ASTR178 Other Worlds A/Prof. Orsola De Marco

BBQ: September 8 th, 12:30PM, at the back of E7B Observing is on October 6 th 7:15PM and 13 th 8:15PM. (Sign up in class or on my door: E7A-316). Assignment 2 posted, due in 17 th September. Moon practical due in 17 th September. Announcements Sample questions 1,3,5-15, 18-22,25-34

In last class: the terrestrial planets III and gas giants part I Talk by Sarah Chamberlain Water on Mars Life on Mars? Exploration of the outer solar system. Jupiter and Saturn. Atmospheres Inner composition Magnetic fields

In this class: gas giants part II Jupiter and Saturn. Atmospheres Inner composition Magnetic fields The rings The moons of Saturn and Jupiter Io

Jupiter and Saturn

The compositions of Jupiter and Saturn They are mostly made of hydrogen (H) and helium (He). H lacks spectral lines at relatively high densities and low temperatures – hard to detect H spectroscopically. Low densities of J. and S. indirect evidence that they are not made of rock. Presence of CH 4 and NH 3 indirect evidence for presence of abundant H. UV spectra have H lines – 1960s confirmation of H composition. He confirmed in 70s and 80s when spacecrafts measured spectra in detail detecting signature of collisions between H and He. J. has “cosmic” (also called solar) abundances: 86% H, 14% He (by number) S. has much less helium: 96% H, 3% He. S. is less massive than J. – it cooled more rapidly. Helium on S. froze and precipitated to the centre, where it cannot be detected.

Missions to the outer planets Pioneer 10: launch 1972, first through asteroid belt; at Jupiter 1973; lost contact early Pioneer 11: launch 1973, Jupiter 1974, Saturn 1979, lost contact The Pioneer anomaly … Voyager 1: launch 1977, Jupiter 1978, Saturn 1980, still going. Voyager 2: launch 1977, Jupiter 1989, Saturn 1981, Uranus 1986, Neptune 1989, interstellar mission still active. Galileo: launch 1989, arrived at Jupiter 1995, deployed probe, orbits Jupiter Cassini: launch 1997, Jupiter 2000, Saturn 2004, deployed probe on Titan. New Horizons: launch 2006, will arrive at Pluto 2015!

The Voyagers Launched in 1977 Arrived at Jupiter 1979 Arrived at Saturn 1980/81 Arrived at Uranus and Neptune in 1986/89 Still operational – interstellar missions

The Great Red Spot, the white ovals and the brown ovals.

Why is the GRS long-lived? Zonal winds up to 500 km/s circulate at zone/belt boundaries

The three white ovals merged in 2000 to become a new storm High clouds in a storm or in white zones or white ovals/storms are due to frozen ammonia. The GRS is higher than the white clouds because of the power of the storm. There, reaction with Sun’s UV radiation turn the colour to red. The new white spot was seen to turn redder in 2006: storm grew in intensity and went higher.

Saturn’s rare storms Rarely, spots are noticed on S. They appear to be every 30 years. WHY? S. has less internal heat – might have to do with fewer storms. They are thought to be equivalent to thunderstorms – rising gas which solidifies into crystals (ammonia in the case of S.). Lightning also detected by Cassini – confirming storm interpretation.

The atmospheres of Jupiter and Saturn Heavily influenced by their internal heat – convection. E-W and W-E “zonal winds” between 500 km/s (Jupiter) and 1800 km/s (Saturn). Below Jupiter’s surface they are faster (650 km/s), showing that the source of the energy is the planet’s heat. Clouds are made of ammonia (highest), ammonium hydrosulfide (medium) and water crystals (lowest). They are more compressed on Jupiter than on Saturn (higher gravity). Clouds on Saturn are deeper and details harder to see hence the overall banding of S. is duller than for J. The brown clouds are the lowest, the white the medium and the red the highest, but why the colours is not known.

The zones are cool high clouds, the belts are warm loser strata We are not sure whether belts or zones are rising

Bands in gas giants are the same as circulation cells on Earth They result from convection and spin

Galileo’s probe did not find the expected water Layer – possibly it dropped in a dry area, equivalent to a desert. Jupiter has the same composition as the Sun, but has more heavy elements – accumulated through impacts. Ar, Xe, Kr are also too abundant: clues on origin?

Jupiter and Saturn: oblate due to rotation. The degree of oblateness depends on the distribution of mass. Models of the mass distribution on J. and S. indicate that they have 2.6% and 10% of their mass locked in a small rocky core. For Jupiter this is 11,000 km in diameter, 8 times Earth’s mass with pressures of 70 million bars. Saturn has a larger core. Both planets have a layer of liquid ices which have precipitated after collisions. They are lighter and float on the rocky core. Above the ices is a thick layer of helium and liquid metallic hydrogen – high pressure! It is likely that the inner rocky core was formed first and onto it H and He accreted. Another scenario is that J and S formed Like stars do – collapse of the cloud material.

Jupiter’s and Saturn’s magnetic fields Generated by the spinning liquid metallic hydrogen. 14 times Earth’s! For Saturn’s field is a little weaker: less liquid metallic hydrogen because less mass, less pressure. Jupiter’s magnetosphere: 16 times the area of the Moon

Phase diagrams

Radio emission from Jupiter Radio emission due to synchrotron radiation: charged particles from Io’s volcanos are accelerated in the magnetic field and emit radiation. Periodic changes reveal inner period. Saturn has a lesser emission – why?

Saturn’s rings Noticed by Galileo ~1610 Disappeared by 1612 Reappeared in 1613 Huygens in 1655 predicted that. This is due to the equinox – how so? 1675 Cassini noticed the gap between A and B rings. 1800s the fainter C ring was found.

Saturn‘s Equinox Saturn’s Equinox is only every 15 years, why? During the Equinox objects embedded in the rings cast the longest shadow. We can therefore spot objects that protrude from the flatness of the rings….

Saturn‘s Equinox: August 2009 Can anybody spot anything???

The composition of Saturn’s rings Could the rings be a solid sheet? 1857 Maxwell says no James Keeler sees the inner parts of the rings rotate faster – it is not a rigid sheet. They reflect 80% of the sunlight that falls on them – might be ice. Confirmed in the 70s (Gerard Kuiper) using IR spectroscopy. Voyager and Cassini spacecrafts found temperatures to range between -180 o and -200 o C – ice would be….icy! Radio absorption determined size of particles to be 1 cm – 5 m. Most particles about 10 cm.

The formation of planetary rings Warning: this drawing is misleading as it seems that a solid rock would be disintegrated by arriving at the Roche limit.

The formation of planetary rings Warning: this drawing is misleading as it seems that a solid rock would be disintegrated by arriving at the Roche limit.

The composition of Jupiter’s rings Reflect only 5% of sunlight that falls on them so they are very faint. Have only 1/100,000 th of the mass of Saturn’s rings, so they are faint. Rocky particles only 1  m in diameter. Cannot be seen from Earth - Discovered by Voyager 1 in 1979 Particles from impacts onto its moons. Ring at about 2 Jupiter radii from the centre of Jupiter.

Voyager 1 image of the Saturn’s rings

Cassini image of the Saturn’s rings’ drapes

Backlit Saturn’s rings (Voyager 1) Why is the Cassini division bright?

Compare the Cassini division reflecting light and scattering light The F ring is made of 1  m particles – measured by light scattering

Colour variations depend on small amounts of trace elements. These trace elements have not yet been identified. Colour variations suggest that there is little mixing from ring to ring. Rings might have been added at different times and contained traces of different original materials. Cassini image

Voyager discovered the D, G and E rings. E and G likely formed from particles spewed out by Enceladus.

Small moons can shape a ring: Pandora and Prometheus shepherd particles into the F ring.

Small moons can shape a gap too: Daphnis clears the Keeler gap

These spokes maintain the same shape throughout the orbital periods of the rings. Do you find this strange?

Giant Moons

Noticed by Galileo ~1610 Could be resolved by naked eye were it not for Jupiter’s glare. Synchronous rotation. Innermost 3 have orbital periods in a 1:2:4 resonance. Why only 3 not all 4? Transits and occultations used to measure diameters The Galilean satellites

The Pioneers and the Voyagers satellites measured the moons’ masses – how? From radii and masses one could infer densities – how?

Key Ideas Composition and Structure: Jupiter and Saturn are both much larger than Earth. Each is composed of 71% hydrogen, 24% helium, and 5% all other elements by mass. Both planets have a higher percentage of heavy elements than does the Sun. Jupiter probably has a rocky core several times more massive than the Earth. The core is surrounded by a layer of liquid “ices” (water, ammonia, methane, and associated compounds). On top of this is a layer of helium and liquid metallic hydrogen and an outermost layer composed primarily of ordinary hydrogen and helium. All of Jupiter’s visible features are near the top of this outermost layer.

Key Ideas Saturn’s internal structure is similar to that of Jupiter, but its core makes up a larger fraction of its volume and its liquid metallic hydrogen mantle is shallower than that of Jupiter. Jupiter and Saturn both rotate so rapidly that the planets are noticeably flattened. The rotation of both planets’ interiors is revealed by variations in the radio emissions from the planets. Both Jupiter and Saturn emit more energy than they receive from the Sun. Presumably both planets are still cooling.

Key Ideas Atmospheres: The visible “surfaces” of Jupiter and Saturn are actually the tops of their clouds. The rapid rotation of the planets twists the clouds into dark belts and light zones that run parallel to the equator. Strong zonal winds run along the belts and zones. The outer layers of both planets’ atmospheres show differential rotation: The equatorial regions rotate slightly faster than the polar regions. For both Jupiter and Saturn, the polar rotation rate is nearly the same as the internal rotation rate. The colored ovals visible in the Jovian atmosphere represent gigantic storms. Some, such as the Great Red Spot, are quite stable and persist for many years. Storms in Saturn’s atmosphere seem to be shorter-lived.

Key Ideas There are presumed to be three cloud layers in the atmospheres of Jupiter and Saturn. The reasons for the distinctive colors of these different layers are not yet known. The cloud layers in Saturn’s atmosphere are spread out over a greater range of altitude than those of Jupiter, giving Saturn a more washed-out appearance. Saturn’s atmosphere contains less helium than Jupiter’s atmosphere. This lower abundance may be the result of helium raining downward into the planet. Helium “rainfall” may also account for Saturn’s surprisingly strong heat output.

Key Ideas Magnetic Fields and Magnetospheres: Jupiter has a strong magnetic field created by currents in the metallic hydrogen layer. Its huge magnetosphere contains a vast current sheet of electrically charged particles. Charged particles in the densest portions of Jupiter’s magnetosphere emit synchrotron radiation at radio wavelengths. The Jovian magnetosphere encloses a low-density plasma of charged particles. The magnetosphere exists in a delicate balance between pressures from the plasma and from the solar wind. When this balance is disturbed, the size of the magnetosphere fluctuates drastically. Saturn’s magnetic field and magnetosphere are much less extensive than Jupiter’s.

Key Ideas Rings: Saturn is circled by a system of thin, broad rings lying in the plane of the planet’s equator. This system is tilted away from the plane of Saturn’s orbit, which causes the rings to be seen at various angles by an Earth-based observer over the course of a Saturnian year. Structure of the Rings: Saturn has three major, broad rings (A, B, and C) that can be seen from Earth. Other, fainter rings were found by the Voyager spacecraft.

Key Ideas The principal rings of Saturn are composed of numerous particles of ice and ice-coated rock ranging in size from a few micrometers to about 10 m. Most of the rings exist inside the Roche limit of Saturn, where disruptive tidal forces are stronger than the gravitational forces attracting the ring particles to each other. Each of Saturn’s major rings is composed of a great many narrow ringlets. The faint F ring, which is just outside the A ring, is kept narrow by the gravitational pull of shepherd satellites. Jupiter’s faint rings are composed of a relatively small amount of small, dark, rocky particles that reflect very little light.