Where are we and which way forward? Isabelle Ramdoo 12 November 2013, Helsinski Economic Partnership Agreements.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
REGIONALISM: A TRADE STRATEGY FOR AFRICA? Paul Kalenga WTO SYMPOSIUM 21 April 2005.
Advertisements

1 Overview of Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) and related fisheries issues European Commission 15 June 2005 EU/ACP Economic Partnership Agreements.
AN ANALYSIS OF EU-SOUTHERN AFRICAN RELATIONS Medicine Masiiwa University of Zimbabwe
EPAs and services in 2008 and beyond What challenges lie ahead for the ACP countries?
The future of EU-Africa trade relations Isabelle Ramdoo ECDPM 24 July 2014 Is there a life after EPAs?
Regional Trade Agreements and the WTO Jo-Ann Crawford, RTA Section, TPRD
Institute for World Economics and International Management - IWIM The Challenges of EPAs for Regional Integration and Trade Capacity Building in Southern.
SADC EPA NEGOTIATIONS tralac EPA REVIEW WORKSHOP LYNETTE GITONGA 23 January 2008.
1 INTERNATIONAL TRADE ARRANGEMENTS SA TRADE AGREEMENTS DIRECTORATE: INTERNATIONAL TRADE FEBRUARY 2012.
Short courses on key international economic issues for delegates from permanent missions in Geneva Trade agreements between developed and developing countries.
Market Access to the EU: Rules of Origin Eckart Naumann tralac Conference Stellenbosch, South Africa November 2004.
Agency, Resistance and Regional Disunity Negotiating an Economic Partnership Agreement between the EU and Southern Africa Peg Murray-Evans University of.
F. Matambalya / Cotton Marketing1 State of Play of the EAC-EU EPA Negotiations By Prof. Francis Matambalya University of Dar es Salaam
South Africa’s Regional Trade Agenda: Reflections on SACU, SADC, EPAs
Africa Regional Workshop on WTO Negotiations Trade Preferences : EPA /WTO Negotiations 02 September 2005 Cape Town, South Africa Paulina M. Elago Deputy.
1 Economic Partnership Agreements: A new approach to ACP-EU economic and trade cooperation Claude Maerten, European Commission Head of Unit TRADE C 2
Trade Agreements: Main challenges the EU sugar sector Plenary Meeting-Sectoral Social Dialogue Committee on Sugar Patrick PAGANI.
The interim EPAs – some facts TIPS Workshop, Pretoria 4-5 March Dr Mareike Meyn.
EPAs and regional integration – what future for SADC and COMESA? TIPS Workshop, Pretoria 4-5 March Dr Mareike Meyn.
Briefing Notes on EPA Negotiations Presentation to Joint Foreign Affairs and Trade and Industry Hearings, 27/2/2008.
Where are we and what challenges for development? Isabelle Ramdoo 13 November 2013, The Hague Economic Partnership Agreements.
Overview of Day 1 Ximena Gonzalez 4th March 2008 Subtitle: Presenter: Date: TIPS/AusAID EPA Workshop.
1 EPA REVIEW WORKSHOP Cape Town, South Africa REVIEW OF THE SADC EPA NEGOTIATIONS Paul Kalenga 23 January 2008.
Negotiating Services in the SADC EPA tralac Cape Town 20 Febr Gerhard Erasmus.
1 UPDATE ON THE EPA NEGOTIATIONS CUTS/WTO Regional Outreach Workshop Nairobi. By: Ambassador Nathan Irumba SEATINI (Uganda )
Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA) and the Pacific Trinnex, Proinvest Vanuatu, August 2010.
What are the costs of a non-EPA? TIPS Workshop, Pretoria 4-5 March Dr Mareike Meyn.
Workshop on PACP EPA Market Access Offers August 2010 Shangri-La's Fijian Resort Sigatoka, Fiji.
Current Affairs-SADC-EAC-COMESA (TFTA)  Tripartite launched June 2011 in SA with objective to pursue FTA, cross- border infrastructure and regional industrial.
TRALAC ANNUAL CONFERENCE WTO/EPA ISSUES 13 October 2005 Cape Town, South Africa Paulina M. Elago Deputy Director: TFCBP TRADE HUB GABORONE.
ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENTS NEGOTIATING OBJECTIVES AND STRATEGIES OF AND OUTCOMES FOR SUB-SAHARAN AFRICAN COUNTRIES Ambassador Nathan Irumba Executive.
ECDPMPage 1. Francis Osiemo, ECDPM ICTSD/TMEA/UoN Policy Dialogue, 23 September 2015 Nairobi, Kenya Advancing Regional Integration.
DEPARTMENT: AGRICULTURE AGRICULTURAL TRADE NEGOTIATIONS GERDA VAN DIJK SENIOR MANAGER: INTERNATIONAL TRADE PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE FOR AGRICULTURE 22 FEBRUARY.
Week 6: Trade and Regionalism in Africa Development Problems in Africa Spring 2006.
Current situation and future prospects 27 th Meeting of the ACP-EU Economic and Social Interests Groups EESC, October 2014 Isabelle Ramdoo Deputy.
Current situation and future prospects 27 th Meeting of the ACP-EU Economic and Social Interests Groups EESC, October 2014 Isabelle Ramdoo Deputy.
The EPA Negotiations in Africa & at the SADC level: some comments Subtitle: Presenter: Date: TIPS Myriam Velia 5th March 2008.
Economic Partnership Agreements: Development Challenges for Southern Africa Paul Kalenga Trade Law Centre for Southern Africa.
The new EPAs – comparative analysis of contents and challenges for 2008 Christopher Stevens, Mareike Meyn, and Jane Kennan.
PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON TRADE AND INDUSTRY 1 CHEESE AGREEMENT MR. VICTOR MASHABELA CHIEF DIRECTOR: BILATERAL TRADE RELATIONS INTERNATIONAL.
© WTO - OMC The WTO Influence in EU FTAs, through the dispute settlement lens CLEER, The Hague, November 2010 Edna Ramirez-Robles.
Economic Partnership Agreements and Regional Integration Paul Kalenga Tralac Annual Trade Law Conference 11 November 2004.
EPAs - what has happened so far? TIPS Workshop, Pretoria 4-5 March Dr Mareike Meyn.
ACP- EU Trade. Regional Overview  million people  GDP 472 bn Euros  Total EU-ACP trade 86.5 bn Euros  This represents 4.3% EU trade but 29.7%
International Trade and Economic Development Update on WTO, TPR and EPA Presented to the Portfolio Committee on Trade and Industry By: Dr Rob Davies Minister.
1 Economic Partnership Agreements: A new approach to ACP-EU economic and trade cooperation Remco VAHL, DG TRADE Brussels, 13 June 2005.
STATUS & EXPECTED OUTCOMES OF JOINING THE EAST AFRICAN COMMUNITY By Justin NSENGIYUMVA Secretary General Ministry of Commerce, Industry, Investment Promotion,
1 TRADE AGREEMENTS: IMPACTS ON AFRICA (AGOA & THE EU-SADC ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT KZN EXPORT WEEK 27 – 29 October 2015.
Mareike MeynInstitute for World Economics and International Management - IWIM ICTSD Workshop Untangling Fisheries and Trade: Towards Priorities for Action.
Europe and the Least Developed Countries (LDCs): trade, aid and the ACP states.
TRADE POLICY OPTIONS FOR EASTERN AND SOUTHERN AFRICA Paul Kalenga 14 TH OCTOBER 2005.
Economic Partnership Agreeements European Commission Directorate- General Trade 1.
EPA NEGOTIATIONS IN SADC Paul Kalenga Trade Policy Adviser RTFP / SADC Secretariat April 2, 2007.
Presentation to the Select Committee on Trade and International Relations on the SADC and EU Economic Partnership Agreement Presentation by Ms Niki Kruger.
Sustainability and human rights in EPAs: Dr San Bilal (& Isabelle Ramdoo) German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development BMZ, Berlin,
Presentation on the SADC and EU Economic Partnership Agreement
Legal and Institutional Aspects of SACU
Update on EPA Negotiations
Impact of Trade Agreements on South African Business
TRALAC Conference 13 –14 October 2005 Cape Town
Overview of the Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA)
The interim EPAs – some facts
EPAs - what has happened so far?
Preferential Trade Agreements Or Trade blocs Ch. 12
Chief Director: Trade Negotiations
Department of Trade and Industry
DIRCO PRESENTATION ON The SADC-EU Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA) Impact on South Africa’s Foreign Policy.
SADC-EU EPA: AN OPPORTUNITY
ACP-EU Negotiations of Economic Partnership Agreements:
CHEESE AGREEMENT BETWEEN SOUTH AFRICA AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Presentation transcript:

Where are we and which way forward? Isabelle Ramdoo 12 November 2013, Helsinski Economic Partnership Agreements

1.Setting the scene 2.Some key facts 3.Where are we now? Some figures and the state of play of the negotiations 4.Challenges ahead 5.What are the risks? 1.Which way forward? Structure of presentation ECDPMPage 2

Prior to 2008: Lome to Cotonou Preferences: unilateral, non- reciprocal preferential market access BUT not compatible with WTO Difficult, uncertain and costly WTO waivers between Art 36 Cotonou Agreement: parties committed to start EPA negotiation to address WTO compatibility Since 2008 – Trade outside of Cotonou agreement. EPAs are stand-alone agreements; However: many unfinished negotiations – to avoid trade disruption, EC Reg. 1528/2007 – provisional application of EPAs for countries that had at least initialed an EPA (although interim) Deadline to finalise all unfinished business: 1 st October Setting the scene: Key milestones ECDPMPage 3

Stage I 09/2002 – 09/2003: All ACP negotiations Stage II 10/2003 – 2007: Regional negotiations  West Africa: 16 countries (ECOWAS + Mauritania)  Central Africa: 8 countries  East and Southern Africa: 11 countries (COMESA minus)  East African Community: 5 countries (full region)  Southern Africa – 6 countries + SA joined later (SADC minus)  Caribbean region – 15 countries  Pacific: Pacific Forum – 14 countries Since then: Only 1 full EPA (CARIFORUM) signed in 2008; 1 African region ESA (4 countries) signed in 2009 – all countries ratified. The remaining 17 countries (have agreements that are legally challenging Africa: CA (Cameroun signed in 2009, not ratified) West Africa: Ivory Coast and Ghana 2. Refresher: Key facts ECDPMPage 4

3.a Where are we now? ECDPMPage 5

3.b Countries concerned by deadline and regime applied in 2014 ECDPMPage 6

Source: Bartels L & Goodison P (2011): EU Proposal to end preferences for 18 African and Pacific States : An Assessment – Trade Hot Topics, Commonwealth Secretariat – Figures are from c Who will be affected and by how much? Biggest losers: Fiji (97.4% exports) Swaziland (96.3%) Both sugar exporters (€339/tonne) Kenya and Namibia also likely to suffer Page 7ECDPM

1.ECOWAS: 2 main issues 1.Market access offer 2.Development chapter (PAPED – additional resources) 3.Other contentious issues: MFN Clause; EU Domestic subsidies and support to agriculture; Obligations to negotiate FTAs with countries where EU has CU (Turkey, San Marino, Andorra) 2. EAC: Mainly contentious issues 1.Export taxes; MFN, 2.RoO; 3.Agriculture; 4.non -execution clause (ICC/Kenya) 3. State of Play of current negotiations Page 8ECDPM

3. SADC: 1.Export taxes, MFN 2.South Africa/SACU market access both on agriculture and NAMA; RoO cumulation with SA; 3.infant/distress industries; 4. Central Africa: 1.Slow negotiations. 2.Key remaining issues include MA offer; MFN, Export taxes development 5. Pacific: Recently agreed to freeze negotiations because of fisheries 6. ESA: 1 outstanding issue: customs cooperation agreement but not an issue with deadline ECDPMPage 9

Deadline 1 st Oct So far, on contention issues, little flexibility on both sides Timeline towards deadline: given pace of negotiations, even if negotiations are completed there might be problems with implementation Risk of failure: Some countries might be left without preferences; likely implications for regional integration (Kenya? Ivory Coast? Cameroun? Swaziland?) 4. Challenges ahead ECDPMPage 10

If agreements are concluded: Timeline is unrealistic Risk of trade disruption pending ratification: economically challenging and politically unacceptable If trade talk collapse: some countries may sign for fear of market disruption; big risk for regional (dis)integration; multiple trade regimes applicable to exports to EU with negative impacts on RI Diplomatic and political challenges : EU-Africa Summit – risk of derailing strategic discussions; mistrust at level of countries/regions; More broadly: geostrategic implications – partners might turn elsewhere 5. Risks ahead ECDPMPage 11

10 years on, all technical possibilities have been explored; but yet no agreement Becoming evident that EPA has negative impact on the overall Europe-Africa relationship; Increasingly urgent to promote positive and constructive atmosphere to maintain the broader strategic relations between Europe and Africa Needs pragmatic and realistic solutions on both sides: outcome most likely to be resolved at political level Important to weigh the political cost of a possible failure/ undesirable outcome within the broader EU-Africa relationship; 6. Which way forward? ECDPMPage 12

Best way is to prepare for the worst! But are we prepared for a failure? What “extra-mile” are we ready to go or can we afford to go? Prepare for “smooth landing” if/when negotiations fail: agree to disagree and anticipate how to continue to engage constructively should that happen. ECDPMPage 13

Thank you Isabelle Ramdoo Page 14