Extreme Deviations Herds with large percentage of their cows on Elite List may have two management systems in their herds: High producers Low producers.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
ABSTRACT The objective of this research was to derive factors to predict daily milk yield when milk is sampled once per d for cows milked three times (3x)
Advertisements

Class 14 Testing Hypotheses about Means Paired samples 10.3 p
Measures of Dispersion
Overview Revising z-scores Revising z-scores Interpreting z-scores Interpreting z-scores Dangers of z-scores Dangers of z-scores Sample and populations.
Measures of Central Tendency. Central Tendency “Values that describe the middle, or central, characteristics of a set of data” Terms used to describe.
Review of Basics. REVIEW OF BASICS PART I Measurement Descriptive Statistics Frequency Distributions.
The Normal Curve Z Scores, T Scores, and Skewness.
Review of Basics. REVIEW OF BASICS PART I Measurement Descriptive Statistics Frequency Distributions.
BHS Methods in Behavioral Sciences I
October 26, 2001Threshold from Standard Deviation1 Rich Christie University of Washington Distribution Design Working Group Webex Meeting October 26, 2001.
As with averages, researchers need to transform data into a form conducive to interpretation, comparisons, and statistical analysis measures of dispersion.
SHOWTIME! STATISTICAL TOOLS IN EVALUATION DESCRIPTIVE VALUES MEASURES OF VARIABILITY.
Paul Cornwell March 31,  Let X 1,…,X n be independent, identically distributed random variables with positive variance. Averages of these variables.
Quiz 5 Normal Probability Distribution.
STATISTIC & INFORMATION THEORY (CSNB134) MODULE 2 NUMERICAL DATA REPRESENTATION.
Chapter 2 Describing Data with Numerical Measurements General Objectives: Graphs are extremely useful for the visual description of a data set. However,
Back to the basics, Part2 Data exploration: representing and testing data properties Spyros Veronikis Electrical and Electronics Engineer Dept. of Archives.
Chapter 3 – Descriptive Statistics
Ch2: Probability Theory Some basics Definition of Probability Characteristics of Probability Distributions Descriptive statistics.
Statistical Tools in Evaluation Part I. Statistical Tools in Evaluation What are statistics? –Organization and analysis of numerical data –Methods used.
Describing Behavior Chapter 4. Data Analysis Two basic types  Descriptive Summarizes and describes the nature and properties of the data  Inferential.
2002 ADSA 2002 (HDN-1) H.D. NORMAN* ( ), R.H. MILLER, P.M. V AN RADEN, and J.R. WRIGHT Animal Improvement Programs.
C. P. Van Tassell, G. R. Wiggans, and L. L. M. Thornton Animal Improvement Programs Laboratory Agricultural Research Service, USDA, Beltsville,
2003 G.R. Wiggans,* P.M. VanRaden, and J.L. Edwards Animal Improvement Programs Laboratory Agricultural Research Service, USDA, Beltsville, MD
REGRESSION MODEL y ijklm = BD i + b j A j + HYS k + b dstate D l + b sstate S l + b sd (S×SD m ) + b dherd F m + b sherd G m + e ijklm, y = ME milk yield,
DATA MANAGEMENT MBF3C Lesson #5: Measures of Spread.
Determination of Sample Size: A Review of Statistical Theory
Numeric Summaries and Descriptive Statistics. populations vs. samples we want to describe both samples and populations the latter is a matter of inference…
Synchronization Effects on Parameters for Days Open M. T. Kuhn, J. L. Hutchison, and R. H. Miller* Animal Improvement Programs Laboratory, Agricultural.
Part II  igma Freud & Descriptive Statistics Chapter 2 Means to an End: Computing and Understanding Averages.
S519: Evaluation of Information Systems
Section 15.1 Inference for Population Spread AP Statistics
Descriptive statistics in the case of quantitative data (scales) Part I.
 A Characteristic is a measurable description of an individual such as height, weight or a count meeting a certain requirement.  A Parameter is a numerical.
Idaho DHIA Field Supervisor Meeting Steven J. Sievert Technical Director, National DHIA Manager, Quality Certification Services Inc.
Introduction to Statistics Measures of Central Tendency and Dispersion.
Kin 304 Descriptive Statistics & the Normal Distribution
Statistical Fundamentals: Using Microsoft Excel for Univariate and Bivariate Analysis Alfred P. Rovai Univariate Normality PowerPoint Prepared by Alfred.
© 2008 McGraw-Hill Higher Education The Statistical Imagination Chapter 5. Measuring Dispersion or Spread in a Distribution of Scores.
Ashley H. Sanders and H. Duane Norman Animal Improvement Programs Laboratory Agricultural Research Service, USDA, Beltsville, MD
Unit 2 – Statistics Standard Deviation and Normal Distribution Mr. Solórzano – Algebra 2.
Statistical Fundamentals: Using Microsoft Excel for Univariate and Bivariate Analysis Alfred P. Rovai The Normal Curve and Univariate Normality PowerPoint.
Chapter 7: The Distribution of Sample Means
Chapter 6: Descriptive Statistics. Learning Objectives Describe statistical measures used in descriptive statistics Compute measures of central tendency.
LESSON 5 - STATISTICS & RESEARCH STATISTICS – USE OF MATH TO ORGANIZE, SUMMARIZE, AND INTERPRET DATA.
© 2006 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. 1 Chapter 10 Descriptive Statistics Numbers –One tool for collecting data about communication.
Lecture 3: Skewness and Kurtosis
BPK 304W Descriptive Statistics & the Normal Distribution
Kin 304 Descriptive Statistics & the Normal Distribution
Descriptive measures Capture the main 4 basic Ch.Ch. of the sample distribution: Central tendency Variability (variance) Skewness kurtosis.
Chapter 3 Descriptive Statistics: Numerical Measures Part A
Classifiers based on 3D-head acceleration data
Variation Coefficient
Frequency and Distribution
Quantitative Methods PSY302 Quiz Normal Curve Review February 7, 2018
Being Descriptive Without Being Mean
Measures of Variability
آشنايی با اصول و پايه های يک آزمايش
Measures of Central Tendency
FOUR MOMENTS: Ways to Describe a (Univariate I/R) Distribution
BPK 304W Descriptive Statistics & the Normal Distribution
Numerical Descriptive Measures
Chapter 3 Statistical Concepts.
Univariate Statistics
Correlations Among Measures of Dairy Cattle Fertility and Longevity
Simulate Multiple Dice
FOUR MOMENTS: Ways to Describe a (Univariate I/R) Distribution
Effectiveness of genetic evaluations in predicting daughter performance in individual herds H. D. Norman 1, J. R. Wright 1*, C. D. Dechow 2 and R. C.
Measures of Dispersion
DRQ #10 AGEC pts October 17, 2013 (1 pt) 1. Calculate the median of the following sample of observations for a variable labeled.
Presentation transcript:

Extreme Deviations Herds with large percentage of their cows on Elite List may have two management systems in their herds: High producers Low producers Can cause inflated evaluations when high & low producers are in the same management group

Herds with Elite Cows ~300 herds with 5+ cows on elite list Do their descriptive and normality statistics provide any useful characteristics to identify potentially “bimodal” herds? Does their 1 st lactation ME milk deviation distribution look “visually suspicious”?

Look suspicious to you?

Data 12 most “important” dairy states Calculate each cow’s 1 st lactation ME milk deviation from herd annual mean ME milk herds N  10 (per year) Descriptive statistics, Normality test statistics Sub data sets of herds with 5+ cows on elite list

Statistics (1) Descriptive statistics: Skewness (SKEW) Kurtosis (KUR) Standard error of the mean (STDMEAN) Standard deviation /  Sum of weights

Statistics (2) Normality statistics: Normal vs. non-normal Kolmogorov statistic (KS) Problems with normality tests: Very sensitive to herd size (i.e. >30% of CA herds are “not normally” distributed compared to < 3% in PA, WI, MN) Should not be used as only criteria

Preliminary Results Herds with +5 cows on elite list, “not normal”, “visually suspicious”, had higher SKEW and STDMEAN than herds that “looked okay” Herds with +5 cows on elite list, “not-normal”, had higher SKEW, KUR, and KS than herds designated “normal” All herds, “not-normal”, had higher SKEW and KUR than herds designated “normal”

Identifying Herds Use normality and descriptive statistics: KS  0.08 & (KUR  0.8 || SKEW  0.35) & STDMEAN  250 This threshold successfully identifies ALL of the “visually suspicious” herds and ~29% of all herds (5387 out of 18194) If threshold restricted to herds found not normally distributed first (880 out of 18194), it identifies only 235 herds

STDMEAN & KS vs. % on Elite List The higher STDMEAN or KS, the larger the % of cows on the Elite List

Adjusting Herd Data Based on the value of KS and STDMEAN, incrementally adjust heritability (as in heterogeneous variance adjustment) Result: records from herds with abnormal distributions receive less weight