RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May 20061 Australia’s Anti-Terrorism Legislation: The National Security State and the Community Legal Sector Dr Mark.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Department of Human Services Sex, HIV and the law Dr Rosemary Lester Communicable Disease Control Unit Department of Human Services.
Advertisements

Revision – AREA OF STUDY 1 PARLIAMENT AND THE CITIZEN
World Society for the Protection of Animals Indicators for Enforcement – a global perspective Enforcement of European Animal Welfare Related Legislation.
Action on Elder Abuse. Much, but not all, of the new legislation is about infrastructure Statutory basis of Safeguarding Boards A duty to cooperate Brief.
Pearson Education, Inc., Longman © 2006 Chapter 15 Civil Liberties Policymaking American Government: Policy & Politics, Eighth Edition TANNAHILL.
The Bill of Rights and the Criminal Trial Process.
Bali Process Technical Expert Workshop on Mutual Legal Assistance and Law Enforcement Bangkok, Thailand, June 2011 Celia Maunder International Crime Cooperation.
Lecturer: Miljen Matijašević Session 8, 7 May 2014.
Using human rights in domestic law: Jack Thomas case study Cecilia Riebl Lawyer July 2008.
Chapter 17 Law and Terrorism.
Chapter 15 Counter-terrorism. Introduction  United and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism.
Preventing Violent Extremism: ASB in relation to the policing of security Dr Basia Spalek Institute of Applied Social Studies University of Birmingham.
29 May 2006RNSA Workshop 1 Social Implication of National Security RNSA Workshop The risk of public data availability on critical infrastructure protection.
APEC – Sydney September 2007 Kirrillie Moore Senior Solicitor April 2006 – September 2007 Objectives: Generally - To identify the inequalities in the laws,
UNCLASSIFIED Strategies for leading crisis command across organisations for greater interoperability Superintendant Michael Chew AFP ACTP – Counter Terrorism.
“ Strengthening the prevention of torture in the Philippines through enhancing policy and collaboration between all relevant stakeholders”
Brad Butt MP February 10, – criminalize the advocacy or promotion of terrorism offences in general; – counter terrorist recruitment by giving our.
1 OVERVIEW PRESENTATION FREEDOM OF INFORMATION (SCOTLAND) ACT 2002.
+ Protecting Individual Liberties Section 1 Chapter 14.
Law and Terrorism “The laws will thus not be silent in time of war, but they will speak with a somewhat different voice.” Chief Justice Rehnquist.
1 Bioterrorism and Legal Issues: Commonwealth of Massachusetts Donna E. Levin, Esq. General Counsel Massachusetts Department of Public Health.
Chapter 2 The criminal investigation process. In this chapter, you will look at the role of police and the courts in the criminal investigation process.
NSW Interagency Guidelines for Child Protection Intervention 2006 Briefing Information Session Child Protection Senior Officers Group.
The Patriot Act Protecting the US or Violating People’s Freedoms.
Legal Studies Law enforcement agencies Today we will investigate law enforcement agencies: Definition Jurisdiction Roles Using court cases, statutes and.
 The bicameral System  The structure of the Commonwealth and Victorian Parliament  Role of the Upper and Lower house in both Federal and State Parliaments.
Anti-terrorism legislation.  What are human rights  Anti-terrorism legislation  Human rights protection in Australia.
Choose a category. You will be given the answer. You must give the correct question. Click to begin.
Preparing for SAC 2B Monday 27 May Focus your revision on…  Restrictions on the power of the Commonwealth and the State Parliaments  The role.
Legal Aid of Cambodia Bangkok, August 2015 Mr. RUN Saray Executiva Director And Lawyer Legal Aid of Cambodia ACCESS TO LEGAL AID Presentation by.
Legal Aid of Cambodia Bangkok, August 2015 Mr. RUN Saray Executiva Director and Lawyer Legal Aid of Cambodia WitnessProtection Presentation by.
Unit 1: What is justice? The Canadian Judicial System The Police  What is the role of police in society?  What police organisations exist in Canada?
Law Reform Commission Criminal Process Pre-Trial Procedures Pierre Rosario DOMINGUE Chief Executive Officer Wednesday, May 7,
Chapter 6 International crime. In this chapter, you will study the concept of international crime. You will be introduced to the main categories of international.
Unit 2 Human Rights Part 3 Civil and Human Rights.
Access to the courts is vital for an effective legal system.
Lecture 4. OUTCOMES What must the equity plan include?. What must affirmative action measures include? Which factors are taken into account in determining.
Chapter 20: Civil Liberties: Protecting Individual Rights Section 2
Confidence Building Measures Anatoly A.Streltsov D.Tech., D.J., prof. deputy director of the IPII MSU named by M.V.Lomonosov.
Australia’s Implementation of the People Trafficking Protocol Presentation by Sandra Bennett International Crime Branch Australian Government Attorney-General’s.
Defendant’s Rights and the Right to Privacy AMERICAN GOVERNMENT.
Annex A ASBOs are a powerful tool for protecting victims and stopping anti-social behaviour. Much effort goes into getting the ASBO by the agencies involved.
American Government and Organization PS1301 Wednesday, 3 December.
Integrating legal need research into centres’ strategic planning Polly Porteous - Combined CLCs’ Group NSW NSW CLC State Conference 8 April 2008.
Civil Liberties.  It is often said in the American justice system that it is better to allow ten guilty people to go free than to let one innocent person.
VCE Legal Studies: Evaluating the role of the court as a law-maker
Higher Modern Studies Pupil Conference April 2008 USA Presented by George Clarke USA.
SESSION SIX YOU ARE NOT ALONE SERVICES WHICH ARE AVAILABLE TO HELP.
The Bill of Rights and the Criminal Trial Process.
Investigating Shipping Pollution Violations Pacific Module 3: Domestic Enforcement.
Bell Ringer At last year’s Super Bowl, the government secretly used face recognition software on people attending the event by using surveillance cameras.
I can understand that sources of law include The Constitution, The Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Treaties, statutes, and common law. I can understand.
Legal Considerations Members in Practice (MIP) Members in Business (MIB)
Legal Considerations Members in Practice (MIP) Members in Business (MIB)
PROTECTION OF RIGHTS 1. Balancing Rights 2. Rights of Accused 3. Rights of Victims 4. Questions to Complete.
Chapter 14.4 CIVIL LIBERTIES CHALLENGES This section focuses on government and civil liberties.
Health and Social Care Vetting and Barring Scheme (VBS) Review of the Scheme.
Law and Terrorism Chapter 17.
Chapter 2 The criminal investigation process
Legal Implications.
WitnessProtection Presentation
Arrest: Citizen and Police Rights
The accused The accused – someone charged with or on trial for a crime
War on Terror.
Restrictions, including those restrictions permitted by the European Convention on Human Rights Duty of confidentiality Official Secrets Legislation.
Patrick Sefton | Principal, Brightline Lawyers
Justice in the Criminal Justice System
Border Procedures for Minors
Border Procedures for the Removal or Detention of Minors
Chiamaka Anyaegbu Centre for Socio-Legal Studies
Presentation transcript:

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s Anti-Terrorism Legislation: The National Security State and the Community Legal Sector Dr Mark Rix Graduate School of Business University of Wollongong The paper considers the implications for the community legal sector of the Australian Government’s recent national security and anti-terrorism legislation The series of Bills enacted by the Australian Parliament since September removes many of the rights and freedoms that Australians have been able to take for granted Other concerns with the legislation relate to the use of force, sedition, and legal representation for those held in preventative detention Community legal centres (CLCs), that comprise the community legal sector, have the important role of informing citizens of their basic rights and assisting citizens in exercising their rights The paper considers what effects the anti-terrorism legislation will have on the community legal sector’s effectiveness in playing this important role

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May An Australian National Security State? The Australian Government’s national security website is an important source of information The website is hosted by the Attorney-General’s Department and introduces and explains the anti- terrorism legislation that has been passed into law over the past three years or so Michael Head (2005) identifies 4 noteworthy features of this legislation: 1. It defines terrorism in sweeping terms 2. Permits the banning of political groups 3. Allows for detention without trial or evidence 4. Shrouds the intelligence and security agencies in secrecy and permits secret trials Nevertheless, the terrorist threat to Australia remains relatively minor

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May An Australian National Security State? This is in spite of Australia’s military involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan and its support for the US-led global war on terrorism Also often overlooked are: Australia’s relative geographical isolation its border protection and immigration control system, and Its lack of a “human infrastructure” with the capacity to mount a major homeland terrorist attack

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s Anti-Terrorism Laws The Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Legislation Amendment (Terrorism) Act 2003 gives ASIO the power “to obtain a warrant to detain and question a person who may have information important to the gathering of intelligence in relation to a terrorist activity” The act enables ASIO to detain a person without judicial warrant for up to 7 days and to interrogate them for 24 hours within that 7-day period While being interrogated, a detainee has to Answer all questions Provide all information or material requested of them Prove that they do not have the material requested—if they are unable to do so and do not provide the material they can be imprisoned for up to 5 years

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s Anti-Terrorism Laws The National Security Information (Criminal and Civil Proceedings) Act 2004 Extends the protection from disclosure of “security sensitive information” to include certain civil court proceedings Permits the prosecution and conviction of individuals on the basis of information which is not tendered in evidence for national security reasons It also allows for partially or wholly secret trials, evidence to be censored, and defendants and their legal counsel to be excluded from trial proceedings

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s Anti-Terrorism Laws The Anti-Terrorism Bill (No. 2) 2005 According to Attorney-General Philip Ruddock the Bill’s “key features” include A regime enabling courts to impose controls on persons who pose a terrorist risk to the community Allowing for the detention of a person for up to 48 hours to prevent an imminent terrorist attack or to preserve evidence of a recent attack An extension of the stop, question and search powers of the Australian Federal Police Enhanced powers for the AFP to obtain information and documents enabling it to respond to or prevent a terrorist attack In issuing a control order, a court can impose conditions on an individual including that they wear a tracking device, are prohibited or restricted from talking to another person including their lawyer, and are prohibited or restricted from using a telephone or the internet Police can detain without charge a person who they suspect will carry out an imminent terrorist act or is planning to carry out such an attack

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s Anti-Terrorism Laws The provision allowing for a person subject to a control order to be informed why it was imposed is weakened by the severe restrictions on the disclosure of information, e.g. when national security would be prejudiced While the Bill, as amended, gives a person subject to preventative detention and control orders the ability to repudiate the orders, because there is insufficient evidence formally to charge them with an offence they would not know precisely what they were opposing or challenging The 2005 Bill includes a newly-defined crime of sedition The authorities have only to suspect a person of seditious intent to use, “urge” or threaten the use of force for them to be able invoke the relevant provisions

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s anti-terrorism legislation: what are the implications for the community legal sector? The Australian Government relies on the community legal sector to provide free legal services to some of the most disadvantaged members of the Australia community The sector has as its raison d’être improving access to justice and equality before the law for all Australians In providing legal services to disadvantaged individuals and groups the sector is acknowledged to be a key part of the Australian Government’s social justice strategy However, the sector often finds itself in conflict with the Government and its agencies when seeking to improve access to justice and equality before the law for its clients The recent national security and anti-terrorism legislation is likely to mean that the conflict and tensions between the Government and sector will become more intense

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s anti-terrorism legislation: what are the implications for the community legal sector? There are more than 200 CLCs across Australia About 129 of these are funded under the Commonwealth Community Legal Services Program (CCLSP) The CCLSP has a number of significant objectives: Assist people experiencing some form of systemic or socio- economic barrier to accessing legal services and/or whose interests should be pursued as a matter of public interest Provide people with early assistance through the provision of appropriate information and referral Enable clients to gain a practical and improved understanding of the legal and other options available to them Through providing appropriate casework assist clients in gaining an enhanced opportunity to pursue outcomes consistent with their legal rights and entitlements

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May Australia’s anti-terrorism legislation: what are the implications for the community legal sector? In addition, CLCs undertake Community Legal Education (CLE) and law reform and policy work CLE is designed to provide individuals and groups with information to improve their knowledge and understanding of the legal system and their ability to use legal processes effectively CLE also informs people of their rights and how to exercise their rights Law reform and policy work is designed to enable CLCs more effectively to meet the legal needs of the communities and individuals they serve Through this work CLCs play an important role in maintaining social order and preventing social fragmentation It also helps to maintain people’s confidence in and compliance with the law and the legal system

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May The community legal sector: protecting Australia’s national security In ensuring that people have confidence in and comply with the law CLCs help to preserve social order and prevent social fragmentation They thus have an important role in protecting Australia’s national security The sector will with greater frequency and urgency be called upon to ensure that ordinary Australian citizens have access to justice and enjoy equality before the law This is a function that it will have to perform even while it continues to undertake the activities set down for it in CCLSP The sector’s CLE work will become even more important focusing on the legislation that makes it possible for the authorities to detain people without trial or evidence

RNSA Social Implications Workshop 29 May The community legal sector: protecting Australia’s national security CLE work will also have to focus on the 2005 Bill’s provisions enabling the authorities to withhold information from a person subject to a control order when they believe that disclosure would, e.g. prejudice national security Through its CLE work the sector will also have to inform and educate members of Muslim communities, and other so- called ‘suspect’ groups, about the 2005 Bill’s preventative detention and control order provisions It is these communities and groups who are most at risk from the persecution, harassment and arbitrary detention permitted in the legislation The crime of sedition can also be used by the authorities to persecute and harass members of these communities The sector will have to be vigilant and energetic in defending Australia’s national security from the national security authorities whose efforts to protect national security may only serve to undermine it