Contracts: Clickwraps and Idea Submissions Intro to IP – Prof Merges 4.16.09.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Sale of goods II Fall UCC offer & acceptance Goods Merchants What about mixed contracts? What if UCC does not govern the issue? Offer: I, BUYER,
Advertisements

Sales Contracts.  Sale – Contract in which ownership of goods transfers immediately from the seller to the buyer  Ownership – Collection of rights that.
Welcome to Jeopardy!.
Offer and Acceptance.  Offer and Acceptance- Both sides agree on mutual terms  Genuine Assent- Entering under your own free will (Not being forced)
Click your mouse anywhere on the screen to advance the text in each slide. After the starburst appears, click a blue triangle to move to the next slide.
Sales Contracts Chapter 12.
1 George Mason School of Law Contracts I G.Offer and Acceptance II F.H. Buckley
Click Wrap Contracts Richard Warner.  Web sites typically contain an agreement defining the terms on which the web site may be used.  In many cases,
Business Law: Ch 6 Offer and Acceptance.
Business Law: Ch 6 Offer and Acceptance.
Shrinkwrap Contracts Richard Warner. ProCD v. Zeidenberg ProCD sold a CD that contained every phone number and address in every telephone directory in.
Ideas; Publicity Intro to IP – Prof Merges
1 ON-LINE CONTRACTING n What law applies? –Uniform Commercial Code, Article 2 –Uniform Computer Information Transaction Act (UCITA) - formerly UCC, Art.
Ideas; Publicity Intro to IP – Prof Merges
Misappropriation & Clickwraps I Intro to IP – Prof Merges
Shrinkwrap, Clickwrap and Beyond Contracts – Prof. Merges Feb. 22, 2011.
Contracts: Clickwraps and Idea Submissions Intro to IP – Prof Merges
Prentice Hall © PowerPoint Slides to accompany THE LEGAL ENVIRONMENT OF BUSINESS AND ONLINE COMMERCE 5E, by Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 13 Sales and.
Offer and Acceptance Online Richard Warner. The Definition of an Offer An offer is  a manifestation of a willingness to enter a bargain  so made as.
Chapter 6: Contract Law Law in Society
Contracts: Clickwraps and Idea Submissions Intro to IP – Prof Merges
Offer and Acceptance Creating an offer Key Words Contract- An agreement between two or more parties that creates obligations. Offeror- The person who.
© 2007 Prentice Hall, Business Law, sixth edition, Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 18: Formation of Sales and Lease Contracts Chapter 18: Formation of.
Copyright © 2008 by West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning Chapter 23 Nature and Form of Sales Contracts Twomey Jennings Anderson’s.
Chapter 121 Termination of an Offer By Offeror By Offeree Revocation Prior to Acceptance* Death or Incapacity Time Limitations Placed in the Offer Rejection.
CHAPTER IV Organization of business relations in trade.
Chapter 7 – Offer and Acceptance
Chapter 7.  An agreement that courts will enforce.  What do you think are some examples of contracts?  What do you think are some examples of agreements.
Offer and Acceptance Section 6-1.
Contracts BCS-LEB-4 The student identifies rights and responsibilities of contract negotiations. BCS-LEB-8 The student explains the legal rules that apply.
P A R T P A R T Contracts Introduction to Contracts The Agreement: Offer The Agreement: Acceptance Consideration Reality of Consent 3 McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Formation of Sales and Lease Contracts Chapter 19.
Formation of the Contract ----How the UCC changes the common law.
Offer and Acceptance Chapter 6. Because of its limited resources the court system is very selective in what it will enforce. Criminal laws and laws allowing.
© 2010 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
Business Law Chapter 7 Review Game. Creation of Offers Termination of Offers Acceptance Final Jeopardy Jeopardy.
© 2004 West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning BUSINESS LAW Twomey Jennings 1 st Ed. Twomey & Jennings BUSINESS LAW Chapter 13 Formation.
Copyright © 2004 by Prentice-Hall. All rights reserved. PowerPoint Slides to Accompany BUSINESS LAW E-Commerce and Digital Law International Law and Ethics.
Meeting of the Minds The parties can form a contract only if they had a meeting of the minds. – They must understand each other and intend to reach an.
FORMATION OF CONTRACTS: OFFER AND ACCEPTANCE Used by permission. For Educational purposes only.
Shrink Wrap Contracts Richard Warner. ProCD v. Zeidenberg  ProCD sold a CD that contained every phone number and address in every telephone directory.
Copyright © 2008 by West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning Chapter 13 Contracts: Offer and Acceptance Twomey Jennings Anderson’s.
COPYRIGHT © 2010 South-Western/Cengage Learning..
IBT - E-Commerce Contracts Issues Victor H. Bouganim WCL, American University.
The Sale and Lease of Goods Section Understanding Business and Personal Law The Sale and Lease of Goods Section 13.1 Contracts for the Sale of Goods.
Chapter 13 Section 1 Bobbie K and Juan R. What is a Sale? The Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) governs sales of goods, also governs contracts to sell goods.
25-1 Chapter 18 Formation of Sales and Lease Contracts.
Sales Law October 20, 2009 Winn. Sales Law October 20 Reading estimate for Thursday 10/22 – Finish Statute of Frauds; Unconscionability 2-13, 2-14 (skip.
1 George Mason School of Law Contracts I G.Offer and Acceptance II F.H. Buckley
Chapter 10 Contracts—Agreement. 2 Introduction Agreement = offer and acceptance. Once an agreement is reached, if the other elements of a contract are.
Chapter 24 Nature and Forms of Sales Twomey, Business Law and the Regulatory Environment (14th Ed.)
Contract Law for Paralegals: Traditional and E-Contracts © 2009 Pearson Education, Upper Saddle River, NJ All rights reserved Formation of Sales.
GOULD’S “MCQ’s in the MORNING” Multiple Choice Program: CONTRACT LAW QUESTIONS, © 2012 GOULD’S LEGAL EDUCATION, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
©2002 by West Legal Studies in Business A Division of Thomson Learning Chapter 18 E-Contracts.
Business Law Chapter 7 Mrs. A Creation of Offers Creation of Offers Terminating Offers Terminating Offers Acceptance of Offers Acceptance of Offers.
2/14/2006Class 161 Class 16, Tuesday, Feb. 14 Announcements Thursday Friday Today’s agenda Problem 3-4 Problem Set 3 Hill v. Gateway 2000.
Ch. 7 Consumer Law and Contracts 7-1 Sales Contracts.
Contracts Offer and Acceptance Business Law Modified: Jan 2013.
CHAPTER 11 Agreement Click your mouse anywhere on the screen to advance the text in each slide. After the starburst appears, click a blue triangle.
Offer and Acceptance Chapter 6.
Drafting Key Commercial and Consumer Contract Terms
Chapter 9 Nature of Traditional and E-Contracts
UCC Sales and Lease Contracts and Warranties
George Mason School of Law
Contracts What You Will Learn: How to identify a contract’s elements
Chapter 6 Offer and Acceptance
Chapter 9 Nature of Traditional and E-Contracts
Presentation transcript:

Contracts: Clickwraps and Idea Submissions Intro to IP – Prof Merges

Agenda Shrinkwrap/clickwrap contracts – K law – Preemption Idea submission cases: implied K and preemption issues

ProCD v. Zeidenberg

Judge Frank Easterbrook

SELECT PHONE is on 5 CDs, contains 90 million listings from both White and Yellow Pages of 77.8 million residential and 13.8 million businesses. You can search for listings on any field: name, address, city, state, ZIP, area code, business heading and SIC code. It offers reverse search capability, matches addresses or phone numbers with names and provides counts by business heading or SIC code. And its fast - just a second or two to search for the listing you want. In addition you have unlimited downloading of listings into a database, word processor, spreadsheet or contact management program. The value and utility of this should be apparent to any salespeople, fundraisers, research and market testing firms,...

SMALL FRY GO ONLINE – 11/1995 Technology lets even tiny businesses outmarket the giants Pro CD Inc., Database America, Cole Publications (a unit of MetroMail), and Dun & Bradstreet all sell nationwide telephone listings on compact disks, including names and addresses, for as little as $175. The CDs let you search by name, zip code, and, in some, by income or business type

Matthew Zeidenberg

District court holding Was there a K? What were its terms?

What term is at issue in ProCD?

“No commercial use”

7 th Circuit Holding When is K formed? Who is offeror? What is mode of acceptance?

Easterbrook: why is this good policy? Business motive “Freedom of K” Consumer benefits

Price Quantity Demanded (000s) D $5 100 $3 170 Total Revenue Price Discrimination

Price Quantity Demanded (000s) D $5 100 $3 170 Price Discrimination Hardcover Softcover

Total Revenue Without Price Discrimination With Price Discrimination $510$710

Price Quantity Demanded (000s) D $5 100 $3 170 Price Discrimination Commer- cial Users Non- commercial Users

Price Quantity Demanded (000s) D $5 100 $3 170 Price Discrimination Commer- cial Users Arbitrage!

Price Quantity Demanded (000s) D $5 100 $3 170 Total Revenue “Perfect Arbitrage” Arbitrageurs’ profits

Freedom of Contract in ProCD What happens if we prohibit “rolling K formation”?

Freedom of Contract in ProCD What happens if we prohibit “rolling K formation”?  All sorts of beneficial K’s will be prohibited; inconvenience for many buyers will result

K Analysis UCC policy: K may be formed in any manner : acceptance of goods (shows that terms in form Ks may not be the final step in acceptance) UCITA draft – not persuasive for Easterbrook

Preemption analysis K involves only 2 parties... Not “good against the world”

Judge Sonia Sotomayor

Ancillary Issues Agreement to arbitrate UCC vs. common law of contracts Sale vs license – crucial distinction – UCC vs. IP licensing law – 1 st sale/exhaustion doctrine

Netscape: assent issues Communicator (browser): required assent before downloading “SmartDownload” (plug-in) did not

Specht v. Netscape Communications Corp., 306 F.3d 17 (2d Cir.2002). We rule against Netscape and in favor of the users of its software because the users would not have seen the terms Netscape exacted without scrolling down their computer screens, and there was no reason for them to do so. The evidence did not demonstrate that one who had downloaded Netscape's software had necessarily seen the terms of its offer.

Online Assent We recognize that contract offers on the Internet often require the offeree to click on an “I agree” icon. And no doubt, in many circumstances, such a statement of agreement by the offeree is essential to the formation of a contract...

“Terms inside Gateway’s box stand or fall together. If they constitute the parties’ contract because the Hills had an opportunity to return the computer after reading them, then all must be enforced.” Hill v. Gateway

“ProCD is about the law of contract, not the law of software. Payment preceding the revelation of full terms is common for air transportation, insurance, and many other endeavors. Practical considerations support allowing vendors to enclose the full legal terms with their products.”

The question in ProCD was not whether terms were added to a contract after its formation, but how and when the contract was formed—in particular, whether a vendor may propose that a contract of sale be formed, not in the store (or over the phone) with the payment of money or a general “send me the product,” but after the customer has had a chance to inspect both the item and the terms. ProCD answers “yes,” for merchants and consumers alike

Notice of terms? Gateway’s ads state that their products come with limited warranties and lifetime support. How limited was the warranty—30 days, with service contingent on shipping the computer back, or five years, with free onsite service? What sort of support was offered? Shoppers have three principal ways to discover these things [ask, request K terms, or wait for the product to arrive].”

Netscape holding “We hold that a reasonably prudent offeree in plaintoffs’ position would not have known or learned, prior to acting on the invitation to download, of the reference to SmartDownload’s license terms hidden below the “Download” button on the next screen.” – p. 881

Nadel v. Play-by-Play Facts – Toy industry structure Causes of action here – Breach of K; quasi-K; “unfair competition”

The toy industry is a 30 billion dollar-a-year business. It's also the last frontier for aspiring independent inventors, with an annual new product turnover of 60 percent and plenty of opportunities for the creative mind. Here, one of the most recognized and successful toy and game inventors in the business teams up with the former head of research and development at Hasbro to bring clear, comprehensive information to aspiring toy and game inventors...who just might bring us the next hula hoop!

Facts Nadel meets with Wasserman Nadel sends prototype The secretary’s testimony – killer for Wasserman!

Doctrine Specific to NY State law: the role of novelty in “theft of idea” cases General (vs. specific) novelty: applied by District Court to bar Nadel’s claims District Court: true for (1) misappropriation and (2) breach of K causes of action

Apfel (NY Case) Distinguished “novelty to the buyer” from “originality” Consideration argument rejected

Property vs contract Cases on “property-based” vs. “Contract-based” causes of action

Held Reversed and remanded Question of novelty to be determined below