Patent linkage and the TPP Commercial considerations relevant to TPP 1 Geraldine Storton Hospira Pty Ltd.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Differential Pricing: Reconciling R&D, IP and Access Patricia M. Danzon PhD The Wharton School University of Pennsylvania.
Advertisements

Consultative expert working group - proposals Barcelona
Pricing Decisions and Cost Management
Patent settlements in the EU EGA perspective Ingrid Vandenborre 18 October 2013.
Saudi Arabia Business Optimism Index – Q Presented by Dun & Bradstreet National Commercial Bank.
Saudi Arabia Business Optimism Index – Q Presented by Dun & Bradstreet National Commercial Bank.
Qatar Business Optimism Survey Q Presented by Dun & Bradstreet South Asia Middle East Ltd. Qatar Financial Centre (QFC) Authority.
Access to medicines – Barriers relating to intellectual property rights and data exclusivity Julian Cockbain & Sigrid Sterckx Yale conference Human rights.
The Medical Innovation Prize Fund S.2210, 110 th U.S. Congress David Reynolds, DrPH Senior Health Policy Advisor Senator Bernie Sanders
APIs – global business developments Gian Mario Baccalini EFCG Board Member, Chairman of EFCG Pharma Business Committee President, B&P Development Srl,
Possible Impact of Market Exclusivity Extension on Pharmaceuticals in Thailand Chutima Akaleephan International Health Policy Program, Thailand 27 August.
An Overview of the Canadian Pharmaceutical Industry
Reimbursement & Pricing in Turkey
The Global Generic Medications Market
Preparing Your Business Plan
 Broad-based health care company that discovers, develops, manufactures, and markets products and services  Abbott's main businesses: ◦ Global pharmaceuticals.
SUCCESS FACTORS IN THE PHARMACEUTICAL MARKETPLACE
The Pharmaceutical Industry in Europe Key data INDUSTRY (EFPIA Total) (*) Production63,127121,311158,647170,000 (e) Exports23,18089,443144,022170,000.
Drug Pricing in Canada Victoria Brown, Anureet Sohi, Lisa Weger SPHA 511.
Pharma & Healthcare Logistics Development Roadmap for Luxembourg T h e r e i s s o m e t h i n g g o i n g o n i n L u x e m b o u r g ! T A S T r u s.
International Max Planck Research School for Competition and Innovation WIPO – Owais Hassan Shaikh IMPRS-CI 2010 Data Exclusivity in Free Trade.
Eli Lilly and company Matt Spahlinger ACG
A Typical Business Plan
Data protection and extension of patent rights TRIPS requirements & TRIPS-plus provisions Carlos Correa.
PATENTS AND HEALTH. A CASE STUDY OF THE UGANDAN CONTEXT. (PHA3 JULY 7 TH 2012 –CAPE TOWN, SOUTH AFRICA) MS. MARIAM AKIROR LLB (HONS) / DIP. SW / CPC. PROG.
Restrictions on exports of medicine: irrational public policy, backdoor efforts to marginalize compulsory licensing, or Northern protectionism? James Love.
International Max Planck Research School for Competition and Innovation WIPO – Owais Hassan Shaikh IMPRS-CI 2010 Data Exclusivity Provisions.
Opportunities in the Pharma Industry Industry sales: $346B Industry sales growth: 42% during the past five years Future growth: 8-10% growth per year;
1 Investing in Innovation Should the EU do more to match US investment in innovative medicines? Brian Ager EFPIA Gastein, 6 October 2004.
Data exclusivity, patents and registration of medicines Karin Timmermans TWN Regional Workshop Kuala Lumpur on bilateral trade agreements Aug
The competition between innovative and generic pharmaceutical companies intensified in the last decades. The models created by innovative pharmaceutical.
TRIPS plus FTAs Rohit Malpani Oxfam America. Public health consequences of TRIPS plus FTAs Prospective studies on FTAs with TRIPS plus provisions –US.
Barriers To International Trade
ABLE LABORATORIES, INC.. Safe Harbor Statement Except for historical facts, the statements in this presentation, as well as oral statements or other written.
Drug Prices in Canada and the US: More Than Meets the Eye? National Academy of Social Insurance Annual Conference Wayne Critchley Executive Director, PMPRB.
International Business Environment May 3, 2010 Evelyn Furia, Kristen Gunthardt, Ben Kelly, Erica Pilarski, and Amy Schatz.
Drug Delivery and Generic Medicine The Challenge ahead; Choose where to play. MENA as an Industry Model Mohammad Refaat Khattab Cairo University; Egypt.
MFJ International, LLC A Global Consulting Firm “FTAs and Pharmaceuticals: a hijacked process?” M. Fabiana Jorge CPTECH November 16, 2006.
Title text here Consumer Perspective on Containing Drug Costs Leigh Purvis, Director, Health Services Research.
Pricing and the Pharmaceutical Industry What’s Realistic? What’s Smart? What’s Right?
UNCTAD/CD-TFT 1 IP Provisions in Bilateral & Regional Trade Agreements and Public Health ICTSD/QUNO Dinner Discussion on IPRs in Bilateral & Regional Trade.
© 2008 Dechert LLP Pharma v. Pharma or Pharma & Pharma: The Legal Interface Between the Makers of Original and Copied Versions of Medicines AIPLA Antitrust,
An Alternative to Pharmaceutical Patents Christian Engström Vice Chairman, The Swedish Pirate Party.
Parallel Trade and the Pricing of Pharmaceutical Products Frank Müller-Langer Conference on „Health Economics and the Pharmaceutical Industry“
The essence of global pharmaceutical marketing. Definitions of marketing ‘Marketing is the management process that identifies, anticipates and satisfies.
Saudi Arabia Business Optimism Index – Q Presented by Dun & Bradstreet South Asia Middle East Ltd. (D&B) National Commercial Bank (NCB)
Strictly confidential How to achieve sustainability in rapidly changing environment? Pavle Marjanović, Country Manager for Actavis Republic of Serbia and.
© 2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin Marketing Management, 8e Chapter Eleven Pricing Strategy Key Words / Outline.
Medicines and Related Substances Amendment Bill 2008 Presented by: Abeda Williams 5 August 2008 Pharmaceutical Industry Association of South Africa.
‘Linkage’ & other TRIPS+ provisions: a public health perspective Karin Timmermans World Health Organization Seminar “Data exclusivity and patent Bangkok.
Issues related to poor IP protection in EMs: Pharmaceutical Example Rob May Commercial Director, Janssen, EMEA Emerging Markets.
Growth in prescription spending had slowed, but increased rapidly in 2014 and 2015 Average annual growth rate of prescription drug spending per capita.
India – The Pharma Advantage Dr. Brian W Tempest Chief Mentor & Executive Vice Chairman of the Board Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited, Delhi, India Tokyo –
Emerging Health Care Issues: The U.S. FTC Report on Follow-on Biologic Drug Competition Sue H. Kim Foreign Attorney Yoon & Yang LLC.
Triumph Pharmaceuticals – Supply Chain Strategy (Part B) University of Michigan - Tauber Institute 12/7/2015.
NAFTA, CAFTA and Access to Medicines and Food Security in Latin America International Aids Conference Session “Globalization and FTAs: their impact, access.
iHEA 9th World Congress Sydney, July 8, 2013
The Physicians Proposal for a National Pharmaceutical Program
Pricing Price is all around us..
Free Trade and Intellectual Property Rights: Implications for the Canadian Pharmaceutical Environment Joel Lexchin MD School of Health Policy & Management.
REIMAGING PHARMACEUTICAL INNOVATION.
Intellectual Property Protection and Access to Medicines
1 The roles of actuaries & general operating environment
FTAA and Access to Medicines
Pricing Decisions and Cost Management
© 2016 Global Market Insights, Inc. USA. All Rights Reserved Construction Equipment Rental Market to cross $ 75 bn by 2024.
An Increasing Demand for Prescription Drugs Drives Profitability
Prescription for Pharmaceutical Reform: Healing an Ailing System
Prescription drug prices: Recent trends and opportunities for change
Global Specialty Pharmaceuticals Market. Report Description and Highlights According to Renub Research report "Specialty Pharmaceuticals Market, by Country.
Presentation transcript:

Patent linkage and the TPP Commercial considerations relevant to TPP 1 Geraldine Storton Hospira Pty Ltd

© Hospira, Inc Overview Who is Hospira? What is patent linkage? Relative market sizes of TPP members Patent linkage hypothetical financial analysis Implications of patent linkage hypothetical for Hospira Discussion Conclusions 2

© Hospira, Inc Our company World's Leading Provider of Injectable Drugs and Infusion Technologies Market leadership positions in: –Generic injectable pharmaceuticals globally –Biosimilars in Europe and Australia –Medication management systems globally Distinguished 70-year history –Pioneer in innovation and safety –Publicly traded since 2004 –~$4 billion in annual revenues –Large, growing global markets –~15,000 employees, 13 manufacturing facilities –Headquartered in Lake Forest, Ill., USA Improving the safety, cost and productivity of patient care 3

© Hospira, Inc Patent linkage and the TPP – what is patent linkage? US FTAs - trend is to include “patent linkage” provisions requiring patent linkage Patent linkage makes regulatory approval dependant on the domestic patent position Patent linkage has been implemented in the US, CA and SG with the following features –Compulsory generic notification if intent to market pre patent expiry –Compulsory stay on regulatory approval if generic sued –Stay is a very effective motivation to sue (equates to compulsory litigation spend) –US only provides generic market exclusivity US New Trade Policy 2007 proposes no inclusion of patent linkage in FTAs Patent linkage in ex-US TPP countries will be detrimental to a generic manufacturer’s ability to bring affordable, high quality generics to market. 4

© Hospira, Inc Patent linkage works when the market size is large, and the pay-off from a single molecule is significant 5 Source: Business Monitor International, IMS Health Compared to other countries in the TPP group, the annual market value for pharmaceuticals in the US is significantly higher. *Note no data available for Brunei

© Hospira, Inc Patent linkage - toward a hypothetical model HSP developed a hypothetical model to determine the impact of patent linkage on generics industries in TPP members Goal – to determine the commercial return on “litigation” investment (if any) bearing in mind: Litigation costs Market value of a product at patent expiry Market share obtained Degree of price discounting Profit margin Probability of success in litigation Any “generic exclusivity” on offer 6

© Hospira, Inc Commercial implications of Patent Linkage Hypothetical – Results 7 The current GMiA estimated typical cost of litigation in Australia is $5M*. Using typical industry ranges for market size, development cost, market share, price erosion and margins a financial model was created. This model did not return a positive profit for the generic manufacturer unless the cost of litigation was low, or the exclusivity period was long. Green shading signifies a positive pay-off (i.e. The pay-off, including the cost of litigating, returns a profit for the generic manufacturer) A threshold value was determined to understand the market value of a drug required to provide a positive return at USD 5M litigation cost and 0.5 years Exclusivity. For the base case this was >USD 200M. Source: Mean litigation cost estimates provided by GMiA. IMS data for number of molecules selling over $200 M pa There are no injectable products* in Australia selling in excess of $200 M pa.

© Hospira, Inc Commercial implications of Patent Linkage Hypothetical – sensitivity analysis 8 For the base case USD 50M product, we varied the input parameters across plausible ranges to understand the sensitivity of the model. We found that with higher value inputs, a negative return is still expected at Current litigation costs and 6 months exclusivity (as the US has). *Source: Legal Fee estimates from GMiA. IMS data for number of molecules selling over $50 M pa There are only 13 injectable products* in Australia selling in excess of $50 M pa.

© Hospira, Inc Patent Linkage – Implications for Hospira Hospira conducted a hypothetical analysis of all of its actual launched products in ex-US TPP countries in the last 4 years. Under a patent linkage system with compulsory litigation and generic exclusivity, none of the products launched in the last 4 years would have had positive financial return associated them. 9

© Hospira, Inc Patent linkage will not work in any country other than the US Patent linkage works in the US only because of the size of the US market –The size of the prize is incomparable –The US is 50% of WW pharma market & totally eclipses ROW pharma markets Patent linkage will be very problematic for every other TPP member, including Australia –The relative size of the market is significantly smaller –Compulsory patent litigation is cost prohibitive –Generic market entry will be delayed or eliminated 10

© Hospira, Inc Patent linkage will not work in any country other than the US This generic entry delay (due to patent linkage) will cripple government spending on pharmaceuticals because it will: –Deny the public timely access to cost effective medicines –Inflate health care costs –Be detrimental to government’s ability to manage spending on pharmaceuticals 11

© Hospira, Inc Conclusion Patent linkage in ex-US TPP countries will be detrimental to a generic manufacturer’s ability to bring affordable, high quality generics to market. The effect of patent linkage will be inequality in health care: –patent linkage will not affect access to affordable medicines in the US, the US public will continue to have access to these medicines, whilst the people of other TPP members will not. 12

Thank you Geraldine Storton Hospira Pty Ltd 13