® © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc. FAA Special Activity Airspace (SAA) Dissemination OGC Pilot Nadine Alameh, OGC; Initiative Director Johannes Echterhoff, iGSI, OGC IPTeam; Initiative Architect

OGC ® OGC at a Glance (1) Founded in 1994, not for profit, consensus based and voluntary Over 416 member organizations (industry, government, academia) (January 2011) adopted OGC Standards (some are ISO Standards) Several hundred software products, implementing OGC Standards Broad user community worldwide, many policy positions for NSDI based on OGC standards Cooperation with other standards organizations and foundations, e.g. ISO, W3C, OMG, etc The Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC) is a non-profit, international voluntary consensus standards organization that is leading the development, promotion and harmonization of standards for geospatial and location based services. 2Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® OGC at a Glance (2) OGC Vision: to achieve the full societal, economic and scientific benefits of integrating location resources into commercial and institutional processes worldwide 3Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

Making Location Count... OGC’s Approach for Advancing Interoperability Interoperability Program (IP ) - a global, innovative, hands- on rapid prototyping and testing program designed to unite users and industry in accelerating interface development and validation, and the delivery of interoperability to the market Specification Development Program –Consensus standards process similar to other Industry consortia (World Wide Web Consortium, OMA etc.). Outreach and Community Adoption Program – education and training, encourage take up of OGC specifications, business development, communications programs Compliance Testing and Certification Program - allows organizations that implement an OGC standard to test their implementations with the mandatory elements of that standard 4 Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® OGC Interoperability Program Proven process to rapidly develop, test, validate and demonstrate new standards based on real world use cases identified by OGC members Effective way for members to quickly align industry to advance standards to meet priority needs Efficient and competitive process, regularly yielding a high-level of industry participation and cooperation Repeatable process – over 30 initiatives successfully conducted using proven policies and procedure 5Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Interoperability Experiment Plugfest OGC Network Pilot Specification Program Technology Maturation And Compliance Testbed Specifications Implementations Demonstrations Interoperability Program Development Testbed 6Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Interoperability Program Interoperability Initiatives Testbeds are fast-paced, multi-vendor collaborative efforts to define, design, develop, and test candidate interface and encoding specifications. These draft specifications are then reviewed, revised, and, potentially, approved in the OGC Specification Program. Pilot Projects apply and test OGC specifications in real world applications using standards based commercial off-the-shelf (SCOTS) products that implement OGC Specifications. Interoperability Experiments are brief, low-overhead, formally structured and approved initiatives led and executed by OGC members to achieve specific technical objectives that further the OGC Technical Baseline. Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium7

OGC ® OGC Aviation Testbeds Sponsored by –FAA (AIM, SWIM and NNEW) and EUROCONTROL Focus –Validation and advancement of AIXM and WXXM –Delivery of Aeronautical and Weather information on-demand via OGC Web Services –Increased uptake by industry for AIXM and WXXM –Delivery of Standards-based Commercial Off-The-Shelf (SCOTS) products Challenges –Dealing with the (complex) temporality of aeronautical information –Dealing with metadata/lineage of information –Handling Digital NOTAMS – Events – Event content/Event filtering –Standardized styling of information –Encoding and filtering of 4D/5D weather information (e.g. radar data, weather forecasts, etc) Outcomes –Changes to AIXM/WXXM –Changes to OGC/ISO standards –SCOTS products on the market 8Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® OGC Aviation Testbeds Aviation in OGC Web Services Testbed 6 OWS-6 – –Public Engineering Reports –Outcomes Aviation Clients Event Service Change Requests to AIXM and Web Services Aviation in OGC Web Services Testbed 7 OWS-7 – –Public Engineering Reports: –Outcomes Standards-compliant Commercial Off-The-Shelf products (SCOTS) Open source validator Portrayal More Change Requests 9Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Aviation in OGC Web Services Testbed 8 Kickoff Meeting –9-11 March 11 Final demonstration - Interoperability Day at OGC TC –22 September 2011 Final delivery (reports and videos) –30 September Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Interoperability Experiment Plugfest OGC Network Pilot Specification Program Technology Maturation And Compliance Specifications Implementations Demonstrations Testbed Interoperability Program Development Pilot 11Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Interoperability Program Interoperability Initiatives Testbeds are fast-paced, multi-vendor collaborative efforts to define, design, develop, and test candidate interface and encoding specifications. These draft specifications are then reviewed, revised, and, potentially, approved in the OGC Specification Program. Pilot Projects apply and test OGC specifications in real world applications using standards based commercial off-the-shelf (SCOTS) products that implement OGC Specifications. Pilot projects help users understand how to best implement interoperable geoprocessing that meets their requirements for application, spatial data and info sharing. Pilot projects help identify gaps for further worl. Interoperability Experiments are brief, low-overhead, formally structured and approved initiatives led and executed by OGC members to achieve specific technical objectives that further the OGC Technical Baseline. Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium12

OGC ® FAA SPECIAL ACTIVITY AIRSPACE (SAA) Information Dissemination OGC Pilot Extend the SAA SWIM Services to enable the dissemination of SAA information (including updates) to National Airspace System (NAS) stakeholders and other external users via OGC Web Services RFQ Issued –20 Sept 2010 RFQ Responses Due –18 October 2010 Kickoff Meeting –13-15 December 2010 Demo at AIM COI Meeting –June pm Demo at AIXM/WXXM Conf –Aug/Sep Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Team ParticipantsOrganization/Team Jim Perkins, Navin Vembar, Allen ProperFAA (sponsor organization) Glen Landry, Kevin LewFAA/CNA (sponsor representatives) Nadine AlamehOGC Mike Frey, Ken Gochenour, Dave OscaiBoeing/Jeppesen (US) Steve MillerConcept Solutions (US) Roger BrackinEnvitia (UK) David BurggrafGaldos (Canada) Johannes EchterhoffiGSI (Germany), OGC IP Team Thomas EverdingInstitute of Geoinformatics - U of Muenster (Germany) Jeroen DriesLuciad (Belgium) Christian Grothe, Daniel Bykowski, Barbara Glombiowska Lufthansa Systems FlightNav (Switzerland) Debbie Wilson, Daniel Hardwick, Ian PainterSnowflake (UK)

OGC ® Goals / Objectives Goals –Disseminate SAA information (including updates) to users via OGC Web Services –Promote the implementation of adapters to support external stakeholders Objectives –Provide access to SAA information (including updates) via OGC Web Services –Expose SAA information services to the NAS stakeholders with emphasis on airlines to automate flight dispatch and planning –Develop architecture that can accommodate future requirements Expose SAA information services to DoD systems to automate scheduling and information synchronization 15Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® SAA Pilot Requirements SAA Retrieval OGC WFS 2.0 AIXM SAA 5.1 static and dynamic info SAA Portrayal OGC FPS, WMS & SLD user-defined styles static and dynamic nature SAA Update Notifications OGC Event Service SAA activation updates DNOTAM compliant notification according to user subscription criteria 16Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® OGC Suite of Standards (1/2) OGC Catalogue Service - ebRIM profile (Registry/CSW) –for discovery of metadata, services and related information objects – OGC Web Feature Service (WFS) –for storage and management of geographic information – OGC Event Service (draft) –for publish/subscribe based access to streams of geographic information 17Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® OGC Suite of Standards (2/2) OGC Web Map Service (WMS) –for requesting map images of datasets from geospatial data stores – OGC Feature Portrayal Service (FPS) –for portrayal of geographic information retrieved from WFS(s) –based on: OGC Styled Layer Descriptor (SLD) Profile of WMS OGC Symbology Encoding (SE) – – 18Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Suite of Standards from Aviation Domain Aeronautical Information Exchange Model (AIXM) –to enable the management and distribution of Aeronautical Information Services (AIS) data in digital format – Digital NOTAM Event Specification (draft) –for harmonized encoding of information (in AIXM) currently published through NOTAM messages 19Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Architecture SAA Databases SAA Static Repository (NASR) SAA Operational Repository (SAMS) SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Build on Access Update External Clients NAS Stakeholders, Partners, Airlines, etc 20Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Architecture SAA Databases SAA Static Repository (NASR) SAA Operational Repository (SAMS) SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services External Clients NAS Stakeholders, Partners, Airlines, etc Subscriber File : SAA baseline data (Airspace geometry, Times of Use, Associated units, etc) AIXM 5.0 produced by NASR system published in advance of effective date, provided on 28 day cycle Subscriber File : SAA baseline data (Airspace geometry, Times of Use, Associated units, etc) AIXM 5.0 produced by NASR system published in advance of effective date, provided on 28 day cycle Schedule feed : SAA operational scheduling data (airspace identifier & type, activation status [pending, waiting to start, hot], start/end time, altitudes etc) produced from SAMS system data published on FAA web page, updated every minute Schedule feed : SAA operational scheduling data (airspace identifier & type, activation status [pending, waiting to start, hot], start/end time, altitudes etc) produced from SAMS system data published on FAA web page, updated every minute Schedule Feed Subscriber File 21Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Architecture SAA Databases SAA Static Repository (NASR) SAA Operational Repository (SAMS) SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Event Service WFS Registry/ CSW FPS/WMS Get SAA Info As Images Get SAA Info As AIXM Get SAA Updates As Events External Clients NAS Stakeholders, Partners, Airlines, etc Discover SAA Services And Information Schedule Feed Subscriber File 22Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Architecture Event Service Adapter SAA Databases SAA Static Repository (NASR) SAA Operational Repository (SAMS) SAA SWIM Services Schedule Feed Subscriber File Event Service FPS/WMS Registry/ CSW WFS GaldosEnvitia, LuciadLuciad, SnowflakeIfGI IfGI, Snowflake Lufthansa Systems LuciadEnvitia Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium 23

OGC ® COMPONENT DEMONSTRATIONS 24Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® What you will see Dissemination and usage of FAA SAA data via open, interoperable OGC Web Service interfaces Multiple OGC Web Service implementations providing interoperable access to SAA data in complementary ways Multiple client implementations using data retrieved from the same service, to achieve different goals Enhanced query capabilities supported by OGC Web Services 25Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Order of Demonstrations Web Feature Service Event Service Feature Portrayal Service / Catalog Service / FPS client Luciad client Lufthansa Systems client 26Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Web Feature Service Demonstration SAA Databases SR / NASR OR / SAMS SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Event Service WFS Registry/ CSW FPS/ WMS FPS/ WMS Clients Schedule Feed Subscriber File Relevant components: 27Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Web Feature Service Demonstration 28Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Web Feature Service Demonstration - Summary Standards based provisioning of static and dynamic SAA information Comprehensive querying capabilities supporting typical questions 29Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Event Service Demonstration Relevant components: SAA Databases SR / NASR OR / SAMS SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Event Service WFS Registry/ CSW FPS/ WMS FPS/ WMS Clients Schedule Feed Subscriber File 30Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Event Service Demonstration 31Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Event Service Demonstration - Summary Automated publication and delivery of dynamic SAA information to interested clients, based on sophisticated filter criteria 32Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Catalogue Service / Feature Portrayal Service & Client Demonstration SAA Databases SR / NASR OR / SAMS SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Event Service WFS Registry/ CSW FPS/ WMS FPS/ WMS Galdos/Envitia Client Schedule Feed Subscriber File Relevant components: 33Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Catalogue Service / Feature Portrayal Service & Client Demonstration 34Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium (Part 1 - Catalogue Demo)(Part 2 – FPS & FPS Client Demo)

OGC ® Catalogue Service / Feature Portrayal Service & Client Demonstration - Summary Registry: standards based, flexible discovery of resources, supporting diverse metadata models FPS / FPS client: standards based portrayal of SAA information in light-weight client 35Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Luciad Client Demonstration SAA Databases SR / NASR OR / SAMS SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Event Service WFS Registry/ CSW FPS/ WMS FPS/ WMS Luciad Client Schedule Feed Subscriber File Relevant components: 36Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Luciad Client Demonstration 37Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Luciad Client Demonstration - Summary Multi-purpose, standards based client - supporting SAA information retrieval, notification and portrayal 38Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Lufthansa Systems Client Demonstration SAA Databases SR / NASR OR / SAMS SAA SWIM Services OGC Web Services Event Service WFS Registry/ CSW FPS/ WMS FPS/ WMS Lufthansa Systems Client Schedule Feed Subscriber File Relevant components: 39Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Lufthansa Systems Client Demonstration 40Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Lufthansa Systems Client Demonstration - Summary Standards based integration of SAA information in COTS electronic charting product 41Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® CONCLUSION 42Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Accomplishments Another successful OGC Interoperability Program Initiative, despite having to work around scope and requirements changes due to SAA source data limitations –Cooperation and coordination among multi-national participants Academic institutions Aeronautical information technology companies Commercial GIS product development representatives –Consistent and responsive contributions and support from FAA participants and representatives –Special thanks to Johannes Echterhoff in leading this effort, in recognition of his organizational, management, and note-taking skills 43Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Accomplishments Implemented support for AIXM 5.1 in OGC standards based web service components Mapped AIXM 5.0 data into AIXM 5.1 Supported AIXM 5.1 temporality model Supported SAA AIXM schema extension Tested the draft Digital NOTAM Event Specification Implemented WFS and ES support for complex airspace geometries, aggregated airspaces, and improved filter capabilities in spatial queries Interfaced WFS and ES with available data sources via adapter components Implemented support for portrayal of AIXM 5.1 data (via WMS, FPS and Registry) Time-dependent map display styling Demonstrated the value of geospatial and temporal data fusion for the display and use of airspace activation data in realistic aviation scenarios 44Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Lessons Learned 45Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium Implemented AIXM / OGC standards are mature enough for industry adoption OGC, GML and AIXM standards clarifications Draft standards need to be finalized (e.g. Event Service) Using OGC Web Services for SAA data dissemination Integration of static and dynamic data (via WFS) enables value added functions such as airspace proximity notification Retrieving static and dynamic AIXM data from a single source (WFS), fine grained retrieval of AIXM feature timeslices needs work Support for snapshot timeslices is important for decision support scenarios Demonstrated usefulness of time dependent, greater than 2D portrayal of SAA information Challenges Having more stable requirements and established data standards would facilitate integration efforts, especially with short-duration initiatives Data quality does not yet meet requirements for productive use, SAA data has to be validated for consistency before being disseminated

OGC ® Value Added Aviation Industry –Demonstrated value of OGC open standards compliance in facilitating cost-effective multi-vendor tool integration –Standards-based approach makes interface implementation viable –Demonstrated support for both lightweight, browser-based client visualization including cross-section perspective, and thick client tools with more advanced data analysis and rendering –Implemented architecture can better address realistic flight data decision support requirements and at the same time potentially reduce the number of cases of non- compliance of airspace users –Offers enhanced pilot situational awareness for onboard systems –Provided insight to industry on what changes are required to take advantage of AIXM compliant data disseminated via OGC web services FAA –Created a single consolidated source of SAA data for dissemination using OGC- standard web services and AIXM message formats –Beta test of AIXM-format airspace definitions and AIXM 5.1 SAA extensions –Utility of consolidating separate VFR images into single VFR chart display 46Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® Future Directions Industry Standards –Further evolution and refinement of AIXM temporality model conventions and guidelines to enable more practical and efficient implementations –Automate SAA business rule constraint processing (using schematron) –Use of WFS 2.0 pre-defined queries to support SAA data analysis and notifications AIM Systems –Explore OSGi deployment of OGC service components using a common FUSE ESB –Refinements to AIM systems and service architectures in the context of consolidated static+dynamic AIXM feature representations –Extend architecture to support end-to-end management (including editing, adding and approval) of SAA information in the system –Test integration of SWIM-based SAA services with OGC service components –Performance benchmarking and assessment of comparative architecture scalabilities 47Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® The Future is Now 48Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® The Future is Now 49Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

OGC ® The Future is Now 50Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium

For More Information Open Geospatial Consortium, Inc SAA Pilot Demo page OGC Aviation Domain Working Group Copyright © 2011 Open Geospatial Consortium