Behind the open sea somewhere there is the land of my dreams: happiness among immigrants in Europe Olli Kangas Research Director, Social Insurance Institution.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Theory and Politics of External Citizenship Rainer Bauböck 2 nd EUDO Citizenship Plenary Conference January 2010 University of Edinburgh © Rainer.
Advertisements

1 Alternative measures of well-being Joint work by ECO/ELSA/STD.
Understanding womens employment in Europe: the importance of class and gender. Tracey Warren.
1 Relative GDP per capita 2000 PPPs, OECD = countries. Estimates for Source: OECD National Accounts.
Second Generation Immigrants Attitudes and Behavior under Multiculturalist Policies Matthew Wright American University Irene Bloemraad.
Doing an Econometric Project Or Q4 on the Exam. Learning Objectives 1.Outline how you go about doing your own econometric project 2.How to answer Q4 on.
Children’s subjective well-being Findings from national surveys in England International Society for Child Indicators Conference, 27 th July 2011.
Wellbeing and Measures of Subjective Wellbeing Dan Weijers 14 December 2011.
Donald Lien September 12,  What is this?  Where does it come from?  Why do we care?  Is it here to stay?
Neil Codd, Head of Economics, City of London School for Girls
Quality of Life and Quality of Government: Survey based evidence on the connections Robert Manchin.
Quality of Life in Ireland Presentation by Clive Brownlee, Diageo Ireland & Gerard O’Neill, Amárach Consulting 11 th March 2003.
The “Difference Between Heaven and Earth”: Urban-rural Disparities in Health and Well-being in China Donald J. Treiman California Center for Population.
Cross-national Differences in Public Consent to Divorce Effects of Cultural, Structural and Individual Factors Dr. John Gelissen Department of Methodology.
Poverty Research and Poverty Measurement in Finland 2nd Peter Townsend Memorial Conference Bristol Veli-Matti Ritakallio University of Turku,
Welfare State Institutions, Unemployment and Poverty - A comparative study of EU countries M. Azhar Hussain & Olli Kangas.
Cancer inequalities in Europe UKACR & NCIN Conference, 17/18 June 2010 Dr. Andrea Micheli Director Descriptive Study and Health Planning Unit Fondazione.
MONITORING SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT ISSUES AND CHALLENGES PANEL DISCUSSION International Forum on Monitoring National Development: Beijing, Peoples Republic.
Beyond Indices? The potential of fuzzy set ideal type analysis for comparative analysis of children’s well being John Hudson and Stefan Kühner Department.
Intergenerational contributions to childcare across Europe Alison Smith University of Edinburgh.
The Nordic Countries.
Access to Citizenship European Trends and Comparative Approaches Maarten Vink ICS-UL ENCONTRO COM A CIÊNCIA 2009 Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian, 29 e 30.
A deeper and wider Union – What do Germans think of it? Prepared for the Lecture “Saksa nyky- Euroopassa” by Michael Kull, M.Soc.Sc. Centre.
American Pride and Social Demographics J. Milburn, L. Swartz, M. Tottil, J. Palacio, A. Qiran, V. Sriqui, J. Dorsey, J. Kim University of Maryland, College.
Trade Unions and Social Democratic Parties Yesterday and Today Lucio Baccaro MIT European Social Democracy: Roots and Prospects March 2008 Hotel.
Statistics CanadaCitizenship and Immigration CanadaStatistics CanadaCitizenship and Immigration CanadaStatistics CanadaCitizenship and Immigration CanadaStatistics.
Multi-national study of children’s subjective well-being: learning from the pilot work in England Larissa Pople, The Children’s Society International Society.
The East European Consumer Paul Flatters, CEO, The Future Foundation June 2007.
Comparing approaches of different (partly) register-based countries Eric Schulte Nordholt Senior researcher and project leader of the Census Statistics.
American Pride and Social Demographics J. Milburn, L. Swartz, M. Tottil, J. Palacios, A. Qiran, V. Sriqui, J. Dorsey, J. Kim University of Maryland, College.
1 1 Gender perspectives in migration analysis  Migration statistics in Norway  Gender perspectives in the analysis of migration statistics Kristin Egge-Hoveid.
Does Inequality Matter in China? Lina Song University of Nottingham.
Old, Sick and Alone ? Living arrangements, health and well- being among older people RGS-IBG Annual International Conference London, 2006 Harriet Young.
ESM=MCCSMESM=MCCSM Brussels, Meagre Collective of Country-specific Social Models Arjan Lejour.
2005 Seminar 1: Choosing country Health Politics Ana Rico, Associate Professor Department of Health Management and Health Economics
1 Counting immigrants and expatriates : a new perspective (Published in « Trends in International Migration » OECD 2005) Jean-Christophe Dumont and Georges.
Household wealth What we can learn from micro data registers Gitte Frej Knudsen Søren Brodersen.
Living arrangements, health and well-being: A European Perspective UPTAP Meeting 21 st March 2007 Harriet Young and Emily Grundy London School of Hygiene.
SOCIAL QUALITY INDICATORS: SINGAPORE M Ramesh LKY School of Public Policy National University of Singapore Paper presented at the Asian Conference on Social.
1 The Labour Market Integration of Immigrants in OECD Countries on-going work for OECD's Working Party 1, EPC presented by Sébastien Jean (OECD) Workshop.
Subjective well-being Ype H. Poortinga Tilburg University, Netherlands & University of Leuven, Belgium.
World in Crisis Global Imbalances: Inequality in the World Today Dr Malcolm Fairbrother School of Geographical Sciences World in Crisis.
Issues with Representing the Welfare of Agents U(x) is fundamentally Unobservable, proxies are needed, here we deal with some of the issues.
The experience of Denmark with global disability questions in surveys Ola Ekholm & Henrik Brønnum-Hansen, National Institute of Public Health, University.
The Meanings of ‘Happiness’ and What They Mean for Policymaking Dan Weijers 20 October 2011.
Standard of Living vs. Quality of Life Disparity between the Nations of the World.
Living arrangements, health and well-being: A European Perspective UPTAP-ONS Meeting Southampton University 19 th December 2007 Harriet Young and Emily.
Surveillance and Surveys Higher Blood pressure among Inuit migrants in Denmark than among Inuit in Greenland Bjerregaard et al.
Estimating gross domestic product (GDP) of 289 NUTS regions in Europe with subjective indicators for human and social capital.
Heather O’Connell University of Wisconsin Center for Demography and Ecology Institute for Research on Poverty Introduction. Researchers acknowledge the.
Inequality and Happiness: Are Europeans and Americans Different? Alberto Alesina (Harvard), Rafael Di Tella (Harvard), and Robert MacCulloch (London School.
International Relations (11) New Europe and European Union 김 병 구
Social Issues (ST2): Wealth and Health Inequalities Aims of Study Theme (Pupils should be able to): Give evidence of inequalities in wealth and health.
Happiness in Europe Cross-country differences in the determinants of subjective Well-Being EPUNet Conference 2006 Peder J. Pedersen University of Aarhus.
1 Well-being Consequences of Unemployment Namkee Ahn (FEDEA) J. R. García (FEDEA) J. F. Jimeno (Banco de España)
Introduction to Sociology: Quality of Life Siniša Zrinščak January 19, 2016
Michal Radvan Tax on Property Transfers Michal Radvan.
Methodology of estimating the annual number of usual resident population in Latvia Baiba Zukula Deputy Director of Social Statistics Department Central.
SUBJECTIVE WELL-BEING AND PUBLIC POLICY Richard A. Easterlin University of Southern California Institute of Medicine May, 2013 (With help from Laura Angelescu-McVey,
Transportation-related Injuries among US Immigrants: Findings from National Health Interview Survey.
Trends in attitudes toward income equalization across European countries. Do changing economic conditions matter? Renzo Carriero and Marianna Filandri.
Hearing impairment among 50+ year old Europeans Results from the SHARE survey Karen Andersen-Ranberg, MD, PhD Associate Professor, Andreas Kryger Jensen,
Is the subjective well-being of children worth studying?
Child well-being in the macro context
Kenneth Nelson Professor of sociology
Eric Lin University of Nevada, Reno
FINLAND: THE HAPPIEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD
FINLAND: THE HAPPIEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD
Confidence Variable Information
Presentation transcript:

Behind the open sea somewhere there is the land of my dreams: happiness among immigrants in Europe Olli Kangas Research Director, Social Insurance Institution of Finland Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Southern Denmark

WHY HAPPINESS AND IMMIGRANTS The allusions in the title fits very well to my position as a H. C. Andersen Professor in the happy country of Denmark Klaus Petersen, my Danish colleague, once asked me whether a Finn becomes more happy when s/he moves to Denmark -- the country often depicted to be the happiest country in the world. The study is a humble attempt to answer Klaus’ inquiry.

Contents Why life-satisfaction and happiness? Data Happy immigrants live in happy countries Welfare state regime matters What is the new Sampo Conclusion: A personal statement

Two traditions of welfare research Objective measures – Resources: GDP, income, poverty, level of education, employment etc.matter – No interest in feelings – E.g. The Swedish level of living surveys Resurces: money, education, employment, family etc… Subjective measures – Interest in end-status; feelings matter – Finnish Erik Allardt’s having, loving and being – EU statistics provide more and more data on subjective welfare – Happiness is cool even for the hard-boiled economists

Happiness – a real thing? Some argue that happiness is not a real thing and not a proper object for scientific inquiry Psychologists, armed with fancy brain probing devices, argue that happiness is electric activity in the frontal part of the brains From the social science point of view: – which kind of social phenomena cause positive electric waves in our brains

In Kalevela, the Finnish national epos... There is a story about the SAMPO a happiness and wealth generating magical device Made by the black-smith Ilmarinen – Painting by Akseli Gallen-Kallela, 1893

But, as usually a fight about the ownership of such a useful device immediately began in the following fight the Sampo, unluckily enough, was lost to the sea bottom never has it been found again Akseli Gallen-Kallela 1896

Therefore... There is a constant seek after compensatory measures for Sampo - at home and more and more abroad In this presentation I will look at some of those measures that contribute to happiness and life satisfaction among immigants in Europe: – The regimes of happiness among the European countries in the 2000s – Who is happy and who is less happy? – How can we explain happiness? – Which factors contribute to happiness in Europe?

Data European Social Survey (ESS) Since 2002 the ESS has been carried out at two-year intervals – The latest year of observation used in this study was The size of the cross-sectional data varies from the low 579 in Iceland (2004) to the sample size of in Germany in 2010.

In the individual waves, the number of immigrants in most countries is too low for reliable statistical analyses. Data for different years are pooled – observations on immigrants in 28 countries. – The smallest sample is from Bulgaria 50 observations – the largest one, the Swiss sample, contains immigrants Immigrant status is attached to each respondent born outside the country of residence

Furthermore Countries collapsed into welfare regimes Nordic – Den, Fin, Nor, Swe Central European – Aut, Bel, Fra, Ger, Lux, Nl, Swi Anglo-American – Ire, UK Southern European – Cyp, Gre, Ita, Por, Spa Post-socialst – Bul, Cro, Cze, Est, Hun, Lat, Pol, Rus, Slove, Sla, Ukr

Happiness & life-satisfaction two indicators for subjective well-being in the ESS. a) Happiness: “How happy are you?” b) Life satisfaction: “How satisfied you are with your life as a whole?” – The respondents could express their happiness on a continuous scale that runs from 0 ‘extremely unhappy’ to 10 ‘extremely happy’. – Here subjective well-being = (a+b)/2

Strong correlation between life- satisfaction and happiness To gain a more robust measure for subjective well- being, the two variables were merged (happiness + life satisfaction)/2. – 0 = very unhappy – 10 = very happy

Unstandardized OLS regression coefficients Constant8,247*** Gender0,096** Age-0,038*** Age squared/10000,402*** Economic difficulties-1,001*** Income Quartile0,050*** Bad health-0,684*** Unemployed-0,402*** No friends-0,533*** Feeling unsafe-0,092** Discrimination-0,317*** Trust in people0,306*** Trust in institutions0,381*** Adj. R squared0,305

Happiness, gender, regime of birth and the regime of residence

Inequalities and happiness

Money and happiness - some correlation between GDP per capita and happiness - but huge differences between countries at the same prosperity level (eg EST vs. CYP) - Money matters but institutions rule

Ingredients for the new Sampo???

Is everybody the black-smith of his/her own happiness? What are the elements of Ilmarinen’s modern SAMPO? – Equal society for all – High (inter-generational) income mobility – Low level of poverty – Adequate safety net in all respects – Non-corrupt institutions -> – High level of trust Macro level characteristics explain more than individual level variables

Happiness in Denmark

Land of fairy tales: to be an immigrant and happy “ Behind the open sea, somewhere there is the Land of my dreams, But without wings I can't fly and prisoner I'm of the ground But in my dreams, Which fly so high I walk there every night…” – Unto Mononen’s tango ”The land of my dreams” (1956)