Phillip K. Dick: A real thing is one which, when you stop believing in it, doesn’t go away.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Philosophy Through the Centuries
Advertisements

Theories of Knowledge Knowledge is Justified-True-Belief Person, S, knows a proposition, y, iff: Y is true; S believes y; Y is justified for S. (Note:
Philosophy of Science The last fifty years. Divergence Questioning methods, validity, facts Realism/Antirealism Incommensurability The emergence of relativism.
What is Social Theory?. Theory Harrington 2005: 1-3 Greek word theōria, opp. of praxis contemplation / reflection Reflection on the value and meaning.
The ontological argument. I had the persuasion that there was absolutely nothing in the world, that there was no sky and no earth, neither minds nor.
Perception & the External World
PHILOSOPHY 107 (STOLZE) Notes on Geoffrey Gorham, Philosophy of Science, Chapter 4.
Science and Christianity Dave Scott and Daphne Brenner.
Meditations on First Philosophy
1 From metaphysics to logical positivism The metaphysician tells us that empirical truth-conditions [for metaphysical terms] cannot be specified; if he.
By Amelia, Caitlin, Dani and Andrew
Charting the Terrain of Knowledge-1
Defending Common Sense Direct Realism. The trouble with sense-data  Key feature of Representative Realism and anti-realist theories. But…  The object/appearance.
Plato BC The Republic Updated, 10/3/07.
Direct realism Michael Lacewing
Scientific realism. Varieties of (the problem of) realism Ontological: is there a mind-independent world? Epistemological: can we know something about.
Indirect realism Michael Lacewing
Defending direct realism Hallucinations. We can identify when we are hallucinating Another sense can help us detect what is reality and what is a hallucination.
© Cambridge University Press 2011 Chapter 1 The problem of knowledge.
Introduction to Ethics Lecture 9 The Challenge of Cultural Relativism By David Kelsey.
SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES Open-Mindedness and related concepts.
Is there a rational basis for the belief in God..
Descartes on scepticism
Rationalism: Knowledge Is Acquired through Reason, not the Senses We know only that of which we are certain. Sense experience cannot guarantee certainty,
Truth and Reality. Announcement: Tutorial Group 10 will meet next Wednesday at 2:00 Reminder: Your portfolio will be due on December 3 rd. Submit a hard.
More categories for our mental maps  How we understand knowledge has repercussions for how we understand our place in the world.  How we understand.
Philosophy of Mind Week 3: Objections to Dualism Logical Behaviorism
Epistemology Revision
 According to philosophical skepticism, we can’t have knowledge of the external world.
“The Problem of Knowledge” Chapter 1 – Theory of Knowledge.
Bellringer: The astronomer Carl Sagan said “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” What did he mean by this? Do you agree?
BERKELEY’S CASE FOR IDEALISM (Part 1 of 2) Text source: A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge, sectns. 1-21,
MIDTERM EXAMINATION THE MIDTERM EXAMINATION WILL BE ON FRIDAY, MAY 2, IN THIS CLASSROOM, STARTING AT 1:00 P.M. BRING A BLUE BOOK. THE EXAM WILL COVER:
Descartes Meditations. Knowledge needs a foundation Descartes knows he has false beliefs, but he does not know which ones are false So, we need a method.
René Descartes ( AD) Meditations on First Philosophy (1641) (Text, pp )
+ Research Paradigms Research Seminar (1/2 of book complete with this PP)
PERCEPTION. Why an issue? Sensory perception a key source of our beliefs about the world. Empiricism – senses the basis of knowledge.
DIVIRGENT PHILOSOPHIES These Philosophies Have an Affect on the Business Education Curriculum.
Varieties of Scepticism. Academic Scepticism Arcesilaus, 6 th scolarch of the Academy Arcesilaus, 6 th scolarch of the Academy A return to the Socratic.
René Descartes, Meditations Introduction to Philosophy Jason M. Chang.
“Cogito, ergo sum.” “I think, therefore I am.”.  chief architect of 17 th C intellectual revolution  laid foundations of ‘modern scientific age’
Feedback from 5 mark question: Outline and explain the argument from perceptual variation as an objection to direct realism. Point to consider: DR = objects.
CHAPTER 3: R EALITY AND B EING. I NTRODUCTION Metaphysics is the attempt to answer the question: What is real? You might think that reality just consists.
KNOWLEDGE OF THE EXTERNAL WORLD THEORIES OF PERCEPTION.
A tree falls in a forest but there is no one to hear it, does it make a sound?
The secondary quality argument for indirect realism R1.When I look at a rose, I see something that is red. R2.The red thing cannot be the rose itself (since.
Need worksheet from yellow folder – arg from perceptual variation.
What Science is Not. 1. It is not a process that seeks the truth. (The goal of science is to come as close as we can to understanding the cause and realities.
Building Blocks of Scientific Research Chapter 5 References:  Business Research (Duane Davis)  Business Research Methods (Cooper/Schindler) Resource.
BC The Republic is one of Plato’s longer works (more than 450 pages in length). It is written in dialogue form (as are most of Plato’s books),
Paradigms. Paradigm Defined A paradigm is a set or pattern of ideas, beliefs and values used by individuals and societies as a means of making sense of.
René Descartes Brandon Lee Block D.
An Outline of Descartes's Meditations on First Philosophy
1. I exist, because I think. 2. I am a thinking thing 3
Direct Realism Criticisms
Knowledge of the external world Realism (continued)
David Hume and Causation
Michael Lacewing Mackie’s error theory Michael Lacewing © Michael Lacewing.
Issues in bioethics Is there “objective truth” in ethics? By
Issues in bioethics Is there “objective truth” in ethics? By
Question 1: INSTRUCTIONS Each person will answer the questions. If you get it right, you get the points. If you get it wrong, you get a strike.
Recap So Far: Direct Realism
Recap – Direct Realism - Issues
Do we directly perceive objects? (25 marks)
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 7 Berkeley
Descartes -- Meditations Three
Philosophy Sept 28th Objective Opener 10 minutes
THE NATURE OF SCIENCE.
Introduction to Philosophy Lecture 12 Moral Realism and Relativism
The Nature of Science.
Presentation transcript:

Phillip K. Dick: A real thing is one which, when you stop believing in it, doesn’t go away.

SOME REFERENCES ON REALISM ACHINSTEIN (2010) EVIDENCE, EXPLANATION & REALISM ALSTON (1996) A REALIST CONCEPTION OF TRUTH DEVITT (1991) REALISM AND TRUTH HARRÉ (1986) VARIETIES OF REALISM HERSH (1997) WHAT IS MATHEMATICS, REALLY? HILDEBRAND (2003) BEYOND REALISM & ANTIREALISM KITCHER (1993) THE ADVANCEMENT OF SCIENCE LAUDAN (1990) SCIENCE AND RELATIVISM MUNITZ (1990) THE QUESTION OF REALITY NIINILUOTO (2004) CRITICAL SCIENTIFIC REALISM PSILLOS (2007) SCIENTIFIC REALISM PUTMAN (1987) THE MANY FACES OF REALISM SEARLE (1995) THE CONSTRUCTION OF SOCIAL REALITY WESTERHOFF (2011) REALITY

SCIENTIFIC REALISM (1)ASSERTS THE EXISTENCE OF PHYSICAL ENTITIES (e.g., planets, pigeons, frogs, ferns, magnetism, mammoths, germs, gravity) INDEPENDENT OF OUR HUMAN PERCEPTIONS, HISTORIES, INTERESTS, AND CONCERNS. FOUNDED ON (BUT NOT EXCLUSIVE TO!) A “COMMON SENSE” REALISM. (e.g., Seattle and sea hawks are not mere figments of our imagination—i.e., THERE ARE FACTS OF THE MATTER). (2) NATURAL SCIENCE CAN TELL US SOMETHING ABOUT THE ENTITIES AND PATTERNS OF THE WORLD IN (1) THAT AT LEAST APPROXIMATELY REFLECTS WHAT IS THE CASE AS EVINCED, FOR EXAMPLE, BY THE EXTRAORDINARY SUCCESSES OF SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING—THE “MIRACLE” ARGUMENT. THERE ARE DISCOVERIES. THIS DOES NOT MEAN THERE HAVE BEEN NO FAILURES OR REFORMULATIONS, OR THAT SCIENCE SEEKS “ABSOLUTE TRUTH”—WHATEVER THAT MEANS. MANY, MANY MYSTERIES WILL ALWAYS PREVAIL, BUT THAT’S WHAT SCIENCE IS ABOUT: TO EXPLORE THE MYSTERIES OF NATURE.

OED: ILLUSION (1)The fact or condition of being deceived or deluded by appearances, or an instance of this; a mental state involving the attribution of reality to what is unreal; a false conception or idea; a deception, delusion, fancy. (2) Something that deceives or deludes by producing a false impression; a deceptive or illusive appearance, statement, belief, etc. An unreal visual appearance, an apparition, phantom. (3) Sensuous perception of an external object, involving a false belief or conception: strictly distinguished from hallucination, but in general use often made to include it, and hence = the apparent perception of an external object when no such object is present, or of attributes of an object which do not exist. (4) The argument from illusion (Philosophy): the argument that the objects of sense experience, usually called ideas, appearances, or sense-data, cannot be objects in a physical world independent of the perceiver, since they vary according to his condition and environment.

SCHRÖDINGER WALTER MOORE (1990). SCHRÖDINGER LIFE AND THOUGHT “… it contains much of physics and, in principle, all of chemistry.” PaulDirac