Is IP Going To Take Over The World: Offense Isaac Chung Gary Bramwell.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Views of Technology Futures An Internet Perspective Geoff Huston Internet Society October 2000.
Advertisements

Saif Bin Ghelaita Director of Technologies & Standards TRA UAE
1 Scalability is King. 2 Internet: Scalability Rules Scalability is : a critical factor in every decision Ease of deployment and interconnection The intelligence.
McGraw-Hill©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 2000 Chapter 28 Real-Time Traffic over the Internet.
29.1 Chapter 29 Multimedia Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display.
TCP/IP Protocol Suite 1 Copyright © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. Permission required for reproduction or display. Chapter 25 Multimedia.
Is IP going to take over the world (of communications)? Pablo Molinero-Fernandez, Nick McKeown Stanford University Hui Zhang Turin Networks, Carnegie Mellon.
H. 323 and firewalls: Problem Statement and Solution Framework Author: Melinda Shore, Nokia Presenter: Shannon McCracken.
Resource Pooling A system exhibits complete resource pooling if it behaves as if there was a single pooled resource. The Internet has many mechanisms for.
Point-to-Point Network Switching Advanced Computer Networks.
VIPER – Voice over IP with Enhanced Resiliency Abstract: VoIP call quality is subject to Internet conditions, and users may experience periods of low quality.
April 1999Networking Trends/Habib Youssef 1 Networking Trends Habib Youssef, Ph.D. Department of Computer Engineering King Fahd.
1 Solutions to Performance Problems in VOIP over Wireless LAN Wei Wang, Soung C. Liew Presented By Syed Zaidi.
Voice Over Internet Protocol “VoIP” Muayyed Al Kadhem Abdulkhaleq Al Musaleem.
Is IP going to take over the world (of communications)? Pablo Molinero-Fernandez Stanford University Nick McKeown Stanford University Hui Zhang Turin Networks,
Protocols and the TCP/IP Suite
CS158B Project By Shing Chau Jerry Ko Ying Li
Where Does Circuit Switching Make Sense In the Internet? Pablo Molinero-Fernández High Performance Networking Group Stanford University.
2/15/2011Harvard Bits1. 2/15/2011Harvard Bits2 US Telegraph “Network” in 1856.
Network Neutrality 4/21/20111Harvard Bits. 4/21/2011Harvard Bits2.
Stanford University August 22, 2001 TCP Switching: Exposing Circuits to IP Pablo Molinero-Fernández Nick McKeown Stanford University.
Point-to-Point Network Switching Computer Networks Computer Networks Spring 2012 Spring 2012.
1 Networking Basics: A Review Carey Williamson iCORE Professor Department of Computer Science University of Calgary.
BUDAPEST UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY AND ECONOMICS DEPARTMENT OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND MEDIA INFORMATICS BUDAPEST UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY AND ECONOMICS.
VOIP ENGR 475 – Telecommunications Harding University November 16, 2006 Jonathan White.
MPLS networking at PSP Co Multi-Protocol Label Switching Presented by: Hamid Sheikhghanbari 1.
6. Next Generation Networks A. Transition to NGN B
Protocols and the TCP/IP Suite Chapter 4. Multilayer communication. A series of layers, each built upon the one below it. The purpose of each layer is.
VOIP (Voice Over Internet Protocol) CDA 4527 Fall 2006.
Optimizing Multi-Layered Networks Towards a Transparently Optical Internet Presenter: Moshe Zukerman Electronic Engineering Dept., City University of Hong.
Communications Recap Duncan Smeed. Introduction 1-2 Chapter 1: Introduction Our goal: get “feel” and terminology more depth, detail later in course.
 Introduction  VoIP  P2P Systems  Skype  SIP  Skype - SIP Similarities and Differences  Conclusion.
Lecture 15. IGP and MPLS D. Moltchanov, TUT, Spring 2008 D. Moltchanov, TUT, Spring 2015.
Voice over IP in the Enterprise. What is VOIP? The use of data networks to carry voice without a loss of sound quality The use of data networks to carry.
Skype P2P Kedar Kulkarni 04/02/09.
Introduction and Overview Chapter 1. Why Study TCP/IP? Forms global Internet base technology Has accommodated explosive growth well Protocols work over.
Section 2.31 The TCP/IP reference model the de facto Internet standard demonstrates arbitrary nature of layers –various models are possible –OSI & TCP/IP.
MPLS and Traffic Engineering Ji-Hoon Yun Computer Communications and Switching Systems Lab.
Applied Communications Technology Voice Over IP (VOIP) nas1, April 2012 How does VOIP work? Why are we interested? What components does it have? What standards.
CCNA 1 Module 10 Routing Fundamentals and Subnets.
TCP/IP Protocol Suite 1 Chapter 25 Upon completion you will be able to: Multimedia Know the characteristics of the 3 types of services Understand the methods.
2000/3/9QoS Introduction1 References: 1.Paul Ferguson and Geoff Huston, Quality of Service, John Wiley & Sons, Xipeng Xiao and Lionel M. Ni, “Internet.
ECE 4450:427/527 - Computer Networks Spring 2015 Dr. Nghi Tran Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering Lecture 2: Overview of Computer Network.
Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP). Basic Components of a Telephony Network.
VOICE OVER INTERNET PROTOCOL. INTRODUCTION SCENARIOS IN INTERNET TELEPHONY VOIP GATEWAYS IMPORTANCE OF VOICE OVER IP BENEFITS & APPLICATIONS ADVANTAGES.
Ch 1. Computer Networks and the Internet Myungchul Kim
Computer Networks with Internet Technology William Stallings
FUTURE OF NETWORKING SAJAN PAUL JUNIPER NETWORKS.
QoS research in a complicated world Christian Huitema Architect Windows Networking & Communications Microsoft Corporation.
QoS: Where, When, and Why? Ed Knightly ECE/CS Departments Rice University (and without bankruptcy along the way)
Congestion control for Multipath TCP (MPTCP) Damon Wischik Costin Raiciu Adam Greenhalgh Mark Handley THE ROYAL SOCIETY.
ﺑﺴﻢﺍﷲﺍﻠﺭﺣﻣﻥﺍﻠﺭﺣﻳﻡ. Group Members Nadia Malik01 Malik Fawad03.
Congestion exposure BoF candidate protocol: re-ECN Bob Briscoe Chief Researcher, BT Nov 2009 This work is partly funded by Trilogy, a research project.
Voice over IP B 林與絜.
1 “ ” Multiservice networking is emerging as a strategically important issue for enterprise and public service provider infrastructures alike.The proposition.
International Telecommunication Union Workshop on Next Generation Networks: What, When & How? Geneva, 9-10 July 2003 NGN Research in China Jiang lin-tao.
2 2 Semester 1 JEOPARDY Robert C. Gates BA, MS, CCNA.
PSDNs Public Switched Data Networks
Voice and Video over IP.
The Internet Book. 3 The Internet Works Well The Internet is a marvel of technical accomplishment. TCP/IP: – Accommodates growth and change not imagined.
TCP/IP Protocol Suite 1 Chapter 25 Upon completion you will be able to: Multimedia Know the characteristics of the 3 types of services Understand the methods.
Section #7: Getting Data from Point A to Point B.
Challenges in the Next Generation Internet Xin Yuan Department of Computer Science Florida State University
Voice over Internet Protocol Presenter: Devesh Patidar Arunjay Singh August 2, 2009.
This paper is Misleading Shu, Johnny. Paper summary Many IP assumptions are wrong IP is not suitable for some networks Suggest using circuit switching.
“End to End VoIP“ The Challenges of VoIP Access to the Enterprise Charles Rutledge VP Marketing Quintum Technologies
Jia Uddin Embedded System Lab.  MPLS  IMANET  IMANET network model  Proposed model of IMANET with MPLS  Conclusion.
Presented by Maria Shah. Road Map  VoIP Benefits  VoIP Protocols  VoIP Analysis  Advantages  Disadvantages  Implementing  Security  Summary.
4G WIRELESS SYSTEM Presented By S. RAVINDER 06U61A0435.
John Horrocks Quality of Service John Horrocks
Presentation transcript:

Is IP Going To Take Over The World: Offense Isaac Chung Gary Bramwell

Claim: IP does not dominate global communications VOIP Commercially available from Vonage, Skype, Comcast, etc. Video On Demand and IPTV Streaming Video Circuit switching is still big and established, but IP is rapidly gaining

Claim: IP is not more efficient Argues bandwith utilization in core network is lower Actually provides less delay for end users Response time is same for crowded flows IP lets at least some traffic through, circuit lets none

Claim: IP is not more robust IP is a best-effort service Upper layer protocols like TCP deal with this fact Transparent to application layer

Claim: IP is not simpler So? Increased diversity of clients and sources requires complexity to handle Trades complexity for flexibility

Claim: IP cannot support real-time applications “There is a widely-held assumption that IP network can support telephony and other real-time applications” An assumption made true VOIP IPTV Streaming media/Webcasting “It is doubtful a new solution…an displace the reliable and high quality of service (QoS) provided by today’s TDM-based infrastructre. True, but it has no need to replace it to support real-time apps

IP and Circuits living together…mass hysteria! Argues that IP could be used on the fringes of network with a circuit-switched core Don’t support claims that IP isn’t good at traffic isolation, traffic engineering, fault isolation, and manageability

Circuit switching has to manually scale to match IP “Similarly circuit switching has to respond to the increases in traffic of packet switching, by adapting its capacity along core/edge gateways accordingly” This won’t work because…

…Things scale too quickly to manually adapt Thanks to Geoff Huston. on April 1, 2007

Conclusion Paper argues against the plausibility of services that are already in place Claims were based on comparing an established system with a still-new Internet Paper had no actual conclusion or point