REFUSAL OF TREATMENT – ADOLESCENT WITH CANCER Rabbi Prof. Avraham Steinberg.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Decision-making at End-of-Life Dr Mary Kiely Consultant in Palliative Medicine Calderdale & Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust.
Advertisements

2005. Why is it necessary When person lacks capacity physicians have power and influence over them which could be abused 30% pts on acute medical wards.
Ethics Relating to Children in Research in FP7
Medical Consent Guardianship Board. Consent to Medical or Dental Treatment A patient cannot receive medical treatment without consentA patient cannot.
Proactive Interventions: Incorporating a Children’s Rights Approach
University Research Ethics Committee Workshop on procedure and data protection issues 30th May 2008.
Lecture 3 Values & principles of professional ethics By Dr. Hala Yehia.
Bledsoe et al., Paramedic Care Principles & Practice Volume 1: Introduction © 2006 by Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, NJ Chapter 7 Ethics in.
The principles In Medical Ethics Lecturer :Noha Alaggad
Introduction to basic principles
Competency Assessment. Competency and Capacity Capacity/Competency –Legal, clinical, ethical and social construct –“Ability of an individual to make autonomous.
Problem: Enabling the child to make independent decisions and to express her/his views in decisions about cultural practices or protect the child's right.
Ethical and Legal Implications of Practice Chapter 5.
Obtaining Informed Consent: 1. Elements Of Informed Consent 2. Essential Information For Prospective Participants 3. Obligation for investigators.
Consent Purpose of consent to treatment –moral purpose –clinical purpose –legal purpose “It is trite law that in general a doctor is not entitled to treat.
Treatment for Mental Disorders and Protection of Patients’ Rights Mary Donnelly Law Faculty, University College Cork Centre for Criminal Justice and Human.
Medical Ethics. Medical Ethics [vs. Professional ethics]  Ethical dilemma is a predicament in which there is no clear course to resolve the problem of.
Baltic Dental Meeting Palanga Dana Romane The Patient in the Centre – Patient’s Involvement in the Treatment Process, Full Awareness and.
1 Consent for treatment A summary guide for health practitioners about obtaining consent for treatment Bridie Woolnough Resolution Officer Health Care.
Advance Care Directives Act 2013 An overview- what’s new, what’s different Kathy Williams, Senior Policy Officer.
Idara C.E.. Three ethical principles guides research with human participants. principle of Autonomy 1. The principle of Autonomy requires investigators.
SEN 0 – 25 Years Pat Foster.
Proxy Consent. Civil code of the Philippines Competency of minors  Art. 38. Minority, insanity or imbecility, the state of being a deaf-mute, prodigality.
REGULATION OF HEALTH PRACTICE Prof Ames Dhai. Introduction Constitution Statutes (Acts of Parliament) Common Law Criminal.
Organ, body, authority Prof. Gyula Bándi. A reference to the competent organ or body, particularly to the competent authority, are part of legal regulation.
Dr Mike Ewart Smith Division of Psychiatry, University of Witwatersrand The Ethics of Informed Consent: Revisiting the Doctor Patient Relationship.
Medical Law and Ethics Lesson 4: Medical Ethics
Ethics and End-of-Life Care Part 2: Autonomy and Futility Michael Wassenaar, PhD February 9, 2012.
Patient Understanding in Informed Consent Robert F. Dunton, MD Chief, Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery Upstate Medical University.
Ethical issues in old age medical care. The Four-Principles Approach developed in the early 1980’s by well-known American bioethicists Tom Beauchamp and.
INFORMED CONSENT Some Philosophical Puzzles Professor David Archard
Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants of HKICPA
Legal capacity law reform in the Czech Republic and rights of persons with disabilities Conference on Autonomy and Inclusion Copenhagen, 7- 8 June 2012.
Patient’s Bill of Rights. The pt. has the right to considerate and respectful care. The pt. has the right to considerate and respectful care. The pt.
1 Protection of Vulnerable Subjects in Research Melody Lin, Ph.D. December 2012.
Research Profession and Practice ETHICS IN ADVANCED PREHOSPITAL CARE.
Professor David Stanley Northumbria University.  “Human participants or subjects are defined as including living human beings, human beings who have.
Louise Wilson, Solicitor.  Royal Assent – April 2005  Came into force April & October 2007  Many common law principles now enshrined in statute  Court.
I.T. Gangaidzo MA, BM BCh(Oxon); DTM&H(Lond); FRCP(Lond)
Basic Nursing: Foundations of Skills & Concepts Chapter 7 ETHICAL RESPONSIBILITIES.
MEDICAL ETHICS and The End of Life. PRIMA FACIE DUTIES AUTONOMY BENEFICENCE NON - MALEFICENCE JUSTICE UTILITY.
PA Profession ETHICS COMMITTEE RIGHT TO REFUSE TREATMENT Salvatore Barese, PA-C.
CONSENT IN PAEDATRIC PATIENT. CONSENT Consent is the granting to someone the permission to do something they would not have the right to do without such.
Consent & Vulnerable Adults Aim: To provide an opportunity for Primary Care Staff to explore issues related to consent & vulnerable adults.
12/24/2015Miss Samah Ishtieh1 Managerial Ethics Patient Rights & Nursing Ethics Prepared by: Miss Samah Ishtieh.
A DISCUSSION AT DIOCESAN CENTRE LEADING TO WRITING SUBMISSIONS TO THE PARLIAMENTARY SELECT COMMITTEE ON HEALTH 15 TH NOVEMBER 2015 Write for Life.
MEDICAL ETHICS and The End of Life. ETHICAL THEORIES DEONTOLOGY CONSEQUENTIALISM VIRTUE ETHICS.
Dr.Abedalrahman Shqaidef. Introduction Negligence Risks Encountered as a Clinician Ethical Decision Making.
Withholding and refusing optional treatment. Cases Withholding treatment Karen Ann Quinlan -Right to die controversy in US -Valium and alcohol  unconscious.
Idara C.E.. Three ethical principles guides research with human participants. principle of Autonomy 1. The principle of Autonomy requires investigators.
Bridie Woolnough Resolution Officer Health Care Complaints Commission
By MUREREREHE Julienne BDT(Hons) KHI..  Informed consent is a legal document, prepared as an agreement for treatment, non-treatment, or for an invasive.
Elsevier Inc. items and derived items © 2006 by Elsevier Inc. Slide 1 Ethics in Healthcare.
Ethics Some Approaches.  Students will not undertake any research project on children (under 16)  Students will not normally research on individuals.
Introduction to Medical Ethics Ray Noble Centre for Reproductive Ethics and Rights UCL Institute for Women’s Health University College London.
Medical Law and Ethics, Third Edition Bonnie F. Fremgen The Physician–Patient and Physician-society relationship Chapter 5.
Dennis is 90 years old, he has fallen over and needs an operation, the medical team states that his wife can consent on his behalf, if he is unable to.
Medical Ethics  A set of guidelines concerned with questions of right & wrong, of duty & obligation, of moral responsibility.  Ethical dilemma is a.
Research Profession and Practice ETHICS IN ADVANCED PREHOSPITAL CARE.
Bledsoe et al., Essentials of Paramedic Care: Division 1 © 2007 by Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, NJ Division 1 Introduction to Advanced Prehospital.
LEGAL ISSUES COMMON IN NURSING PRACTICE PRESENT BY: DR. AMIRA YAHIA.
BIOETHICAL PRINCIPLES Beauchamp and Childress 2001;Gillon 1986
Chapter 7 Ethics in Advanced Prehospital Care
Informed Consent to Treatment
Patient Autonomy & Informed consent
A Patient has the Right to…..
Decision-making at End-of-Life
Define Law A System of rules and guidelines which are enforced through social institutions to govern behavior, wherever possible Shapes politics, economics.
Presentation transcript:

REFUSAL OF TREATMENT – ADOLESCENT WITH CANCER Rabbi Prof. Avraham Steinberg

GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS

PRINCIPLES OF BIOETHICS AUTONOMY BENEFICENCE NON-MALEFICENCE JUSTICE

SECULAR MEDICAL ETHICS Based on the overriding principle of autonomy it is a widely accepted ethical axiom nowadays that a competent patient has the right to refuse medical interventions even if the refusal might cause him harm. Is an adolescent competent enough for such decision?

SECULAR MEDICAL ETHICS - PROBLEMS Insufficient information and explanation Lack of understanding of the facts Lack of a good physician-patient relationship Desire of the patient for more attention from the caregiver and the like Occasionally, the refusal is due to social pressure, or depression, or the influence of medications

JEWISH MEDICAL ETHICS - PRINCIPLES The validity of autonomy in halakhah is limited. A person has no right to bring harm to his body by refusing sound medical treatment. According to halakhah, the physician is obligated to heal and the patient is obligated to seek healing. Therefore, the medical treatment is often not determined by the desire and consent of the patient but by the objective facts. Coercion to accept medical therapy can be viewed as coercion to fulfill commandments.

HALAKHIC RULES AND REGULATIONS If the patient has a life-endangering illness or wound of which the physician has a complete and clear understanding and offers a standard and effective treatment, one can force the patient to accept the treatment even if he refuses. If it is necessary to desecrate the Sabbath to save life and the patient wishes to be stringent and not allow it, one should force him to accept because such a man is a pious fool. The law which requires patient coercion to accept therapy applies only to standard and effective therapy and not to situations where there is doubt about the efficacy of the proposed therapy.

HALAKHIC RULES AND REGULATIONS Even when a treatment is considered to be life-saving, if it is suspected that coercion might result in a significant anxiety which can worsen the medical condition of the patient, then coercion should be avoided. Although in principle one must coerce a patient to accept life-saving treatment even. In practice, in many instances the medical opinion is uncertain and there are doubts about certain decisions. Therefore, in such instances, one should not coerce the patient. If a patient refuses to accept a certain medical treatment because he feels that the treatment is not proved to be efficacious, one should not coerce him. If the treatment is not a standard one, and certainly if it is experimental, the patient should not be coerced.

ISRAELI DYING PATIENT ACT Article F: Treatment of the Terminally Ill Minor 24. A minor’s parent is authorized to represent him regarding his medical treatment, whether in the matter of prolonging his life or in the matter of refraining from prolonging his life … if he has no parents, or the parents’ guardianship has been revoked and no other guardian has been assigned for the minor, or if his guardian is not a close person, the institutional committee will make a decision in respect of him.

ISRAELI DYING PATIENT ACT A minor who is a terminally ill patient is entitled to participate in the adoption of a decision regarding his medical treatment, if these two conditions are satisfied: (1)The minor is aware of his condition and requests to participate in the adoption of the decision regarding him; (2) The responsible physician determines that the minor's cognitive and mental capacity and maturity enable his participation in adopting the decision regarding him.

ISRAELI DYING PATIENT ACT A responsible physician will give the minor information that pertains directly to his health or his medical treatment, if these two conditions are satisfied: (1) The responsible physician is convinced that giving the information, or a part of it, will not cause physical or mental harm to the minor, or endanger his life; (2) The responsible physician has determined that the minor’s cognitive and mental capacity and maturity enable him to appropriately understand the information and its meaning.

ISRAELI DYING PATIENT ACT (a) In the event of a dispute between the parents of a minor who is a terminally ill patient, or between them and the responsible physician, with regards to his medical treatment, an institutional committee will resolve the matter. (b) Where there is a dispute between a minor who is a terminally ill patient and his parents, or between them and the responsible physician, with regards to his medical treatment, the following provisions shall reply:

ISRAELI DYING PATIENT ACT (1)Where the minor expressed his wish for his life to be prolonged the responsible physician will act in accordance with that wish, subject to the provisions of this Law; (2)If a minor less than 15 years of age has expressed his wish that his life not be prolonged, an institutional committee will decide on the matter.

ISRAELI DYING PATIENT ACT (c) When an institutional committee discusses the matter of a minor who is a terminally ill patient, it should hear the minor’s position as well, if expressed, and the committee should also receive the particulars of the information that was given to the minor. (d) The institutional committee will take the best interests of the minor into account among its other considerations, and will be entitled to determine that his life should not be prolonged, if convinced that prolonging his life would not be in his best interests, subject to the provisions of subsection (b)(1).

THANK YOU !