How Can China Solve Its Old- Age Security Problem? Estelle James (2002)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Anna Nechai, PhD Legal and Pension Expert
Advertisements

No. 1 Organizing Eldercare The Danish Case in a Comparative Perspective Morten Balle Hansen, Professor, PhD Department of Political Science, Aalborg University.
PRIVATIZATION OF SOCIAL SECURITY: LESSONS FROM CHILE by Peter Diamond Presented by Agata Narożnik Ertem Ejder.
Enterprise Annuity in China Oct 28, 2009 Prepared by Wentao Yuan.
Assessing the impact of an aging workforce across global organizations.
Pension System Reform in the Republic of Macedonia Kiev, May 2004.
1 Productivity and Growth Chapter 21 © 2006 Thomson/South-Western.
Challenges for financing and providing long-term-care in Eastern Europe Johannes Koettl and Sarbani Chakraborty Europe and Central Asia Regions – Human.
Facilitating longer working lives: the need, the rationale, the how David A. Wise Harvard University and the NBER.
Social Security Includes a number of government programs designed to insure stability in income and standard of living Programs in Social Security: 1.Old.
Chinese Economy: Current Issues and Future Scenarios FAN Gang National Economic Research Institute China Reform Foundation November, 2004.
The fiscal impact of pension reform: economic effects and strategy Ewa Lewicka Kiev – May 27, 2004.
Social Security Includes a number of government programs designed to insure stability in income and standard of living Programs in Social Security: 1.Old.
1 MACROECONOMICS AND THE GLOBAL BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT Fiscal Policy and the Role of Government 2 nd edition.
CHINA: class 3. INDUSTRIAL ACTIVITY GOOD NEWS.
Social Security and Pension Reform in China By Martin Feldstein Presented by Ian Easton For Prof. Wu March 3, 2008.
Pension Payment Level Estimation in the New Rural Pension System Reportor : CHEN Xiaojie North China Electric Power University, Beijing, China.
The 8-7 National Poverty Reduction Program in China: the National Strategy and its Impact Wang Sangui, Li Zhou, Ren Yanshun.
Employee Benefit Plans Joseph Applebaum, FSA October 4, 2002 Views expressed are those of the speaker and do not represent the views of the U.S. General.
 The People’s Republic of China is a communist country.  The Chinese revolution of 1949 brought the communist to power under the leadership of Mao Zedong.
1 CHAPTER TWO EVOLUTION OF SOCIAL SECURITY Objectives of the lecture: After completing this lecture, the students should be able to: 2.1 Explain the historical.
11/27/2007 Pension Reforms in China and Taiwan Hongxia Jiao Yi-Ying Chen.
Research and Planning Administration National Insurance Institute National Insurance Institute Research & Planning Administration Herzliya Conference The.
PENSION REFORM EXPERIENCES IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Ministry of Economy, Labour and Social Policy, Poland Kiev, May 28th,
Structural Change and Labor Policy Reaction in Asia
Taxes, Inflation, and Investment Strategy
The fiscal costs of ageing in the euro area: will the young have to pay the bill? Ad van Riet Head of the Fiscal Policies Division European Central Bank.
PENSIONS IN TRANSITION: United States and Japan Robert L. Clark Professor of Economics North Carolina State University 19 September, 2002.
Pension Systems in Times of Financial Crises: Serbia
RISK MANAGEMENT FOR ENTERPRISES AND INDIVIDUALS Chapter 18 Social Security.
Key Social Security Policy Choices in Thailand by Estelle James.
Xingmin Yin Fudan University May 21, 2013 Disclaimer: The views expressed in this document are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the.
Preliminary country paper On Competition Scenario in Vietnam Prepared by the Central Institute of Economic Management (CIEM) for the 7-UP MARK II Project.
The Role of the Fiscal Policy in Poverty Reduction Youngsun Koh Korea Development Institute.
The Logic of the Budget Process
STRUCTURAL REFORM OF SOCIAL SECURITY Martin Feldstein Presented by Agata Narożnik.
May 29, 2003Below the Surface of the Civil Service Wage Bill1 How much are we paying to be served? Components of Civil Service Pay.
The Economic Effects of Social Security October 10-12, 2005.
FUNDED PENSIONS IN CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE Design and Experience Agnieszka Chlon-Dominczak Cancun, May 15th, 2003.
Design features of an IA System: What Can We Learn from Other Countries? By Estelle James.
1/1 World Economic and Social Survey 2007 Development in an Ageing World Canadian Institute of Actuaries Montreal 15 April 2008 Rob Vos Director Department.
1 BASIC PRINCIPLES OF PENSION ECONOMICS by Estelle James World Bank Institute.
Transition costs and their impact on adequacy Vidija Pastukiene Seminar on Private Pension Provision Transition costs and decumulation phase Tallinn, 6-7.
Chapter 2 The Economy: Myth and Reality E pluribus unum (Out of many, one) MOTTO ON U.S. CURRENCY.
Providing a Safety Net. Why Households Differ One of the main reasons why household income differs is because the number of household members who work.
Chapter 5: Social Security Chapter 5 Social Security Copyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
POLITICS, DEFICITS, AND DEBT The social security debate It’s the demography stupid!
MEETING THE CHALLENGES OF AN AGEING SOCIETY Asia-Pacific Finance and Development Centre Shanghai, October 17, 2007.
1 The Gender Impact of Pension Reform—What Is It and Why? By Estelle James.
Ageing and the Changing Nature of Intergenerational Flows in Thailand
20 CHAPTER Social Security PUBLIC SECTOR ECONOMICS: The Role of Government in the American Economy Randall Holcombe.
Farid Abolhassani Social Health Insurance 15. Learning Objectives After working through this chapter, you will be able to: Define the principles of social.
Enterprise Reform and Private Sector Development Some Possible Lessons from China Qimiao Fan, the World Bank.
Political Economics Riccardo Puglisi Lecture 6 Content: An Overview of the Pension Systems Distinguish Features Economic and Political Explanation A Simple.
Mitchell Wiener 15 December 2011 ILO Expert Meeting Social Security and Social Protection Floor Pension Reform in Indonesia.
Changing employment relations & reforms of social security systems.
Understanding China’s Growth: Past, Present and Future Xiaodong Zhu Department of Economics East Asia Seminar at Asian Institute, University of Toronto.
BUSINESS ORGANIZATIONS Chapter Eight. SOLE PROPRIETORSHIPS Section One.
Chapter 14 Section 3.
The challenges for the Chinese pensions-lessons from Europe? Danping Yan Huazhong University of Science & Technology.
Pension reform in China in international perspective
Changing world of work & reforms of social security systems
LECTURE VII Social Security.
Social Security Includes a number of government programs designed to insure stability in income and standard of living Programs in Social Security: Old.
ZHANG Juwei Institute of Population and Labor Economics
Pension reform in China in international perspective
Local governments revenues of China
Lithuanian pension system and reforms MISSOC Network Meeting Vilnius, October Ministry of Social protection and Labour.
Changing employment relations & reforms of social security systems
China's Basic Pension Gap
Presentation transcript:

How Can China Solve Its Old- Age Security Problem? Estelle James (2002)

Aging Population in China In 1990, only 9% of population was over 65 By 2030, this proportion will be up to 22% By 2030, more than ¼ of world’s old people will live in China Old family system breaks down due to one-two-four (one child, two parents, four grandparents)

Fact The Chinese government now spends only 2% of GDP on formal systems of old-age support, but will spend over 10% in 30 years. This budgetary pressure will interfere with its ability to spend on other important public goods.

Pension Reform The Chinese government is well aware of the looming social security crisis and is determined to do something about it. Projected reforms: _ prefunding _ unifying a fragmented system

Observations from Historical Data Social Security is an urban phenomenon in China In 2000, one pensioner for three covered workers In 2000, covered workers comprised less than 10% of total population but 50% of urban employees, mostly SOE and government employees.

Observations: continued Pensioners comprised almost ¼ of population over 60. They are mainly living in urban areas where they previously had state sector jobs. Dependency ratio (pensioners/covered workers) increased by 50% during the 1990s.

Observations: continued The pension spending as a percent of GDP has trebled over the past decade. The average pension equals GDP per capita or ¾ of average SOE wage. Spending has risen faster than revenue and a surplus at the beginning of the 1990s has turned into a deficit by the end.

During the Cultural Revolution The provision of old-age security became a responsibility of each state enterprise, financed out of current revenue. Workers in the formal sector stayed at the same enterprise throughout their working lives. The enterprise provided housing, medical care and old-age security to its workers and pensioners.

Cultural Revolution: continued At that time, there were very few pensioners since China still had a young population. Cash pensions equaled wage and both were extremely low since the country was poor. The biggest expenses were covered in kind. Agricultural workers did not have any formal old-age security program.

During the Shift to a Market Economy Problem: Unfunded employer-sponsored pensions became unsustainable. Reasons: _ Old industries lacked the resources to finance expected pensions _ Older enterprises burdened with large social security obligations could not compete with new enterprises with no pensioners _An enterprise-based pension system deters worker mobility

Reasons: continued _Wages have risen rapidly and pensions have risen even faster. _It was difficult for state enterprises to lay off redundant workers. Early retirement was often used as an alternative to firing _The burden of past liabilities made it difficult to restructure state enterprises

Municipal Pooling: Experimentation with municipal pooling began in ’s State Council Document 77 encouraged the pooling of pension obligations at municipal level, on a pay-as-you-go basis

Advantages of Pooling Shift responsibility from enterprise to a broader unit All pension costs would be covered out of municipal pool of funds Flourishing young enterprises would help to subsidize failing older enterprises Worker mobility within a municipality would be facilitated

Problems of Pooling Some municipalities (particularly those with declining industries) lacked the resources needed to pay the pension bill. Such municipalities had to require high contribution rates, which put them at a disadvantage. Municipalities did not have skills and capacity to administer the social security, so enterprises continued to keep most of the records, determine size of pension and eligibility for normal and early retirement.

Failure of Pooling Municipal pooling existed on the paper but it was very limited in practice, compliance fell dramatically, and costs grew much faster than revenues. Over past decade, the Chinese government has become increasingly aware that municipal action alone will not suffice and will not even work.

Failure of Pooling: continued The declining share of SOEs in the economy accelerated the rise in the dependency rates for the social security system, which mainly served SOEs, while workers in newer forms of enterprise were largely unprotected. The possibility of social unrest among pensioners where enterprises and municipalities were unable to pay the bill was a further problem.

Keys to the Long-Run Solution Structural unification Prefunding A shift to Defined Contribution Plans

Gradual Move Toward Keys In 1995, with State Council Document 6, China adopted a multi-pillar system. Document 6 gave municipalities two choices – one emphasizing the funded defined contribution pillar and the other allowing a greater role for the public defined benefit pillar. However, this led to further differentiation, multiple plans and confusion.

New System In 1997 with State Council Document 26, the government defined more narrowly what the outlines of the system should be. The new system would consist of two components: _ a basic (flat) benefit that equaled 20% of the average wage in the region for 15 years of work; _ a contribution of 11% toward individual retirement accounts.

New System: continued Pensioners would continue getting their old benefits and new workers would enter the new system directly Current workers would get a mixture of the new and old systems. In 1998, the Ministry of Labor and Social Security was established to oversee this new system.

Basic Benefit Basic benefit _similar to flat public benefit in UK _ensure minimum living standard _ in the long-run, it would be financed on a pay-as-you-go basis by a 13% contribution from enterprises to a municipal or provincial pooled fund.

Individual Accounts Accounts are supposed to be prefunded. The replacement rate that will be yielded by the accounts depends heavily on the rate of return.

Implementation Issues Up to early 2000s, China was far from implementing this new system. Three key problems have emerged _ growing deficits and inability to cover transition costs and fund the accounts _ moral hazard under decentralized administration _ inefficient investment of the funds

Nature of Transition Problem in China Transition costs are low in countries where the implicit pension debt is small, and China has a relatively small implicit pension debt. The Chinese implicit pension debt is small because only ¼ of its labor force (the urban state sector) is covered by social security.

Nature of Transition Problem in China: continued In China some coastal areas (with few pensioners and many young workers) can cover their current obligations with a low contribution rate and are accumulating a surplus. Most areas, however, especially the northeast or inland areas (with declining industries, old non-functioning state enterprises, many pensioners, and few young workers ) are struggling to cover their bills.

Evidences on helps from MOF In 1997 MOF transferred money to help cover deficits in five municipalities By 1999 it had transferred more than US$2 billion to help 21 municipalities make pension payments. In 2000, US$4 billion in 25 municipalities

How to Finance the Transition: Experiences from Other Countries Downsizing benefits _ replacement rate _indexation method _retirement age _ conversion rate of accounts to annuities

Using Proceeds of SOE assets It is logical to link SOE assets and pension liabilities It is not clear who own the assets- enterprise, municipality, or central government? In 2001 Chinese government decreed that companies would have to sell off state- owned shares equivalent to 10% of the proceeds and turn this revenue over to a newly created central entity, the National Social Security Fund.

Using Proceeds of SOE assets: continued The National Social Security Fund would transfer the funds to areas where they are most needed to pay pensions, unemployment insurance, and other social security liabilities. In the past, state-owned shares could not be sold. The new rule applied to Chinese companies listing on both overseas and domestic markets. The proceeds from these assets sales were to be allocated, not necessarily to the municipalities they originated from, but to the municipalities with the highest pension debts and least fiscal capacities of their own.