York Antwerp Rules 2004 Progress or problems for Underwriters and Shipowners? Tim Madge FAAA - Partner Mediterranean Average Adjusting Company Marine Law.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
by Zeynep Özkan Özeren ÖZKAN Law Office
Advertisements

CHARTERERS DEFAULT - LIEN OVER CARGO BY IAN GOULSON.
CARRIERS PACKAGE Presented by.
Auto Claims The at fault driver of a vehicle that damages other property or injures other people is liable for the cost of repairs. North Carolina financial.
AIDA XIV World Congress 2014 Rom, 30 th September 2014 Marine Insurance WP “Sue and labour expenses – H&M on German terms or P&I?” Dr. Maximilian Guth,
Mega Container Ship Casualties – General Average
International Logistics, Risk, and Insurance
22 Lloyd’s Salvage Agreement LOF
ENVIRONMENTAL SALVAGE A CURRENT STATUS Robert B. Parrish President, The Maritime Law Association of the United States September 17, 2012.
Chapter 14: Salvage Chapter 15: General Average.  A. Contract Formation & Terms  §14-1 Nature/Elements of Marine Salvage ◦ Historical reasoning ◦ Applicable.
111 Attendance at the two dates you are assigned is mandatory Presentation date Evaluation date Attendance at the other eight (8) class dates will count.
IMCC - 26/28 October 2005 DUBLIN IMCC 2005 SALVAGE – SCOPIC CLAUSE HULL & MACHINERY UNDERWRITERS’ PERSPECTIVE.
Diminution of Value Coverage Implications Presented by Bill Wilson, CPCU, ARM, AIM, AAM Director, IIABA’s Virtual University Presented by Bill Wilson,
Law I Chapter 18.
Virtual Arrival an Initiative by Shipping to reduce GHG emission Singapore 8 may 2012 Senior Manager Research & Projects INTERTANKO.
Subrogation under Japanese Law
Insurance Law CHAPTER 19.
1 Keys for Chapter 5 Keys for Chapter 5 1. Do you think the insurance company should pay the claim to the insured? Why? Yes, the insurance company should.
YORK-ANTWERP RULES AND PLACES OF REFUGE FOLLOWING THE CMI CONFERENCE 2004 By Ben Browne Shaw and Croft.
INTRODUCTION TO GENERAL AVERAGE
Click your mouse anywhere on the screen to advance the text in each slide. After the starburst appears, click a blue triangle to move to the next slide.
SELF ASSESSMENT. ORDER OF PRESENTATION: 1.WHAT IS SELF ASSESSMENT (SA). 2.WHO ARE REQUIRED TO FILL OUT SA FORM. 3.FILING & PAYMENT DATES. 4.PENALTIES.
MARITIME TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT DOCUMENTS. Bill of Lading (B/L) Master B/L House B/L Non-Negotiable B/L Clean B/L Charter Party (C/P) Shipping/Booking.
TRANSPORTATION OF GOODS Introduction –Conventions Hague Rules Air Carriage Marine Insurance.
Chapter 50 Insurance.
Insurance Is protection for individuals against possible financial losses Provides protection against many risks such as unexpected property loss, illness.
MARITIME TRANSPORTATION MANAGEMENT
Maritime Claims An Underwriter ’ s Perspective Eamonn Magee LLB. BL.
CMI’s work on revision of York- Antwerp Rules. Sjørettsforeningen, By Sveinung Måkestad Vice President Gard AS.
© 2007 Prentice Hall, Business Law, sixth edition, Henry R. Cheeseman Insurance.
The information contained in this presentation is intended for illustration purposes only and does not provide coverage, actual policy terms and conditions.
Dublin International Marine Claims Conference - 29th September / 1st October 2004 INTERNATIONAL MARINE CLAIMS CONFERENCE CLAIMS HANDLING FRENCH MARKET.
MARINE INSURANCE.
The Norwegian Marine Insurance Plan
Meeting with the Romanian Motor Insurers’ Bureau Bucharest 19 th August 2004 Ulf Lemor.
© 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible website, in whole or in part.
MARINE INSURANCE.
Analysis of Insurance Contracts
Workers’ Compensation and Employers’ Liability Who is an Employer? Employer Liability Under Common Law State WC Laws Common Features Types of Injuries.
Tilde Publishing and Distribution ISBN: Import/Export Mapping International Trade for Australian Business Cargo Insurance.
Joint Venture Agreements. Joint Ventures Joint Venture (JV) : Two or more construction contractors jointly competing for a particular project pooling.
DUTY OF THE ASSURED Prepared by: Ms. Norazimah Mazlan.
The Law of Salvage Lecture 2008 Professor, jur. dr Svante O. Johansson.
ANNUITIES AND POLICY CONDITION OF LIFE INSURANCE.
Marine Claims – Loss of Hire NMIP Chapter 16 By Sveinung Måkestad, Vice President, Gard AS The Nordic Association of Marine Insurers 1.
PPT ON GENERAL INSURANCE & TAXATION
PRINCIPLES :- BASIC PRINCIPLES LEGAL PRINCIPLES.
-CHARTERPARTIES- INTRODUCTION
1. 2 Charter Party A contract whereby a shipowner agrees to place his ship, or part of it at a disposal of a person ( the charterer) for the carriage.
GENERAL AVERAGE Prepared by: Norazimah Mazlan.  It is a form of mutual insurance that developed before the emergence of marine insurance.  Rhodian law.
Association of Average Adjusters Revisions to the York-Antwerp Rules Mega container ships – practicalities of declaring GA and casualty handling October.
Project Ⅱ Task 6 Bill of lading. Section 2 III. Bill of lading A bill of lading (sometimes referred to as a B/L) is a transport document issued by a carrier.
CONTROLLING COSTS Choosing the Right Insurance Program Kevin D. Smith, CPCU, ARM Vice President Workers’ Compensation.
HOW TO PROTECT YOUR INTEREST IN A SALE CONTRACT Focus on what you “get” when you sign!
Chapter 5 Maritime Lien. 一、 Definition of maritime liens(ML) : CMC Art. 21 A maritime lien is the right of the claimant, subject to the provisions of.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 14 – Transport policy Bilateral screening:
Insuring Your Future Objective: Discuss the common types of insurance Identify when an insurable interest is present Bellwork: What kinds of insurance.
MARINE INSURANCE.
Study 5 – The Gross Earnings and Profits Form C40 – Business Interruption Insurance.
Eastern Mediterranean University
Chapter 9 Financial Statements.
GLOBAL RISK GLOBAL COVERAGE
Carriage of Goods by Sea – liability of a carrier
The Rotterdam Rules and General Average
general average Dr. Iva Savić
Chapter4 MARINE INSURANCE.
SALVAGE – SCOPIC CLAUSE
Automobile Insurance: The Basics
7. Measures to avert or minimize loss
Did you know? 30% of losses during transit are unavoidable.
Presentation transcript:

York Antwerp Rules 2004 Progress or problems for Underwriters and Shipowners? Tim Madge FAAA - Partner Mediterranean Average Adjusting Company Marine Law and Insurance 2006, Moscow

What is General Average?

General Average A form of international maritime law/ practice - first incorporated in York Rules Exists irrespective of insurance or fault of any party. All parties contribute to sacrifices and expenditure for the common safety/ safe prosecution of the voyage. Contribution based on values at end of voyage. Property lost subsequently on voyage does not contribute. Security = Underwriters’ Guarantee or cash deposit or Bank Guarantee + Average Bond signed by Consignees. Terms incorporated in Charter Parties & Bills of Lading.

Typical GA Sacrifices For common safety: Jettison of cargo at a time of peril Loss/ damage to ship or cargo extinguishing a fire Damage to main engines refloating a laden vessel which is aground and in peril Loss/ damage to property owned by third parties in consequence of refloating operations

Typical GA Expenditure Salvage costs Port charges at port of refuge Crew wages at port of refuge Cargo discharge for repairs Cargo storage/ reloading costs Temporary repairs Overtime on repairs

Expenditure allowable York Antwerp Rules: 1974/ 1994 Expenditure for common safety and for common benefit (safe prosecution of voyage) 2004 For common safety but certain expenditure for common benefit now limited

Reasons leading to 2004 Rules Perceived widening of scope of GA in 1994, such as anti-pollution measures Cargo often contribute more than Vessel due to higher values Reapportionment of Salvage in GA considered unnecessary and expensive Desire to restrict GA to Common Safety and to limit Common Benefit First set of YAR Rules introduced without consensus between Shipowning and other interests 2004 Rules only applicable if incorporated in Charter Parties/ Bills of Lading.

Effects of 2004 Rules Who wins? Who loses?

Salvage awards in General Average Salvage based on values at termination of salvage services. Contribution to General Average based on values at end of voyage. Further losses/ damage/ sacrifices after termination of salvage services and before end of voyage affect contributions ultimately payable for salvage in GA. Limits under YAR 2004.

Salvage allowable in GA York Antwerp Rules……..1974/ LOF/ negotiated settlements paid by all parties Yes No Paid by one party on behalf of all Yes Yes

Independently negotiated Salvage awards 1974/ 1994 Rules Salved value Settlement GA Ship $ 3,000,000 $200,000 (6.7%) $250,000 Cargo 9,000, ,000 (8.9%) 750,000 $12,000,000 1,000,000 1,000,000 = 8.3% Under 2004 Rules payments remain as settled

LOF Salvage award SHIP Sound value US$10,000,000 Deduct fire damage 1,000,000 Salvage US$ 9,000,000pays US$468,750 CARGO 1 st consignment Sound value US$3,250,000 Deduct fire damage 250,000 US$ 3,000,000pays US$156,250 2 nd consignment Sound value US$3,250,000 Deduct:- Fire damageUS$250,000 Extinguishing damage 600, ,000 US$ 2,400,000 pays US$125,000 US$14,400,000 pays US$750,000 = 5.2% of values

Reapportionment of salvage in GA SHIP Sound value US$10,000,000 Deduct fire damage 1,000,000 GA (Salvage) US$ 9,000,000pays US$450,000 CARGO 1 st consignment Sound value US$3,250,000 Deduct fire damage 250,000 US$3,000,000pays US$150,000 2 nd consignment Sound value US$3,250,000 Deduct:- Fire damageUS$250,000 Extinguishing damage 600, ,000 US$2,400,000 Add back Extinguishing damage 600,000 US$3,000,000pays US$150,000 US$15,000,000pays US$750,000 = 5% of values

Effects of reapportioning salvage costs in GA Benefits of a favourable settlement by one interest shared by others – 2004 Rules Individual Hull or Cargo Underwriters could gain or lose depending on figures. No change for Owners. Uninsured/ unrepresented interests share in salvage arbitration costs Rules Hull and Cargo Underwriters lose. No change for Owners. Disproportionate legal costs representing time charterers’ bunkers or freight shared by Ship and Cargo – 2004 Rules Hull and Cargo Underwriters gain. No change for Owners.

Excluding Salvage from GA Underwriters save the costs and time required to reapportion salvage although still necessary to collect GA security. Individual Hull or Cargo Underwriters could gain or lose as a favourable salvage settlement or disproportionate legal costs not shared. Hull and Cargo Underwriters lose because uninsured/ unrepresented interests do not share salvage arbitration costs. Beneficial for Owners as exclusion makes GA absorption clauses in Hull policies more effective.

Crew wages York Antwerp Rules……… 1974/ Crew wages: Deviating to port of refuge and resuming voyage Yes Yes While detained effecting repairs Yes No Likely considerable losses to Shipowners under YAR 2004

Temporary repairs (1974/1994) Temporary repairs to complete voyage US$100,000 Assumed savings:- Cost of handling cargo…….US$50,000 Extra detention expenses to effect permanent repairs………. 25,000 Allowance in GA…..US$75,000 Excess US$25,000 not allowable.

Temporary repairs (2004) Temporary repairs …..US$100,000 Permanent repairs…… 400,000 US$500,000 If estimated permanent repairs at port of refuge:- A. If US$500,000 = no GA allowance B. If US$450,000 = US$50,000 allowable, subject to GA savings Rules result in higher claim PA claim on Hull Underwriters but lower costs to Cargo Underwriters.

Transhipment/ forwarding cargo 1974/ 1994/ 2004 Rules Owners not normally obliged to forward cargo Requires special agreement Savings in costs allowable Allowances under 1994/2004 Rules limited to costs which cargo interests would incur forwarding at their own expense (Hull Underwriters may be liable for the extra costs which not GA)

GA Commission and Interest 2004 Rules No commission allowable under 2004 Rules to party paying GA expenditure. Benefit to Underwriters but considerable loss to Shipowners as they usually incur the expenditure (previously 2% excluding crew wages and fuel replaced after the voyage). Rate of interest on GA expenditure and sacrifices to be set annually by CMI under 2004 Rules. Previously 7% fixed rate under 1974/ 1994 Rules. Likely benefits to Underwriters but considerable losses to Shipowners.

Time Bar New rule in 2004 – Subject to mandatory rule on time limitation under any applicable law: - Rights to GA contribution cease unless party claiming brings legal action within 1 year of GA Adjustment issue date. - No action can be brought after 6 years from termination of GA voyage. - These periods can be extended by agreement of the parties. - Rule does not apply between the GA parties and their Underwriters.

Summary of changes in 2004 Salvage excluded except when paid by one party. No crew wages during detention at port of refuge. Different treatment of temporary repairs. No commission (previously 2%) CMI set rate of interest annually (previously 7% p.a.). Time bar provision.

Example comparing GA allowances Allowance Salvage US$ 500,000 Remains as paid Wages to port of refuge 2,5002,500 Wages at port of refuge17, Temporary repairs75,000 50,000 Commission 11, Interest 40,000 2,000 (if 4%) US$ 646,500 54,500

General Average in future Shipowners may continue to insist on YAR 1974 or 1994 as more favourable than B/Ls providing for 1994 YAR still apply as YAR 2004 are new set of rules, not an amendment or modification of 1994 Rules. Absorption clauses could reduce number of GA claims against cargo. BIMCO Average Bond Clause may reduce time and costs of collecting GA security.

End of Voyage