Human Genome Research Project University of Otago Funded by the New Zealand Law Foundation.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Legal Capacity, Personhood and Supported Decision Making

Advertisements

1 Large research and medical databases in clinical and research multi-centres trials A Swiss Perspective June 19, 2012 European Commission International.

Confidentiality, Consent and Data Protection Elizabeth M Robertson Deputy Medical Director Grampian University Hospitals Trust.

The Legal Rights of People with Dementia in Health and Social Care

Polokwane, WORKING WITH CHILDREN World Health Organisation (2011) Cognitively ready for disclosure 8-11 years Children of school going age should.

A presentation to the AABHL Conference Auckland, July 2012 Alison Douglass, Barrister Lynne Bowyer, Bioethics Centre, University of Otago A Douglass and.

CRUZAN v. DIRECTOR, MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH U.S. SUPREME COURT 1990.

Childcare Issues in the Young Persons Programme Deirdre Carey Social Worker The Drug Treatment Centre Board.

Workshop 501 and 505 Review barriers to communication

© Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, 2006 Circle of Care Ontario University & College Health Association - May 24, Manuela Di Re Associate.

Obtaining Informed Consent: 1. Elements Of Informed Consent 2. Essential Information For Prospective Participants 3. Obligation for investigators.

2/16/2010 The Family Educational Records and Privacy Act.

Code of Ethics – Discussion Question

Absence Management To be used in conjunction with the 1st Class HR ‘Absence Management’ Management Guide available at

Baltic Dental Meeting Palanga Dana Romane The Patient in the Centre – Patient’s Involvement in the Treatment Process, Full Awareness and.

1 Consent for treatment A summary guide for health practitioners about obtaining consent for treatment Bridie Woolnough Resolution Officer Health Care.

Property of Common Sense Privacy - all rights reserved THE DATA PROTECTION ACT 1998 A QUESTION OF PRINCIPLES Sheelagh F M.

Ethical Issues of Elder Care. Objectives Apply the concept of decision-specific capacity to older adults. Apply the concept of decision-specific capacity.

The Nuffield Council on Bioethics Report : The collection, linking and use of data in biomedical research and health care: ethical issues. Martin Richards.

1 National Training Programme for New Governors 2005 Module 3 Ensuring accountability.

The principles used by AUTEC in granting ethical approval for research.

Research Excellence Framework : Equality and Diversity Working Methods and Code of Practice University of Wales, Trinity Saint David Matt Briggs Eleri.

Putting the UN Disability Convention into practice Sara Brunet, Senior Lawyer and UNCRPD lead officer, EHRC.

First steps for a data protection commissioner: Some suggestions from New Zealand Katrine Evans Assistant Commissioner (Legal and Policy) Kuala Lumpur,

Obtaining Consent. Informed Consent  Patients have a right to information about their condition and the treatment options available to them. The amount.

Proxy Consent. Civil code of the Philippines Competency of minors  Art. 38. Minority, insanity or imbecility, the state of being a deaf-mute, prodigality.

1 The Dentist’s Legal Responsibilities to the Patient Dental Law and Ethics.

Assessment & treatment Least restrictions on rights and dignity Support persons to make/participate in decisions Provide oversight & safeguard Role of.

Privacy, Confidentiality and Duty to Warn in School Guidance Services March 2006 Disclaimer - While the information in these slides are designed to reflect.

Prof. György BAZSA, former president Hungarian Accreditation Committee (HAC) CUBRIK Workshop IV Beograd, 13 March, 2012 European Standards and Guidelines.

Investigation and case planning Your responsibilities under the Children Act 1989 Brayne & Carr: Law for Social Workers: 10e Chapter 9.

LAW AND ETHICS FEBRUARY 3, LAW Law is the basic framework of society and is the context for application of ethics.

The Eighth Asian Bioethics Conference Biotechnology, Culture, and Human Values in Asia and Beyond Confidentiality and Genetic data: Ethical and Legal Rights.

Mediation in the application of the 1980 Convention Regional Conference on the 1980 Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction.

“What’s Ethics Got To Do With It” Presentation to the Canberra Evaluation Forum Gary Kent Head Governance Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.

Case study: fluoridation of water Professor Jonathan Montgomery Professor of Health Care Law, University of Southampton; and Chair, Hampshire Primary Care.

Evaluation of implementation of informed consent in obstetrics & gynecology operations in Khartoum- Sudan 2009 Umbeli T 1, Marium A A 2, & Elhadi M A Pub.:

Business Project Nicos Rodosthenous PhD 28/10/ /10/20141Dr Nicos Rodosthenous.

The consent in health care.  Defining consent  Age of consent  How to give consent  Factors impacting on the ability to make a decision  The ethical.

Describing ethical competences - caveats turning ethical principles into competences is a challenge: nonetheless competences have been described for some.

Matsievskaya Larissa Leonardovna Karaganda 2014 Karaganda State Medical University Department foundations of psychology and communicative skills.

Competency and Consent Presentation to the First International Conference on Individualized Funding and Self-Determination, Seattle, 2000 Marcia Rioux.

New Rules for the Digital Age NSW Ombudsman Symposium 26 May 2009.

Making the best use of assessment Waldemar Martyniuk.

Developing a Framework In Support of a Community of Practice in ABI Jason Newberry, Research Director Tanya Darisi, Senior Researcher

Ethical AND legal issues in GENETICS. objective 1- introduction. 2-major needs in study of ethics. 3-Ethical Principles in Medicine. 4-The Special Position.

Consent & Vulnerable Adults Aim: To provide an opportunity for Primary Care Staff to explore issues related to consent & vulnerable adults.

An Introduction to the Privacy Act Privacy Act 1993 Promotes and protects individual privacy Is concerned with the privacy of information about people.

Data Protection: Workplace, Health and Safety. Employers’ responsibilities Employer obliged to provide safe place of work. Health and Safety Act 2004.

TRAINING COURSE. Course Objectives 1.Know how to handle a suspected case 2.Know how to care for a recognized trafficked person referred to you Session.

Community surgery : staying out of trouble. Miss Nicola Lennard : 12 June 2015:

Access to Information: Bolivia Main Headline Goes Here Special Meeting of the Juridical and Political Affairs OAS December 13, 2010 Laura Neuman Access.

APEC Engineers Workshop Legal Considerations - Central Register Sept 2015 Angela Frawley, General Counsel.

APEC Privacy Framework “The lack of consumer trust and confidence in the privacy and security of online transactions and information networks is one element.

Patients and doctors making decisions together GMC Guidance 2008.

Angela McKinnon Child health lead Aberdeenshire CHP NHS Grampian Jan 2015.

Sharing Personal Information Programme Wales Accord on the Sharing of Personal Information (WASPI) for organisations involved in the protection, safety,

Key Knowledge Confidentiality Year 4 Medical Ethics and Law Thread Course The Ethox Centre, University of Oxford.

Involving children in decision-making has received much attention in New Zealand, and internationally, recently. Care of Children Act 2004 attempts to.

CARING FOR CHILDREN IN NORTHERN IRELAND: Reflecting on the work of the NI Children’s Commissioner Dr. Alison Montgomery.

Research ethics.

Clark Holt Limited (Co. No ), Hardwick House, Prospect Place, Swindon, SN1 3LJ Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation.

Ethical, legal and social aspects of public health genomics Mark Taylor, School of Law, University of Sheffield 7 th November 2014.

Evidence-based Insurance Medicine What is Cochrane and Cochrane Insurance Medicine? Rebecca Weida, MSc University of Basel.

Understand safeguarding of children and young people (for those working in the adult sector) Key learning points.

Kids' legal rights in medical care, your obligations and risk minimisation 27 April 2017.

The Children Act 1989 Allocates duties to local authorities, courts, parents and other agencies in the United Kingdom to ensure children are Safeguarded.

Capacity and Consent

Data workshop WhOSE DATA IS IT ANYWAY? Alexia Christie

IAPP TRUSTe SYMPOSIUM 9-11 JUNE 2004

Presentation transcript:

Human Genome Research Project University of Otago Funded by the New Zealand Law Foundation

Newborn Screening: Richman Wee Project Manager Law Foundation-sponsored Human Genome Research Project Envisioning Changing Expectations and Future Proofing

What started off interest in this Own thinking to date - tidying up the ‘clutter’ re presentation at H Screening Symposium Oct ‘dancing around the most stirring issue’, re informed consent Prelude

Look at the issue of ‘Informed Consent’ blood spot collection use (immediate and subsequent/secondary) storage/destruction/return transfer Parental consent Decision-making authority and process… awareness, communication, information disclosure, participation for the responsible care of and interest of newborns Today

Re-examining & Rethinking Language and Concepts (Legal/Ethical) Picture: UK Newb Scn Prog Ctr, Policies and standards, Apr 2005, page 23 RolesInterests Purpose(s) Purpose(s) & Expectation(s) RightsResponsibilities ConsentAuthorisation

Interests of various parties Whose and what interests? Taking stock, weighing, reconciling all interests, to extent possible, with the aim of advancing relevant and key interests Balancing likelihood of Harm vs Benefit How can joint/shared responsibilities, duties and rights – generally and overall –be better exercised or respected in the (best) interest of relevant party/ies? Sense of time: immediate, short-term, long-term

and the bigger picture … How … - provide benefits and protect from harm - promote relevant interests as best as possible - fulfil the purpose(s) intended/agreed … keeping clearly in mind and observing the central purpose - meet expectations - help & support decision-makers exercise their responsibilities ?

Newborn Parents State (instns & processes) HealthcareProviders Community/ies Interests – whose ?

Expectations - - Expectations within, and broadening, the context of the ‘purpose(s)’ of an intervention When? Whose? What? How to meet them? Why?

Responsibilities (cf rights) … for care of the newbornHealthcareProvidersParents Newborn

Authorisation - Examining ‘Consent’ Justification: Not necessary? Not desirable? Not practicable?

Authorisation - Comparing and Examining ‘Consent’ ‘Types’ of Consent (cf. Refusal): A. Explicit / Express Consent* B. Exceptions to explicit / express consent* 1. Emergency* 2. Legislation* (Statutory Authorisation) – public health, mental health legislation *as per Wildeman & Downie

Authorisation - Comparing and Examining ‘Consent’ C. Implied Consent* (1) Subsumed Consent* i. sub-procedure or necessarily incidental to procedure explicitly consented to ii. contains a blanket consent to other unspecified procedures - significant nexus *As per Wildeman & Downie

Authorisation - Comparing and Examining ‘Consent’ C. Implied Consent (cont.) * (2) Consent inferred from conduct* (3) Routine procedures* (4) ‘Reasonable’ consent* D. No Consent (Arguments from Impracticality*) (1) Too costly* (2) Too complex* *as per Wildeman & Downie

Authorisation - Comparing and Examining ‘Consent’ Presumed Consent (Iceland Biobank, cadaveric organ procurement) Deferred Consent (emergency research) Generic Consent for Genetic Screening (Annas 1994) Proxy Consent (children, organ donation by legally competent, some research contexts) Substitute / Surrogate Consent (legally incompetent, PVS, circumcision)

Authorisation Who from? Hierarchical (legally recognised) ordering ? What (substantive/content) ? When seek it ? How seek it ?

Authorisation Not intended to circumvent/undermine the notion of Consent Intended, as a starting point, to reflect and convey more accurately what is going on Promote relevant interests and meet expectations Support responsible care of newborns

Voluntary participation having ‘built-in barometer’ as an indicator … also requiring initiatives to support promotion of awareness & understanding Community/ies-dependent over time (bottom-up cf top-down, but consider dynamic exchange) Postlude

Led by Prof Mark Henaghan, Dean of Law, Otago Sponsored by NZ Law Foundation web: