Performing a Fiduciary Review of Trust Administration FIRMA April 2009 Independent Fiduciary Services ® Independent Fiduciary Services, Inc.  805 15 th.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Dimension 1.1: State goals and objectives (objectives) Leadership Behavior: Deliberative Standard The Standards Director prepares, monitors, and maintains.
Advertisements

Organizational Governance
CHAPTER 2 Client-Adviser Relationship. Introduction A vast amount of information is available to clients, but an adviser’s judgement is needed. Building.
Internal Control.
Discretionary vs. Directed Investment Risk By: Melody Bohlmann IM&T Investment Risk Manager IM&T Investment Risk Manager Wells Fargo Wealth Management.
IS Audit Function Knowledge
From an Operational View Point and as part of the Investment Process and Fiduciary Responsibilities of Trustees Fran Asp Asp Management Consulting
For broker/dealer use only. Not for use with the public Client Experience, Investment Management Process, Wealth Management Services graphics.
Customized Service Models for 3(16) Fiduciaries
Purpose of the Standards
Starting A Foundation: Guidance for Advisors Hilary Pearson President & CEO Philanthropic Foundations Canada October 2008.
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT FUNDS AND ERISA Marcia S. Wagner, Esq.
Auditing Standards IFTA\IRP Audit Guidance Government Auditing Standards (GAO) Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS) International Standards on.
Welcome to the Board! (and did we mention your Fiduciary Responsibility?)
Brought to you by the Nationwide ® Advanced Consulting Group Best Practices When Working With Your 401(k) Clients.
Accounting as a Form of Communication
DAA and GEP Orlando Audit & Compliance or Audit vs. Compliance.
NEW SEC AUDITOR INDEPENDENCE REQUIREMENTS Financial Executives International Janet Luallen Director - Technical Activities.
1 Non-Profit Fiscal Governance Shawn Gillon, CPA.
FIRMA National Risk Management Training Conference A New Look at Conflicts of Interest By Regina D. Stover Senior Vice President Pittsburgh, PA April 10,
Investment Adviser Workshop: the New Form ADV Part 2, New Rules, and the IA Switch.
All information contained within this document is proprietary to Risk Limited Corporation. prepared by Commercial Real Estate Hedging & Risk Management.
Regulatory Roundup: 2014 Examination Priorities Presented by: Erika Subieta, J.D extension 216 National Compliance.
Marcia S. Wagner, Esq. PARTICIPANT ADVICE & THE BROKERAGE WINDOW.
Other Financial Polices: Outside Investment Managers Allison Peck Lankford, J.D. VP/General Counsel, Blue Grass Community Foundation
Fiduciary Responsibility Frye Financial Center Creating, Protecting and Preserving Wealth
Fee Disclosure Requirements Not FDIC insured. May lose value. No bank guarantee. FOR PLAN SPONSORS How they affect you and your participants.
Marcia S. Wagner, Esq. The Do’s, Don’ts and Best Practices for 3(16), 3(21) and 3(38) Fiduciaries.
670600© 2012 Murphy, Hesse, Toomey & Lehane, LLP. All Rights Reserved. 1 Understanding Your Fiduciary Duty: Selecting and Monitoring Vendors Presented.
Chapter 07 Internal Control McGraw-Hill/IrwinCopyright © 2014 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Joint Forum of Financial Market Regulators Guidelines for Capital Accumulation Plans November 2004 The Impact DC Plan Sponsors G3-PD Colin Ripsman Toronto.
Considering Internal Control
Internal Control in a Financial Statement Audit
F IDUCIARY R ESPONSIBILITIES R. S COTT G ARDNER, CIMA S ENIOR I NVESTMENT A DVISOR P ACIFIC P ORTFOLIO C ONSULTING, LLC.
Introduction to Auditing. Introduction The role of audits is critical in the business environment of the early twenty-first century. Important decisions.
Maximizing Captive Value Through Teamwork. Speakers: Irena Kaler, Executive Director/CAO, RWJ Health Network Insurance Services Ken Rand, Managing Director,
Issues in Corporate Governance: Board Structures and Functions Based on a Student Presentation by Joshua Shullaw and Matthew Domeyer.
Implementing a Medicare Compliance Program. Implementation of Medicare Compliance Program Rules & procedures to reduce chance of wrongdoing High level.
Oversight of the ERISA Fiduciary April 9, 2008 J. David Thompson Bank of New York Mellon Corporation.
Evaluation of Internal Control System. Learning Objective 1 Contrast management’s need for internal control with the auditor’s need to consider internal.
ESOPs: It’s More Than a Matter of Trust Presented by: Dan Reser President; Fiduciary Services, Inc
Balance Between Audit/Compliance and Risk Management- Best Practices FIRMA 21 st National Training Conference Julia Fredricks, U.S. Chief Compliance Officer.
Regulation R Overview FIRMA Orlando, FL April 6-10, 2008 Sally Miller
Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Investment Management “Hot” Topics What would I expect to find in the way of Best Practices?
Developing an Investment Governance Framework
Thinking Outside the Box: Is It Dangerous for You and Your Plan? Discussion Leader: Marcia S. Wagner The Wagner Law Group Defined Contribution Summit November.
Financial Management & Internal Control for Utility Companies Julia Barber, CPA and Sherman, Barber & Mullikin, CPAs Madison, IN
©2012 Prentice Hall Business Publishing, Auditing 14/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Section 404 Audits of Internal Control and Control Risk Chapter.
CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE Portfolio Management CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE Portfolio Management Cleary / Jones Investments: Analysis and Management.
HAYNES BARKER INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, LLC Portfolio Management & Analysis, Financial Planning, & Wealth Transfer Strategies 233 D Oil Well Road Jackson,
Presenter Name Title MFS Investment Management ® Age-Based Milestones ©2010 MFS Investment Management ®. MFS ® investment products are offered.
ICAJ/PAB - Improving Compliance with International Standards on Auditing Planning an audit of financial statements 19 July 2014.
Investment Policy Setting for Nonprofits SCANPO KNOWLEDGE NETWORK WEBINAR APRIL 20, 2016 PRESENTED BY MARIO NARDONE, CFA, PRESIDENT – EAST BAY FINANCIAL.
F8: Audit and Assurance. 2 Audit and Assurance Designed to give you knowledge and application of: Section A: Audit Framework and Regulation Section B:
©©2012 Pearson Education, Auditing 14/e, Arens/Elder/Beasley Considering Internal Control Chapter 10.
Copyright © 2014 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall. Chapter
Shared Services and Third Party Assurance: Panel May 19, 2016.
Case Study: Examination of an Investment Adviser to a Hedge Fund Dalia Osman Blass, Division of Investment Management Pete Driscoll, Office of Compliance.
COPYRIGHT © FIDUCIARY YOUR GUIDE TO GLOBAL FIDUCIARY INSIGHTS Prudent Practices for Investment Fiduciaries.
Chapter 6 Internal Control in a Financial Statement Audit McGraw-Hill/IrwinCopyright © 2012 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Harvard Club ● July 18, 2016 ● © IA Watch 2016 ● 1 Beyond the BICE  Marcia Wagner, The Wagner Law Group, Boston  Jamie Fleckner, Partner, Goodwin.
The New Fiduciary Rules
WAMIC, District 7 & 8 Conference March 30, 2017
Independent Guide, Trusted Partner
Understanding 401k Fees, revenue and revenue sharing arrangements
Board of Directors Roles and Responsibilities
EVERY BROKER DEALER SHOULD KNOW
Internal Audit’s Role in Preventing Fraud and Corruption
Governance Issues Learning Objectives
Presentation transcript:

Performing a Fiduciary Review of Trust Administration FIRMA April 2009 Independent Fiduciary Services ® Independent Fiduciary Services, Inc.  th Street, NW  Suite 1120  Washington, DC   744 Broad Street  Suite 1120  Newark, NJ 

2 Theory Behind the Review  Trustee(s) are responsible for the prudent management of the Trust  Trustee(s) typically have the power to delegate their fiduciary authority  Trust functions that are frequently delegated include:  Trust administration  Investment management  Custody

3 Theory Behind the Review If Trustees delegate their authority :  They must delegate in a prudent manner  Are there documented processes and procedures in place that demonstrate a prudent process?  They must monitor the functions that have been delegated  Direct monitoring by Trust  Use of external firm for on-going monitoring  Periodic, comprehensive review of delegated functions by qualified, independent and experienced firm

4 Characteristics to Look For in a Fiduciary Auditor  Experience  Primary business is investment consulting  Serve a diverse client base  Independence  No brokerage or investment management affiliates  No revenues of any kind from investment managers or broker/dealers  No conflicts of interest  Dual expertise – as fiduciary and consultant

5 Areas for Review – Legal Framework  Review Structure of the Trust  Governance & Organizational Framework ( corporate trustee, individual trustee, multiple trustees; board of trustees, committees )  Decision-making Process (How are decisions made?)  Roles & Responsibilities (Defined? Documented?)  Delegations (What functions have been delegated? To whom?)  Relevant Laws & Regulations: Constraints?  Federal & State Laws and Regulations  Uniform Prudent Investor Act

6 Areas for Review – Governance Framework  Review Governing Document(s) that control the management and operations of the Trust  The Trust Document (or comparable governing document) - Key areas of review include:  Trust Purposes, Goals & Objectives  Trustee and Committee Powers, Duties & Limitations  Fiduciary Standards  Administrative Procedures; Financial & Tax Requirements  Compensation & Fees  Conflicts of Interest  Communication with Beneficiaries

7 Areas for Review – Governance Framework  Review Governing Document(s) that control the management and operation of the Trust  Trustee Delegation(s)  Scope of Delegation(s)  Restrictions? Limitations?  Adherence to Fiduciary Standards  What standard applies to trustee(s)?  What standard applies to service providers?  Oversight and Monitoring  Is there a monitoring function?

8 Areas for Review – Contractual Arrangements  Review contractual arrangements between the Trust and its advisors, which may include:  A Trust Administrator  Investment Consultants & Investment Managers  A Trustee Bank  Tax Advisor(s)  Legal Counsel  Key areas of review include:  Scope of Work  Fiduciary Standards  Fees  Conflicts of Interest

9 Areas for Review - Investment Policy, Asset Allocation and Structure  Review Investment Policy Statement and supporting documents for clarity and completeness, including:  Asset Class and Manager Guidelines  Tax planning  Cash flow guidelines  Review the asset allocation and the process through which the asset mix is determined  Review current investment manager structure  Is it consistent with investment policy and objectives?  What types of investment products are utilized, e.g., commingled funds and/or separately managed accounts?  Are portfolios are managed by Trustee Bank or outside entities?  Evaluate how tax objectives and other constraints factor into specific investment decisions

10 Areas for Review - Investment Performance, Reporting and Benchmarking  Review current investment performance reports to determine whether they are clear and contain the necessary exhibits  Evaluate the appropriateness of performance evaluation measures, and utilized and recommend changes in benchmarks as necessary  If a Trustee Bank manages a portion of the Trust assets, explore whether potential conflicts exist between the Bank’s investment management practices and its investment reporting and evaluation responsibilities  Review how conflicts are “managed”

11 Areas for Review – Manager Due Diligence  Review process through which potential new or replacement investment managers are identified, evaluated and selected  Review the process and materials through which investment manager recommendations are presented to the Trust and how decisions are made  Understand and evaluate how outside investment managers are evaluated on an ongoing basis  Understand the process through which outside investment manager activity is incorporated into and reflective of the Trust’s overall tax planning and implementation strategy

12 Areas for Review – Costs, Brokerage and Trading and Custody  Review the fee schedules for outside investment managers and investment vehicles and whether those fees are within commercially reasonable ranges.  Evaluate the process by which calculation and payment of fees are controlled.  Evaluate the process through which Trustee Bank assures best execution in its own trades and monitors best execution in the trades of its outside managers, where applicable.

13 Areas for Review – Costs, Brokerage and Trading and Custody  Evaluate the process and controls over use and reporting of soft dollars and similar brokerage credits relative to the obtaining and use of “research” for the benefit of the Trust.  Evaluate the basis, commercial reasonableness, computation, and controls over Trustee Bank’s compensation for its various roles, identify any possible conflicts or lapses of control, and recommend corrective measures.  Evaluate Trustee Bank ’s process and controls over reclamation of taxes withheld on foreign investment income, voting of proxies, making and effectuating decisions on corporate actions, and deciding and acting on securities class action and other claims.

14 Fee Structure for Review  The fee structure should help to ensure that the fiduciary auditor’s advice is independent and objective; totally free of conflicts of interest  Flat fee  NO other compensation of any sort from the engagement, such as fees or commissions from investment managers, broker dealers, commission recapture programs