N. Ponthieu March 30th, 2007 1 A few thoughts on scanning strategy F. R. Bouchet, M. Bucher, F. X. Désert, N. Ponthieu, M. Piat.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The second LDB flight of BOOMERanG was devoted to CMB polarization measurements Was motivated by the desire to measure polarization : –at 145 GHz (higher.
Advertisements

Further Inference in the Multiple Regression Model Hill et al Chapter 8.
Adaptive Hough transform for the search of periodic sources P. Astone, S. Frasca, C. Palomba Universita` di Roma “La Sapienza” and INFN Roma Talk outline.
Planck 2013 results, implications for cosmology
S-PASS, a new view of the polarized sky Gianni Bernardi SKA SA On behalf of the S-PASS team CMB2013, Okinawa, June th 2013.
Foreground cleaning in CMB experiments Carlo Baccigalupi, SISSA, Trieste.
K. Ganga – CMB Science and Observations 1 Rencontres du Vietnam /08 The QuaD CMB Polarization Experiment K. Ganga APC.
Distinguishing Primordial B Modes from Lensing Section 5: F. Finelli, A. Lewis, M. Bucher, A. Balbi, V. Aquaviva, J. Diego, F. Stivoli Abstract:” If the.
Contamination of the CMB Planck data by galactic polarized emissions L. Fauvet, J.F. Macίas-Pérez.
Motion Tracking. Image Processing and Computer Vision: 82 Introduction Finding how objects have moved in an image sequence Movement in space Movement.
Component Separation of Polarized Data Application to PLANCK Jonathan Aumont J-F. Macías-Pérez, M. Tristram, D. Santos
ASIC3 WorkshopLandsdowne, VA May 16-18, 2006 J. Harder Page 1 Calibration Status of the Solar Irradiance Monitor (SIM) : The Present and the Future Jerald.
Cryogenics for B-Pol S. Masi, reporting from F.X. Desert L. Piccirillo …. Use SAMPAN as a baseline, and look for improvements/variations.
Foreground limits on the detectability of the B-mode by Bpol Enrique Martínez-González (IFCA) Marco Tucci (IAC) Bpol Meeting, 27-October-2006, Orsay.
Page 1 1 of 20, EGU General Assembly, Apr 21, 2009 Vijay Natraj (Caltech), Hartmut Bösch (University of Leicester), Rob Spurr (RT Solutions), Yuk Yung.
1 CALICE simulation results G.Villani oct. 06 Progress on CALICE MAPS detector simulations: Results for 1.8 x 1.8 µm 2 Discussions & conclusions Next step.
CMB Polariztion B. Winstein Chicago, CfCP General Introduction to the Problem The CAPMAP Solution.
CMB large angular scale, full sky polarization anisotropy has been measured moderately well, but not well enough – The value of reionization fraction derived.
Thoughts on Ground-based lensing measurements Chao-Lin Kuo Stanford/SLAC KIPAC.
SLAC, May 12th, 2004J.L. Puget PLANCK J.L. Puget Institut d'Astrophysique Spatiale Orsay.
Spaceborne Weather Radar
SensEye: A Multi-Tier Camera Sensor Network by Purushottam Kulkarni, Deepak Ganesan, Prashant Shenoy, and Qifeng Lu Presenters: Yen-Chia Chen and Ivan.
Separating Cosmological B-Modes with FastICA Stivoli F. Baccigalupi C. Maino D. Stompor R. Orsay – 15/09/2005.
Congresso del Dipartimento di Fisica Highlights in Physics –14 October 2005, Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Milano Towards an optimized scanning.
ATLASGAL ATLASGAL APEX Telescope Large Area Survey of the Galaxy F. Schuller, K. Menten, P. Schilke, et al. Max Planck Institut für Radioastronomie.
Recent determination of Gamma with Cassini M.T. Crosta, F. Mignard CNRS-O.C.A. 5th RRFWG, June, Estec.
Gridding Daily Climate Variables for use in ENSEMBLES Malcolm Haylock, Climatic Research Unit Nynke Hofstra, Mark New, Phil Jones.
6/11/2012 Building on NEAT concept - M. Gai - INAF-OATo 1 Building on NEAT concept M. Gai – INAF-OATo (a) Extension of science case (b) Payload implementation.
US Planck Data Analysis Review 1 Christopher CantalupoUS Planck Data Analysis Review 9–10 May 2006 CTP Working Group Presented by Christopher Cantalupo.
Precession during merger R. O’Shaughnessy (UWM) J. Healy, L. London, D. Shoemaker (Georgia Tech) Midwest Relativity Meeting, Chicago arXiv:
Joint analysis of Archeops and WMAP observations of the CMB G. Patanchon (University of British Columbia) for the Archeops collaboration.
PHY306 1 Modern cosmology 4: The cosmic microwave background Expectations Experiments: from COBE to Planck  COBE  ground-based experiments  WMAP  Planck.
PACS Spectrometer Spatial Calibration plan in PV phase A.Contursi D. Lutz and U. Klaas.
Cosmic Microwave Background Carlo Baccigalupi, SISSA CMB lectures at TRR33, see the complete program at darkuniverse.uni-hd.de/view/Main/WinterSchoolLecture5.
1 Detection of Cellular Activity Within A Defined Space Undergraduate Project – Final Presentation Spring 2008 Doron BrotEyal Cimet Supervisor:Yossi Hipsh.
Dipole of the Luminosity Distance: A Direct Measure of H(z) Camille Bonvin, Ruth Durrer, and Martin Kunz Wu Yukai
The Very Small Array Angela Taylor & Anze Slosar Cavendish Astrophysics University of Cambridge.
EBEx foregrounds and band optimization Carlo Baccigalupi, Radek Stompor.
1 Overview of Polarimetry Outline of Talk Polarized Physics Machine-Detector Interface Issues Upstream Polarimeter Downstream Polarimeter Ken Moffeit,
The Planck Satellite Hannu Kurki-Suonio University of Helsinki Finnish-Japanese Workshop on Particle Cosmology, Helsinki
Large Area Surveys - I Large area surveys can answer fundamental questions about the distribution of gas in galaxy clusters, how gas cycles in and out.
Adventures in Parameter Estimation Jason Dick University of California, Davis.
TIPS - Oct 13, 2005 M. Sirianni Temperature change for ACS CCDs: initial study on scientific performance M. Sirianni, T. Wheeler, C.Cox, M. Mutchler, A.
3rd International Workshop on Dark Matter, Dark Energy and Matter-Antimatter Asymmetry NTHU & NTU, Dec 27—31, 2012 Likelihood of the Matter Power Spectrum.
Iván Agudo with the collaboration of: S.N. Molina, J. L. Gómez (IAA-CSIC) T. P. Krichbaum, A. Roy, U. Bach (MPIfR) I. Martí Vidal (Chalmers) B. Campbell.
Analysis of Need to go to Space J. Bartlett, R. Battye, F. Bouchet, A. Challinor, K. Ganga, A. Jaffe, R. Stompor.
Blind Component Separation for Polarized Obseravations of the CMB Jonathan Aumont, Juan-Francisco Macias-Perez Rencontres de Moriond 2006 La.
On the detection of the tensor-to-scalar ratio r using the CMB B-modes
Tim Pearson US Planck Data Analysis Review 9-10 May 2006 US Planck Data Analysis Review Source Extraction Tim Pearson.
150GHz 100GHz 220GHz Galactic Latitude (Deg) A Millimeter Wave Galactic Plane Survey with the BICEP Polarimeter Evan Bierman (U.C. San Diego) and C. Darren.
Belle General meeting Measurement of spectral function in the decay 1. Motivation 2. Event selection 3. mass spectrum (unfolding) 4. Evaluation.
1 James N. Bellinger Robert Handler University of Wisconsin-Madison 11-Monday-2009 Laser fan non-linearity James N. Bellinger 20-March-2009.
Jochen Weller Decrypting the Universe Edinburgh, October, 2007 未来 の 暗 黒 エネルギー 実 験 の 相補性.
Orbits and Sensors Multispectral Sensors. Satellite Orbits Orbital parameters can be tuned to produce particular, useful orbits Geostationary Sun synchronous.
IPS Observations Using the Big Scanning Array of the Lebedev Physical Institute: Recent Results and Future Prospects I.V.Chashei, V.I.Shishov, S.A.Tyul’bashev,
Timelike Compton Scattering at JLab
UFOAnalyzerV2 (UA2) the key of accuracy
Investigation of different flyby geometries for asteroid Steins - Surface area, stereo and phase angle coverage Sofie Spjuth Max-Planck-Institut für Sonnensystemforschung.
Monte Carlo Quality Assessment (MC-QA)
Beam Deconvolution Map-Making
A polarimetric approach for constraining the dynamic foreground spectrum for global 21-cm measurements (with applications for DARE) Bang D. Nhan University.
Synopsis “The Matrix”: polarisation and pulsar timing
GPI Astrometric Calibration
Ben Wandelt Flatiron Institute
Hour 38 Scattering Cross Sections
F. Crescioli, P. Giannetti, M. Dell'Orso, G. Punzi, G. Volpi
Apex scanning strategy & map-making
Separating E and B types of CMB polarization on an incomplete sky Wen Zhao Based on: WZ and D.Baskaran, Phys.Rev.D (2010) 2019/9/3.
Imaging Topics Imaging Assumptions Photometry Source Sizes Background
LFI systematics and impact on science
Presentation transcript:

N. Ponthieu March 30th, A few thoughts on scanning strategy F. R. Bouchet, M. Bucher, F. X. Désert, N. Ponthieu, M. Piat

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Polarized map making in principle Solution : Covariance matrix of I, Q, U Redundancy together with angular homogeneity impact on the S/N + IQU decorrelation Minimum An intuitive estimator of the quality of the pointing is

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Polarization systematics mitigation The main systematic effects are not spin-2 quantities, so they average out if the angular coverage is homogeneous Especially true for the most ‘’serious’’ ones like differential gain Can gain 1 order of magnitude in rejection between two scanning strategies Hu et al, 2004 Ponthieu & Hivon, 2007 in prep Scanning strategy is the first tool for systematic mitigation

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Example: WMAP Short term redundancy on all angular scales Good angular redundancy on most of the sky

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Examples: parameterization Planck –  = 85 deg, T spin = 60 sec – a = 10 deg, T prec = 6 months EPIC/JPL –  = 45 deg, T spin = 63 sec – a = 50 deg, T prec = 3.2 h WMAP Planck EPIC

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Exploring the parameter space Trajectory of one pixel on the sky

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Exploring the parameter space Parameters:  3 angles  3 rotation speeds Goal:  Short term redundancy on all angular scales  Large fraction of the sky covered in a few days  Good angular coverage  Jacknife possibilities some constraints  The scan speed of the line of sight must be compatible with the beam, the detector time constant  The sampling rate must be compatible with the telemetry (if no onboard aggressive data compression)  Cope with thermal effects, solar pannels orientation, SCAO etc… Example of set of parameters:  = 45  = 45 T  = sec T  = 2400 sec T  = 20 sec

N. Ponthieu March 30th, day, detector at r/3 (  =2.5deg) N hits cos2 

N. Ponthieu March 30th, days, detector at r/3 (  =2.5deg) N hits cos2 

N. Ponthieu March 30th, days, detector at r/3 (  =2.5deg) N hits cos2 

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Figures of merit Redundancy and homogeneity Want some more deeply integrated regions to really dig into systematics ? Calibration ? How deep do we want to integrate vs how much sky do we want to cover in the same amount of time ? … etc… At this stage of the study, we did not have to quantify exactly the benefit from a particular set of parameters. But we did find one that is feasible and meets the constraints we set.

N. Ponthieu March 30th, Conclusion Scanning strategy is essential to sensitivity It is the first tool to mitigate systematic effects Is is a powerful tool It is a strong driver of the mission architecture non homogeneous sky coverage compromises E/B separation It will be a strong driver of the data analysis, compression…? Cf. Radek’s talk