Introduction to Legal Analysis, Weight of Authority & Dicta Syllabus Review © Professor Njeri Mathis Rutledge, LRW.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
By Vikash kumar, Yashvardhan Singh & group 1 ST YEAR (B.B.A LLb.)
Advertisements

Courts and Court Systems Chapter 2. Copyright © 2007 Thomson Delmar Learning Objectives Explain the difference between trial and appellate courts. Explain.
Our Precedential Court System
Case Law: The Courts Trial courts are the entry to the court system. Trial courts are where attorneys present evidence and make arguments, and a judge.
United States Legal System. Three Branches of Government.
Law and Legal Reasoning Enforceable rules governing relationships among individuals and between individuals and their society Enforceable rules governing.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2011 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 1 Legal Foundations.
UNIT 3 LEGAL STUDIES AO3- THE ROLE OF THE COURTS
The Court System By: Professor Mika Cleveland Marshall Law.
Doctrine of Precedent.
Legal Research 101: Researching Local, State & Federal Cases Rita Kaiser, King County Law Library & Ann Hemmens, University of Washington Law Library Washington.
CS 5060, Fall 2009 Digital Intellectual Property Law u Class web page at: u No textbook. Online treatise at:
Law 11 Introduction. 2 Sources of American Law o Constitutions – federal plus every state; everyone in U.S. subject to federal constitution plus one state.
Chapter 1 – Business and Personal Law. Judicial Decisions In the American legal system, judicial (court) decisions are primary sources of law, in addition.
 Introduction to the legal system and legal research  Using electronic tools to find legal authority and resources  Conclusion/Question & Answer.
4 CHAPTER 4: APPLICATION OF LAW. Using Case Law Court Hierarchy.
Legal Analysis Rationale. What it is Reason for the decision or holding “The opinion” Utilizes traditional forms of logic Deductive Start with rule More.
Lecture for the Georgian Bar Association October, 17, 2014 Professor Edward C. Harris Chicago-Kent College of Law Copyright © 2014.
Sources of Law Chapter 5. Introduction American legal system is based on English law  Colonists who first came to the US were governed by the English.
PA201 Introduction to Legal Research Unit 2 – Statutory Research A. E. Sloan (2009). Basic Legal Research Tools and Strategies (4 th ed.). New York: Aspen.
Chapter Three Laws: Their Sources. Constitutional Law The federal government and each state have constitutions. Constitutions are documents whose primary.
Chapter Four Finding the Law: Legal Research. Primary Sources Constitutions Statutes Case Law Ordinances.
California Law January 21 Sources of Law. SOURCES OF LAW CONSTITUTIONS CASE LAW STATUTORY LAW ADMINISTRATIVE REGULATIONS LOCAL ORDINANCES Rules of Court.
Unit 2 - Analyzing Statutory Law and Legislative History.
Chapter 1 The Fundamentals of Authority Legal Analysis: The application of law to facts.
Common law legal systems vs. Civil law legal systems.
YR 12 LEGAL STUDIES How courts make law. Chapter overview This chapter looks at the concepts of Common law Doctrine of precedent Judgments and precedents.
Unit 2 Legal Research What is the law?. There are four main sources of law Constitutions Statutes Court opinions (also called cases) Administrative regulations.
Goals: Students will 1. Complete discussion re case law study. 2. Understand basic legal jurisprudence. 3. Take first vocabulary quiz. 4. Understand the.
American Law: Structure and Authority Margaret Schilt Associate Law Librarian for User Services D’Angelo Law Library.
Introduction to American Law Government and Legal System.
Assignment Define Law According to the Austin’s theory of Law. Also write down different kinds of Law.
Law and Legal Reasoning
Chapter 1 The Legal Environment
 Is used to point out the origin or the beginning of the stream law.  Is used to denote the causes of law or the matter of which law is composed.  By.
USING SHEPARD’S & KEYCITE EFFECTIVELY Melissa Sievers Librarian RFK Main Library
Chapter Four Finding the Law: Legal Research. Introduction to Law, 4 th Edition Hames and Ekern © 2010 Pearson Higher Education, Upper Saddle River, NJ.
judicial review  the court’s authority to review a law to determine whether the law is in conflict with the Constitution.
- My name is Mitzi Dease Paige and I am your instructor. I want you to know I am committed to assisting you in making this a great learning experience.
Chapter 1 U.S. Legal System. Chapter Objectives After reading this chapter, you will know the following: The primary sources of law in the U.S. legal.
Legal Reference Questions in a Non-Law Library May 17, 2016 Joan Shear, Boston College Law Library Suzanne Hoey, Massachusetts Trial Court Libraries.
LRW Research 2. Review  Sources of Authority Enacted law Enacted law ConstitutionsConstitutions StatutesStatutes Court rulesCourt rules Administrative.
Judicial Precedent As Law. Judicial Precedent Judicial precedent refers to sources of law where past decisions of the judges create law for future judges.
THE ABILITY OF JUDGES TO MAKE LAW. INTRODUCTION: COMMON LAW  Common law – founded in England, adopted by Australia  It is law developed through the.
Types of Laws Chapter 1-2. Sources of Law What’s Your Verdict? (pg. 10) The federal constitution guarantees the citizens of the U.S. many rights. These.
Chapter 2: Legal Research Presented by: Alexis Saperstein.
Understanding legal authority for research purposes What is LAW? How do we define it?
Chapter 1 U.S. Legal System.
V. SOURCES OF LAW APPLICABLE TO FLORIDA CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS
U.S. Legal System Chapter 1.
Introduction to the American Legal System
Courts of Law Also called “king’s courts” where judges were appointed by the king. Remedies limited to those provided at law, i.e., land, chattel, money.
Analogizing and Distinguishing Cases
Hames/Ekern: Introduction to Law, 3rd edition
Legal Research and Analysis
The Federal Judicial System: Applying the Law
How Laws are Made: The Courts.
CHAPTER 12 CASE LAW ANALYSIS
Sources of Law Legislature – makes law Executive – enforces law
United States Legal System
Paralegal’s Role in Research
Advanced Legal Analysis and Writing Class 1
Class Exercise Class Website How a Bill Becomes a Law.
Sources of Law Legislature – makes law Executive – enforces law
The Role of the Courts in Law-Making
Precedent.
Sources of law Mrs. Hill.
Introduction to Law Law- set of rules, rights, and obligations that are binding on a society. Formal code of conduct. Law can be classified by its source,
Chapter 6— Case Law Analysis
Chapter 1 Test Review.
Presentation transcript:

Introduction to Legal Analysis, Weight of Authority & Dicta Syllabus Review © Professor Njeri Mathis Rutledge, LRW

Stare Decisis stä’-rā dě-sī-sĭs legal doctrine when judicial opinions operate as law short for stare decisis et non quieta movere – is a Latin term meaning : “to stand by precedents and not disturb settled points.”

What’s a Precedent? A court’s past decision, recognized as authority

Mandatory or Binding Precedent Refers to authority the courts are required to follow To determine if precedent is mandatory you must determine: –whether the earlier case arose out of the same jurisdiction as the current court –whether the earlier case was by a higher court –whether the case is factually similar applying the same law

Persuasive or Non-Binding Precedent Refers to a case the court may consider, but is not required to follow. Usually considered if the issue of law was not previously litigated in the particular jurisdiction, so the court will look to other cases for guidance

Vertical System State courts must follow precedents from higher courts in the same jurisdiction Federal courts bound by higher courts in the same jurisdiction

Court of Last Resort  Intermediate Appellate Court  Trial Court

Primary Sources of Law Common law (judicial decisions) from Judges Enacted Law (statutes, constitutions, administrative regulations)

Secondary Sources of Law Sources that explain or give commentary on primary authorities Not considered very persuasive, but help locate primary authority Examples: treatises, hornbooks, law review articles, legal encyclopedias

Hierarchical Relationship of Primary Authority Constitutions –May place constraints on state statutes and case opinions that are contradictory Statutes –May constrain case law and administrative regulations or rulings –But a court may still interpret meaning of a statute or constitutional provision to determine if it applies Case law –May constrain administrative decisions Administrative decisions

Which Has Greatest Precedential Value A state statute or an opinion of that state’s highest court An agency regulation or a state statute A state constitutional provision or a state statute

An opinion of the state’s highest court or ruling by a state agency State constitutional provision or an opinion from state’s highest court Example adapted from Linda H. Edwards, Legal Writing & Analysis (2003).

Holding vs. Dicta Holding – statement in the court’s decision about the issues before it (the court’s answer) Courts bound by precedent are only bound by the holding of the prior cases Courts are not bound by dicta Holding is limited to the court’s statements resolving the question actually at issue (issues necessary to the result reached)

Holding vs. Dicta Dicta – remarks that are not essential to the holding Dicta – can be statements about principles of law Dicta – statements about how the law might apply in hypothetical facts A judge may choose to follow dicta, (persuasive) but is never bound to do so In some cases the dicta may be debatable

Example, State v. Haley Fn. 5 The state contends that we answered this question in the affirmative in State v. Peters, supra. The defendant in Peters alleged that his mother’s illness required him to drive her to the hospital. The severity of the defendant’s mother’s illness was not in issue, but we noted in passing that “the jury could have found [from the evidence] that the situation appeared to defendant to be life threatening.”... The issue in Peters involved the second element. Our brief discussion of the “injury” element was therefore dictum rather than a considered interpretation of the pertinent statutory language.

Holding vs. Dicta The holding in a case can be formulated narrowly or broadly When writing about judicial decisions, choose your words wisely –Example: for the holding try—the court held –Example: for dicta try—the court stated, explained, or hypothesized

Exercise – recognizing holding & dictum

Dictum or Holding An item must be physically delivered unless physical delivery would be impracticable.

Dictum or Holding An item locked in a safe deposit box in a bank closed for the weekend need not be physically delivered.

Dictum or Holding A small, light, freely accessible item must be physically delivered in order to complete a valid gift.

Dictum or Holding To constitute a valid gift of personal property, the donor must manifest his intention to make the gift.

Analyzing Statutes

Statutes Defined – written law enacted by a legislature Both federal and state statutes Local statutes from city or county government - ordinances

Locating Statutes Codes Statutes are usually divided into titles, topical areas Further divided into sections §

Annotated Code Some statutes, like cases published multiple places Annotated code has text of the statute and research references. –Historical notes, case summaries, cites to secondary sources Unannotated code only has the text of the statute.

Statutes & Legal Analysis Thinking or writing about legal analysis –Begin with the statute –Follow with cases interpreting the statute If a statute has been interpreted by the courts, discuss the relevant case law If there is binding precedent interpreting the statute, explain how the interpretation applies to the facts of your problem