Bangalore, India,17-18 December 2012 Sustainable Broadband Communications: International Perspective – Common Criteria David Martin, Head of International Assurance, Common Criteria Scheme Director, CESG, UK, Joint ITU-GISFI Workshop on “Bridging the Standardization Gap: Workshop on Sustainable Rural Communications” (Bangalore, India, December 2012)

David Martin Involved in Information Assurance Standards for many years Chair of International Common Criteria Development Board Scheme Director for the UK Common Criteria Scheme (operated by UK government) Representing UK Scheme - reporting on new CC vision statement Bangalore, India,17-18 December

3 Common Criteria - Background Standards for Assurance of IT Product Security 26 Nations (more to come) 16 Nations evaluate/certify products Also an ISO standard (15408 and 18045) Run by a Management Committee (with an executive to support) and a Development Board

Bangalore, India,17-18 December Common Criteria – The Value Manufacturers do not have to evaluate products in multiple places. Evaluation is very expensive in time and money Good cyber defence (and sustainable telecom) needs many more products evaluated All nations agree and procure to the common standard Industry involvement (CCUF)

Bangalore, India,17-18 December Common Criteria – New Vision – Rationale -1 CC usage has been little changed for more than 12 years A number of nations found that:- The focus on ‘assurance level (EAL)’ was damaging product security Not enough products are evaluated - Cyber defence needs many more Expertise is applied in the wrong place, inconsistently, and without wide peer review.

Bangalore, India,17-18 December Common Criteria – New Vision – Rationale -2 Smartcard Community has developed a very effective way of using CC Work has taken place to support a similar approach for general IT products Resulting in the CCMC (management Committee) vision statement – published in September 2012

Bangalore, India,17-18 December For more information Common Criteria Portal: The vision statement links from the front page Other links show the products, schemes, operating documents etc. Also see CCUF at

Existing Approach Bangalore, India,17-18 December

New Approach Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Technical Communities Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Meeting virtually Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Much quicker and more effective Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Bespoke design/evaluation Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Better to have known standards Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Other Important developments Common view on cryptography Security Configuration Automation Strong Linkage to Vulnerability/Weakness reporting Supply Chain working group Consistent Government Procurement (and other major users) – addressing what ‘recognition’ really means Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Common support for procurement Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Bangalore, India,17-18 December Common Criteria – New Vision – Summary More assurance than a simple ‘EAL approach’ Uses worldwide expertise, instead of relying on single ‘expert’ Open, Transparent, Repeatable – as befitting an International Standard Step change in volume – better for cyberdefence Lowers procurement costs

Bangalore, India,17-18 December What does this mean for Sustainable Broadband Communications? More assurance (Ignore ‘EAL’ look at what is assured) More responsive Lower cost Wider range and choice of products Uses worldwide expertise, instead of relying on single ‘expert’ Open, Transparent, Repeatable – as befitting an International Standard

Bangalore, India,17-18 December Further detail First International Technical Community about to launch – based on USB storage device Many more to follow next year Already many TCs exist (mostly US based)

Example TC Areas Networking (NDPP, Firewalls, VPNs, etc) Storage (USB, Hard disks, etc) Applications on Operating systems Mobile telecoms (VOIP, SIP, MDM, etc) Multifunction devices (printers etc.) Bangalore, India,17-18 December

Bangalore, India,17-18 December Telecoms Applicability 3gPP discussion – potential development of cPPs Could extend to system approaches Key is to have the real technical expertise setting the standards CCRA maintains the fairness, the reliability/reputation, and the worldwide recognition for vendors

Conclusions and Recommendations Bangalore, India,17-18 December