Evaluating a rating scale for assessing trainee clinical psychologists’ clinical skills in-vivo. Dr. Alison Tweed* and Ms. Rebecca Graber Introduction.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Year Two Year Three Year One Research methods teaching in the social sciences: An integrated approach to inquiry- based learning.
Advertisements

Continuous Assessment of Practice West Midlands Mental Health in H. E. Educators Conference Steve Wilding. Clinical Educator. Bernie Kitchen – Practice.
Standardized Scales.
Introduction to Competency-Based Residency Education
Evaluating health informatics projects Reasons for and problems of evaluation Objective model Subjective model.
IMPLEMENTATION OF PMTO IN ICELAND EVIDENSEKONFERENCE – DENMARK 2012 Margrét Sigmarsdóttir.
Creating a Therapeutic Milieu in an Acute Psychiatric Setting
Review of Tomorrow’s Doctors Ben Griffith. The GMC’s role in medical education Promotes high standards Currently covers undergraduate education and the.
Towards a renewed student internship in Ghana’s polytechnics: Through collaborative curriculum design in design teams.
Personal and professional development in the early years of the medical curriculum.
Research Paper Critical Analysis Research Paper Critical Analysis 10 ways to look at a research paper systematically for critical analysis.
In the name of Allah. Development and psychometric Testing of a new Instrument to Measure Affecting Factors on Women’s Behaviors to Breast Cancer Prevention:
ACHE Competency Assessment Model
A qualitative study exploring the CBT experience of dementia patients and their carers Mary Opoku (2012)
Improving Communication in the Emergency Department: The 5 Cs Model of Consultation Educational Soundbites CORD Academic Assembly 2011 San Diego, CA Chad.
Dr Sally Boa and Dr Joan Murphy Professor Pam Enderby Funded by NHS Education Scotland Conducted by Talking Mats Limited © Talking Mats Ltd 2014.
Comparing Generic Student Learning Outcomes among Fresh Graduates in the Workplace Comparing Generic Student Learning Outcomes among Fresh Graduates in.
Teaching and assessment of clinical Hauora Māori in 4 th year medicine at the FMHS, Auckland Dr Sue Crengle 3rd December 2009.
Stuart Hollis Where are we now? An exploration of the provision of teacher training programmes for the Learning and Skills Sector following the 2007 Workforce.
DEVELOPING AND SHARING RESOURCES Embedding Learning Development to enhance student experience.
1 Article Number (4) Application of Objective Structured Clinical Examination in Community Health Nursing Course: Experience of Staff Members and Students.
2012 Regional Assessment Workshops Session 2 Dr. Maryellen Cosgrove, Dean School of Business, Education, Health and Wellness Gainesville State University.
Research methods in clinical psychology: An introduction for students and practitioners Chris Barker, Nancy Pistrang, and Robert Elliott CHAPTER 12 Analysis,
Short Course in Undergraduate Clinical Supervision: The effect on personal and professional growth in both supervisors and students San Schmutz, Elize.
Development and Validation of the Drexel University ACT/CBT Therapist Adherence Rating Scale: Phase II Kathleen B. McGrath, Evan M. Forman, Kimberly L.
Carers’ involvement and participation in the planning and implementation of staff training. (carers’ assessments) Presentation Denise Coy, Carers Lead.
Dr Renu Bindra Joint Strategic Needs Assessment. Policy background January 2006 “Strategic Needs Assessment” October 2006 “Joint Strategic Needs Assessment”
Introduction to Development Centres Sandra Schlebusch The Consultants.
Examination of Public Perceptions of Four Types of Child Sexual Abuse Prevention Programs Brandon Kopp Raymond Miltenberger.
LABORATORY PROCEDURES Routine Biochemical, Pathological, Microbiological and Radiological Investigations COMPUTERS Internet Navigation Basics of Computers.
The Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat Le Secrétariat de la littératie et de la numératie October – octobre 2007 The School Effectiveness Framework A Collegial.
RLV Reliability Analysis Guidelines Terry Hardy AST-300/Systems Engineering and Training Division October 26, 2004.
Measuring Non-technical Aspects of Surgical Clinician Development in an Otolaryngology Residency Training Program Jennifer J. Shin, M.D. S.M. Michael J.
Simulation in an undergraduate nursing programme: How do Students rate their learning? by Nancy McNamara MHSc (hons), BN, RCompN, CATE.
PaRROT Program Introduction. Learning objectives Understand and be aware of: History, objectives principles and expected outcomes of PaRROT Program content,
PERSONALITY DISORDER Managed Regional Clinical within a Development Clinical within a Development Network Programme Network Programme.
 Basics in Training Facilitation What do I need to know Vilanova, October 2015.
Scottish Improvement Science Collaborating Centre Strengthening the evidence base for improvement science: lessons learned Dr Nicola Gray, Senior Lecturer,
A Professional Development Series from the CDC’s Division of Population Health School Health Branch Professional Development 101: The Basics – Part 1.
PRACTICED BASED RESEARCH Overview 25 th November 2013.
Preceptors’ Experience of Using a Competency Assessment Tool Toni Ui Chiardha, Miriam McNicholas, Evelyn Byrne, Eimear Burke, Adrienne Montgomery, Marcella.
Revised Quality Assurance Arrangements for Registered Training Organisations Strengthening our commitment to quality - COAG February 2006 September 2006.
Outcomes – Gaye Powell. * “... a predicted measure of change that demonstrates a valid and significant therapeutic impact following an agreed intervention.”
Easing Transition into Working in the NHS: Piloting an Enhanced Shadowing Programme for Overseas Doctors J Metcalf #, H Woodun*, N Pierce #, J Golla #,
Introduction to Psychological Skills Training
Participants Observational data collected from participants who took part in the large scale randomised controlled evaluation of the Incredible Years Toddler.
DEVELOPING AND TESTING THE STANDARD OF PRACTICE AND EVALUATION OF CRITICAL-CARE-NURSING TOOL (SPECT) FOR GRADUATES OF CRITICAL CARE NURSE EDUCATION PROGRAMS.
Review of Observation Policy What triggered the review? 4 in-patients deaths where observation was a factor. Methodology Reviewed SUI reports and disciplinary.
EVALUATING EPP-CREATED ASSESSMENTS
An Alternative Certification Examination “ACE”, to assess the domains of professional practice.  Morris M1*, Gillis AE2, Smoothey CO3, Hennessy M1, Conlon.
Introduction Developed in collaboration with: Lead Advisor
PATIENT INVOLVEMENT IN MEDICAL EDUCATION
Nursing Journal Clubs Enhance Evidence-Based Practice
Factors facilitating academic success: a student perspective
Empathy in Medical Care Jessica Ogle (D
Data Managers’ Forum What’s in it for us?
Workforce Planning Framework
Father Muller Medical College & Hospital, Mangalore, Karnataka.
Assessing learners’ needs
An Evaluation of Practitioner Based Enquiry as a Method of Building Senior Management Team Capacity and Self-Efficacy Elizabeth Bolton, Richard Lockhart,
The impact of small-group EBP education programme: barriers and facilitators for EBP allied health champions to share learning with peers.
McREL TEACHER EVALUATION SYSTEM
Cuyamaca College Library
The Assessing Cycle Module 1 Assessment Assessment Accountability Data
Meta-analysis, systematic reviews and research syntheses
McREL TEACHER EVALUATION SYSTEM
Framework for Erasmus+ Staff Competencies Project DE01-KA
3.4 Follow-up – developing new studies, new questions
GP TUTOR DAY Research Workshop Dr Clare Morris, IHSE Head of Research
Presentation transcript:

Evaluating a rating scale for assessing trainee clinical psychologists’ clinical skills in-vivo. Dr. Alison Tweed* and Ms. Rebecca Graber Introduction and Objectives Developing clinical skills is seen as a core competency within clinical psychology training. Yet, there are no published, formalised or standard means of assessing trainees’ acquisition of clinical skill in- vivo, despite a call for this from the training community (Gallichan & Mitchell, 2008). This poster reports on reliability and validity evaluation research of the Clinical Skills Assessment Rating Form (CSA-RF), a seven- domain rating scale developed at the University of Leicester to assess trainees’ clinical skills in-vivo. Design and methodology The evaluation incorporated a mixed-methods design, undertaken in two phases: Phase 1 (Quantitative) used correlations and factor analysis to establish validity and reliability estimates and determine the factor structure of the scale. Phase 2 (Qualitative) investigated how the scale was used by paired raters as intended for Programme assessments. Tape-recorded rating sessions were analysed using Thematic Analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006). Results Phase 1 (Quantitative) Statistical analysis revealed acceptable levels of internal consistency (construct validity) of the scale. Chronbach’s alpha = Inter-rater reliability analysis is still ongoing. Factor analysis revealed 5 factors accounting for 50.7% of the variance: Demonstrating Professional Therapeutic Engagement, Creating a Secure Base, Formulation, Facilitating Mutual Understanding and Session Structure. Phase 2 (Qualitative) Thematic analysis is still underway. A preliminary model has been developed (see below). Core themes relate to the negotiation of raters’ expectations according to principles or guidelines of “good enough” performance. Negotiation between raters is undertaken within personal and inter-personal frameworks, using what happens on the video as a starting point for discussion. Discussion and Conclusions The CSA-RF appears to be a valid in-vivo measure of the generic clinical skills of trainee clinical psychologists. Whilst the research has been undertaken using simulated patients, it is expected that the findings can be generalised to genuine clinical populations. Findings from Phase 2 will inform the development of training materials for new raters. The study has gone some way to answering a need for a robust measure of clinical skill that can be applied to diverse therapeutic orientations. The CSA-RF has applicability for Clinical Psychology Programme staff on a national level who are interested in providing more formalised means of assessing trainees’ generic clinical skills. Participants Eighteen qualified clinical psychologists took part in Phase 1, each rating eight different 15-minute interactions of trainees undertaking a clinical session with a simulated patient on video. In Phase 2, ten clinical psychologists (five pairs) rated one 30-minute interaction, first individually and then jointly to reach a consensus. Expectations NEGOTIATION Outcome: Is the trainee good enough? Personal Inter-personal What happens References and Contact Information Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3 (2), Gallichan, D. & Mitchell, A. (2008). Making the case for in-vivo assessment s of clinical competence. Clinical Psychology Forum, 184, *University of Leicester, School of Psychology, Clinical Section, 104 Regent Road, Leicester, LE1 7LT.