Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Analysis of power spectra of Sun-like stars using a Bayesian Approach Thierry Appourchaux Symposium.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Modeling of Data. Basic Bayes theorem Bayes theorem relates the conditional probabilities of two events A, and B: A might be a hypothesis and B might.
Advertisements

Bayesian Estimation in MARK
Inspiral Parameter Estimation via Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) Methods Nelson Christensen Carleton College LIGO-G Z.
Lectures on Stochastic System Analysis and Bayesian Updating June 29-July James L. Beck, California Institute of Technology Jianye Ching, National.
TNO orbit computation: analysing the observed population Jenni Virtanen Observatory, University of Helsinki Workshop on Transneptunian objects - Dynamical.
Bayesian statistics – MCMC techniques
Gaussian Processes to Speed up Hamiltonian Monte Carlo Matthieu Lê Journal Club 11/04/141 Neal, Radford M (2011). " MCMC Using Hamiltonian Dynamics. "
Transit Analysis Package Zach Gazak John Tonry John Johnson.
Patrick Gaulme Thierry Appourchaux Othman Benomar Mode identification with CoRoT and Kepler solar- like oscillation spectra 1 SOHO-GONG XXIV, Aix en Provence.
Paper Discussion: “Simultaneous Localization and Environmental Mapping with a Sensor Network”, Marinakis et. al. ICRA 2011.
Deciding, Estimating, Computing, Checking How are Bayesian posteriors used, computed and validated?
CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL SEQUENCE ANALYSIS Bayesian Inference Anders Gorm Pedersen Molecular Evolution Group Center for Biological Sequence Analysis Technical.
Part 4 b Forward-Backward Algorithm & Viterbi Algorithm CSE717, SPRING 2008 CUBS, Univ at Buffalo.
Course overview Tuesday lecture –Those not presenting turn in short review of a paper using the method being discussed Thursday computer lab –Turn in short.
End of Chapter 8 Neil Weisenfeld March 28, 2005.
CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL SEQUENCE ANALYSIS Bayesian Inference Anders Gorm Pedersen Molecular Evolution Group Center for Biological Sequence Analysis Technical.
G. Cowan Lectures on Statistical Data Analysis Lecture 14 page 1 Statistical Data Analysis: Lecture 14 1Probability, Bayes’ theorem 2Random variables and.
IE 594 : Research Methodology – Discrete Event Simulation David S. Kim Spring 2009.
Bayes Factor Based on Han and Carlin (2001, JASA).
1 Bayesian methods for parameter estimation and data assimilation with crop models Part 2: Likelihood function and prior distribution David Makowski and.
Overview G. Jogesh Babu. Probability theory Probability is all about flip of a coin Conditional probability & Bayes theorem (Bayesian analysis) Expectation,
G. Cowan SUSSP65, St Andrews, August 2009 / Statistical Methods 1 page 1 Statistical Methods in Particle Physics Lecture 1: Bayesian methods SUSSP65.
Bayesian parameter estimation in cosmology with Population Monte Carlo By Darell Moodley (UKZN) Supervisor: Prof. K Moodley (UKZN) SKA Postgraduate conference,
1 Physical Fluctuomatics 5th and 6th Probabilistic information processing by Gaussian graphical model Kazuyuki Tanaka Graduate School of Information Sciences,
ECE 5984: Introduction to Machine Learning Dhruv Batra Virginia Tech Topics: –Statistical Estimation (MLE, MAP, Bayesian) Readings: Barber 8.6, 8.7.
CSC321: 2011 Introduction to Neural Networks and Machine Learning Lecture 11: Bayesian learning continued Geoffrey Hinton.
Bayesian analysis for Pulsar Timing Arrays Rutger van Haasteren (Leiden) Yuri Levin (Leiden) Pat McDonald (CITA) Ting-Ting Lu (Toronto)
G. Cowan Lectures on Statistical Data Analysis Lecture 1 page 1 Lectures on Statistical Data Analysis London Postgraduate Lectures on Particle Physics;
Fast Simulators for Assessment and Propagation of Model Uncertainty* Jim Berger, M.J. Bayarri, German Molina June 20, 2001 SAMO 2001, Madrid *Project of.
Maximum Likelihood - "Frequentist" inference x 1,x 2,....,x n ~ iid N( ,  2 ) Joint pdf for the whole random sample Maximum likelihood estimates.
Bayesian Reasoning: Tempering & Sampling A/Prof Geraint F. Lewis Rm 560:
Bayesian Phylogenetics. Bayes Theorem Pr(Tree|Data) = Pr(Data|Tree) x Pr(Tree) Pr(Data)
1 Tree Crown Extraction Using Marked Point Processes Guillaume Perrin Xavier Descombes – Josiane Zerubia ARIANA, joint research group CNRS/INRIA/UNSA INRIA.
3rd International Workshop on Dark Matter, Dark Energy and Matter-Antimatter Asymmetry NTHU & NTU, Dec 27—31, 2012 Likelihood of the Matter Power Spectrum.
Markov Chain Monte Carlo for LDA C. Andrieu, N. D. Freitas, and A. Doucet, An Introduction to MCMC for Machine Learning, R. M. Neal, Probabilistic.
BAYES and FREQUENTISM: The Return of an Old Controversy 1 Louis Lyons Imperial College and Oxford University CERN Summer Students July 2014.
Reducing MCMC Computational Cost With a Two Layered Bayesian Approach
SUPA Advanced Data Analysis Course, Jan 6th – 7th 2009 Advanced Data Analysis for the Physical Sciences Dr Martin Hendry Dept of Physics and Astronomy.
1 Chapter 8: Model Inference and Averaging Presented by Hui Fang.
CS Statistical Machine learning Lecture 25 Yuan (Alan) Qi Purdue CS Nov
Bayesian Modelling Harry R. Erwin, PhD School of Computing and Technology University of Sunderland.
Statistical NLP: Lecture 4 Mathematical Foundations I: Probability Theory (Ch2)
Introduction: Metropolis-Hasting Sampler Purpose--To draw samples from a probability distribution There are three steps 1Propose a move from x to y 2Accept.
G. Cowan SUSSP65, St Andrews, August 2009 / Statistical Methods 1 page 1 Statistical Methods in Particle Physics Lecture 1: Bayesian methods SUSSP65.
Density Estimation in R Ha Le and Nikolaos Sarafianos COSC 7362 – Advanced Machine Learning Professor: Dr. Christoph F. Eick 1.
Ch 1. Introduction Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning, C. M. Bishop, Updated by J.-H. Eom (2 nd round revision) Summarized by K.-I.
CSC321: Lecture 8: The Bayesian way to fit models Geoffrey Hinton.
Monte Carlo Sampling to Inverse Problems Wojciech Dębski Inst. Geophys. Polish Acad. Sci. 1 st Orfeus workshop: Waveform inversion.
Overview G. Jogesh Babu. R Programming environment Introduction to R programming language R is an integrated suite of software facilities for data manipulation,
10 October, 2007 University of Glasgow 1 EM Algorithm with Markov Chain Monte Carlo Method for Bayesian Image Analysis Kazuyuki Tanaka Graduate School.
Generalization Performance of Exchange Monte Carlo Method for Normal Mixture Models Kenji Nagata, Sumio Watanabe Tokyo Institute of Technology.
Markov Chain Monte Carlo in R
CS479/679 Pattern Recognition Dr. George Bebis
Probability Theory and Parameter Estimation I
Graduate School of Information Sciences, Tohoku University
Bayesian data analysis
Ch3: Model Building through Regression
Introduction to the bayes Prefix in Stata 15
Special Topics In Scientific Computing
Multidimensional Integration Part I
Filtering and State Estimation: Basic Concepts
Statistical NLP: Lecture 4
Graduate School of Information Sciences, Tohoku University
Appetizer: Statistical methods in XSPEC
Lecture 11 Generalizations of EM.
#10 The Central Limit Theorem
CS639: Data Management for Data Science
Bayesian Statistics on a Shoestring Assaf Oron, May 2008
The Nathan Kline Institute, NY
Computing and Statistical Data Analysis / Stat 10
Presentation transcript:

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Analysis of power spectra of Sun-like stars using a Bayesian Approach Thierry Appourchaux Symposium COROT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Contents Bayesian over frequentists How does a Bayesian approach work? Results for asteroseismology Conclusion

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Frequentist (MLE) Parameters to be evaluated (frequency,…) Data (power spectra,…) Information (a priori) Likelihood

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Frequentist (MLE)

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Bayes theorem Posterior probability Prior probability Normalisation factor Parameters to be evaluated (frequency,…) Data (power spectra,…) Information (a priori) Likelihood

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Bayesian over frequentist Bayesians address the question everyone is interested in by using assumptions no-one believes. (i.e. the validity of the prior) Frequentists use impeccable logic to deal with an isssue of no interest to anyone. (i.e. the trueness of the likelihood) Lyons (2007)

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Bayes theorem in practice A priori: any information known (statistics, parameters,…) What ? –the posterior probability of the parameters How ? –Set prior probability for the parameters knowing what you know (or believe to know…) –Express likelihood of the data given the parameters –Recover Posterior probability by: In full using Markov Chains or Maximizing the Posterior probability (MAP) –Recover global likelihood of the model Gregory (2005)

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) Example with a Gaussian prior: See Gaulme et al (MAP) Poster P-II-013

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) Primary objective: recover in full the posterior probability If analytical solution not feasible use numerical solution using MCMC based on the Metropolis-Hasting algorithm Explore space parameters with parallel tempering Provide either the full posterior probability or the median and the associated quartiles Recover global likelihood of the model See Benomar et al (Markov Chains) Poster P-II-012

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Some results Benomar et al (MCMC) Poster P-II-012 Gaulme et al (MAP) Poster P-II-013

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 MLE: –Garcia et alPoster P-II-016 –Deheuvels et alPoster P-II-018 Bayes: –Reegen Poster P-I-005 –Benomar et al (Markov Chains)Poster P-II-012 –Gaulme et al(MAP)Poster P-II-013 –Campante et al (MAP)Poster P-II-015 Power spectrum fitting

Symposium CoRoT 2009 – Cité Universitaire – 2 February 2009 Conclusion Bayesian approach is slowly starting A lot work needed for exploring various alleys Don’t forget: the Bayesian approach is more conservative… …and look at the posters