SUMMARY AND ANALYSIS OF CCHPs 2013- 2014 REPORT P RESENTED AT THE JAHSR TRM MEETING 24 th OCTOBER, 2013 Dr. Anna Nswilla Coord. District Health Services.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
KENYA HEALTH SECTOR PARTNERSHIP Third IHP+ Country Health Sector Teams Meeting Brussels, December 2010.
Advertisements

Donald T. Simeon Caribbean Health Research Council
Overview of the Global Fund: Guiding Principles Grant Cycle / Processes & Role of Public Private Partnerships Johannesburg, South Africa Tatjana Peterson,
The Republic of Uganda WAKISO DISTRICT COUNCIL. ALGAF IV. SESSION III: TAKING THE LEAD IN COORDINATION AND ACTION : STRATEGY AND PARTNERSHIPS. IMPLEMENTATION.
Presentation to the 2014 International AIDS Conference
TANZANIA HEALTH SECTOR STRATEGIC PLAN III, : MIDTERM ANALYTICAL REVIEW Leonard E.G. Mboera, PhD, DIC National Institute for Medical Research Dar.
COMMUNITY HEALTH FUND Best Practices in Tanzania Workshop Singida District Council Juma H.Tantau CHF Coordinator.
Healthcare Waste Management Programme
1 KARAGWE DISTRICT COUNCIL Funding drug gaps by using CHF By Dr Ruta Thomas.
Comprehensive M&E Systems
DEPARTMENT OF COOPERATIVE GOVERNANCE AND TRADITIONAL AFFAIRS PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE Municipal Infrastructure Grant (MIG) Projects and.
Recommendations and findings from RHMT training on PlanRep3 and CCHP Guidelines For DPG-H 03 September 2014 Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation.
Does the Quality of Governance Contribute to the Quality of Health Care in Bangladesh? Presented by: Mohammad Shafiqul Islam Ph.D Candidate School of the.
Project for Capacity Development in Regional Health Management Phase 2 3 September 2014 DPG-H Meeting 1.
Dr. Richard B. Munyaneza, MD, Rwanda Ministry of Health.
How to IMPLEMENT responses. Who and when ? IMMEDIATEPERIODICLONG TERM Region National Woreda Facility Comm’ty Level and timing of action.
Ministry of Health Syed Anwar Mahmood Federal Secretary (Health) Government of Pakistan Saving Children’s lives through Community based Interventions.
PERFORMANCE AUDIT REPORT ON MANAGEMENT OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE (A CASE STUDY ON HEALTH CENTERS) 8/16/20151 Dr. Anna Nswilla CDHSMoHSW.
Process of Development of Five Year Strategic Plan for Child Health Development Dr Myint Myint Than Deputy Director (WCHD) Department of Health.
9/5/  Background  District Health Services  Council Health Services Boards and Health Facility Governing Committees (CHSB and HFGC)  Regional.
PRIORITY SETTING PROCESS ON NUTRITION AND USE OF GUIDELINES IN RESOURCE ALLOCATION IN ARUSHA DISTRICT COUNCIL Temina Mkumbwa MPH-Executive Track 22 nd.
Dr. A. O. Mwakilasa Needs Assessment Report 1 Needs Assessment Human Resources Development in the Health Sector in Tanzania: Needs, Priorities and Potentials.
ESPON Seminar 15 November 2006 in Espoo, Finland Review of the ESPON 2006 and lessons learned for the ESPON 2013 Programme Thiemo W. Eser, ESPON Managing.
PEER LEARNING DISTRICTS INITIATIVE REPORT ON INITIAL ASSESSMENT OF MANAGEMENT AND DELIVERY OF HEALTH SERVICES Presentation to DPG-Health and SWAp-TWG1.
“Public-Private Health Forum guiding the way forward for partnerships to improve health in Tanzania” Dr. Adeline Kimambo Co-Chair PPHF Executive Board.
Introduction to Health Management Information System (HMIS) By Claud J. Kumalija Head HMIS 06 th November, 2008.
Uganda Health Information Strategy Eddie Mukooyo, MD, MSc Assistant Commissioner Health Services Dublin, Ireland 13 th September 2010.
Donor financing and expenditure for PHC in Uganda Dr. Betty Kyaddondo Population Secretariat Uganda.
WHO and the Global Fund harmonized tool for Pharmaceutical Country Profiles Richard Laing & Enrico Cinnella, November 2011.
Intergovernmental transfers current situation, challenges and future.
HELLEN A. WERE HEALTH ECONOMICS TRACK 2 ND COHORT UNITID FELLOWSHIP PROGRAM 24/05/2011.
Challenges in Data Collection and Dissemination of National Development Indicators, including MDGs The Experience of Cambodia by Lay Chhan National Institute.
Regional Health Management Report on FY2012/13 and Plan 2013/ R.D. Mutagwaba, Regional Health Services Coordinator, MOHSW.
Pharmaceutical, Infrastructure and Food Safety Working Group Technical Review Meeting 7-8 th September 2010.
USE AND MANAGEMENT FUND Dr. Winfred Philemon Kyambile District Medical Officer HANANG CHF BEST PRACTICE WORKSHOP DAR ES SALAAM 02/02/2007.
FEEDBACK FROM RMO/DMO MEETING HELD ON 8 th -12 th SEPTEMBER, 2014 IN MOROGORO Joint Annual Health Sector Review 6 th November 2014.
Zimbabwe Human Resources for Health Strategic Plan ( ) Regional HRH Strategic Planning Meeting Harare June 2011.
REVISED COMPREHENSIVE COUNCIL HEALTH PLANNING (CCHP) GUIDELINE FOR LGAs 2010 A Report presented at JAHSR – Technical Review Meeting on 07 th - 8 th September.
TNCM Oversight Committee and GF Flow of Funds Presentation to DPG-Health May 6, 2015.
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES REVIEW CONTENT, METHODOLOGY AND INSTRUMENTS Presented by: Nguyen Viet Anh, Member of the Prime Minister’s Special Task Force.
CHAPTER V Health Information. Updates on new legislation (1)  Decision No.1605/2010/QĐ-TTg approving the National Program for Application of information.
STRATEGIC PLAN & BUDGET PRESENTATION TO THE SELECT COMMITTEE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH 6 APRIL 2005.
Summary and Analysis of RHMT Reports 2009/ R.D. Mutagwaba, Regional Health Services Coordinator, MOHSW.
Rapid Budget Analysis (RBA) Health Sector December 4, 2013.
RESOURCE MOBILIZATION FOR FAMILY PLANNING SUPPLIES An Advocacy Work for Political and Financial Commitment in Tanzania.
Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.
Joint Annual Health Sector Review Meeting to be held on 7 th – 9 th October, 2009 Kunduchi Beach Hotel - DSM Ministry of Health and Social Welfare Health.
FIJI PERSPECTIVE. Donor programs well aligned to strategic priorities of Government However, the lack of a proper framework to guide the Government- Donor.
Capability Assessment of PMO- RALG Presentation for the Development Partners Group Meeting Wednesday 27 th of October 2015 Supported by DANIDA.
UNFCCC secretariat, Financial and Technical Support Programme Tshering Sherpa, Associate Programme Officer Compilation of information contained in recently.
DISTRICT SUPPORT AND QUALITY MANAGEMENT Overall component objective ‘ To support provision of efficient and comprehensive health services which respond.
Pilot Grant Program EGAD Study OCCUPATIONAL & ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH.
QUARTERLY PERFORMANCE OF THE MUNICIPAL INFRASTRUCTURE GRANT (MIG) – 2005/06 AND 2006/07 FINANCIAL YEARS Presentation to the Select Committee On Finance.
Tanzanian German Programme to Support Health Monitoring and Evaluation Susanne Pritze-Aliassime.
TANZANIA MAINLAND NATIONAL HEALTH POLICY AND STRATEGY REPORT.
Proposed Policy Commitments for 2016 Joint Annual Health Sector Review (JAHSR) –Policy meeting 11 th February
United Republic of Tanzania Ministry of Health & Social Welfare MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL WELFARE NATIONAL AIDS CONTROL PROGRAM HIV CARE AND TREATMENT.
Recent Trends and Challenges of Local Management in LAO PDR By Bouangeun OUNNALATH Ministry of Finance, LAO PDR.
Eastern Caribbean Countries Health System and Private Sector Assessments 2011 Lisa Tarantino USAID’s Health Systems 20/20 Caribbean & Strengthening Health.
11 Laboratory Quality Improvement for clinical HIV/AIDS Services in the Uniformed Forces Mwaibako, J, Shija, L; Haverkamp, G; van den Hombergh; Katebalila,
Establishing a SWCA through Safecare approach; The experiences, successes and challenges Presented by Dr Eliudi Eliakimu On behalf of other Authors: Bayoum.
SIERRA LEONE: Existing Expenditure & Budget Tracking Process Peter N. Sam-Kpakra Deputy Financial Secretary Ministry of Finance and Economic Development.
Regional, District Leadership and Facility Pediatric Quality Improvement Teams (PQITs) as Champions of Implementation Sustainability 3rd NQIF 26th - 28th.
February 25, Today’s Agenda  Introductions  USDOE School Improvement Information  Timelines and Feedback on submitted plans  Implementing plans.
1 Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Most Vulnerable Children Quality Improvement Trainings in five Regions of Tanzania Author: Flora Nyagawa 1 ; Kusekwa.
PRESENTATION OF FINDINGS GRANTEES NEED ASSESSMENT
Introduction/Background Aim of the assessment was to assess the impact of the 3 institutions MOHCDGEC, PO-RALG and MOFP in the flow of funds from national.
UGANDA: Budgeting, resource tracking and domestic advocacy practices.
iCCM Experience Malawi
Presented by Richard Laing
Presentation transcript:

SUMMARY AND ANALYSIS OF CCHPs REPORT P RESENTED AT THE JAHSR TRM MEETING 24 th OCTOBER, 2013 Dr. Anna Nswilla Coord. District Health Services MOHSW Ministry of Health and Social Welfare and Prime Minister’s Office, Regional Administration and Local Government

Outline of the presentation Objectives of the assessment METHODOLOGY FINDINGS Challenges Recommendations

Objectives of the assessment Main objective Check for compliance with the national guidelines for improvement of quality service delivery. Provide results to be used by the Management (MOHSW& PMORALG) and other stakeholders for decision making and actions Trigger the approval and funding for annual CCHPs by BFC members Specific objective Oversee that planned activities address the councils’ identified priority health problems in line with the national priorities (MDGs, MKUKUTA, HSSP III, National Health Policy etc.) Identify weak LGAs and RHMTs for further technical assistance to improve their CCHPs 3

Methodology Assessors from Zonal Health Resource Centre, University Computing Centre, MOHSW, PMO-RALG, MOF, GIZ & WAJIBIKA Four assessments carried out, where gaps were communicated to planning teams and technical Support was provided The process involved pre-testing of the integrated CCHP in PlanRep3 Health Macro with the new Councils and regions. Assessment criteria developed and applied 4

FINDINGS Results for Preliminary assessment 2013/2014

Assessment Results showing the status of the council performance in all four rounds Assessment Number of councils assessed Recommen ded for funding % recommende d for funding Not recommended for funding 1st Assessment round % 111 2nd Assessment round % 24 3rd Assessment round % 4 4th Assessment round 44100%0

Sources of Health Funding at Council level for

Total budget share per Region and across Councils

Budget allocated to priority areas 2013/2014

Intervention Burden and Expenditure Shares 2013/14

Budget Shares according to Essential Health Interventions 2013/14

Shares of budget according to essential health interventions, non specific delivery support and interventions not addressing BOD

Funding flows financing mainly essential health interventions

Funding flows financing Non Specific delivery support interventions

The sources of funds for interventions not addressing BOD

Percentage of Health Facility by Type FY 2013/14

Total number of Health Facilities per region

Number of Health facilities planned for construction per region

Numbers of Health Workers by different cadres, by June 2012 PPM to be considered for Biomedical training

Guidelines shares vs. actual planned shares for medicines, medical supplies, equipment and laboratory reagents in 2013/14

Budget allocated for medicines, medical supplies, and equipment and laboratory reagents

Trend of TB cases

Trend of births attendance at health facilities and community delivery from 2008-

Trend of Family Planning acceptance rates,

Severe malnutrition by region, FY 2013/14

Proportion of low birth weight tendency,

Proportion of low birth weight, by region, FY 2013/14

Trend of immunization and Vitamin A Supplementations from

Trend of outpatients from

Family Planning Budget by source of fund, FY

Family Planning Budget by region, FY

P4P Indicator status by Region

Total Health Support Shares FY

Observations from the CCHP Priority health problems stated were not matching with the available data in the situational analysis tables. Most of the targets were not addressing the priority health problems and activities were not addressing interventions Resource allocation against Burden of disease were not matching because more resources were allocated to interventions not addressing the BoD and supportive interventions. Inadequate budget allocated to the activities addressing cost effective essential health interventions Budget outside Council account was not well understood e.g. activities funding sources were liked to wrong funders available in PlanRep3 (i.e. Central Govt via MSD/medicines, multilateral, Global Fund and NGOs etc) were either put on OC or DEV budget. 35

Observations… New councils were not trained on PlanRep3 as a result they faced difficult to use the tool. Integration of PlanRep3 that incorporated new structure (New Regions, Councils, Wards & Villages) was released mid April 2013 that caused New council to enter CCHPs using the old councils Planrep3 Code as the result councils re-entered the CCHPs in new PlanRep3 A lots of capacity development needed, and intense follow-up and mentoring. This lead to delays in the availability and analysis of data. Most of councils were either under budgeted or over budgeted on the ceiling provided

Observations… Most DMOs are newly appointed/acting, inadequate skills in preparation of the CCHPs Most of the councils that originated from the old ones has no CHMTs which lead the old ones to prepare two CCHPs Knowledge gap within the RHMTs on CCHPs and PlanRep3 tools has resulted to poor quality of Plans submitted by LGAs. RHMTs were not trained on PlanRep3 Micro to support CHMTs, PlanRep Health Meso for assessing and analyzing CCHPs as a result CCHPs were not analysed well Most of tables and forms was not filled with the required data ( MoHSW/DPs). 37

Observations… Most of the resources from National Programs have not been captured in the Planrep3 because data are not available to CHPT to be included in their plans (Malaria, NACP - ARVs, TB, EPI, FP commodities under GF). The result is that allocations measured against the BODs appear to be small. activities were not addressing essential interventions, Targets were not addressing council identified health priority problems, priority problems were not formulated based on the data available on the situational analysis tables and as not indicating the magnitude of the problem, target were not addressing the objectives and not SMART and some had no measurable parameters, activities were linked to wrong activity inputs (GFS Codes

Observations… In some council, resource allocation and Burden of disease does not match and some activities were not addressing the interventions and health problems defined in the PlanRep3 as the result activities were linked to the wrong priority areas. It was also observed that HBF and HBG allocation were not in line with the ceilings and the concept of community initiatives activities is not adequately understood by CHMT’s.

Observations… shortage of skilled health workers in both the management teams and health services provision this is made worse by frequent changes; transfers of Health Managers, suspension, new staff employed who have never been exposed or trained on the planning skills specifically on developing the CCHP. Most of the staff with skills to plan are over worked and are working for long hours to produce the results which we see today.

Observations… However, also other sources outside the health basket fund need to be considered in order to improve allocation and service delivery especially in rural District Councils. Some council failed to allocate resources addressing patient safety, environmental health and sanitation services in the health facilities. Most of the interventions were addressing environmental health and sanitation in the community, while their health facilities are dirt thus, becomes difficult to address the environmental health, hygiene and sanitation at the health facility level.

Observations… Inadequate capacity of the teams who prepares the plans even those of experience, Example, Ilala MC receives one of the highest shares of funds for health service implementation, making an insufficient plans much more of a critical concern than for those Councils which are new or receive smaller share. Also some council lacked DMOs, or had DMOs that were transferred during the scrutinization process. In these cases, most of the DMOs and District Health Secretaries were newly employed in the Councils.

The PlanRep3 System is still in development It does not capture and reflect some of the reports/data differ and also the reporting part is not well covered.

Challenges Councils were not responding on the observations given timely as the result we have worked for long time under constrained Most of the councils return their CCHPs without making correction/changes based on the observations made by the assessors. The CHPTs capacity on Planning is very low that result the quality of plans are not good Late disbursement of fund (May/June) at council level caused CHMTs during the planning period to be away for supervision Most of data were not filled in the tables and few that were available the data quality was not good The RHMT lack CCHP/PlanRep3 Assessment skills

Recommendations Develop PlanRep3 Health MESO for RHMT and conduct training for RHMT on PlanRep3 Health Meso and PlanRep3 Micro (Health) in order for the central level to receive more consolidated plans from RMHT/RS. Provide Capacity building for Central level (MOHSW and PMO- RALG) so that they are able to support RHMTs as well as CHMT during planning and report compilation. The Ministry in collaboration with PMORALG and UCC continue provide technical support as required on CCHP planning and Reporting (Physical & Financial) processes at District and Regional level. 45

Recommendations Continue Capacity building to the CHMT/CHPT on the use of the CCHP Planning Guideline & PlanRep3 Database for Planning and reporting and have short term training from the UCC to refresh their knowledge, Improve data collection and utilization through HMIS/DHS, HRHIS and link into PlanRep3. Councils to be directed to contribute a percentage of the budget from their collected Council Own sources revenues to support health services in their jurisdiction.

Recommendations DMOs/CHMTs to make sure the resources provided at Council level be included in the CCHPs as receipts in kinds from all sources including NGOs so that they do not destruct the plan. NGOs to provide tentative budget estimates or activities or areas to be supported for a particular year during pre-planning meeting with stakeholders at Council level. MOHSW in collaboration with PMORALG to compile suggestions for systems improvement from the LGAs and use to update PlanRep Micro (Health Sector), PlanRep Health Meso and PlanRep Health Macro.

Recommendations Provide ceiling to LGAs early and any other information or instruction during or before starting planning period. PlanRep3 be developed to web based, and Export of Expenditure from EPICOR to Planrep3 be ensured (mutual export and import of data) Operationalize the planning template for the HCs and Dispensaries to involve Lower health facilities plans which captures community contribution that have to be included in their CCHP, to reflect community participation, involvement and ownership of the implementation of health services at their respective area. 48

Thanks for your attention