NewSpace Tipping the Balance of Domestic Liability Regimes: A U.S. Perspective Nathan A. Johnson J.D., George Washington University Law School 2014 LL.M.,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Informed Consent v. ITAR: Regulatory Conflicts that Could Constrain Commercial Human Spaceflight P.J. Blount IAA 1 st Symposium on Private Human Access.
Advertisements

1 16TH ECSL SUMMER COURSE ON SPACE LAW AND POLICY September 3rd-14th, 2007 Noordwijk, Wednesday 12th, 15 :30-16 :45 Lecture on : Risk management and insurance.
The UK Space Agency: Our plan for space Dr Alice Bunn, Director of Policy November 2014.
Residential Structural Retrofit Program – A Collaborative Opportunity – California Earthquake Authority July 2010.
© 2013, XL Group plc companies. All rights reserved. MAKE YOUR WORLD GO Yellow R= 255 G= 255 B= 0 Orange R= 244 G= 121 B= 32 Magenta R= 236 G= 0 B= 14-
3 rd Manfred Lachs International Conference ‘NewSpace Commercialization and the Law’ Montreal, March 2015 NewSpace, Small Satellites and Law: Finding.
Launch & Space Liability Insurance Overview Presentation to COMSTAC
Regulating Space Tourism: impact on registration requirements and exposure to liability André FARAND, ESA Legal Department Cologne, Germany, 10 June 2005.
ARIANESPACE PROPRIETARY / PRIVILEGED PROJECT PLUS WORKSHOP 29/30 January 2004 Towards a harmonised approach for National Space laws in Europe CdP.
Purpose and modes of State indemnification Project 2001 Plus Towards an harmonised approach for Nations Space Legislation in Europe. Berlin, 29/30 January.
By Prof. Dr. Ram S. Jakhu, Panel Chair 8 TH ANNUAL MCGILL CONFERENCE ON INTERNATIONAL AVIATION LIABILITY & INSURANCE Montreal: 18 April 2015 INTRODUCTION.
1 Status of the German Draft Legislation on Space Activities Dr. Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd, DLR Project 2001 Plus Workshop „Towards a Harmonised Approach for.
Futron Corporation 7315 Wisconsin Avenue, Suite 900W Bethesda, Maryland Phone Fax ISO 9001 Registered Better.
By Ram S. Jakhu Associate Professor Institute of Air and Space Law McGill University 16 March Some Legal Aspects of Private Space Stations.
By: P. Brinkman, Senior Technical Advisor, FAA Date: August 15, 2011 Federal Aviation Administration Federal Aviation Administration Federal Aviation Administration.
International Treaties on Insurance and Liability related to Nuclear Accidents Michel Vandersmissen Attorney-at-law, Brussels Bar AEEC, 23 November 2009.
© 2012, XL Group plc companies. All rights reserved. MAKE YOUR WORLD GO Yellow R= 255 G= 255 B= 0 Orange R= 244 G= 121 B= 32 Magenta R= 236 G= 0 B= 14-
National Center for Remote Sensing, Air and Space Law The University of Mississippi School of Law National Center for Remote Sensing, Air and Space Law.
Shadow Banking: New Regulatory Issue 1. s/tid_150/index.htm
Page 1 Commercial Space Transportation Advisory Committee (COMSTAC) May 18, 2007 Brett Alexander John Gedmark President Executive Director President Executive.
2007 Commercial GSO Demand Forecast May 2007 Beth King COMSTAC Technology & Innovation Working Group Cover art by John Sloan/FAA 2007.
Futron Corporation 7315 Wisconsin Avenue, Suite 900W Bethesda, Maryland Phone Fax ISO 9001 Registered Better.
Presented to: By: Date: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Commercial Space Transportation Orbital Debris 10 June, 2015 Symposium for the Small.
1 James A. Vedda, Ph.D. The Aerospace Corporation Center for Space Policy & Strategy Study of the Liability Risk Sharing Regime in the United States for.
The Economic Impact of Commercial Space Transportation on the U.S. Economy May 20, 2004 Paula Trimble Federal Aviation Administration Associate Administrator.
Federal Aviation Administration UN COPUOS Group D on Regulations and AST International Outreach Update John Sloan FAA Office of Commercial Space Transportation.
By Yaw Nyampong International Conference on Air Transport, Air and Space Law and Regulation Abu Dhabi, UAE, April 15-16, 2009.
Introduction to the FAA Office of Commercial Space Transportation AST Pre-Workshop to the Center of Excellence for Commercial Space Transportation Research.
2008 Non-Geosynchronous Orbits Commercial Space Transportation Forecast John Sloan Federal Aviation Administration Office of Commercial Space Transportation.
John D. Rummel East Carolina University and the McGill University Institute of Air and Space Law “Due Regard” in Space Activities: Avoiding Harmful Contamination.
Commercial Space: A New Frontier Dr. George C. Nield Deputy Associate Administrator for Commercial Space Transportation January 9, 2007 Federal Aviation.
National Coalition of Spaceport States Briefing for the Advanced Spaceport Technology Working Group (ASTWG) Meeting Kennedy Space Center May 15, 2001 Presented.
1 ADVANCED SPACEPORT TECHNOLOGY WORKING GROUP May 15, 2001 Stewart W. Jackson Commercial Space Transportation Federal Aviation Administration FAA/AST LICENSING.
2006 Commercial Space Transportation Forecast for Non-Geosynchronous Orbits John Sloan Federal Aviation Administration Office of Commercial Space Transportation.
2006 Commercial GSO Demand Forecast May 2006 Lisa Hague COMSTAC Technology & Innovation Working Group Cover art by John Sloan/FAA.
2004 Commercial Space Transportation Forecast for Non-Geosynchronous Orbits (NGSO) John Sloan Federal Aviation Administration Associate Administrator for.
Federal Aviation Administration Federal Aviation Administration International Outreach Update FAA Office of Commercial Space Transportation COMSTAC RLV.
PROJECT 2001 PLUS GLOBAL AND EUROPEAN CHALLENGES FOR AIR AND SPACE LAW AT THE EDGE OF THE 21ST CENTURY International Symposium Maternushaus Cologne, 8th.
Presented to: Risk Management Working Group, COMSTAC By: Laura Montgomery, Senior Attorney for Commercial Space Transportation, FAA Date: October 13, 2011.
2010 Commercial GSO Demand Forecast Chris Kunstadter Senior Vice President XL Insurance Cover art by John Sloan/FAA 19 May.
Commercialization of Space 31 March Commercialization Use of equipment sent into or through outer space to provide goods and services of commercial.
Copyright 2004 Northrop Grumman Corporation 0 21 June 2004 Doug Young NG Lead Executive for Project Constellation Northrop Grumman Corporation Cooperating.
2011 Commercial GSO Demand Forecast Ronnie Johnson Strategic Planning United Launch Alliance Cover art by Phil Smith,
2009 Commercial GSO Demand Forecast 21 May 2009 Kevin Reyes Director, Business Development Boeing Launch Services Cover art by John.
COMMERCIAL SPACE TRANSPORTATION FORECAST FOR NON- GEOSYNCHONOUS (NGSO) ORBITS Kate Maliga Program Manager The Tauri Group 14 May 2013 COMSTAC Meeting.
COMSTAC Risk Management Working Group October 28, 2009 Chris Kunstadter XL Insurance
Federal Aviation Administration 1 FAA AST Overview Presentation Federal Aviation Administration Overview of the Federal Aviation Administration.
11 Space Transportation Policy and Market Risks Panel 5 – International Customers, Competitors and Partners The George Washington University Elliot School.
SPACE Act of 2015 Dr. Sarah J. Nilsson, Esq. A 3 ir Conference January 2016.
RISK MANAGEMENT WORKING GROUP John Vinter International Space Brokers, Inc Wilson Boulevard, Suite 990 Rosslyn, Virginia Telephone: (703)
COMMERCIAL SPACE INDUSTRY ANALYSES & STUDIES 1. CLAYTON CHRISTENSEN ON THE ROLE OF DATA AND THEORY IN STRATEGY AND INNOVATION 2.
Reusable Launch Vehicle Working Group Commercial Space Transportation Advisory Committee Presented to COMSTAC Meeting George Whitesides, RLVWG Chairman.
Emerging Developments & Issues - Suborbital Commercial Spaceflight
Federal Aviation Administration Federal Aviation Administration The Regulatory Role of the Federal Aviation Administration in Space Transportation With.
1 Session 1 Perspective for More National Space Legislation - Report of the Rapporteur - Dr. Michael Gerhard, DLR Project 2001 Plus Symposium, Cologne,
Federal Aviation Administration 1 FAA AST Presentation at ESIL-1 October 26, 2011 List of Recent Papers 2011 Overview of the FAA Center of Excellence for.
2005 Commercial Space Transportation Forecast for Non-Geosynchronous Orbits John Sloan Federal Aviation Administration Office of Commercial Space Transportation.
Federal Aviation Administration Federal Aviation Administration Presented to: COMSTAC By: Bretton Alexander, RLV Working Group Chair Date: May 11, 2011.
© 2012, XL Group plc companies. All rights reserved. MAKE YOUR WORLD GO Yellow R= 255 G= 255 B= 0 Orange R= 244 G= 121 B= 32 Magenta R= 236 G= 0 B= 14-
© 2011, XL Group plc companies. All rights reserved. I MAKE YOUR WORLD GO Yellow R= 255 G= 255 B= 0 Orange R= 244 G= 121 B= 32 Magenta R= 236 G= 0 B= 14-
Effects of Changing Economics on Space Architecture and Engineering Gary Oleson April 12, 2016 Engility Proprietary Information.
Australia’s civil space policy environment and the review of the Space Activities Act 1998 Dr Anne Byrne, General Manager, Manufacturing and Services Policy.
STM 2014 LONG Paper #1004 Small Satellites and State Responsibility Associated With Space Traffic Situational Awareness George Anthony Long, Esq. Managing.
Professor Melissa de Zwart, RUMLAE, Adelaide Law School
Reforms In Insurance Sector In India
Regulatory Uncertainty for Non-Traditional Commercial Space Activities
Space Law & Small Launchers
Legal Issues Critical to SSA
London Institute of Space Policy and Law
4th Luxembourg Workshop on Space and Satellite Communication Law
Presentation transcript:

NewSpace Tipping the Balance of Domestic Liability Regimes: A U.S. Perspective Nathan A. Johnson J.D., George Washington University Law School 2014 LL.M., University of Nebraska College of Law 2015 (expected)

NewSpace Affect on Space Development Nathan A. Johnson1 Combined 2014 GSO and NGSO Historical Launches and Lunch Forecast (“2014 Commercial Space Transportation Forecasts,” FAA May 2014) “an emerging new segment of space launch demand” – FUTRON white paper “Market Characterization: Launch of Very-Small and Nano Sized Payloads Enabled by New Launch Vehicles” IAC-10.E6.3.9

National Risk for Space Activities Outer Space Treaty, Art. VI -“international responsibility” -“authorization and continuing supervision” Liability Convention -Art. II “absolute liability” -Art. III: fault based Nathan A. Johnson2 Question: Does Increased NewSpace Activity Expose Governments To More Risk?

Domestic Liability Regime: United States Nathan A. Johnson3 Launch & Reentry -Who needs a license? US citizen; or Launching from the US -What does a license require? Inspection Payload Review Monitoring Financial Responsibility

Balance of Risk: Private v. Public Financial Responsibility = Risk Sharing Tier 1: Insurance (or other demonstration) To cover the MPL to Third-Parties, as determined by the FAA Not to exceed $500 Million (+ $100 Million for Government) Tier 2: Government Appropriation, aka Indemnification If claims exceed Tier 1, Congress will seek to appropriate funds Up to an additional approximately $2.8 Billion (in 2015) Nathan A. Johnson4 Should Indemnification Be Allowed to Expire? *SpaceX

Government Jurisdiction over Space Activities - Direct Authorization FAA – Launch & Reentry FCC – Spectrum NOAA – Remote Sensing -Indirect Authorization (Payload Review) NASA Department of Defense Department of State Nathan A. Johnson5

Case Study: Satellite Internet Constellations Nathan A. Johnson6

Case Study: Bigelow Lunar Habitat Nathan A. Johnson7 *Bigelow Aerospace

Concerns from Insurance Market New Launch Vehicles Human Spaceflight Nathan A. Johnson8

Conclusion Private Companies still investing, developing, and seeking regulatory certainty US Government has enough flexibility to support or intervene where they deem risk Nathan A. Johnson9

Questions, Criticisms, Contributions: Nathan A. Johnson