Trutz Haase RESOURCE ALLOCATION MODEL FOR LOCAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANIES 7 th February 2013 LCDP National Event, F2 Rialto, Dublin v04.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Place and Economic Activity: Key issues from the area effects debate Nick Buck ISER, University of Essex.
Advertisements

Are Area-Based Deprivation Indices A Nonsense? Dennis Pringle Dept. of Geography, NUI Maynooth; National Institute For Regional And Spatial Analysis; and.
Trutz Haase & Jonathan Pratschke THE 2011 POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX FOR SMALL AREAS (SA) Conceptual Underpinnings Dublin, August 2012.
The 2011 Pobal HP Deprivation Index for Small Areas (SA) Statistical Features Dublin, August 2012.
Trutz Haase & Jonathan Pratschke THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX An Inter-temporal and Multi-jurisdictional Analysis Stormont, 13 th November 2013.
Background Neighbourhood characteristics such as socio-economic status (SES) have been shown to correlate with poorer health outcomes, mortality rates,
Trutz Haase THE IRISH DEPRIVATION MEASURES Applications and Outlook Revision, June 2012.
Cambridgeshire Health Trainers Bidding Event June 4th 2009 Holiday Inn, Impington Cambridge.
Local and Community Development Programme 2011 Goal 2 Output Analysis Aileen Gilchrist 4 th October 2012.
University of Oxford Centre for the Analysis of South African Social Policy What can Social Science Contribute to Neighbourhood renewal? Indices of Multiple.
Experimental Research Designs
Role and potential small and medium-sized urban areas Latvia’s case
Bruce D. Baker, AEFA 2009 Rearranging Deck Chairs in Dallas: Contextual Constraints and Within District Resource Re-allocation in Urban Texas School Districts.
Deprivation and its Spatial Articulation in the Republic of Ireland Methodological Considerations in the Construction of Area-based Indicators Trutz Haase.
Stephen Petterson Bob Phillips Options for HPSA and MUA/MUP designation.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds Understanding Population Trends and Processes.
Scottish Neighbourhood Statistics and the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) 2004 TRACEY STEAD OFFICE OF THE CHIEF STATISTICIAN SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE.
GRA 6020 Multivariate Statistics Factor Analysis Ulf H. Olsson Professor of Statistics.
HDI and its neglect in Pakistan
Accounting for Rural deprivation
OECD World Forum “Statistics, Knowledge and Policy”, Palermo, November Territorial Indicators for Regional Policies Vincenzo Spiezia Head,
Contributed by National Academy of Statistical Administration, India.
Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) 2009 East Ayrshire Andrew White Office of the Chief Statistician 16 th February.
Spatial Simulation for Education Policy Analysis in Ireland An Initial Exploration Gillian Golden University College Dublin
Measuring Development
Measuring population development from social cohesion perspective by women and men according to the Census data Urve Kask Statistics Estonia.
Abcdefghijkl Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation 2004 and Scottish Neighbourhood Statistics Robert Williams.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds understanding population trends and processes.
Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) 2009 ScotStat Public Body Analyst Network Andrew White and Matt Perkins Office of.
Recent developments in the UK Using the indices and the underpinning data Tom Oxford Consultants for Social Inclusion (OCSI) David McLennan.
Racial and Spatial Health Disparities in the Delta Arthur G. Cosby Professor & Director Social Science Research Center Mississippi State University Public.
Understanding climate impacts on vulnerable people Local Health and Wellbeing in a changing climate, Nottingham Friday 1 st March 2013 Sarah Lindley, University.
Trutz Haase Jonathan Pratschke ALL-ISLAND HP DEPRIVATION INDEX Conceptual Underpinnings ICLRD - Maynooth College - 26 th November 2014.
Crossing Methodological Borders to Develop and Implement an Approach for Determining the Value of Energy Efficiency R&D Programs Presented at the American.
Rural-Urban Interaction in NL: Understanding & Managing Functional Regions Functional Regions Element Update Funding support provided by the Canada- Newfoundland.
The East Ayrshire Experience Primary 1 to 3 Free School Meals Pilot Andrew Kennedy : Head of FM.
Key Competences and Education for Adults in Poland Together Towards Integration.
GENDER SPECIFICITY AND GENDER BUDGETING IN BULGARIA: SOCIO AND ECONOMIC ASPECTS GENDER SPECIFICITY AND GENDER BUDGETING IN BULGARIA: SOCIO AND ECONOMIC.
Indian and Northern Affaires indiennes Affairs Canada et du Nord Canada First Nation and Inuit Community Well-Being : Describing Historical Trends ( )
An overview of multi-criteria analysis techniques The main role of the techniques is to deal with the difficulties that human decision-makers have been.
MEAP / MME New Cut Scores Gill Elementary February 2012.
Standardization of Rates. Rates of Disease Are the basic measure of disease occurrence because they most clearly express probability or risk of disease.
United Nations Workshop on Revision 3 of Principles and Recommendations for Population and Housing Censuses and Evaluation of Census Data, Amman 19 – 23.
Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) 2009 Understanding Deprivation and Making the Most of Local and National Datasets.
Trutz Haase & Jonathan Pratschke THE 2011 POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX FOR SMALL AREAS (SA) An Inter-temporal Analysis Dublin, August 2012.
Trutz Haase & Jonathan Pratschke THE LONGITUDINAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX (ED) An Inter-temporal Analysis spanning Dublin, 2014.
Applied Quantitative Analysis and Practices
A UK Spatial Planning Framework Will French RTPI National Planning Forum 20 June 2006.
Constructing the Welfare Aggregate Part 2: Adjusting for Differences Across Individuals Salman Zaidi Washington DC, January 19th,
ChildONEurope Seminar Current EU Framework for addressing child poverty and well-being Julie Bélanger, Research Leader 26 November 2015.
Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) Matt Perkins Office of the Chief Statistician 11 th August 2009.
Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) 2009 Dumfries & Galloway Andrew White Office of the Chief Statistician 05 th February.
The micro-geography of UK demographic change Paul Norman School of Geography, University of Leeds understanding population trends and processes.
Developments in the estimation of the value of human capital for Australia Presented by Hui Wei Australian Bureau of Statistics Australian Bureau of Statistics.
Advances in Mixed Method Poverty Research: Lessons Learned in a Colombian Case Study EDNA BAUTISTA HERNÁNDEZ MARÍA FERNANDA TORRES 1st of July, 2013.
Towards A Development Index Framework to Measure and Manage Development.
Trutz Haase Jonathan Pratschke KNOWLEDGE 4 HEALTH Innovative Analytical Techniques in Health Research: A showcase of Structural Equation Models Knowledge.
Using Latent Variable Models in Survey Research Roger E. Millsap Arizona State University Contact: (480)
APPLICATIONS FOR STRATEGIC ASSESSMENT,
Taking Part 2008 Multivariate analysis December 2008
The 2016 Pobal HP Deprivation Index for Small Areas (SA) Conceptual Basis Dublin, August 2017.
An exploration of (area-based) social inclusion and community development training programmes in Ireland Seamus McGuinness Research Professor Pobal Conference:
The 2011 Pobal HP Deprivation Index for Small Areas (SA) An Inter-temporal Analysis Dublin, August 2012.
Knowledge 4 Health Innovative Analytical Techniques in Health Research: A showcase of Structural Equation Models Knowledge 4 Health Conference, 25th May.
International Labour Office
SSSTDI Autumn Meeting 25th Nov 2016
The 2016 Pobal HP Deprivation Index for Small Areas (SA) Conceptual Basis Dublin, August 2017.
The Pobal HP Deprivation Index An Inter-temporal Analysis
Profiling indices geographically: A platform for targeted action
The 2016 Pobal HP Deprivation Index for Small Areas (SA) Conceptual Basis Dublin, August 2017.
Presentation transcript:

Trutz Haase RESOURCE ALLOCATION MODEL FOR LOCAL DEVELOPMENT COMPANIES 7 th February 2013 LCDP National Event, F2 Rialto, Dublin v04

OVERVIEW 1.There are three factors which lie at the heart of a rational resource allocation for Local Development Companies: i.the relative size of the target population, ii.the relative affluence or deprivation of the respective areas, and iii.historical allocations 2.In Ireland, a robust measure for social disadvantage is provided by the Pobal HP Deprivation Index 3.Designing a Resource Allocation Model is not rocket science 4.Even a rudimentary Resource Allocation Model will facilitate a superior allocation of resources. It is based on objective criteria, results in a fairer distribution according to set criteria, is needs-focused and transparent in its application

WHY TO ADJUST FOR DEPRIVATION?  At least since the early 1990s it has been a widely shared understanding amongst policy makers that structural policies aimed at the individual alone do not suffice to overcome the disadvantage inherent in communities that comprise of a high level of concentration of people with exceptional needs.  The core of successive Local Development Programmes has been to provide additional resources to those communities which can objectively been identified to be amongst the most disadvantaged, and to assist them in breaking the spiral of decline.

THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - CONCEPTUAL UNDERPINNINGS  EFA is essentially an exploratory technique;.i.e. data-driven  all variables load on all factors  the structure matrix is the (accidental) outcome of the variables available  EFA cannot be used to compare outcomes over time  CFA requires a strong theoretical justification before the model is specified  the researcher decides which of the observed variables are to be associated with which of the latent constructs  variables are conceptualised as the imperfect manifestations of the latent concepts  CFA model allows the comparison of outcomes over time  CFA facilitates the objective evaluation of the quality of the model through fit statistics Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA)Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA)

 Demographic Decline (predominantly rural)  population loss and the social and demographic effects of emigration (age dependency, low education of adult population)  Social Class Deprivation (applying in rural and urban areas)  social class composition, education, housing quality  Labour Market Deprivation (predominantly urban)  unemployment, lone parents, low skills base THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - UNDERLYING DIMENSIONS

Age Dependency Rate  1 Population Change  2 Primary Education only  3 Third Level Education  4 Professional Classes  5 Persons per Room  6 Lone Parents  7 Semi- and Unskilled Classes  8 Male Unemployment Rate  9 Female Unemployment Rate  10 Demographic Growth Social Class Composition Labour Market Situation THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - MODEL SPECIFICATION For a detailed discussion on the fitting of a model using Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) see Haase & Pratschke, 2005, 2008

most disadvantaged most affluent marginally below the averagemarginally above the average disadvantagedaffluent very disadvantagedvery affluent extremely disadvantagedextremely affluent THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - MAPPING DEPRIVATION

THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - DUBLIN INNER CITY (ED LEVEL) Look at North Dock C and Mansion House A, which are defined as “marginally below average deprivation” in an ED-level deprivation analysis

THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - DUBLIN INNER CITY (SA LEVEL) The SA-level analysis shows the detail of the distribution of affluence and deprivation within North Dock C and Mansion House A.

 true multidimensionality, based on theoretical considerations  provides for a balanced approach between urban and rural deprivation  is sensitive to demographic groups with higher services needs  no double-counting  rational choice to indicator selection  uses variety of alternative fit indices to test model adequacy  identical structure matrix across multiple waves  identical measurement scale across multiple waves  true distances to means are maintained (i.e. measurement, not ranking) THE POBAL HP DEPRIVATION INDEX - SUMMARY

MODELLING POPULATION SHARES ACCORDING TO RELATIVE DEPRIVATION T – TOTAL POPULATION L – LOW (48.3%) M – MEDIUM (22.4%) H – HIGH ( 7.4%) T : >5 STD (Total Population) L: 0 STD 48.3% Population M: -1 STD 22.4% H: -2 STD 7.4%

THE RESOURCE ALLOCATION MODEL 2011 Census of Population 2011 Pobal HP Deprivation Index Reference Database for 18,488 Small Areas Total Population 100% Low Deprivation 48.2% Medium Deprivation 22.4% High Deprivation 7.4% 0% 100%0% Data aggregation to spatial area of interest (Local Development Company, Local Authority etc.) Administrative data on current allocations Combined Target Allocation Data Sources Reference Models Model Choices

The LDCs and LCDP …  represent the locus of “democratic experimentalism” (Charles Sabel, 1996)  embody society’s knowledge about (spatial) deprivation  demonstrate at local level how effective policies to ameliorate deprivation can be devised  act as advisors in the wider policy arena  aim at influencing resource distributions in the wider policy arena, such as to acknowledge the social gradient in health, education, housing and other outcomes The work of the LDCs and LCDP has to be exemplary in nature BACK TO THE ESSENCE OF THE LCDP

A Resource Allocation Model which …  takes into account both total population and relative deprivation  operationalizes the choices made with regards to stated objectives and criteria  allows for combination of alternative models according to varying SES gradients  can be applied to partial and total budgets or human resource allocations  allows resources to be scaled according to available budgets  allows for the stepwise implementation over multiple years SUMMARY