Development Agreements – when are they exempt? Cyrus Mehta, Partner Nabarro LLP 58151864.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Irish Commercial Property – Recent Legal Developments SIMON HANNIGAN 20 th June 2013.
Advertisements

Introduction to leases 2: further issues 23 January 09 Outline lecture Nick Jackson.
1 ARE 306Unit 15 Tenancies. 2 Definitions l Lessee l Lessor l Rent.
Property Management Workshop REAL ESTATE SESSION Presented by Nisha Kumar, Attorney-Advisor, Office of the Assistant General Counsel for General Law, GC-77.
CFP Reform Implementation of the Landings Obligation: Context and Process.
National Smartcard Project Work Package 8 – Report on financial services legislation.
Conferinţa Naţională ALB Joi, 19 octombrie 2006 A new Sort of Public Private Partnership: Leasing Agreements with Public Institutions Matei Florea.
IMPORTANT DOCUMENTS AND MANAGING DEBT SERVICE Presented by: Timothy J. Reimers, Esq. QUATEMAN LLP February 3, 2011 Oakland, California CALIFORNIA DEBT.
CARBON CONTRACTS - the PCF experience September 30, 2002.
Financial Assistance Workshop Contract versus Grant.
Model Rules on EU Administrative Procedures Book IV – Contracts Presentation for the ReNEUAL Conference 2014 EU Administrative Procedures – European Ombudsman.
Community Gardens. Purpose To promote the local food initiative within the City of Berkeley’s Climate Action Plan. To adopt definition of community gardens.
Condominiums, Co-ops, and other Multiunit Interests.
CHAPTER IV Organization of business relations in trade.
National Smartcard Project Work Package 8 – Security Issues Report.
Regulatory Framework and Legal Issues Relating to Islamic Finance Presentation by Atiq S. Anjarwalla Anjarwalla & Khanna, Advocates ALN (Africa Legal Network)
1 The Current Situation Regarding PPPs and Concessions in the EU Olivier Moreau European Commission, DG MARKT.C1
Water and Wastewater Certification 1 Water & Wastewater Reference Manual.
Condominiums, Co-ops, and other Multiunit Interests.
Exploring the Luxembourg Rail Protocol Martin J Fleetwood – Partner Secretary, Rail Working Group.
1 Fair competition between the public and the private sector - Community law on public contracts and concessions Florian Ermacora European Commission,
Sustainable Procurement and Community Benefits Getting ready for Procurement Reform in Scotland Jennifer Marshall.
1 Acquisition, Relocation and Displacement For Local Officials.
©2008 Sutherland Three Things You Need to Know About the HIRE Act Carol Tello Robb Chase December 15, 2010.
PLA Working Group and Paper on Procurement and Land Development Agreements after Auroux v Roanne Duncan Osler, MacRoberts LLP.
© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU Martin Oder, LL.M. Legislative Options for Regulating Concessions.
Session “International standards for planning and conducting procurement process” Contracting entities and contracts covered – coverage issues according.
Maximising Investment Opportunities: releasing value from estates Barclays Private Equity 15 th May 2008.
Business Law and the Regulation of Business Chapter 19: Introduction to Sales and Leases By Richard A. Mann & Barry S. Roberts.
Contracts in Real Estate Transactions Chapter 6. Contracts in Real Estate Transactions Necessary Elements of a Contract –Offer and acceptance, Counteroffer.
E3M Seminar: New Opportunities for Partnership between Social Enterprises and Commissioning Authorities Co-production, including commissioning without.
National Smartcard Project Work Package 8 – Corporate Structures Report.
Deferred Receipt Mechanisms Long Lease Seminar Edinburgh 1 June 2010.
Finding a PPP Partner Essential EU Law Considerations Bernard Wilson Maribor, 18 January 2005 Bernard Wilson Maribor, 18 January 2005.
Bent Egebart - Receipts – Reduced contribution from the Commission? (3-parties in FP6 projects ?) Financial Guidelines for Indirect Actions.
EuropeAid Delegated Co-operation November EuropeAid 2 SUMMARY BACKGROUND TO CO-FINANCING AND DELEGATED COOPERATION INDIRECT CENTRALISED MANAGEMENT.
DR MAREK PORZYCKI JAGIELLONIAN UNIVERSITY Reorganisation and winding-up of credit institutions in the EU.
Foreign Trade (Regulation) Rules, 1993 Sec 1 Short title and commencement Sec 2 Definitions Sec 3 Grant of special licence  Where any IEC no is cancelled.
The statute of frauds required that, to be enforceable, the following six types of contracts had to be in writing: MY LEGS  Contracts in consideration.
Possible management strategies in light of Jean Auroux v Roanne Rebecca Rees Partner Trowers & Hamlins LLP 29 th September 2009.
PLA Seminar on Auroux Unintended Consequences of the Judgment – 29 September 2009 Jonathan Davey, Partner, Head of Commercial Group, Addleshaw Goddard.
Skyway Transaction Basic Considerations. Why Privatize The Skyway?
Procurement law and development agreements: case law update Cyrus Mehta, Partner Nabarro LLP.
Private and Public law lesson 6 The principles of the Italian constitutional order: the economic relationships.
© 2015 OnCourse Learning Texas Real Estate Brokerage and Law of Agency, 6 th Edition.
Networks ∙ Services ∙ People Marko Bonač GÉANT General Assembly GÉANT Voting Working Group Recommendations Porto, 18 June 2015.
NIFHA Annual Conference 2014 Great Homes, Thriving Communities 24 October 2014 Micaela Diver, A&L Goodbody.
Обдуманные ходы Эффективные решения PPP as a mechanism for infrastructure formation in Kazakhstan: legal aspects
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 28 – Consumer and Health Protection.
New Models and New Challenges for Public Services – a Legal Perspective Tracy Giles 10 March 2015.
Conclusion of agreement with the state and postal communication operators for the provision of Postal communication services Yerevan;
Alternative Delivery Models – Legal issues Kim Howell, Partner Geldards LLP.
LEB Slide Set 14 Competition Law Matti Rudanko. LEB Slide Set 14 2 A Constitution of Market Economy Well-functioning markets – an unwritten fundamental.
Real Estate Principles, 11th Edition By Charles F. Floyd and Marcus T. Allen.
PRIVATE LAW.
Marek Stavinoha Legal officer DG MOVE A4 European Commission
Contracts Within and Exceptions to the Statute of Frauds
Introduction to Sales and Lease Contracts
Markkinoiden juridinen toimintaympäristö Kalvot 15
Shared and Transferred Interest in Real Property
European Maritime Law Organisation Malta Maritime Law Association JOINT EMLO AND MMLA SEMINAR VALLETTA, MALTA, 8 MAY 2014 Philip Wareham Hill Dickinson.
Uniform Commercial Code
Legal Responsibilities of a Conservation District
IPR AND CONCENTRATIONS
Real Estate Principles, 11th Edition
Daniel Ehrenberg Innovative Tools for Creating and Preserving Affordable  Housing: Legal Issues and Considerations.
Marc Abenhaïm Sidley Austin LLP 19 September 2014
The New Provisions of the Amended Remedies Directive
Legal Issues for Hubs Music Mark Conference 2018
Andrea Sundstrand Associate Professor
Presentation transcript:

Development Agreements – when are they exempt? Cyrus Mehta, Partner Nabarro LLP

Land transactions “Pure” land transactions (transfers, leases, licences) are not caught Public works contracts: –for the carry out of works –contracting authority “engages a person” to carry out works Regulation 6 (2)(e) – exemption for contracts for the acquisition of land and (existing) buildings But state aid requirements: Commission’s Notice on sale of land and buildings

“Mixed” contracts Gestion Hotelera –“main object” test –“incidental” works Article 1(2)(b) Directive: “Public contracts having as their object …” Quedlinburg –“main purpose” was not acquisition of land, but procurement of building Example: leases with covenants to refurbish “Severability” of works

Contractual commitment to develop Contract: –for works –contracting authority engages a person … –“contract” has a Community law definition (see AG in City of Cologne) Does an intention or expectation suffice? Context of development Flensburg case –sanctions for failure to develop –re-acquisition of property –but how specific can requirements be?

Contractual commitment to develop cont.. ECJ reference in Mueller “specified requirements” –how specific? –outline parameters do not suffice? Development “opportunities” as works concessions? –But still need to show “works contract”

Miscellaneous Regulation 34 – subsidised works contracts Use of public/private SPVs for development –unlikely to be “in-house” (Teckal etc.) –is there a “works” contract? –Commission’s IPPP notice Planning obligations : quality standards, e.g. Code for Sustainable Homes

Summary Where EU procurement rules may not apply: –“pure” land transactions –contracts where “main object” is disposal of land –no contractual commitment to develop –contracts with outline specification