Centralization Which treatment for whom when? LBP forum 2012 Tom Petersen, PT, PhD Back Center Copenhagen Denmark.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

The Power of Behavioural Change and the Role of Cognitions in symptom severity and disability: Research Questions What treatments are effective for symptoms.

Advertisements

Improving care for Treatment Resistant Depression Prednisolone Suppression Test predicts response to intensive treatment 7 Poor naturalistic prognosis.

A Comparison of Early Versus Late Initiation of Renal Replacement Therapy in Critically III Patients with Acute Kidney Injury: A Systematic Review and.

Evidence-Based Management of the Acute Lumbar Spine.

ANALYZING MORE GENERAL SITUATIONS UNIT 3. Unit Overview  In the first unit we explored tests of significance, confidence intervals, generalization, and.

Analysis & Expressing Resultd in Clinical Trials Dr. Khalili.

Mechanical Diagnosis & Therapy of the Spine:

The Cochrane Reviews of Acupuncture Doris Hubbs, MD, FACP April 26, 2013.

ODAC May 3, Subgroup Analyses in Clinical Trials Stephen L George, PhD Department of Biostatistics and Bioinformatics Duke University Medical Center.

Detecting an interaction between treatment and a continuous covariate: a comparison between two approaches Willi Sauerbrei Institut of Medical Biometry.

1 Moderators of Treatment Effects in the General Medicine Literature: Looking for Improvement Nicole Bloser, MHA, MPH University of California, Davis June.

Estimation and Reporting of Heterogeneity of Treatment Effects in Observational Comparative Effectiveness Research Prepared for: Agency for Healthcare.

G aps, challenges and opportunities Theo Verheij University Medical Center Utrecht Lower Respiratory Tract Infections in Primary Care.

Hepatitis web study Hepatitis web study Peginterferon alfa-2b + Ribavirin in GT 1-6 (Flat versus Weight-Based Ribavirin Dosing) WINR Study Phase 3 Treatment.

Asthma Leslie Boss (CDC) Carlos Camargo Denise Dougherty (AHRQ) Virginia Taggart (NHLBI) Sandra Wilson With Special Thanks to: Barbara DeVinney (NIH/OD)

Centre Cérébrovasculaire COMORBIDITY ANALYSIS AND 3 MONTHS FUNCTIONAL OUTCOME IN ACUTE ISCHEMIC STROKE: DATA FROM ACUTE STROKE REGISTRY AND ANALYSIS.

McKenzie Extension Exercises

Hepatitis web study Hepatitis web study WINR Study Flat versus Weight-Based Ribavirin Dosing Phase 3 Treatment Naïve, Chronic HCV Jacobson IM, et. al.

Treatment Based Classification of the Spine- An Evidence Based Journey for the Physical Therapist Tara J. Manal, PT, DPT, OCS, SCS Gregory E. Hicks, PT,

Are Your Employees Receiving The Most Effective Physical Therapy? Stephen Hunter PT, OCS Administrator, Intermountain Rehabilitation Agency.

Physiotherapy Research Society May 2012 Stephen May, Sheffield Hallam University.

A Randomized Trial Comparing Interventions in Patients with Lumber Posterior Derangement. Author: Schenk. Journal of Manual & Manipulative Therapy, Volume.

Dr. Birgitte M. Blatter Work related interventions improving return-to-work of workers with MSDs and some Dutch examples.

High Intensity Comparators: Active Psychotherapy Denise E. Wilfley, Andrea E. Kass, & Rachel P. Kolko Department of Psychiatry Washington University School.

Outcome after Total Knee Arthroplasty in the Patients with Psychologic Disorder Nam-Hong Choi, M.D. Young-Eun Park, M.D. Knee & Shoulder service Department.

Chronic Low Back Pain Gregory E. Hicks, PT, PhD University of Delaware.

Management of Chronic HCV Infection by PMDs Rod Rahimi Osler Journal Club

RESPONSE TO ANTIDEPRESSANT MEDICATION, COGNITIVE BEHAVIOR THERAPY AND PLACEBO IN CHRONIC TENSION-TYPE HEADACHE VARIES WITH PSYCHIATRIC COMORBIDITY & HEADACHE.

What would you recommend as first line therapy for a 68 y/o woman with advanced pancreatic cancer and limited metastatic disease with ECOG-1? Gemcitabine.

Care Planning: Better health begins here... April 2013.

Introduction to Pathophysiology. Definitions Pathophysiology-the physiology of abnormal states; specifically the functional changes that accompany a particular.

Ardiana Murtezani MD, PhD 1, 2, Nerimane Abazi MD 1,2, Zana Ibraimi PHARM PhD 2,Fatime Haxholli MD 1,2, Zana Agani DDS PhD 2,3, Elena Kamberi DDS 2.

A Quantitative Multi-Gene RT-PCR Assay for Prediction of Recurrence in Stage II Colon Cancer (CC): Selection of the Genes in 4 Large Studies and Results.

Illness perceptions? ‘The Patient’s (hi)story’. Behavior Explanation Interpretation, Representation Ideas, Beliefs, Cognitions about illness Importance.

Common Therapies for Back Pain:

1 Chiropractic visit observations among a group of patients who received chiropractic care for acute neck pain.

Clinical Writing for Interventional Cardiologists.

Published in Circulation 2003 Rory Hachamovitch, MD, MSc; Sean W. Hayes, MD; John D. Friedman, MD; Ishac Cohen PhD; Daniel S. Berman, MD Comparison of.

This study has been supported by Psychotherapy for traumatised refugees – a randomised clinical trial Jessica Carlsson, M.D., PhD Charlotte Sonne, M.D.,PhD-student.

Risk Stratified Analysis Improves Prediction of Treatment Benefit Over Subgroup Analysis: Findings from Intergroup N9741 HK Sanoff, ME Campbell, HC Pitot,

Bangalore S, et al. β-Blocker use and clinical outcomes in stable outpatients with and without coronary artery disease. JAMA. 2012;308(13): ?

Conceptual Addition of Adherence to a Markov Model In the adherence-naïve model, medication adherence and associated effectiveness assumed to be trial.

Of Chiropractic Clinical Research Palmer Center for Chiropractic Research.

Bivalirudin: Myths vs Reality? Dr Reman McDonagh Nycomed UK Ltd Conflict of Interest: Senior Manager working for Nycomed UK Ltd.

Corso di clinical writing. What to expect today? Core modules IntroductionIntroduction General principlesGeneral principles Specific techniquesSpecific.

The DVD Trial. Source Reinecke H, Fobker M, Wellmann J, et al. A randomized controlled trial comparing hydration therapy to additional hemodialysis or.

Critical Appraisal of a Paper Feedback. Critical Appraisal Full Reference –Authors (Surname & Abbreviations) –Year of publication –Full Title –Journal.

Meri Mirčeta, Ana-Maria Mitar Medicinski fakultet, Medicina Sveučilište u Splitu 3.ožujka.2016.

Methodological quality assessment of observational studies Nicole Vogelzangs Department of Psychiatry & EMGO + institute.

Metabolic Syndrome and Progression of Mild Cognitive Impairment

Summary Author: Dr. C. Tom Kouroukis, MD MSc FRCPC

for Overall Prognosis Workshop Cochrane Colloquium, Seoul

Telehealth and Research

CORAL Trial design: Patients with renal artery stenosis and hypertension or chronic kidney disease were randomized to renal artery stenting (n = 467) vs.

• the prevalence of pain related fear in patients with chronic

Current Evidence: STarT Back Screening Tool

What Predicts Disability Progression in Multiple Sclerosis?

Subsequent Healthcare Utilization Associated With Early Physical Therapy for New Episodes of Low Back Pain in Older Adults Deven Karvelas, MD University.

Modified Rankin score 0-2

Treating to Target in MS

Dragged-Fovea Diplopia Syndrome

JAMA Ophthalmology Journal Club Slides: Binocular iPad Game vs Part-time Patching in Children With Amblyopia Holmes JM, Manh VM, Lazar EL, et al; Pediatric.

Radiofrequency denervation for chronic low back pain

Exercise / Physical Activity as Medicine Special interest group

Serum Vitamin C (mg/dl) by Salad Intake

Branford S et al. Proc ASH 2013;Abstract 254.

MATRIX: Radial vs. Femoral

Multimodal Approaches to Cracking the Code in Low Back Pain

Translating Data From Trial to Practice

Yoga treatment for chronic non-specific low back pain

Presentation transcript:

Centralization Which treatment for whom when? LBP forum 2012 Tom Petersen, PT, PhD Back Center Copenhagen Denmark

Subgroups Is it possible to identify particular subgroups of patients with LBP that would benefit the most from specific types of exercises?

Wash out effect Foster et al. 2011

Subgroup designs overview Prognostic factors Single group design. Hypothesis generating. All pt.s is analyzed as if they received one treatment. Not possible to differentiate beween prognostic factors and effect modifiers. Treatment effect modifiers Two group designs. Hypothesis testing. Single subgroup RCT: Is treatment effective in pre-specified group? Two-group plus subgroup covariate RCT: Are outcomes for a subgroup receiving a particular treatment (compared to control) better than for patients not in subgroup that receive same treatment? Multi-arm subgroup system RCT: Are outcomes for a range of treatments better if those are matched to a specific subgroup, than if same treatments are randomly given to patients? Kent et al. 2010

Prognosis - Single group designs Directional preference Review based on one study: Not a useful prognostic predictor of functional disability in patients with mixed duration of symptoms treated with McK-method and manipulation. Centralization Review based on 23 studies: Useful predictor in acute, subacute, and chronic patients treated with McK- method, CBT, strengthening, light mobilisation, or manipulation. However, lack of prediction in three studies of predominantly subacute patients. May et al in press

Effect modification + Subgroup - Subgroup Treatment effect modification _ AB AB Prognostic effect Treatment effect Difference in treatment effect Kent et al. 2010

DP - Two group designs

Centralization - Two group designs

Conclusions – Effect modification Directional preference Conflicting evidence regarding short term effect of McK vs manipulation in patients with acute/subacute LBP. Low evidence for short term effect of McK vs strengthening exercises in patients with mixed duration of symptoms. Clinically important. Centralization Very low evidence for long term effect of McK vs manipulation in patients with acute LBP. Clinically important. Moderate evidence for long term effect of McK vs manipulation or strengthening exercises in patients with mixed duration or chronic LBP. Questionnable clinical importance in chronic LBP. Peripheralization a stronger effect modifier?