Creating an EU recycling society Its not (just) implementation Dr Michael Warhurst, Resource and Consumption campaign Friends of the Earth Europe June.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
EU SCP/SIP Action Plan Regulatory update and insight European Economic and Social Committee Hearing, 10 December 2008, Bettina Lorz DG Environment, European.
Advertisements

Waste Management and Resource Efficiency
High Level Sub-regional Consultation on Advancing Action on Short Lived Climate Pollutants (SLCP) in Southeast and Northeast Asia 19 August 2014, Bangkok,
CARBON FOOTPRINT TOOL OF WASTE MANAGEMENT IN EUROPE 01/04/2014 Xavier Gabarrell, Joan Rieradevall, Pere Llorach.
Main Developments in EU Environment Policy. 1.The 7 th Environmental Action Plan 2.Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Updated Directive 3.Timber.
INTEGRATED PLANNING: THE LINKS BETWEEN URBAN WASTE MANAGEMENT, SANITATION AND ENERGY.
BOOMERANG ALLIANCE WASTE In A Changing Climate. Boomerang Alliance Objective… By… TO BRING WASTE BACK TO ZERO 1.Adopting Waste Levies to fully recover.
„Business opportunities in waste treatment” Conference -Tel Aviv
Annual Conference 2008 Future Challenges for the Waste Management Industry Waste Framework Directive - Impact on the European Waste Management Industry.
Lena Ek Member of the European Parliament. Lena Ek Member of the European Parliament The EU risks permanently lowered growth path The European economy.
Environmental Sustainability in the Extractive Industry: The Case for Climate Change Mitigation Dr Uwem E. Ite.
Greenhouse Gases and Waste Management Michael Cant Golder Associates Ltd. MWA Spring Workshop May 2015.
6 April 2004Presentation to LOGON Environmental Policy in the European Union A guide to improve understanding of how EU environmental policy is made and.
RETHMANN ENTSORGUNGS AG & CO. KG FEAD Congress in Stockholm Egbert Tölle RETHMANN Entsorgungs AG & Co. KG - Member of the Board - Waste Shipment.
Waste The U.S. produces 11 billion tons of waste per year. Industrial waste –about 400 million metric tons per year in the U.S. Municipal Waste- A combination.
Challenges of Resource Efficiency Karolina Fras European Commission – DG Environment 21 October 2009.
Seite BDE Bundesverband der Deutschen Entsorgungs-, Wasser- und Rohstoffwirtschaft e.V. Setting the right framework to mobilise the potential of bio-waste.
EU focus on waste management. European waste management is particularly challenging: environmental protection must be achieved without distroying the.
European Innovation Partnership on Raw Materials Conference on Initiatives related to the EIP on Raw Materials, 19 April 2013 Work Package 4 Improving.
Moving towards Zero Waste
Moving Towards Zero Waste
The role of waste management and energy from waste in a circular economy- SITA UK’s proposed Severnside development Sept 2009 Stuart Hayward-Higham.
Nirmala Menikpura Institute of Global Environmental Strategies (IGES) Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions and other impacts from recycling activities:
Summary of LCA Review including carbon issues Julian Parfitt WRAP LCA Symposium ‘Making the most of LCA thinking’ 23 November 2006, Savoy Place, London.
SITA incinerator plans Presentation to Cornwall County Council 17 th September 2008.
1 An Overview of EPR Jim Frey, CEO of Resource Recycling Systems What it Means for North Carolina, and What are Viable Alternatives NC SWANA Fall Conference.
Reuse and Recycling Social Enterprises in the European Union (RREUSE) 2nd Annual Community Reuse Network Ireland Conference 10/11/2011 Michal Len RREUSE.
Latest EU policy developments in the field of bioenergy
Circular Economy – European Perspective Environmental Services Training Group Local Authority Environmental Conference Athlone, Ierland, 7th May 2015 M.
EU waste and resource policies Andreas Versmann European Commission – DG Environment Zero waste – February 2009.
A European and National Context for Waste Esther Kiddle Director TK Associates 28 November 2013.
>> Focus on environment Waste management in the Netherlands Vibrant India Day Round Table meeting 22th October 2012 Nijenrode University
Deutsches Institut für Urbanistik „System of waste management in Germany – turning waste into benefit (separate collection, recycling, reuse) – outlook.
EU Legislation in the field of environment – key developments in 2007 and rd ECENA Plenary Meeting 18 September 2008.
Biofuels – EU policy context Funding and Legislation Workshops Glasgow, 26 May 2011 Francesca Giannini Scotland Europa.
European Topic Centre on Sustainable Consumption and Production (ETC/SCP) 1 Municipal solid waste management in EEA member countries- A review of achievements.
Workshop on Recycling of Waste Tirana, Albania September 20 – 21, 2011 Tsvetelina Borissova Filipova Senior Project Manager/Lawyer Environmental.
Carbon Footprint of residual Municipal Solid Waste (rMSW) Management -
Municipal Solid Waste Generation, Recycling, and Disposal in the U.S. for 2006 U.S. EPA Office of Solid Waste November 2007.
Local campaigning on waste. Contents 1.Introduction I.Who works on waste, and why? II.Waste in the UK – national FoEcus 2.Sustainable waste management.
Progress and Priorities : Sustainable Development & the low carbon economy Sustainability West Midlands 10 th December 2009 Tom Anderson.
The new Waste Framework Directive Commission’s perspective Karolina Fras DG Environment, European Commission.
Legislation Update: The Packaging Regulations, the WEEE Regulations and the Batteries Directive Tessa Bowering Environment Officer (Waste)
Smooth Sailing Ahead Partnering With Sustainability and Waste Compliance & Mitigation Fernando Berton, CIWMB.
LCAs and policymaking: The good, the bad, and the ugly Dr Michael Warhurst, Friends of the Earth.
Assessment of separate collection in 28 capitals of the EU
An end to disposal What needs to be done locally, nationally, and at EU level, in order to phase out residual waste Dr Michael Warhurst, Friends of the.
Closing the loop – An EU Action Plan for the Circular Economy
COPS, 2 nd Mai 2013, H. Leuenberger Promotion of Green Industries in Recycling Heinz Leuenberger PhD Director, Environmental Management Branch.
Is resource efficiency slipping off the agenda? Ariadna Rodrigo Friends of the Earth Europe November 2014.
The EU waste Policy – Latest News Michel SPONAR - European Commission, DG Environment.
Circular Economy Closing the loop – An EU Action Plan for the Circular Economy Peter Czaga, DG Environment.
2015 Waste Proposals: Impact Assessment Julius Langendorff Unit A.2 Waste Management & Recycling DG Environment.
Lecture (11): Waste Recycling
Moving towards Zero Waste
Addressing Resource Efficiency and Climate Change
EU Circular Economy Package
Environmental benefits RO-17 Green Industry Innovation Programme Romania 14 Oct. 2016, Bucharest Mihai-Lucian Toniuc  
Lithuanian Energy Institute
Closing the loop – An EU Action Plan for the Circular Economy
Reflections on European Waste Management
Impacts of new Legislation on waste statistics
The European Strategy for Circular Economy – Plastics Strategy and revised Waste Legislation Joanna Drake – Deputy Director-General DG ENV, European Commission.
SCP in the 7th Environmental Action Programme
E-WASTE: A VALUABLE SOURCE OF RESOURCES
Challenges of Resource Efficiency
Recycling and Recovery of Plastic Packaging - An Industry Perspective - Financial opportunities & legislative barriers for the Circular Economy Brussels,
E-WASTE SURVEY: TAKING GLOBAL ACTION Federico Magalini UNITED NATIONS UNIVERSITY – Institute for Sustainability & Peace Rome, 7 September 2011.
The new EU Waste Legislation: Implementing and Delegated Acts
Presentation transcript:

Creating an EU recycling society Its not (just) implementation Dr Michael Warhurst, Resource and Consumption campaign Friends of the Earth Europe June 2010

Contents 1.A resource efficient EU? 2.Reality of EU recycling 3.Where should we be in 2020? 4.Policy options for a resource efficient EU

The resources challenge We are using ever-increasing quantities of the world’s resources Europe is particularly dependant on imported resources – see our ‘Overconsumption?’ report [3] There is an urgent need for more policies to boost eco-efficiency The resources agenda will get more important in future years, as consumption in large countries – e.g. China and India – continues to increase. Business pressure is increasing –E.g. Raw Materials Initiative

EU “Resource Efficiency”? >€5 billion worth of materials Dumped in landfill or incinerators every year... [1]

The ‘Gone to Waste’ report Methodology: –Used Prognos data to estimate the amount of ‘routine’ recyclables that aren’t being recycled The report does not cover the rarer metals from WEEE etc. –Used a conservative valuation of these materials We did not consider the cost of recycling –Used established methodology to calculate climate benefits of recycling this material Results – if this material was recycled [1]: –The material would have had a minimum potential monetary value of €5.25 billion. –We would have saved CO 2eq emissions of 148 million tonnes, equivalent to taking approximately 47 million cars off the road per year.

What’s going wrong? Poor implementation... But this is not the only problem:

EU MSW Recycling rates

What’s going wrong? Poor implementation –A standard DG Environment response –But if every EU nation is not doing enough, then it must be more than this.... Low ambition, e.g. –No overall recycling target until we got a 50% target into the Waste Framework Directive revision Frozen policymaking, e.g. –Packaging recycling targets last revised in 2004 And still promote ‘recovery’ of plastic, when landfill is better for the climate than most incineration [2]

Packaging recycling targets “No later than 31 December 2008 the following minimum recycling targets for materials contained in packaging waste will be attained: –(i) 60 % by weight for glass; –(ii) 60 % by weight for paper and board; –(iii) 50 % by weight for metals; –(iv) 22,5 % by weight for plastics, counting exclusively material that is recycled back into plastics; –(v) 15 % by weight for wood.” Is this really the best Europe can do?

Resource efficient?

Important? Does European industry's access to resources matter? Does the creation of jobs matter? Does climate change matter? If yes, then we need a step change in recycling

A 2020 vision for waste The EU is measuring its resource use, and creating policies to reduce it. Waste volumes are reducing, with waste prevention targets in place. All member states are aiming beyond 70% reuse & recycling, with many exceeding this by some margin –All waste streams and types are being addressed –There is a focus on spreading best practice around Europe (including in market development). There is a regulatory ban on recyclable materials (including WEEE, batteries & household recyclables) entering residual waste treatments Product policy is making things more long lasting, more reusable and more recyclable –Including an extension of producer responsibility to new product groups – Toys? Furniture?

How do we get there? 1.Create new drivers on resource efficiency –Beyond climate or energy 2.Strengthen – and create - legislation to ensure that all materials are captured – at sufficient quality –E.g. landfill/incineration bans –Higher packaging and other recycling targets 3.Strengthen product regulation to ensure products are long lasting and recyclable 4.Share best practice – not worst practice –Stop creating over-capacity for residual waste and focus on flexible and climate-friendly residual waste treatments... –Focus on quality recycling and reuse –Collection & anaerobic digestion, composting of biowaste

A new driver for resource efficiency Friends of the Earth, with Sustainable Europe Research Institute, are campaigning to get the EU to measure and reduce its resource use We have selected four indicators [4], all including the ‘rucksack’/footprint of imported goods: –Total resource use (tonnes), which can be subdivided into biogenic/non biogenic and down into individual materials –Water use for nations, water footprint for products –Land use for nations, land footprint for products –Greenhouse emissions - both Kyoto and the GHG rucksack of imported products for nations, carbon footprint for products These should be incorporated into impact assessment –Impact assessment of existing TS ignored resource efficiency

Conclusions We are nowhere near creating a sustainable waste (resource) management approach across Europe –based on ‘Best Available Techniques’ not ‘whatever we can get away with’ New measurement, targets and measures are need to stop the loss of valuable resources Inaction – and an appeal for ‘improved implementation’ – is not a viable response to our current economic & environmental situation –We should focus on moving to >70% recycling as soon as possible. –Some countries will require more time than others – but this should be the minimum target for all

EU MSW Recycling rates

References [1]“Gone to waste: the valuable resources that European countries bury and burn”, Friends of the Earth, October 2009: [2]Eriksson, O., & Finnveden, G. (2009). Plastic waste as a fuel - CO2-neutral or not? Energy & Environmental Science, 2(9), [3]“Overconsumption? Our use of the world’s natural resources”, Friends of the Earth Europe/Sustainable Europe Research Institute, September 2009: [4]“How to measure Europe’s Resource Use”, Sustainable Europe Research Institute for Friends of the Earth Europe, July 2009: See also this briefing: “Measuring our resource use: A vital tool in creating a resource-efficient EU”, Friends of the Earth Europe, April For more information on Friends of the Earth Europe’s work on Waste & Resources, see