‘ Soft-regulation’ and the modernisation Of employment relations under the British Labour government (-97-2000) MARK STUART.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Partnership Working The evidence base. Partnership working What is partnership working? Principles of partnership working Benefits? Success factors? Challenges?
Advertisements

1 Module 4: Partners demand and ownership Towards more effective Capacity Development.
PRESENTATION TO THE ANNUAL LABOUR LAW SEMINAR 30 JUNE 2011 COMMISSION FOR CONCILIATION, MEDIATION AND ARBITRATION.
EAC HIGHER EDUCATION POLICY
Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations
Dealing with Training and Education at European level The industriAll Europe approach 1.
HR Manager – HR Business Partners Role Description
Labour Market Reforms Presentation to EFC Council By Director General.
Best practice partnership models
Putting Research Evidence to Work Research Seminar 14 th January 2009.
Role of RAS in the Agricultural Innovation System Rasheed Sulaiman V
SMALL BUSINESS AND WORKPLACE SAFETY AND HEALTH: THE CHALLENGE; THE OPPORTUNITY Small business and working conditions: Eurofound research findings Jean-Michel.
Lecture 6 Employee relations
Learner demand and workplace participation for learning Prof. MARK STUART.
Leeds University Business School Statutory Trade Union Learning Representatives (ULRs) Within the British VET System Mark Stuart Leeds University Business.
Education and Culture LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE FORMER GENERATION OF HIGHER EDUCATION PROGRAMMES IN RUSSIAN FEDERATION José Gutierrez Erasmus+ : Higher.
Session 3 - Plenary on implementing Principle 1 on an Explicit Policy on Regulatory Quality, Principle 3 on Regulatory Oversight, and Principle 6 on Reviewing.
From the Personnel manager to HRM and beyond Mike Emmott Employee Relations Adviser CIPD.
Linking the European Youth Strategy to the YOUTH IN ACTION opportunities Hans-Georg Wicke JUGEND für Europa – NA for YOUTH IN ACTION in Germany Rotterdam,
- Mobilising Actors - Universities, Researchers & the Lisbon Strategy Lesley Wilson Secretary General, European University Association (EUA) »Implementing.
Tripartite Initiative on Workplace Learning Campaign Road Show.
The Personal Record of Achievement for Youth Exchanges and Group Initiatives Recognising the skills of young people Building employability Encouraging.
Political Leadership How to influence! And Current OH Issues Carol Bannister Royal College of Nursing of the United Kingdom.
The Use of Mediation in the UK. Trade Union Approach Policies negotiated between the trade union side and the management side Grievances - written statement.
Human Resource Management, 4th Edition © Pearson Education Limited 2004 OHT 16.1 Employee Participation and Involvement Weaknesses The ETUC has pointed.
1 MINISTRY OF LABOUR, SOCIAL SOLIDARITY AND FAMILY ESF HEAD OF MISSION MANAGING AUTHORITY FOR SECTORAL OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME FOR HUMAN RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT.
Partnering for Growth WEF 11 September 2005 Influencing the Policy Debate The South African Challenges and Successes.
Innovation Systems Research Network MCRI Theme III: Social Inclusion and Civic Engagement David A. Wolfe, Ph.D. Program on Globalization and Regional Innovation.
ILO-Brussels’ office Role of social partners in promoting sustainable development, inclusive growth an development R. Delarue, Director.
Bill Ratteree ILO EDUCATION INTERNATIONAL EUROPEAN REGION Vocational Education and Training Round Table October 2009, Budapest.
Creating Entrepreneurship: entrepreneurship education for the creative industries David Clews Subject Centre Manager Higher Education Academy Art | Design.
EU-Regional Policy Structural actions 1 LESSONS FROM THE THEMATIC EVALUATION OF THE TERRITORIAL EMPLOYMENT PACTS Veronica Gaffey, DG Regional.
Quality Assurance in a Changing World María José Lemaitre INQAAHE Conference Abu Dhabi, March 2009.
Equality Framework for Local Government Excellent Level Criteria Overview.
Torrington, Hall & Taylor, Human Resource Management 6e, © Pearson Education Limited 2005 Part 5 Employee relations.
Higher Education and Research: Mission and Interaction David Crosier CONFERENCE TO LAUNCH WORK ON A MASTER PLAN FOR HIGHER EDUCATION IN ALBANIA Tirana,
Policy options and recommendations José Palacín Chief, Innovative Policies Development UNECE Minsk, 19 June 2014.
Verena Schmidt, ACTRAV: TRIPARTITE DECLARATION OF PRINCIPLES CONCERNING MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISES AND SOCIAL POLICY « These slides are partly based on.
Leading educational partnerships What’s new? What’s difficult? What’s the reward? Professor Ann Briggs Newcastle University
Blurring boundaries? New Labour, civil society and the emergence of social enterprise Alibeth Somers Senior Lecturer MPA Programme.
European Commission Introduction to the Community Programme for Employment and Social Solidarity PROGRESS
National Procurement Training Jackie Foster & Graeme Cook Scottish Procurement & Commercial Directorate 1 st March 2011.
The Role of Government in Building Absorptive Capacity Ken Warwick DTI Knowledge Economy Forum VI 17 April 2007.
Alan Seatwo Knowledge Management Specialist How information helps to promote diversities and social justice An overview of an information literacy project.
South Asia Labour Conference Summary of Recommendations.
The United Nations Global Initiative to Fight Human Trafficking (UN.GIFT) at the Informal Joint Briefing to Member States, Vienna, 2 March 2012.
Torrington, Hall & Taylor, Human Resource Management 6e, © Pearson Education Limited 2005 Slide 21.1 Views on Trade Union Recognition The proportion of.
School Improvement Partnership Programme: Summary of interim findings March 2014.
European Public Health Alliance Lobbying, the role of NGOs and communication strategies Tamsin Rose Sofia, 29 October 2005.
The ILO’s approach to Decent Work for Young People Giovanna Rossignotti Coordinator Youth Employment Programme Course (A300850) - Trade union training.
New unionism in telecoms Aims of session To look at structural changes in the sector in Europe since the 1980s taking British Telecom as an example To.
UniCredit European Works Council Global Framework Agreements Milan, April 2009 Oliver Röthig, Head of UNI Finance.
INTEREST BASED PROBLEM SOLVING (IBPS) Does the Statutory scheme in BC support IBPS? Is IBPS new; or is it simply basic principles of effective problem.
HEInnovate A self-assessment tool for higher education institutions (HEIs) wishing to explore their entrepreneurial and innovative potential.
Developing a Framework In Support of a Community of Practice in ABI Jason Newberry, Research Director Tanya Darisi, Senior Researcher
PRESENTATION AT THE TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITIES QUALITY FRAMEWORK Professor Sarah Moore, Chair, National Forum for the Enhancement of Teaching and Learning.
ELEMENTS OF STRATEGY FOR ACHIEVING SOCIAL PROTECTION FLOOR Global Network, Cape Town 7 December 2012 BY AFRICAN LABOUR RESEARCH NETWORK (ALRN)
1 SOCIAL DIALOGUE IN THE IT SECTOR 2 SOCIAL PARTNERSHIP People and organizations from some combination of public, business, and civil constituencies.
European Public Health Alliance Advocating for Better Health in the EU Lara Garrido-Herrero (ANME General Assembly) Frankfurt, 11 November 2006.
Standards & Competencies MA in Social Work Nevenka Zegarac, Full professor, FPN, BU.
STRONG FAMILY AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT IS CENTRAL TO EFFECTIVE SCHOOL REFORM Jan Patterson and Ann Bliss Smarter Schools National Partnerships Key Reform.
HR Strategies & its impact on Business Strategy.
EU programme for education, training, youth and sport
HEInnovate A self-assessment tool for higher education institutions (HEIs) wishing to explore their entrepreneurial and innovative potential.
LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE PRESENT GENERATION OF HIGHER EDUCATION PROGRAMMES IN EASTERN PARTNERSHIP COUNTRIES Klaus Haupt, Head of Tempus Unit Education,
The strategy for lifelong learning
POLICY FORUM Rethinking Irish Economic Development WIFI ACCESS
European social dialogue A new start for social dialogue
Corporate Restructuring And Workers' involvement
Doctoral Education in Europe: An Introduction
Presentation transcript:

‘ Soft-regulation’ and the modernisation Of employment relations under the British Labour government ( ) MARK STUART

Approach Explores the way New Labour sought to modernise British employment relations through non-legislative enactments (soft law) 1.Labour-management partnership (1 st term) 2.Facilitation of workplace change (2 nd term) 3.Trade union modernisation (3 rd term) Soft law allows for wider set of insights into nature of state intervention (though shaped by overall state approach)

DATA Research draws from multiple research projects conducted since 2000 to present day. 1.Labour-management partnership: Survey of trade union representatives (MSF) conducted in 2000 (317 responses, 15%); Partnership Fund research in Finance sector 2.Facilitation of workplace change: ACAS project on NHS modernisation (5 case studies during ) 3.Trade union modernisation: Evaluation of Union Modernisation Fund (2005-current)

Background IR research has tended to focus on the more ‘formal’ aspects of the role of the British state (ie. Hard law) ‘New Labour’ policy situated within the British tradition of ‘voluntarism’ (limited state intervention) and recent ideological commitment to Neo-Liberalism. Emphasis on individual rights, with limited collective changes (NMW; SRP) and not reversal of Tory reforms But, state intervenes in a myriad ways (Howell), with increased emphasis on ‘soft law’ (benchmarking, encouraging, steering)

Labour-management partnership (1) Promoted during Labour’s first term, Based on productive cooperation and end of adversarialism DTI Partnership Fund (50k for joint projects) – definition of partnership was ‘open and vague’ but seen as ‘call for self regulation between the workplace actors (Terry and Smith (2003) Industry for partnership flourished Some academics saw in partnership an opportunity for unions to increase their institutional centrality (Ackers and Payne, 1998); chimed well with idea of the ‘mutual gains enterprise’ (Kochan and Osterman, 1994) Wide body of research sought to question extent of mutual gains: unions incorporated; benefits to employees limited

Labour-management partnership (2) State support diminished during second term and industry for partnership receded Opinion divided between those that see the ‘partnership movement…has run out of steam’ (Guest et al, 2008) and the endurance of partnership agreements (Bacon and Samuel, 2009) 248 partnership agreements between ; in 2007 accounted for 10 percent of workers and 1/3 rd in public sector But research shows it is problematic to conflate partnership with agreements Partnership relates more to culture, policies and practices; good employment relations produces better ‘partnership’ outcomes State endorsement of partnership did little to change employer culture; though state could attempt this as an employer

Facilitating workplace change: the state as employer (1) Assessment of partnership often points to need for intermediation (Cooke, 1990); and also need to build skills and capacity of key actors (ie. Unions and management) Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (ACAS) was a key player (as a state agency) in the ‘Industry for Partnership’ ; played a role in facilitating partnership in NHS change From 2004 New Labour sought to modernise the National Health Service through the Agenda for Change programme Large ‘harmonisation’ programme that was to be implemented through partnership working and consultation machinery But, widespread structural changes meant that at local level consultation machinery was often not working or had broken down

Facilitating workplace change: the state as employer (2) In hospital trusts, organisational mergers had created uncertainty, distrust and tension in consultation forums Uncertainty over what was negotiation and consultation, what issues were to be covered and protection of local interests meant forums had broken down and senior management were not attending; this made Agenda for Change difficult ACAS played role in reinvigorating consultation machinery, through ‘workplace projects’, joint seminars and problem solving groups and the like; recognition of difference and benchmarks with ‘good practice’ were key Consultation became more effective, which in some cases meant more effective employment relations and structures of representation - state role here as employer and facilitator

The modernisation of unions (1) Trade Union Modernisation Fund introduced during New Labour’s third term, from 2006 Up to 10 million was allocated across three rounds, for match- funded union projects (up to 200k) 79 projects funded in total involving a large range of trade unions Seen by some as largely an extension of the Partnership Fund, designed to foster less adversarial union activity and a ‘supply side trade unionism’ (Ewing, 2005) Rationale was to equip unions with the skills: common place to management in global and competitive market place; need to represent diverse groups of workers (transform; demonstrate) Themes partnership working, communication, diversity, modern management methods and professional competence; vulnerability

The modernisation of unions (2) UMF projects were varied, and included: new partnership agreements with employers; extensive upgrading of technological capacities; extensive developments in diversity strategies and roles (eg equality representatives); wider ranging programmes of training; development of ‘management tools’ Key emphasis on internal communications, diversity management and skills upgrading; attempts to engage employers often met with limited success. Difficult to see the UMF as an exercise in state-sponsored social engineering (or if so, it failed); more ‘social exchange’, new ‘opportunity structure’ State resources to encourage internal modernisation and climate for innovation - but politically contentious state investment

Conclusions: Steering the modernisation of employment relations (1) Focus on how New Labour sought to modernise employment relations through soft regulation Can be seen in terms of steering through partnership, facilitation and capacity building (union modernisation) Can this be seen as coherent – partnership seems to underpin New Labour’s neo-liberal agenda for flexibility and consensus But, when partnership failed, state steering sought to push the agenda in the public sector, with support from ACAS, and modernise unions to equip them with the right skills for partnership

Conclusions: Steering the modernisation of employment relations (2) Such coherence not evident: partnership was largely rejected by employers (see argument of disconnected capitalism); unions have been able to use the UMF for their own agendas Focus on soft regulation directs attention to the wider attempts by the state to (re)craft employment relations: state has always intervened in British industrial relations, despite voluntarism, and scholars’ emphasis on the law often results in ‘the exclusion or marginalisation of a much broader range of state actions’ (Howell, 2005). Soft law directs us to these wider actions, but need to placed in the context of state action and also, ultimately, the relationship between hard and soft law (ie. Absent hard law may result in more soft law; but soft law may need some basic hard laws to work)

Conclusions: Steering the modernisation of employment relations