RESOURCES by Vincenzo Spiezia OECD – Territorial Statistics and Indicators Regional and Urban.
The European Union © 2014 Brain Wrinkles.
The European Union © 2014 Brain Wrinkles.
Presentation transcript:

Thorvaldur Gylfason

 Comparison of Europe’s economic performance with that of the United States  Three suggestions o Output per hour worked – that is, labor productivity – is a better measure of economic performance than output per person o Output, like assets, might be better viewed in two dimensions: average level of output, or income, and its distribution across the population o Anthropometric studies might help quantify the missing dimension

 Leaves out ◦ Domestic production (child rearing) ◦ Black economy (drugs trade) ◦ Changes in macroeconomic stocks  Environmental pollution (green national accounting)  Accumulation of external debt  Exchange rate problem has been solved by ppp adjustments  Does not accord well with measures of happiness  Does not take into account the effort behind the output, especially work  GDP per hour says more than GDP per capita efficiency ◦ Reflects efficiency, that is, labor productivity ◦ Sustainable GDP divided by an index of input use would be a still better measure of economic performance

Inefficiency (high food prices, etc.) necessitates more work and results in less output per capita than otherwise, as in Japan

leisure  Europe loves leisure (Blanchard) labor unions  European labor unions reduce work (Alesina) tax burden  Europe’s heavy tax burden reduces willingness to work (Prescott) values  European values – economic culture! – is different than in the US (Phelps)  Conclusion: Perhaps Europeans want to work less than Americans ◦ But voluntary reduction in work need not be a sign of weakness, on the contrary ◦ Double benefit of growth and increased welfare: Higher income, less work

 year old wage earners ◦ Same labor force participation in Europe and US ◦ Suggests similar propensity to work, similar values  Wage earners in their 60s ◦ Three out of four European wage earners have quit work ◦ Half of US wage earners continues to work  Workers in their 70s ◦ Nine out of ten European wage earners have quit work ◦ A fourth of US wage earners continues to work  Perhaps Europeans can afford to retire earlier than Americans? ◦ Europe: More social security, more equality, more time ◦ US: Higher income per capita

Americans work more than all other high-income nations except the Greeks

 How to explain preceding chart 1.Increased labor productivity enables people to work less  More efficiency permits more leisure  Backward-bending labor supply schedule 2.Too much work tends to reduce efficiency  Tired hands make mistakes 3.What we see is simply a downward-sloping labor demand curve  Increased labor productivity and thereby higher wages reduce demand for labor  Probably all three explanations apply

 Despite world’s second highest GDP per capita, US workers need to work hard: Why? ◦ Stronger work ethic in US ◦ Lower taxes encourage work ◦ Less public consumption calls for more private consumption and hence more work ◦ Weaker labor unions price fewer workers out of jobs  One further hypothesis ◦ Large inequalities in US reduce efficiency  Does not show in GDP per capita, but is visible in GDP per hour because social security permits less work ◦ So, assess economic performance in two dimensions  Return and risk (income level and inequality)

 View national economy like an asset  Assets carry returns and entail risks  Return is directly related to risk ◦ Few prefer no risk ◦ Few prefer no risk, because then the associated return becomes too small ◦ Few seek maximum return ◦ Few seek maximum return, because then the associated risk becomes too large ◦ Most stake out an intermediate position, ◦ Most stake out an intermediate position, balancing the desire for a high return against the desire to keep risk low  Does this idea apply to the national economy?

 Anarchy  Anarchy: Income distribution is fair, if all have same opportunities and free markets produce inequality without government intervention  Intervention  Intervention: Income distribution is fair, if all have same opportunities and government secures that... ◦ Rawls ◦ Rawls: The poor have the highest possible incomes ◦ Rawls in reverse ◦ Rawls in reverse: The rich have the highest possible incomes (you know who I mean) ◦ Middle road ◦ Middle road: The middle class has the highest possible incomes ◦ Another middle road ◦ Another middle road: Average income is at a maximum without excessive inequality

Equality South-Africa Sweden France Equality and Efficiency Efficiency (income per capita) Increased equality reduces efficiency Increased equality increases efficiency Utopia? Where is the optimum?

Equality Sweden Efficiency (income per hour worked) Increased equality reduces efficiency Increased equality increases efficiency France US Equality and Efficiency South-Africa

A B C D E F G H I J Mean 10 Standard dev Gini /

Gini index mirrors the standard deviation of the income distribution

Gini index is closely related to the 20/20 ratio

US Turkey Portugal Estonia New Zealand UK Italy Ireland Iceland Greece Australia Poland Latvia Spain Switzerland Canada France Lithuania South Korea Netherlands Luxembourg Austria Slovenia Germany Hungary Finland Slovakia Norway Czech Republic Sweden Belgium Japan Denmark

 Americans do not live as long as Europeans ◦ 1960: Ten months shorter lives in US ◦ 2003: Fifteen months shorter lives in US  White Americans used to be taller than Germans, now Americans are shorter ◦ 1960: Americans were 2-3 cm taller shorter ◦ 2000: Americans are 2-3 cm shorter  Human stature depends mostly on social conditions in youth, and is final ◦ Reflects past economic conditions ◦ Nutrition, environment, health, housing, stress  Is America lagging behind Europe?

 West-Germans, years old, men and women, are on average 1 cm taller than East- Germans  US high-income earners, of both genders and of all ages, are on average 1-2 cm taller than US low-income earners  College-educated Americans, of both genders and of all ages, are on average 3-4 cm taller than those Americans who have acquired no education beyond primary school

 Europe seems to be catching up with the US  Seven European countries already produce more output per hour than the US  Europeans have grown taller than Americans since1960 ◦ In US, a poor underclass reduces average stature and labor productivity, not in Europe ◦ This shows in GDP per hour, but not in GDP per capita, as Americans compensate by working hard  Europeans work less than Americans ◦ Europe can afford to work less due to higher and more equally distributed living standards ◦ Or can it? That is the question